Pope Pius XII, Wartime Pope, Could the Pope Have Done More To Save the Jews
23 Video Views·Oct 29, 2022
The major questions people ask about the wartime policies of Pope Pius XII were,
why did the Pope say so little when the Nazis were committing their brutal atrocities,
both against Jews and Catholics in Poland? Why did the Pope not protest more forcefully
against the persecution of the Jews? Now, in our main videos on Pope Pius XII,
reflecting on David Kirchhoff's book, The Pope at War, we reflected on how the Axis power blitz
creed across Europe in the early years of the war, when many expected Germany to quickly defeat
England and win the war, and how the Allies turned the tide in the last years of the war
when Hitler's German army occupied Rome for nine long months. When Mussolini was removed from power,
the Italian armed forces collapsed, permitting the Nazi Germanys to invade from the north.
Two weeks after capturing Rome, the Nazis started rounding up the Italian Jews to send them to the
death camps. Now many Jews had escaped the initial roundup. Some simply hid out in friend's houses,
suspecting something was up. But now many Jews sought refuge. How eager was Pope Pius XII to
shelter the Jews? After researching the archives of this Pope, Kirchhoff is less accommodating
to the Pope than he was in his prior book, The Pope and Mussolini. As could be expected,
some monasteries and convents turned away the desperate Jews, sending them to their deaths.
Others would admit the Jews only if they agreed to be baptized, while some virtuous clergy hid
as many Jews as they could. And the Vatican newspaper for once broke its silence, complaining
about how Jews who were baptized Catholics were also rounded up for the concentration camps.
But regarding the thousands of Jews sent to their deaths, Pope Pius XII judged that it was best to
say nothing. My major criticism of Kirchhoff is he may have been a bit too harsh on Pope Pius XII
in his policy towards the Jews, and that he buried an important fact in the footnotes that
should have been included in the text. Kirchhoff's assertion is plausible that very few Jews found
refuge in religious houses within the Vatican city itself, and that the Pope was discouraging
these Vatican houses from providing refuge to the Jews. Although he did not turn out the few
Jews that were discovered. And this makes sense, for the Pope did not want to unduly provoke the
Germans into violating the neutrality of Vatican City. But the footnotes also discuss a conversation
between the American envoy and the Cardinal that 180 religious houses outside the Vatican
sheltered over 6,000 Jews, but cautioned against publicizing the fact while the Germans remained
in Italy. Now Pope Pius XII must have verbally approved, and perhaps even verbally encouraged,
the sheltering of this many Jews, and must have been aware of this level of assistance to the Jews.
Or perhaps Kirchhoff was not too harsh on Pope Pius XII. In June 1945, less than a month after
Germany's defeat, in a public speech, the Pope justified the signing of the Concordat with Hitler,
and described the suffering of many Catholics and clergy in Germany and in Poland,
and denounced Nazism. But missing from the speech of Pope Pius XII was any mention of the millions
of Jews who were massacred in the Nazi death camps. Why this oversight after the war was over,
when his remarks could no longer endanger either Jews or Christians? And when examining this
question, we must also ask another question. Why did Hitler respect the neutrality of Vatican City?
And we wonder why Hitler, when the Nazis occupied Rome, why didn't he simply march into the Vatican
and capture, at least intimidate, the Pope? Perhaps he respected the fearlessness of the Pope,
as he knew that Pope Pius XII could not be easily intimidated. For example, in his secret talks with
Pope Pius XII, the Pope would not budge from his demands. And historians often forget that
Hitler's hatred of the Jews was more than ideological. The final solution, the extermination
of the Jews, was the major purpose of Hitler's life. This was the evil aim that he lived for.
Otherwise, why would the Nazis ship Jews to the death camps, tying up valuable trains up to the
very end of the war? To Hitler, gassing Jews was more important than winning the war. And those
who sheltered the Jews were themselves often shipped to the death camps. And many of those
who even publicly objected to the Nazi persecution of the Jews, like the Mar Dietrich Bonhoeffer,
perhaps Hitler wanted to keep the support of the German Catholics.
Kircher reports, Hitler suspected wrongly that the Vatican had played a key role in the King's
decision to replace Mussolini, and he railed against the Pope in the Holy See. Now Goebbels,
his propaganda chief, helped persuade Hitler that taking any action against either the Pope or the
Vatican would be unwise, for it would undercut their propaganda claim to be defending Christian
Europe from the Jews and the Communist hordes. Now in July 1943, Berlin had posted a new
ambassador to the Holy See, Ernst von Weizsäcker, who later claimed he had never joined the Nazi
party. And he impressed the Vatican officials with his sincerity. He was a good Nazi, if there ever
was such a thing. Although he was a Protestant, he even asked for help in enrolling in a class
on Catholic religious culture when he was originally posted. And Weizsäcker, like many
diplomats, was a bit of a cheerleader for the country where he was posted in his discussions
with his government, and he often justified and smoothed over whatever differences he encountered
with the Pope. During the German occupation of Rome, Kircher states that Weizsäcker sent Berlin
the welcome news that the Pope had decided to say nothing about the roundup of Rome's Jews.
Later in the occupation, Weizsäcker said in a message that the Pope is working six days a week
for Germany, and on the seventh day he prays for the Allies. And also, perhaps Hitler, knowing he
was losing the war, knowing that the Pope sought to be a peacemaker, thought that the Pope might
still be useful by easing their final fates. Kircher reports, in Berlin, the end was nearing
for Hitler and the men around him. But his propaganda minister, Joseph Goebbels, still
clung to the slender hope that the Vatican might play a role to save them. And another possible
reason why Hitler chose to simply withdraw the German forces from Rome is that Pope Pius XII
tried to avoid making waves during his pontificate. The speeches of Pope Pius XII were not remarkable
for their inspiring oratory, nor were they remarkable for their clarity. Rather, as Kircher
puts it so wonderfully, his sermons were remarkable for their length and his ability to scatter
nuggets that both sides would be able to point at to support their cause. While government elites in
London, Rome, and Berlin complained behind closed doors about the papal phrases they
deemed pleasing to their enemies, both Axis and Allied governments worked tirelessly to promote
the public impression that the Pope was on their side. Now Kircher reports, as far as we can tell
from the Vatican archives, Pope Pius XII never seriously considered excommunicating either
Hitler or Mussolini, who were both nominally Catholic. But the Nazi leadership showed some
concern that he might. Now if the Pope had excommunicated Hitler, he would likely have
been thrown into a cattle car heading for Auschwitz when the Nazis occupied Rome.
With the hindsight available to historians, Kircher does ask some pointed questions. He asks,
The speed with which the whole apparatus of Italian fascism crumbled when the king
deposed Mussolini in mid-1943, with barely a peep of public protest, shows how tenuous
the Duce's hold was on the Italian people in the end. What would have happened if the Pope
had denounced Italy's impending entry into the war in 1940, and had denounced the constant use
the fascists were making of church authority in justifying their demonization of the Jews?
How many of the men who murdered Jews, or helped round them up to be sent to their deaths,
saw themselves as good Catholics? And perhaps the best answer to many of these questions is
simply to observe that when the Cardinals selected a new Pope after the passing of Pope
Pius XI, they chose to select a Pope that had never been a pastor, a Pope that had been a
diplomat all his working career. For all his faults, and he has many, Pope Pius XII was
unquestionably the most able diplomat in the World War II era. You can question his moral
convictions, but he never showed fear when confronting evil. In our other videos, we
reflected on the secret back-channel setup between Hitler and Pope Pius XII in the beginning of his
pontificate, and how the experiences of the Catholic Church affected the proceedings and
decrees of the Second Vatican Council, called less than two decades after the end of the Second World
War. Some of our slides featured photos of the Miami Beach Holocaust Memorial, and you can view
these photos at our Flickr page. The YouTube description includes a link to our PowerPoint
script that we uploaded to SlideShare, and also our blog. And please consider becoming a patron
of our channel. Plus, you can click on the Meetup or small M icon to participate in our online
discussions, where we practice our future YouTube scripts. And please click on the links for other
videos that will broaden your knowledge and improve your soul.

