We broke 6 knots end to end and in a bend (a loop). 40 samples total. Let us know on our discord page for our new series of How Knot to Tie Ropes on format and the testing you want to see. https://discord.com/invite/Ja2gYHhxYE
00:00 40 Samples to Test 04:14 Tour of knots 05:41 Zeppelin Loop with Whip 06:08 Zeppelin loop 07:17 Alpine Butterfly Loop 08:19 Figure 8 Loop 09:05 Reever loop 10:00 Bowline 11:01 Double Fishermans 11:49 Zeppelin Bend 12:16 Alpine Butterfly Bend 13:01 Other Alpine Butterfly Bend 13:48 Reever bend 14:27 Flemish Bend 15:07 Sheet Bend (Broke LOW) 15:37 Bonus Test 16:46 Conclusion WITH CHART
Oh man, we tested 13 different types of knots,
three times each, all just to find out
they all break around 50% of the MBS.
Got a lot of goodies in this one,
including some bonus ones of course,
in this episode of How Not To Highlight.
Oh!
Hi, I'm Ryan Jinks and welcome to our new Slack Snap Lab.
So I think that intro's funny
because we did this test like six months ago
when we were just building out this lab.
And Carl Mitchell tied, labeled,
and shipped all these knots and ropes to us,
which is super helpful because sample prep
is a huge part of break tests.
And I always have a dozen videos in the bank,
which is how we're able to upload regularly.
But I was going to, well we have 39 samples
plus some bonus ones, so that's like a lot to process,
plus we were decorating.
So I was gonna come up with a nice conclusion for you guys.
Never really got around to that
because I researched the MBS of the rope
because that's relevant to the breaking strength
of these knots, right?
So I ended up going down a rabbit trail with these ropes.
A seven millimeter Edelweiss rope,
which is what is in the video you're about to see,
is a 9.8 kilonewton MBS, or minimum breaking strength.
Now this was super interesting
because some of our samples, spoiler alert,
was nine-ish kilonewtons,
and knots usually reduce the strength of the MBS.
So I looked up the Edelrid seven millimeter rope as well,
which is exactly the same material,
polyamide, nylon, same rope.
It's the same rope, seven millimeters.
So why does Edelrid say there's this 14 kilonewtons?
That's five additional.
That's more than 50% stronger than Edelweiss is claiming.
So I emailed Edelrid and said,
why is your rope 14 kilonewtons?
So Edelrid responded with this.
Our power lock has a 14 kilonewton MBS
because we make the best gear in the game.
Technical data, it's made of polyamide nylon.
Not sure why Edelweiss doesn't compare.
Maybe ask them.
All right.
Well, I never got around to asking them
because that's just a rabbit trail
and I'm clearly making progress here.
And the crane, we just finished putting
the new cable on there.
So now we can start assembling the drop tower.
Spoiler alert.
Anyways, yeah.
So MBS, that's literally the next video I'm going to film
is how that works and why it's not a number
you can always rely on.
Either way, you're probably not gonna die
if you use rated gear in any normal use.
Please put in the comments below
why you think there's a discrepancy
between the two companies.
I think one is using a diverter
and the other one is maybe testing in knots
because there's no way we're getting full strength
with the rope in this video that you're gonna see.
Anyways, I wish the MBS came with context.
I wish gear companies would put out information for us
to not have to trust them,
but to in these contexts, this is what it breaks at
so we can do our own research.
I feel smart enough as an end user
to deserve that information.
But I digress.
We're just testing knots in this video.
So let's go back to it.
Carl Mitchell was excited about these specific knots
and so he tied them in a straight line
and in a bend or in a circle so we can kind of compare.
Now this is a lot of data,
so you can go in the timestamps below
to the knots you wanna see
or just read the description on,
we'll have everything in there
so you don't have to watch them all break.
But there's a little bit,
it's interesting how they break
more than the fact that they all break
super good enough,
except two ends joined together with a butterfly.
That was a good one.
Anyways, a six month younger Ryan
is now going to explain all the knots here on the floor
and then we'll get to breaking.
Okay, here is a lot to go over.
We have a Zeppelin loop,
it's Zeppelin on both sides.
Then you have a Zeppelin loop with a whip on it.
You can see here, the whip holds the tail.
Then butterfly loop is on both ends here.
A figure eight loop,
which is what I am most familiar with,
with the tail tied off.
A Revere loop, never even heard of this one before.
And here's some good old Bolins.
If you are a Bolin-ary,
because I know there's like five ways to tie this,
then here you go.
Maybe we can do a whole series on Bolins later.
Loops is what you call bends.
Apparently, I'm learning stuff here.
Okay, so we are starting with the Zeppelin bend.
That is a pretty neat looking knot.
A Revere bend, here you go.
Wow, butterfly bend.
You have the Flemish.
That is a figure eight.
That is something I've tied a lot of
and did not know is called a Flemish.
Ooh, I know what this one is.
It's a double Fisherman's.
That is something I do.
And here we have a butterfly bend two.
And then you have the sheet bend,
which I still have not mastered.
Broken the knot on the other side.
See the end there.
Zeppelin loop with a whip.
Broken the knot, shocker.
We got the same result as the first one we tested.
Sample 1,096, Zeppelin loop.
Broke on this side.
This overhand here, barrel knot that was here,
has come untied.
And then the one on this side,
it looks like it just kept slipping through
until it cut here.
Same as the last test,
we have those backups there,
that overhand or barrel knot.
Broken the knot.
Very similar to the last one.
It pulled through this.
This knot is still intact, though real tight.
We've got a Zeppelin loop with those backup knots.
Yeah, broke here, pulled through that backup knot.
This is a butterfly loop.
And it has the barrel knot backup overhand.
So knot looks intact over here.
Go check the other side.
There's not much of a knot left here.
That's most likely the backup knot there.
And then what's left of the butterfly.
Sample 1,100, another butterfly loop.
Broken the knot on this side.
And as you can see, as on the last sample,
it leaves us two nice little overhands there.
One for the backup knot barrel knot.
And then that's part of the butterfly loop.
This is the third butterfly loop sample.
We had a failure on this side.
This is a figure eight loop.
And he has these overhand backups.
Looks like it broke on this side.
This side's real tight.
We're thinking that the stated MBS of 9.8 kilonewtons
is based on testing with a figure eight.
That looks pretty likely.
Another figure eight loop.
We got a break in the knot on the other side.
This is our third figure eight loop.
We got failure on the hydraulic side.
This is a reaver loop.
And it does not look like it has any sort of backup,
but I am not familiar with this knot.
Broke on this side.
The whole thing just kind of falls apart once it's broken.
This one, of course, is very tight.
This is the second reaver loop that we are testing.
So this is the second time it's broken on this side.
Looks super similar to the last test.
This is our third reaver loop.
Let's break it.
Something interesting about this test
is all of the samples broke on the dyno side.
These are Bolins or whatever variation of that
that has the bitter end inside of the loop.
Rope got cut in the knot,
but it appeared that the tail was creeping through the knot.
Second Bolin sample.
Very interested to see what happens here.
This is the variation of the Bolin
with the bitter end inside the loop.
We've got a failure in the knot.
Kind of looked like it was slipping,
but this doesn't look much shorter.
This is our third Bolin.
I have moved this tape so it's right next to the knot,
and I'm curious if that will show us how much this moves.
Looking pretty similar to all the other ones.
Broke on the static side.
We have now moved on to bends.
This is a double fisherman's bend.
Oh, okay.
It failed on the carabiner.
This did not break.
Still solid.
Second double fisherman's.
It's nice that I don't have to go over the whole shop
to find the piece.
Broke on the pulling side.
This is our third double fisherman bend.
So, looks like we had a break on the pulling side.
Knot is still there.
Don't think you could untie it.
Oh, it flipped.
It didn't break in the knot.
Nope.
Shocker.
Zeppelin bend, take two.
And I'll have to watch the video again,
but it definitely looks like it broke in the knot.
This is our third Zeppelin bend.
Let's see what happened.
This is a butterfly bend.
This one has the ends terminated, sticking straight out.
Well, ladies and gentlemen,
we have gotten our third type of result.
Butterfly bend with parallel strands X-ing it.
It might break.
All right, like Ryan said, broke at the knot.
Our third butterfly bend
with the parallel ends terminated.
We do have a cut in here
as opposed to pulling all the way through.
There's the remaining knot.
This is more butterfly bends,
but they have a different termination.
They're going out different sides of the knot.
If somebody showed me this and said,
this is a butterfly knot, I would disagree with them.
So the ends are perpendicular to the bend.
Yeah, so slipped there.
Looks very similar to the last test.
This is our third butterfly bend
with the ends perpendicular to the bend.
And we're going to see if it slips all the way through.
That's getting pretty familiar.
This is a reaver bend.
Take a look at that guy.
I'm going to say it broke at the carabiner.
That knot is still intact.
This is our second reaver bend.
Pretty sure that failed at the carabiner.
Reaver bend, third test sample, 1125.
Yeah, I'm going to say it broke in the knot,
these being the two ends on the outside.
This is the first of the Flemish bends.
Let's see what they break at.
This doesn't feel like it was broken over the carabiner,
and I think the knot was further away.
Flemish bend, take two.
Yeah, I'm going to call that breaking in the knot.
Flemish bend number three, go.
It's all the way down here.
Here we go, Flemish bend number three.
And that looks like it failed very similarly
to the other ones, and I'm going to say that's a knot.
This is a sheet bend.
This is our first sheet bend sample.
Oh, yeah, it was.
So as you can clearly see in the video, it just unravels.
Second sheet bend.
It unravels just like the last one.
Sheet bend, take three.
Well, at least it's kind of cool as it unravels.
This cord was already used in the alpine butterfly
with ends perpendicular to the bend.
And it slipped.
You can see some heat damage there, friction damage maybe.
We were curious if you tied a normal alpine butterfly
and pulled it, if it would pop out under enough tension.
Most times when I use this,
I have something clipped into it here,
which would prevent it from popping out
and would probably cut in here somewhere.
But this is something we were curious about,
and we had long enough links because these pulled out.
So let's see what happens.
So we're looking at almost six kilonewtons right there.
Everything's really starting to tighten up.
Ooh, it's getting very small.
All right, broken the knot at 14.9 kilonewtons.
Wow, can't believe you made it to the end of this video.
That was a lot to test.
The conclusion is that was too many samples per video.
And with the drop tower,
after we confirm that knots break the same
or confirm they don't,
that slow pull versus a dynamic shock,
how they break knots,
after we understand how to break knots,
we'll do a how knot with a K
to tie ropes or something like that
and do break tests for one knot
and show how to tie it in the video,
maybe pull it to four kilonewtons,
show how hard it is to untie that,
and then break test it in different diameter ropes,
maybe in webbing, in different ways
so you really just understand this one knot.
And then you can kind of binge watch the knots
you want to see with very little of me talking,
five minute edits, everything's pretty tight,
seven mil, nine mil, 11 mil ropes,
dynamic versus static.
Once we learn how knots work, we can do that.
I would really like your feedback on that.
Check out the top comment
and maybe I'll put like a discord,
we'll maybe try a discord thing,
and you can kind of all have this community chat
on how you want to see us make knot videos.
We're talking about making like a hundred videos
on knots over the next few years.
I really want the format to be exactly what you want
and I want to determine that
before we even start doing knot videos.
This was kind of just showing us how complex it gets
and if we get into too many variables,
it's a lot of data
and it doesn't feel like that good of an episode
or at least entertaining.
So yeah, your feedback is appreciated and your donations
and going to the shop page and clicking affiliate links
since that's how I try to live on.
Anyways, I look forward to your feedback
and we'll see you on the next video.
Cheers.