Under Hitler's Nazi Regime, Were Brave Protests Ever Successful
2 Video ViewsยทOct 29, 2022
Hitler's Nazi regime in Germany was an incredibly brutal regime.
So what is the answer to the question, were brave protests ever successful in Nazi Germany?
The answer is a surprising yes.
Sometimes brave protests against one of the most evil regimes in modern times were successful
and did cause the Nazi state to retreat from its brutal policies.
And much of this discussion is excerpted from our videos on how Christians kept the faith
in Nazi Germany.
Hitler was always probing, always trying to see what more he could get away with.
But even as dictator, Hitler was not totally immune to political pressure.
Hitler sought the willing support of his base, his enthusiastic followers.
Hitler would retreat from policies that proved unpopular.
Hitler encountered stiff resistance from both Catholics and Protestants against their euthanasia
initiatives.
In September 1939, Hitler issued an order to euthanize the disabled and retarded patients
with incurable diseases to eliminate useless eaters.
At first the victims were shot, but as the program expanded, the Nazis experimented with
gassing patients in rooms disguised as showers.
Those who lived near these institutions noticed buses arriving with patients and always leaving
empty and chimneys constantly belching smoke.
How suspicious.
And the euthanasia program soon became an open secret.
Too many were involved in its administration.
Many of these institutions were run by the churches.
Many administrators refused to answer questionnaires inquiring about the status of their institutionalized
patients.
Sometimes the government had to send in their own doctors to fill out the forms to expedite
the killings.
Doctors argued to get people off the lists, sometimes sending the patients back home to
avoid execution.
In addition, doctors and midwives were likewise requested to fill out questionnaires on infants
born with birth defects.
In 1940, after the war started, a Protestant minister spoke out publicly to his congregation,
telling them how we received the urns from the murder institutions with a letter of lies,
so and so dies of this or that illness, and the body was cremated immediately due to danger
of an epidemic.
We could not stand at the grave and say, after it has pleased Almighty God to call our sister
from this life, when we knew that she had been murdered.
We have to stand in front of our patients and say publicly, as the church, this is murder.
This goes against God's commandment and God's will.
We can lobby the government quietly for more humane policies for only so long.
But there is a limit when silence has to have an end, when we can no longer remain silent
about dreadful crimes, because otherwise we are ourselves guilty of those crimes.
Sometime after the practice had been revealed to the public, Bishop von Gehling bravely
condemned the practice from his pulpit.
Do you or I have the right to live only as long as we are productive?
Then someone has only to order a secret decree that the measures tried out on the mentally
ill be extended to other non-productive people, like those who are incurably ill with lung
disease, those disabled on the jobs, and even those severely wounded soldiers.
Then not a one of us is sure anymore of the sanctity of his own lie.
Woe to humanity, woe to our German people, when the sacred commandment, thou shalt not
kill, is not only violated, but when this violation is tolerated and carried out without
punishment.
And he could have added, without permission.
Many people were horrified by these killings.
Sometimes pastors and bishops publicly criticized the killings, more often they appealed directly
to high Nazi officials.
For once, the Nazis backed down.
Less than a month later, Hitler signed an order ending the euthanasia program that had
killed over 70,000 patients.
But the euthanasia program did not finally end until the war ended.
It was simply carried out on a quieter and smaller scale.
Another example is when the hundreds of brave Christian wives publicly protested for many
weeks when their Jewish husbands were sent to concentration camps.
These protests were very public.
Many protests were staged in the streets of Berlin.
The Nazis could not ignore the embarrassing public demonstrations.
So Hitler ordered the release of those Jewish husbands to calm public opinion.
And the most notable protests to the racial policies of Hitler and the Nazis came from
the Pope.
Pope Pius XI was aging with ill health.
Pope Pius XI was worried about his eternal salvation.
He knew that if he spoke out forcefully that the persecution of the church would increase.
But enough was enough.
300,000 copies of his papal encyclical, translated in English with burning concern, were successfully
secretly smuggled into Germany and read from every Catholic pulpit on Palm Sunday in 1937.
Hitler was not named, but rather referred to as the mad prophet oppressing the church
in breaking the terms of the Concordat.
The encyclical proclaimed that true belief in God could not be reconciled with the idolatrous
deification of race, people, or state, that the God of Christianity could not be imprisoned
in a single race, Nazi principle that right is what is advantageous to the people, what
is morally illicit cannot be truly advantageous, and that Christians have no obligation to
obey laws contrary to natural moral laws.
The faithful were bound to believe in Christ, divine revelation, and the primacy of the
Bishop of Rome, challenging the totalitarian claims of the Nazi regime.
The encyclical proclaimed that humility in the spirit of the gospel and prayer for the
assistance of grace are perfectly compatible with self-confidence and heroism, and that
the priest's first loving gift to his neighbor is to serve truth and refute error in any
of its forms.
And both of these proclamations are anathema to Nazi sensibilities of superiority.
Hitler was furious.
The Gestapo seized many of the copies of the encyclical.
A dozen print shops were seized, and hundreds of Catholics were thrown in prison and in
concentration camps.
The Nazis trumped up immorality trials against priests, monks, and nuns, and confiscated
church assets.
But the encyclical did not totally condemn totalitarianism.
Succumbing to the relentless anti-Catholic Nazi propaganda, many Catholics left the church.
But Hitler did not want to overreact.
He wanted the allegiance of the Catholics.
So Hitler planned further retributions against Catholics and the Pope in particular and all
Christians after the war.
Many in the Vatican opposed releasing this encyclical, including the Secretary of State
who had become Pope Pius XII in less than a year.
There were many who did not want to take the risk of antagonizing Hitler and increasing
the persecution of Christians.
And there were some priests who were even sympathetic to the Nazi cause.
Was the Quixotic issuance of this brave encyclical opposing Nazism successful?
Now in immediate early terms, it was not successful, and its main effect was to increase the Nazi
persecution of the church.
But it was successful in that it showed Hitler that he could not always count on the church
always acting like a church mouse to his persecutions.
Or perhaps his enhanced respect for the courage of this brave Pope was a factor in the Germans
not molesting the inhabitants of Vatican City during the Nazi occupation of Rome near the
end of the war.
When Pope Pius XI passed away, on his desk was a similarly harsh encyclical condemning
Nazism.
His successor, Pope Pius XII, was not on death's door, so he suppressed the harsh encyclical
for fear of certain further persecutions of Christians.
Now the encyclical, with burning concern, was successful in demonstrating the bravery
of Pope Pius XI, so history can never accuse the Catholic Church of being totally subservient
to the brutal Nazi regime of Hitler.
The YouTube description includes a link to our PowerPoint script that we uploaded to
SlideShare and also our blog.
And please consider becoming a patron of our channel, plus you can click on the Meetup
or small M icon to participate in our online discussions where we practice our future YouTube
scripts.
And please click on the links for other videos that will broaden your knowledge and improve
your soul.

