This Couldn’t Possibly Work… Could It? | Fan Show Down Episode 5

Tech Lover
46 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 20, 2022
The day is finally upon us. It is episode five of the Fan Showdown. It's been,
uh, it's been some time, a couple weeks since episode four.
Uh, what have you guys been up to in the weeks prior to today? Well, um, spoiler, you guys have
been up to some pretty... things are getting a little outrageous, but, uh, I think that's warranted.
And we got some cool stuff over here. So let's just get right into it. If you're not familiar
with this series, essentially you guys out there are sending me your designs for fans that I'm
going to put on this little test bench made from an A12X25 body. And, uh, the goal here is to try
to make a better fan or a better performing fan than an A12X25. I've been trying it. You guys have
been trying it. Today's episode five. I got four more fans and let's get into seeing who is the
best and if anybody is better. So the first fan we got here, this is made by Dave. This is called
the F1 and the inspiration for this fan from what he has told me is, uh, basically the rear wing of
an F1 car. Now I'm not too familiar with an F1 car. Let's take a look here. Yeah, I see, I see
where he's going. So essentially you got a double, uh, double airfoil here. You got an inner ring and
an outer ring. You got 15 blades. Well, essentially you got 30 because you got 15 and then another 15
underneath it. And what I found most interesting about this, so you got this outer, outer ring and
a mid ring. And if you look closely at the outer ring, you got a little bit of a lip there, somewhat
like, uh, the rear spoiler in F1 car. And what is really cool about it is when you put it into the
fan body that kind of wraps around the, the frame itself. So hopefully, uh, the idea there is to help
guide the flow into the fan better and maybe produce better cooling. Either way, he did a
pretty good job. Now, sound wise, I won't say it's the quietest. Uh, if you watched the video from
yesterday, we did some over-volting of the A12X25 and, um, it got pretty loud. This one also pretty loud
at 0.3 meters. So I measured all these fans at 0.3 meters with the dB meter. This one came in
at about 44.6. But when I ran the smoke test to see how the airflow was looking through this bad boy,
it works. It does a good job of funneling the air into the fan, pushing it through the radiator,
out the back. And from what I can tell, I suspect that this is going to do a pretty decent job at
cooling. Will it do better than the old Noctua here? I'm not sure, but I think Dave's on the
right track. Next up. Now, given the current launch from NVIDIA, or I guess it just launched,
this one's pretty cool. This is the RTX 3080 fan. This was designed by Kevin. And obviously the
inspiration for this fan was the top fan on the 3080. Now, he did say he doesn't have a 3080.
I think it's pretty obvious at this point, unless you're a bot, you don't own one. So this was a
pretty good rendition of the 3080 fan, just looking at pictures on the old internet. And I think he
executed it pretty well. The only issue I had with this fan is when I was printing it, the blades are
so thin. They're literally pretty much one layer line thick. They're just so thin that
the printer had a real rough time keeping those layers together and then pulling the support off
as a little rough. But we got her to work, tried to minimize the damage as much as possible.
And in the end, I think he did a good job hitting what he intended. Obviously, this is a nine blade
design. And noise-wise, it wasn't any quieter than the F1 fan. It was actually louder. This one
clocked in at 45.7 at 0.3 meters. Flow-wise, did a great job, again, of pushing pulling the air
into the fan, pushing it through the radiator. I don't see any issues with this guy being able to
cool the radiator on our stress test, but it's just interesting to see how the the smoke flows
through the radiator from each and every one of these fans. Next up is a fan called the Acceleron.
This one's made by Thomas. It's a nine blade fan. And the inspiration for this one is, well,
nothing. He said there's really no inspiration for this. He was just kind of he just kind of
threw it together. He thought the the step up of the blades look kind of cool. It kind of reminds
me of like Tron for some reason. But again, an easy print. The blades are thick, support easily
detached. Really no problems printing this fan. And it's very interesting looking.
Sound-wise, it was actually one of the more quiet ones. This one came in at 42.5 dBs at 3.3
millimeters, 0.3 meters. The quietest of the bunch so far. Flow-wise, it did an excellent job pulling
the air into the fan, pushing it through the radiator. As you can see, no turbulence to speak
of. Looks pretty smooth. Should do a pretty decent job of cooling our little 7700K. And then we have
somebody that's going by the name Anonymous. And I don't know why I chose to go by Anonymous. Maybe
it is anonymous. I don't know. Either way, this is what he sent me. This fan he's calling the Tulip.
It's seven blades. But as you notice, it's quite tall. The seven blades rotate all the way up to
the top. And if you look in the middle, there's like a little helix. Well, I guess it's like
another seven tinier blades spiraling down in the opposite way in the middle. Now, he said that's
just for support of the main blades and to kind of help the air maybe funnel better into the center,
I guess. But all I know is it looks sweet. And he said he doesn't think this will work.
In his point of view, this was just to see how ridiculous he could possibly make a fan,
which I would say you succeeded on. Noise-wise, other than a slight vibration of the seven blade
spiral design, it wasn't super loud. Came in around 42.5. The coolest part was, though,
when I bust out the old smoke machine. If you remember when I made the,
well, what was it called? DaVinci air screw fan. It kind of threw air all over the place. But this
guy did exactly as intended. The center seemed to help pull air into the core. And it did more
pushing than it did throwing. It didn't throw much smoke out the sides. It was able to actually
push the smoke through the radiator. And being how substantial it is, I was pretty surprised.
So, here are your contenders. The four new fans for episode five. How do you think,
how do you think they fared? Especially, especially over here. I think you're going
to be surprised. So, we'll start in last place of this group. We'll just talk about who did
the worst. You still did better than Bryce, though. Remember that. But who did, who got fourth
place? Well, fourth place might surprise you, but it belongs to Dave and the F1 fan. Now,
this actually surprised me. I thought that this one would do better given how nice it fit within
the fan blades or in the fan shroud and how well the blades came out. But it was not to be. The
average temperature of the F1 fan was 80.6, giving it a delta of 60.1, putting Dave in fourth place
out of these four fans. Rest in peace, Dave. I'm sorry. Your design was an A plus, but performance
wise, we'll give you a B. Third place then. That belongs to Kevin. Kevin's 3080 fan managed to
hammer out third place, which again is kind of surprising. I would have thought it would do
a little better than that given how thin the blades were. Well, obviously, I thought it would
do better than this one, so this is already weird to me. But Kevin's 3080 fan finished with an
average temperature of 79.6, giving it a delta of 59.5, putting him in a solid third place.
So, now we're down to two. Two of the most unlikely ones. This one was designed based on
3080. This one was designed based on an F1 wing. This one was just kind of thrown together based
on what Thomas said. And then this one was just made to see how ridiculous he could make a fan.
And here we go.
