Artificial Gravity is Critical for Mars Exploration & Beyond - SpaceX Starship can make this happen!

Tech Level
93 followers
32 Video Views·Oct 18, 2022
This video is supported by CuriosityStream.
Hey hey, Marcus House with you here. Today something a little different for a change.
So many of you asked me to talk more about artificial gravity systems, and really up until
now with the cost of mass to orbit being so high, it always seemed like something that was incredibly
far down the track. With Starship soon being able to shoot massive components to orbit at super low
cost, this kind of changes the game at that point. Ideas that seem absurd start to become plausible
if you can send stuff to orbit orders of magnitude cheaper than we can right now. But why do this,
and is it really as critical as others make it out to be? You might be surprised.
The price to launch the SLS and Artemis is estimated at 4.1 billion dollars at the extreme
side of things. That of course includes the Orion spacecraft. The payload to low earth orbit of SLS
Block 1 is around 95 tons or so. Falcon 9 is considerably lower, costing around 67 million
or so for a little over 20 tons. Then we have Starship aiming to be able to hurl in excess of
100 tons into low earth orbit on their fully reusable vehicle. The cost for that is not yet
totally clear, but well down the track perhaps it could be between 5 to 10 million dollars. Elon Musk
of course has suggested even lower in the past, so it remains to be seen how cheap that cost could
become compared to today. A benefit often glossed over though is the payload area. Nine meters wide
brings some significant advantages and it is just the sort of benefit that could make it plausible
to create vehicles like this. The very harmful effects of long-term space travel are well known
thanks to the International Space Station and the decades of research. Huge effort in studying the
various effects that microgravity has on these human bodies evolved and optimized for 1G. You
can also jump into this other video here to get to know a little bit more about other such harmful
side effects when traveling on longer duration missions. The link is in the description for that,
but today we are talking about the G-forces or lack thereof. Living in microgravity for a very
long period of time is very hard on these human bodies. Not only does it take a lot of time to get
used to, just think of things like nausea alone among other symptoms, there is a load of related
health issues to worry about. Progressive bone loss, cardiovascular deconditioning, and a rapid
decrease in muscle mass will all eventually leave humans with long-term damage. This has been proven
time and time again with the extensive microgravity research done on the International
Space Station. Now we can create artificial gravity right? I mean these concepts here have
been around for decades. 2001 a space odyssey helped teach us that, but the idea of creating
artificial gravity got its start way back in the 19th century. These proposed space stations that
rotate to create a simulated G-force. These concepts were published decades later with
schools of young scientists actually working on making artificial gravity a reality. Even
creating cultural defining science fiction works such as those by Arthur C. Clarke. The science
side of this is particularly intriguing and although not the main focus of this video,
it is interesting to touch on just a little. Einstein's equivalence principle demonstrated
that artificial gravity was not only possible, but if done right, can be indistinguishable from
gravity that we feel here on earth. And this gave us two possible ways to create that artificial
G-force. The first one is linear acceleration. This involves continually accelerating a spacecraft in
one direction which will result in objects inside the spacecraft being forced in the opposite
direction. If we had a vehicle fuel efficient enough to constantly accelerate at exactly 1g or
9.8 meters per second squared for the first half of the journey, followed by decelerating at 1g
for the other half after flipping the vehicle around, an entire trip to mars could be done
in simulated earth gravity. It seems pretty simple right? So why don't we just do that?
Well this method requires the engines to be firing throughout most of the journey. Engines that are
absurdly fuel efficient and we simply don't have that yet. That is why we love to watch science
fiction shows like The Expanse which has a fictional technology called the Epstein drive.
Just as a thought experiment, a spacecraft that could constantly accelerate at 1g would be able
to travel from earth to mars in just a matter of two to four days. Another side note, if you could
keep accelerating at 1g you could reach relativistic speed in about a year and you would have already
traveled over half a light year. It is just amazing what we could achieve with this technology
but yes I'm sorry to disappoint you there is no such propulsion method yet and chemical propulsion
places massive limits on the amount of fuel that we can carry. Now although artificial gravity tech
of this nature is an exciting sci-fi dream, it's neither feasible or of course efficient. You have
to spend a lot of fuel just to slow down. Saying that, some concepts such as this nuclear pulse
vehicle rendered beautifully here by Hayes Grayart could provide amazing opportunities. Project Orion
as an example was a study of a ship intended to be directly propelled by a series of mini atomic
explosions. These tiny bombs would be ejected behind the vehicle detonating in a precisely
timed manner which would propel the spacecraft forward. I don't know maybe you would like to see
me make a video more dedicated to this sort of thing as it is interesting. Anyway although this
constantly accelerating vehicle could become viable at some point, we have a long way to go.
Now the second way to generate the needed g-force and the main focus of this video
is using centrifugal force. This method achieves the required g-forces by having the living areas
rotating around a central part of the ship. All perfectly balanced of course. A common idea is a
huge rotating disc. Think Hermes from the Martian. A terrific movie if you haven't seen that one.
The centripetal acceleration generated by the circular motion results in that centrifugal
force that produces the same sense of g-force as we feel here on earth. There is a little caveat
here though. The closer you are to the center the faster your habitation area would need to spin to
create the artificial gravity and the more disorienting it would be. Think of being in
something like the Air Force Research Laboratory's centrifuge which is designed to simulate up to 9g.
Even spinning slowly in a tight circle is going to make you feel quite dizzy. This is why many of
the designed proposals are so large especially if you are trying to simulate 1g. Now I could go into
all of the math about why that is but essentially you want as little variance between the gravity
you feel from your head to your feet. If you love the math behind all of this I couldn't do a better
job than this video here by Real Engineering. A link to that is below if you want to check that
out later. Anyway the shorter the radius the more dizzy it's going to make you feel right?
That is the point. One of the first real experiments to achieve artificial gravity
was performed by the Gemini 11 mission in 1966. They used a similar spin technique to what we are
discussing right now. The Gemini 11 spacecraft crew connected their capsule to the Agena booster
with a 30 meter tether. Crew used the engines to put the vehicle into a slow spin and that
rotation rate was only around 0.15 revolutions per minute which is a tiny g-force effect but
were they successful? Well yes but the cabin and its crew experienced a g-force less than 0.001g.
Nowhere near the significant effect that we want but hey it was at least a good proof of concept.
To reach 1g using a similar setup you would need to be spinning at five and a half rotations per
minute. Now here is a similar interesting concept by Small Stars. It uses three SpaceX Starships.
Two on either end and one in the middle called the Gravity Link Starship which as the name suggests
uses these very long rigid metallic trusses to connect to the Starships. This entire structure
could spin to create the required g-force. The radius of this is about 100 meters long so this
design can achieve 1g by rotating about three rotations per minute. Now the problem with such a
system is that the operational logistics are so complex. For example to make a course correction
you need to stop everything spinning, make your corrections and then start everything back up again.
So we humans are working towards this on a much larger more useful scale though right? Well I've
had a bunch of you over the last few months requesting that I talk all about this Gateway
Spaceport Vera Station. More on that shortly but a big thank you to CuriosityStream today
for supporting this video. I am super lucky to have great brands like CuriosityStream working
with me because their content acts as a great source of supplementary information that works
well with topics just like this. CuriosityStream is a subscription streaming service that offers
thousands of award-winning documentaries. Take this video here called Touching the Sun.
Our star can erupt at any moment ejecting out vast waves of charged particles not only towards
Earth that could leave millions of people without power but it could also be devastating for any
future crewed or uncrewed spacecraft. Covered beautifully here, CuriosityStream dives into
great information on NASA's Parker Solar Probe, the first ever mission to touch the sun by dipping
into the outer atmosphere. This probe continues to provide amazing data flying through dangerous
radiation getting closer and closer with each pass. The next such flyby should be in August
next year having flown past its perihelion 12 times already. If everything continues to go to
plan it is going to make 24 passes total. There is a lot to learn here and I've been a subscriber
to CuriosityStream myself for several years and there is just so much to check out. Not just the
great space content that we all obviously love but loads of stuff on travel, history, nature,
science, and technology. It is all here and you can stream this incredible content worldwide on
all of your devices anytime. Just head to curiositystream.com slash marcushouse and
you can sign up for access for less than $20 a year. Yep, the entire year. The link for that
is in the description. Thank you CuriosityStream. So yes, here is the Gateway spaceport which can
be built in only six months. Wow! This gigantic circular space station multiple times the size
of the International Space Station. It is designed to simulate adequate g-forces to support long-term
human habitation and it can accommodate over 1,200 people. The outer ring alone has a diameter of 224
meters or 735 feet. That is incredible right? Well, most of the time when things seem a little
too good to be true they kind of are. There isn't a lot of fine detail in this video but from what
we can tell this concept is inspired by the Von Braun space station. That was designed as a 76 meter
or a 250 foot wide vehicle. Now something really quite interesting discussed in the Gateway
spaceport concept is the automated construction machines. They are presented to collectively build
the majority of the space station in this automated way. This proposed panel construction would take
plates for the hull with Whipple shielding included and join them together to create the
main torus structure. A Whipple shield by the way has got two layers. A bumper and a rear wall. That
is because you want a small impact to disintegrate on the outer wall and then harmlessly expand into
a cloud of fragments and vapor before it hits the inner wall. That can then be deflected much easier.
Anyway, I digress there. The point is that these panels would need to be delivered in mass by a
like SpaceX's Starship. Then these magical robots would electron beam weld them all together at some
astonishing rate. Each unit here being driven electrically with huge batteries. All of a sudden
presto an airtight ring station right? Well there is a bunch of stuff not really shown.
For starters where are the solar panels? This station and the construction is going to need
one heck of a lot of power. Then you also have the huge problem of solar radiation heating the
entire structure up constantly. The International Space Station just as an example has enormous
radiators that are there to remove that waste heat. Finally there is really no funding model
for this. They call out for investors here along with having this odd sort of gateway lottery idea
aiming to create direct funding for construction. So yeah it's kind of weird right? I mean I like
that we are seeing ideas of this presented as concepts but this is currently lacking the
funding model and a lot of technical detail. Perhaps information that will soon be added but
it's hard to go much deeper on it at this point. So is that it? Will artificial gravity space
stations forever be a thing of dreams and science fiction? Well you might be surprised how much
simpler it could actually be. Take a look at this. This is a conceptual spacecraft designed by NASA
called Discovery 2 rendered beautifully by the talented Phragomatic. There's loads of animations
like this right there. So this concept was designed to deliver a 172 ton payload including crew from
earth to Jupiter in 118 days. It has this rotating habitat system that gives a sense of gravity to
the crew. Furthermore it has an initial mass in low earth orbit of around 1690 metric tons.
With Starship being able to deliver around 100 tons to orbit at a time it will actually be even
more feasible to build such a space station than ever. In this case 17 launches or less to get this
gigantic mass into orbit. Considering a launch price of 10 million dollars per flight launching
this entire vehicle could cost around 170 million dollars and just to put that into some perspective
here it took 10 years and 40 flights to fully assemble the international space station.
36 of those were space shuttle flights each costing NASA a much larger 450 million dollars.
Yep you are seeing that right. Just the space shuttle flights alone tallied 16 billion dollars
of the station's 150 billion dollar price tag. Thanks to Starship and SpaceX we might finally
be able to reduce launch costs to a tiny fraction of what it used to be and with that it brings hope
that something like Discovery 2 can be practical in the future. Even the concept of Discovery 2
though is delving a little bit into the category of sci-fi. Though there are a lot of other designs
incorporating artificial gravity take a look at this one. This is NASA's Nautilus X, a space
vehicle estimated to be built with 3.7 billion dollars and 64 months of work. This craft could
take us to the moon, mars, or any mission within 24 months of flight time. It has inflatable modules,
solar arrays, any number of mission-specific propulsion modules, a manipulator arm, and even
docking ports for Orion or commercial spacecraft like SpaceX's Dragon. Most importantly for this
video a habitat ring that would simulate partial g-force to maintain the health of the crew. It is
worth noting that it would not be a full 1g but instead a smaller portion that is just enough
to keep humans safer than a typical microgravity setup. Here is another interesting design again
animated by Phragmatic. This is the Alpha Leo station conceptualized by NEA Mines Group.
It is of course designed to assist with asteroid mining operations. This one just stays in low
earth orbit and acts as a base. A habitable module here is spun around providing the needed g-force.
100 meters for the radius of this one which would provide a much better experience with
that simulated gravity. The entire structure though stands around 700 meters tall. It is
absolutely colossal but what it can't do is travel. So what about something that can travel?
Something that is practical today without any fancy technology or colossal mass to orbit
requirements. There must be a starting point somewhere right? Well what about a design like
called Copernicus B. A very simple vehicle with the crew up on one end and the fuel and
the propulsion way down the other. There is no need for a big ring on this one. We just spin
the entire vehicle. This rocket is around 84 meters in length so smaller than the international
space station and the center of gravity allows for a rotation radius at around 35 meters. Spinning
this a little above 5 rpm would provide a full 1g. That could take a bit of getting used to but
we don't always need a full 1g. Spinning at around 3 rpm would provide around 0.38 g. That is Mars
gravity and it would be much more comfortable. The great thing about this idea is that Copernicus
B could provide one full g for half of the trip from Earth to Mars and then the spin speed can
be reduced to get the crew slowly accustomed to Mars gravity in the last month or so before arriving
at the planet. This is just brilliant as it significantly helps the crew in adjusting and
training to operate on Mars. The mission itself then becomes much more productive too. They don't
need to spend time on the surface needing to adjust to the different g-force. They can just
get on with it. Once the mission is over and they are returning home they could do the reverse
starting off at 0.38 g slowly increasing it to 1g over the trip to get the crew used to
the Earth gravity once again. This is a very simple solution for a reusable Mars transfer
vehicle. You would also need landers of course whether it be SpaceX's Starship or some other
future NASA delivered vehicle but all of this is very plausible. Copernicus is relatively easy to
build. There are just three components. The habitat area, the nuclear thermal propulsion system,
and the liquid hydrogen tank in the middle that can be dropped off once it's empty.
All of this can be taken to space by just three launches. What's more once it is ready to launch
it would only take six months or so to be constructed and it is ready to go. Now you
may have picked up on the nuclear thermal propulsion for this one. Now that is actually
not at all far-fetched and I've got a deep dive all about that along with other near future and
distant future propulsion methods. You may be very surprised how close we actually are
assuming that space agencies can get the approval to launch such technology. The link to that is
right here so do check that out. Now it is of course true that artificial gravity is not the
one magic solution that will solve all of the problems associated with long duration spaceflight.
One super important point to mention is that we as humans actually have zero data that proves
that we could actually live in partial gravity like we find on Mars for long periods of time.
In fact it's kind of always been assumed by me and probably most people that our bodies would
adapt quite fine but for all we know it could be equally as damaging for us to live on the surface
of Mars at 0.3 AG as it is for us to live in microgravity or anything in between. We just
don't know for sure. It's actually bewildering to me that we have never set up experiments in space
to explore this critical question over the last half century. I mean why? We've had plenty of time
and opportunity. Now there is one other even more serious problem and that is cosmic radiation
exposure. That is a problem that we don't even have adequate data to find a solution for let
alone an actual solution prepared. The more I learn about cosmic radiation the more I think
it needs to be talked about. Perhaps a video more dedicated for a future deep dive. Anyway if you
are new to this channel and this topic has earned your subscription a huge welcome to you and of
course thanks a heap for all of the many subscribers out there and those incredible
generous direct supporters watching all the way through this video too. You are all so awesome.
I'll be back on Saturday with the next video covering all of the great stuff going on during
the week. If you would like to help us directly patreon.com slash marcus house is the place to be
for ad-free versions of these video productions that will also have you hooked in with our great
group in discord. The merch links are below if you would like to pick up some new gear just like
this one. Also super helpful. If you enjoyed this video here are some other deep dive ones
if you haven't seen them. They aren't part of that news cycle so they continue to be very relevant.
Thanks again for watching and I'll see you in the next video.
