Who Made This, SpaceX? | Fan Show Down Episode 7

Tech Lover
46 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 20, 2022
Okay, so hopefully
Hopefully I get the lights set up a little better because let's be honest the last video. I did look like a dead person
but um
I kind of did some a little bit more research on how this should be set up. So
Let me know. Okay, but
Today we're going to talk about everybody's favorite little series the fan showdown
I think I got four more guys for us to look at and see if anybody can uh
I don't know get a deal like uh, mr. Like thomas did I mean who knows?
So let's just get right into it
This one right here is called the golden ratio and it was made by adam and his inspiration said well
He said it was the golden ratio and this is another one of those fans that he said took him 30 minutes
To design and we all know what happens
When somebody designs a fan in 30 minutes, they go pro. So this one might have
Uh an epic chance to be one of the better fans we've seen and if you know anything about the golden ratio
um
That's what the design is. I think nautilus shell
I guess if you don't know what it is, i'll put a video in the description from uh
Somebody that I watched that does a really good job describing it
But anyway, there it is golden ratio and he was hoping that the springy design
so if you kind of look at the hub here, it's kind of hard to see but
uh when you
It just it just moves around the fan blades since they bend so much kind of act like a shock absorber in a sense
And it it gives it a little bit of movement and his idea
He knew that that was going to happen. His idea there was that that little bit of movement might make the fan sound
quieter and when I ran the db test
Uh, this one was actually quite quiet and the sound was a nice low pitched hum and it was
It was really almost not even noticeable. So you nailed the the sound the acoustics that you're going for you nailed it
then it was time to you know, plug in the old fog machine and see how the flow the flow worked on this guy and
Nothing really dramatic everything flowed into the fan very well
Looked like it was maintaining a good static pressure pulling the air in and pushing it out as you would expect it to
while doing it pretty quietly, so
Hopeful that this thing would actually perform pretty well on our radiator
Now you guys are going to be proud of me because this time around since it's becoming fall and I can keep the windows
Open and the heat out
I was able to keep the room temperatures a lot more stable than I normally
Can and hopefully when I finally get to move down into the basement after the renovation is done
That won't be a problem anymore, but for now
Everything was pretty stable
So for the golden ratio fan the room temperature was 20.3 degrees and it finished with an average of 82.2
Giving us a delta
Of 61.9. Now, is that good?
Well, if you remember any of the other videos the the past series, you know that that's not the best but when it comes
to these four fans
Who knows now this next one though?
This one actually is kind of cool because if you watched my previous video the one where I look like a dead body
uh, actually another one before that where we ran the big giant fan that I
I basically had printed this large fan and I wanted to power it up and during a printer review
We did that and it exploded very awesomely
Oh my god
But the idea was it was a model of the rolls royce trent series and that's what this is
This is called the major trent the designer's name is leonardo and his inspiration was
Obviously the rolls royce and he did a good job now
He said that you know, it's not perfect to the actual engine, but
I get what he's going for and I don't know why but these big old
Spinners on the front when when you put that on a fan
It looks cool now
I get why they don't do it for production fans because you couldn't really go
A pole configuration with a giant spinner on the front, but I I don't know. I like it
It just adds an aesthetic that I find pleasing. However
Noise wise it was pretty loud. It was literally
I mean if he was going for the jet engine look he also nailed the jet engine sound because this thing racked up an amazing
45.7 db
Uh, you wouldn't call it pleasing to say the least now in the fog test though
Did really well the the spinner kind of funneled air around the hub of the motor
Pulled air in and pushed it out just as you expected nice close blades many of them
So you're thinking that it's you know
You would think that this would put out a nice
Nice bit of static pressure and do very well in the cooling test
Now the room temperature did bump up a little bit to 20.5
But our average temperature finished out at 81.7 giving us a delta of 61.2
So slightly better than the golden ratio, but still not not the best when we think back to the other fans
We've seen in this series, but looks wise
I like it. I really like how it looks with this pla this nice, uh, the nice blue sparkle
I like the big hub. I don't know why but I do and
All in all
If I had to choose which one I wanted to run on my machine
I think I would take this one so far now these next two fans
Are going a little bit above and beyond they uh, not only wanted to make a fan
they wanted to
Make other components to go with it
Which is kind of exciting and it was fun for me to test out because I see where they're going
I see what they're going for. So this next fan is called the ducted fan and right here
It just looks like a regular three-bay flan
three blade fan
Not much to it pretty standard simple blades simple hub
Not very many of them
But you also got this
Now the designer behind this one's name's rob and his uh idea or inspiration behind this was that
He thinks there's a lot of performance left on the table because everybody's you know, trying to design fans, but they're not really considering
The the flow of air into the fan so he thinks that improving the case form will actually give him better performance
And that's what he he did with this ring. So you might notice that it's it's a little rough and that's because
uh, I tried to
Give it a little bit of a sanding to kind of smooth it out because after
With the support material that wasn't really liking to come off there
and I didn't want it to be super rough because that would kind of
Negate the whole reason for having it. So I smoothed it out a bit. It kind of ruined the aesthetics, but
It did smooth it out a little bit noise wise though that that's where it gets interesting three blades
Is going to be loud. It's it's going to have a choppy
helicopter type sound and that's what it sounded like now surprisingly the
The output the sound output at the same distance as like say the major trent which was pretty loud
It was a little quieter at 44.6, but the trent was a higher pitch sound
Where this was a more low?
Wop wop wop like a I don't know it literally sounds kind of like a regular fan
uh, and I found it to
It was perceived to me at least to be louder even though it actually shows a lower dba. So that was weird
um, but the interesting part was when I hooked up the fog machine to see if this shroud was actually doing what he hoped it would
And you know when you stand back and you kick it on it looks like it's doing a really good job of pulling air into
The fan and pushing it through the radiator
But when you get real close up to the bottom and you just kind of look at the the the lip of this duct he made
It's working so you can see that the smoke
Comes across the table and then you can see it start whipping around
the edge of the duct and picking up speed as it moves into the fan, so
He aimed to create a duct to improve airflow and he succeeded even though it was quite loud
Cooling wise though was actually impressive as well
The room temperature this time around was 20.2
And the average the ducted fan showed was 80.4 giving it a delta of 60.2
Now in the grand scheme of things between the fans we've already discussed. That's pretty good now overall versus every fan that's ever been on the show
not so good, but
I'll give them props for going going above and beyond concluding a fan and a duct that worked together very well
Uh didn't have any interference issues when I printed out it hooked up well fit into the fan
