Comparing the LAMY AL-Star, Safari, and Vista Fountain Pens

Goulet Pen Company
7 followers
3 Video Views·Nov 15, 2022
Hey, I'm Brian Goulet of the Goulet Pen Company and Ink Nouveau.
And I get asked a lot of questions about various pens and stuff all the time.
And one of the most common questions I get is,
what is the difference between the Lamy Vista, the Lamy All-Star, and the Lamy Safari?
Well, I remember back from my earliest days, before I really knew much about fountain pens,
I would see these pens talked about a lot online,
but I didn't understand the differences between them.
And so I still very much remember what it was like to be kind of a newbie in the hobby,
and I wanted to put out this video to help to clarify very clearly in video form,
what is the differences between these pens.
So that's what I'm going to do here for you today.
The Lamy Safari, which I have the charcoal color right here,
and the Lamy Vista, which is this clear one, these two are the most similar.
Essentially, the only difference between these two pens is that the Vista is clear
and the Safari has a variety of different colors that are available.
The grip is the same. Everything else is the same.
The whole design of the pen, the size, weight, all that stuff is identical on the two pens,
with the exception of the material that it's made of.
Now, from what I understand, this was before I got into the fountain pen business,
but the Safari used to come in a clear version.
It was called the Clear Safari or something like that, or called the Safari Vista.
I don't remember exactly, but the Vista itself became a separate product.
Basically, it became a separate model from the Safari at some point.
I don't remember exactly when it was,
but I know that now the Vista is sold under its own name.
So that can be a little confusing.
You think, oh, it's a different model.
Maybe it's very, very different.
It's really not.
It's just a clear version.
The word Vista means, you know, to see, you know, things clearly.
So that kind of is a neat little play on words there.
But anyway, the two are exactly the same.
This is what I get asked about the most.
What is the difference between the Lamy Safari and the Lamy All-Star?
Well, the biggest difference between the two is the material that the pen body is made out of.
The Safari here is made of plastic, and the All-Star is made of aluminum.
Looking at them, maybe you can tell, maybe you can't,
but basically they're the same dimensions.
I think the All-Star is just a hair bigger in diameter than the Safari,
but you're really not going to be able to tell that unless you break out
a pair of calipers or a micrometer or something crazy.
But just in practicality, you're not going to be able to tell the difference.
Now, the All-Star is a little bit heavier.
You know, the Safari is about 17 grams.
The All-Star is 22 grams.
Is that enough to make or break the difference?
Maybe.
If you're looking for a super light pen, the Safari may be a little more favorable to you,
especially if you like to not use the cap, if you like to write with it unposted like this.
You know, it's a pretty light pen.
The All-Star is just a little bit heavier,
so if you like a little heavier weight to it, like a little heft,
you might like the All-Star better.
As far as durability goes, the Safari may have a little bit of an edge over the All-Star.
Yeah, the All-Star is aluminum.
Metal is pretty durable.
Aluminum itself can dent kind of easily.
I'm not going to say easily.
If you drop it on the concrete, you're probably going to scratch or dent this pen.
You might scratch the Safari, but it's not going to be as noticeable
as it would be if you did it to the All-Star.
So that's kind of like the only complaint I really ever hear about the All-Star is that,
you know, it can be scratched or dented easier than the Safari.
Me personally, I've never scratched or dented one
because I don't really throw my pen around too much.
If I'm going to have a knock-around pen, I would be more inclined to use a Safari.
Now, you'll notice on this specific pen that the clip is a little bit different.
It's a different color.
Well, that really just depends on the color.
This is a charcoal Safari.
It comes with a black clip.
Most of the other Safaris come with a silver clip like this one.
There's also at least one of the,
a couple of the All-Stars that I can think of that come with a black clip.
So that clip isn't interchangeable between the pens.
Depending on the color of All-Star or Safari that you're choosing,
that's going to determine the color of your clip.
So we got the weight difference.
We've got the material difference.
The other aesthetic difference that you can really tell is the grip section.
On the Safari, your grip is going to match the material of the rest of the pen.
So if you got the charcoal, it's going to be that charcoal.
If you got the yellow one, it's going to be yellow and so on.
With the All-Star, it has kind of this smoky translucent grip
so that you can see the feed inside of the pen.
And that smoky kind of, you know, grayish, blackish,
translucent grip is the same on all the All-Stars.
It doesn't matter what color you buy.
So that is one kind of distinguishable difference.
If you like to see ink inside there, you know, that's cool.
That's definitely a perk to the All-Star.
If you don't really care, it may or may not make a difference for you.
I personally kind of dig it.
But, you know, who knows?
It doesn't really matter that much.
Now, as far as all three pens, they all take the same LAMY ink cartridges.
They take the same converters.
It can use either a Z24 converter, which is what you see in here in my Vista,
which I actually have inked up.
That's why it looks so dark.
It's the one with the red and the black trim.
That's the Z24.
And kind of the reason that this converter is ideal for these pens
is because this converter has these little pegs here
that are made to kind of seat into the back of the grip of the pen.
Now, LAMY makes another converter, a Z26.
This is made for some of their other models like the Accent, the Studio.
This one can just as easily fit in any of these pens.
It doesn't have those little pegs, though,
so it doesn't hold it quite as positively.
But you can still use it.
In fact, you know, with the Vista, you know, you could argue that
the aesthetically, the black and silver trim of that matches a little better.
But really, it's kind of up to you.
Any of these three pens will take either of these converters.
Of course, price is always a factor when you're talking about pens.
The Vista and the Safari are sold at the same price.
LAMY puts a list price of $37 for this pen in the U.S.
Street price is usually going to be lower than that.
The All-Star has a list price of $47.
So it's $10 more that you're paying for the aluminum versus the other two.
Now, is that worth it?
That's really going to depend on your individual taste.
As far as how the pen actually writes, they're all going to be more or less identical.
And the reason is because they all use the exact same nib.
If you look at the grip of these pens, they all have this proprietary LAMY nib
that can be removed and swapped in between all the pens.
So that is one huge perk to the entire LAMY system, if you want to call it that.
All of their pens, with the exception of the LAMY 2000,
use the exact same nib and feed.
So you can switch and swap between them all.
They're available in extra fine through broad, as well as 1.1, 1.5, and 1.9 stub italic.
And you can also get the extra fine through broad in a black color.
So if you happen to like a black nib on something that has more black trim,
you can get that and mix and match on whatever pens you want.
That should clear up some confusion that you might have about the LAMY pens.
But if you have any other questions, you can feel free to leave me a comment on my blog
or on my YouTube channel.
Be sure to also check out my podcast, Ink Nouveau, as well as hit me up on Twitter.
Thanks so much for spending time with me today, and right on.
