The Real History Behind Mulan

Learn Chinese Now
1.7K followers
1.2K Video Views·Dec 6, 2025
💥Discount on Shen Yun tickets: https://www.shenyun.com USE CODE: LCN2026
💥Shen Yun Creations: https://sypa.us/chinese-jared
Subscribe to Learn Chinese Now: http://www.youtube.com/learnchinesenow
Jared on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/MCJaredMadsen
Jared on Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/mcjaredmadsen/
Jared on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/Mcjaredmadsen
You’ve all seen it. Mulan stands atop a snowy mountain pass, staring down Shan Yu, a hulking,
yellow-eyed warlord leading a horde of terrifying horsemen. The movie calls them the Huns. But then
you stop and think, wait a second, wasn’t the big bad of the Huns supposed to be called Attila? And
wasn’t he way over there in Europe threatening Rome, not here in China marching on the Great
Wall? Were Mulan’s enemies really the same dudes who devastated the greatest empire of the West?
Or is this just one of those very long games of historical telephone where multiple civilizations
have blurred together into one barbaric boogeyman? To crack this mystery, we’ve got to go way,
way back. Let’s ride. Over 2,000 years ago, the Chinese had one unending nightmare from
the north. Nomads. They rode horses like second skins, drew deadly bows from atop the saddle,
and could appear at the gates of a city before anyone had the time to light the beacons. These
guys were the reason the Great Wall went up. China’s first emperor didn’t build that crazy
wall in 220 BC to keep the world out. It was to keep them out. These guys were the Xiōngnú,
equestrian lords of the Eurasian steppe. And that unfinished wall would never hold off these
ferocious fighters forever. By the Hàn dynasty a couple decades later, they were once again a
very serious problem. Hàn chronicles described endless campaigns against the Xiōngnú. Sometimes
it was bloody wars. Sometimes awkward peace treaties sealed with royal marriages. Sometimes
trade caravans passing through checkpoints. But the riders of the steppe were always out there,
a looming assurance of uncertainty. But then the Hàn dynasty struck back in
133 BC and they struck back hard. Their campaign culminated in the epic Battle of Mòběi in 119
BC which we covered here. And with that, the great Xiōngnú confederation gradually started
to crack. Some clans submitted to Hàn rule. Others broke off and vanished westward into
the endless Eurasian grasslands. For centuries, few saw them again. But then, 400 years later,
a new massive and merciless mounted army suddenly materialized. But not in China. In Europe. To the
Romans, the Huns were a menace that seemed to appear out of thin air. Writers described them
as short, scarred, ruthless, bow-legged from a lifetime of horseback riding, living in tents,
drinking fermented milk, eating raw meat. Their tactics: Blitzkrieg drive-by bombardments,
relentless swarming skirmishes, firing backwards in false retreats. All breaking
armies before they even had to get close. At their head was Attila, the so-called Scourge
of God. He forced Constantinople to pay him tribute. Bullied Rome itself. For a moment,
it looked like he might steamroll Europe entirely. Sound familiar? The echoes of the Xiōngnú were
impossible to ignore. Both buried their elites with sacrificed horses and rich grave goods.
Both terrified sedentary empires. Even the names matched suspiciously well. Xiōngnú in Old Chinese
sounded something like qhon-na or heon-na. To Latin ears that could easily become Hun.
And modern science has tightened the case. DNA analysis from Hun graves as recent as this year
show a broad mosaic of ancestries, European and Central Asian for sure, but also some notably East
Asian with a few lineages going straight back to the Xiōngnú elite. Add in the archaeology,
add in the tactics, and the simplest answer is the Huns were a distant westward echo of the Xiōngnú.
So, mystery solved, right? The Huns that Mulan fights must be the Xiōngnú, renamed for Hollywood
audiences. Easy. Not so fast. Just when everything seems neat and tidy, history throws a wrench in
it. The Xiōngnú were broken at Mòběi in 119 BC. By 200 AD, they were splintered and scattered. And in
China, they’d either been absorbed or were serving as frontier mercenaries. The Ballad of Mulan,
Mùlán Cí, wasn’t created until hundreds of years later, around the fifth century AD. By that point,
the Xiōngnú weren’t a threat anymore. And Attila, he was 5,000 miles away, either ransacking Italy
or long since dead. So if not the Xiōngnú and not the Huns, who on earth was Mulan fighting?
Her story comes from the era of the Northern Wèi dynasty of the period called the Northern and
Southern Dynasties, the Nánběicháo. Now who were they fighting? A confederation called the Róurán.
These guys were the new top dogs of the steppe, harassing Northern Wèi borders
the way the Xiōngnú had once harassed the Hàn. And who were the Róurán then? Well,
besides also being hunters on horseback, they do have a genetic connection to the Mongols. So,
is that our answer? Was Mulan fighting Genghis Khan’s great great great great granddad?
Well, here’s the twist within the twist. The Northern Wèi weren’t Han Chinese at all. They
were founded by the Xiānbēi, another powerful steppe people who had risen after the Xiōngnú
collapsed. That means Mulan was likely of Xiānbēi heritage, making her a steppe girl in a dynasty
led by steppe rulers, fighting other steppe people. But in an even more curious twist of fate,
the Xiānbēi were actually more genetically similar to the Mongols than the Róurán
were. Which is to say Mulan wasn’t fighting the Xiōngnú or the Huns or really the Mongols. She
herself was an ancient ancestor of the Mongols fighting her other proto-Mongolic cousins.
Crazy, right? But how does this whole lineage actually trickle down to Genghis Khan then? Well,
to answer that question, we have to crawl even deeper into the rabbit hole. You see,
a long long long time ago, the steppe was home to a large confederation of nomads the Chinese
called the Dōnghú, literally Eastern Hu. Hu was a catch-all word for barbarian nomads,
but the Dōnghú were distinct, more eastern in appearance, linguistically closer to what we’d
call Mongolic. Back in 150 BC, the Xiōngnú smashed the Dōnghú, but the Dōnghú didn’t disappear. They
split into branches. One became the Xiānbēi and one the Róurán. And after the Xiōngnú were ousted,
they all came back on the scene with the Northern Wèi dynasty in 386 AD. Then after
the Xiānbēi fell came the Khitan, who got seriously beaten down by none other
than Mù Guìyīng in around the 10th century AD in this video up here. They would then fracture and
be absorbed by the Jurchen in Manchuria, who later would rebrand themselves as the Manchu,
defeat the Míng dynasty at the epic battle of Sarhu in 1619, which I tell the story of up here,
and eventually rule China as the Qīng dynasty. The tale of those big confederations only tells
us the story of the northeast. You see, all the while there were still clans roving on the
Mongolian grasslands. Some coalesced from fallen confederacies, some scattered by past conquests,
some left behind long ago by the Xiānbēi. On their own, they were all inconsequential.
But they shared the same echoes of the old Dōnghú, same ancestral heritage, the same nomadic culture,
the same mastery of the horse, just less of the fame and none of the fortune. And that was about
to change. Among these clans, there was a man named Temüjin. Although he sometimes claimed the
legacy of the Xiōngnú and the Xiānbēi, in reality, he wasn’t the direct heir to either of them.
What he was was the heir of the entire eastern steppe, of the centuries of riders who lived and
died in the saddle. And when he rose, he wove all of those legacies into one banner and united all
of those clans into one empire, the Mongol Empire. And so Temüjin, better known as Genghis Khan,
came from nowhere and everywhere. Not the heir of one lineage, but the culmination of all of them.
He was the climactic chord of a song that had been building up for a thousand years. Not defined by
any one genetic melody, but the harmonies of similar cultures intertwining across millennia.
So, was Disney completely wrong? Yes. But with a history this complicated, you can’t entirely blame
a cartoon for fudging the details. What is true is that Mulan’s ballad takes place in that same
grand story of the steppe. Her little frontier war encapsulates a thousand-year epic connecting
the past and the future. Behind her, the ghosts of the Xiōngnú and the Huns. Before her, the
shadow of Genghis Khan. And if there’s anything to be learned from these scenes of history,
it’s that where you come from doesn’t have to define who you are now. And where you come from
is no limitation to who you can become. So with these famous figures in mind, like, subscribe,
become a member, and break through your own glass ceilings. Until next time, zàijiàn.
