This 120mm Fan BREAKS All The Rules!

Tech Lover
46 followers
15 Video Views·Oct 20, 2022
Well, welcome back.
It's time to do some fan testing.
Actually, all this mini quad race fan thing type deal here
made me want to bust out the mini quad
and try it out again.
It's been like two years since I flew that thing.
It didn't go too bad,
except for like my transmitter had some connection issues,
as you've seen, but everything,
nothing broke, surprisingly, and it was fun.
But now we're back to business
and it might look like we're going hunting today,
but we're actually gonna go hunting for performance.
This video is brought to you by Get In Light.
As someone who has under cabinet lighting,
I can tell you there's two ways of doing it.
You can do it the super sketchy way, like I did,
or you can do it the professional way, which I recommend.
Get In Light offers professional
three color LED under cabinet lights
that can be controlled via integrated switch
or even hardwired.
Out of the box, Get In Light under cabinet lights
have two brightness settings
or can be dimmed down to 10% power
from most standard wall box dimmer switches.
Get In Lights come in two colors, six sizes,
and can be linked together with included linking cable.
The 24 inch model that I have here retails for 99.90.
So if you have a dark and dingy kitchen,
pick up some Get In Lights under cabinet lights
at the link in the description below.
You might've seen this one in the community tab.
This is my nine blade design for my fan,
but you know, I got to thinking,
what's the fun in testing one out?
Let's test a few, but nine blades,
cause the Noctua's nine blades.
Then this is a bit more aggressive on the blade angle.
And this is a three blade.
Hopefully this will maybe push more air,
less load on the motor, cause I'm not sure.
Heat wise, I did put some ventilation in there,
but things get pretty toasty.
And then this one's just for fun.
This is 30 blades.
It's basically a disc, but it looks awesome.
The blade angle's a little less aggressive
than the nine blade.
They are smaller, thinner.
It's basically meant to look like a high bay,
like the high bypass fan on a jet engine.
And that's kind of what it does look like.
But we're going to run this, see how it does.
And then we're going to, well,
I don't even know if this will make air move,
but either way, it'll be cool.
And the idea here, so you can see,
I have the anemometer shroud out,
and I know Bernoulli and his principles and whatnot,
but this is all I have and I haven't made anything new yet.
So we're going to use it.
And as long as I guess we use every fan on the same shroud,
we can at least compare and contrast between the fans
to get like an idea of which one's performing, how good.
So we're going to use this to measure wind speed,
so we can get the CFM of each one of these fans.
And we're also going to measure noise.
And I don't have an awesome DB meter,
but I do have a phone.
So that's as good as it's going to get.
But we're going to see how loud this one is
versus these three designs.
And then, you know, after we have an idea how they perform,
we're going to throw them on the D15
and see how they cool an actual PC.
Now this only runs at 2000.
I don't know if we can get that motor to run that slow,
but we'll get it to run as slow as we can.
And we'll see how they level out.
And then when it's all said and done,
maybe we'll just run them full on and see how they cool.
Or if they explode, like this one.
This one's got a lot of mass on the outside.
I did have one break.
As you can see, I did some testing
of different blade counts, designs,
widths, thicknesses, pitches.
Things didn't always go according to plan.
But it was sweet.
So now these are all, these are all gone.
We don't care about those.
Let's test these.
Okay, so we got, we have our baseline down now.
We have an airspeed of 3.3 meters per second,
which translates into a CFM of 23.2,
given this duct diameter.
Noise levels of 62 dBs.
The average room was 45,
so we're just gonna use that as our base.
Then, you know, what it got.
So 62 for the Noctua.
And RPMs were 2065.
So now it's time to get down to business.
So we're gonna start with the nine blade.
So we gave it a little bit more space around the shroud now,
so hopefully we're not having any issues.
I'm gonna bolt it in,
and see how low of an RPM we can run this thing.
So here we go, contact.
Let's see what we can get RPM wise.
Might be it.
Sit rep, this is not gonna work for CFM readings.
It just doesn't, it's not accurate.
I did use it as like a noise test branch,
so I'll do CFMs basically.
I'm just gonna hold the thing behind it,
and we'll have to find a way to hold this thing shut.
But before we get there,
doesn't that look like a little jet engine?
I think it looks cool.
When I was doing the noise readings though,
I did notice that most of the noise on this setup
comes from the mini quad motor.
Let's see if we can pick it up for you guys.
So I don't know if you guys hear that well,
but it's mostly a whine.
It's from the motor itself.
The blades aren't really,
the blades aren't really that loud.
The 30 blade is the quietest.
But it's mostly, it's just mostly whine from the motor.
But let's find a way to measure the CFMs.
Let's talk some numbers real quick
before we get to cooling stuff.
So after running everything,
I can just show you all the numbers here right now.
The best performer was the three blade.
Also it's the noisiest, but it does move the most air.
This thing, it didn't really move much,
but it looked the coolest.
Looked like a little jet engine.
So now we know where they kind of sit.
Let's see how they cool.
So we'll start off by getting a baseline
with wherever that fan is, there it is.
We'll get a baseline with this guy on our D15.
And then we'll run each one of these blades designs.
We'll first just start out with half throttle,
see how they all perform.
And then we'll just keep going up and up and up
and see if we can run at full speed
or if we break before then.
But first we'll run half,
we'll give it a little half throttle
just so we at least get some numbers.
And then we'll have some fun.
Preliminary scores are in.
And well, they didn't do too bad.
I'll put them on the screen so you guys can see.
But now it's time to step it up a notch.
We're gonna start with a three blade
because I think that this one's gonna do the best.
Now, what do you guys think?
Do you guys think this is gonna do the best
or just let me know in the comments
if you think this is gonna do the best.
Don't be cheating.
Make sure you go down there now,
leave your answer before we run these tests.
But here we go.
We're gonna start with this one, like I said, half stick.
We'll see which blade design does the best.
And then we're gonna take that one
and try to get the max performance.
So here we go.
Before we get started,
I make these models available for everybody.
So if you're gonna do this,
just know that it's not really recommended
to put high speed, spinning, unstable things
in your computer because they could possibly break
and break everything around them.
So just know that going in,
if you're gonna try this, that bad things could happen.
But if you don't wanna try it, I'll do it for you.
All right, that looks like half throttle.
All right, so half speed is about 9,000 RPM.
We'll see how that does.
I don't know how loud that sounds, but it's not quiet.
No, not at all.
It's cool though.
Like, well, it's cool looking, but it's also cool.
Just in case you're wondering,
my phone says it's about 78 decibels,
just right here, about a foot away.
All right, so one survived.
Now let's try the nine blade.
So the motor's surprisingly cool.
It's a good thing.
So here's our nine blade.
You guys have already seen it, but I think it looks cool.
Look, they all look cool.
Quick change blades, patent pending.
All right.
All right, that one's done.
It sounded a little louder.
Now it's time for this guy.
I don't even know if it'll cool anything,
but it looks like a jet.
Aw, I guess I should've tightened
that screw up a little tighter.
This one didn't seem to be as balanced as the other ones,
but well, it got a zero.
It looked cool, but zero.
Where'd my nuts go?
So out of the blades that did finish,
let's see which one did the best.
The A12X25 had an average temperature of 59.1,
max temperature of 65.
The three blade design had 57.2 for an average,
max temperature of 64.
And the nine blade had an average of 57.4
and a max of 64.
So the three blade did a little bit better.
The 30 blade, well, you've seen how that went.
Anyway, let's put the three blade back on there
and crank it up.
See if it'll run full speed or if it'll pull a 30 blade.
Well, that was fun.
So as you can see, the blades, they never did separate.
I mean, this one did, but I think they end up breaking off
because it ran into something at high speed.
But it goes to show that you can make
some pretty cool 3D printed stuff
that can handle some pretty high centrifugal forces.
The problem that they can't handle is heat.
So that's kind of what happened here.
You can see that it slowly started to heat up the motor.
These EMAXs, you know, these red bottoms,
they get quite hot,
especially if you don't have good ventilation.
And, you know, I do, I try to put some ventilation in there,
but I can't really make them too much bigger
or we're gonna lose the integrity of the hub.
But it ran for, I don't know, a good three, four minutes
before it lost its shape, contracted the shroud,
and then the nut backed off,
and then it was all off to the races.
I didn't run this guy because I would assume that the,
you know, based on how the temperatures did,
you wouldn't see much better out of this one
and then you'd end up destroying it.
And I'm not gonna lie, I kind of like it.
So I'll leave that as like a little display.
But we did prove that you can take a 3D printer
and make a fan that does perform just as good
as a fan you could buy.
You know, yeah, it was really loud,
especially when it's running full out.
There's no way you could sit by that all day,
but half throttle was still loud.
Wouldn't want to be next to that, but it does work.
And that's all that really matters.
We just proved that it worked.
It was fun to try.
And, you know, if you have some of these red bottoms,
this is the RS2205 from Emax.
I'll put these models on my Thingiverse account
so you can download, you know, the 30 blade,
the nine blade, the three blade.
You can even make your own.
Somebody did ask if I'd make a little video
on how to design fan blades,
and I'll throw that out there in the coming week or so
just so you guys can get an idea
if you're using some sort of 3D modeling software
to make blades on your 3D printer.
I'll just give you a little tutorial on how I do it
and maybe it'll help you out.
Somebody asked if I could do that, so that'll be coming.
If you have any other ideas
on things you want to make spin really fast
that can cool things or do really anything,
let me know in the comments down below
because we'll check them out.
But in a nutshell, we made a better fan.
Not a quieter fan, but a better one.
Until next time.
