Ten Hag’s HUGE Clearout | Who Stays & Who Goes?

First Athletic
10 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 18, 2022
Right then I think this is a video that's going to stir some debate but it's one that we need to
have and I'd like you to get involved in the comments as well once I've finished
let me know which ones you agree with which ones you disagree with. This is a video where we're
going to look at the rebuild of Eric Ten Hag and it's who needs to stay and who needs to go. So
let's start with the very easy ones shall we? Who needs to go? Paul Pogba. Anyone disagree with that?
No one? No one? Yeah I didn't think so. So Paul Pogba, his foot is well and truly out of the
door at the moment. His dismissal has to be considered part of the cultural reset. The
circus that he brings has caused nothing but harm, undermining different managers, undermining the
club. United need to move beyond him. I can't convey my excitement when we signed him, what I
thought this would lead to. I was genuinely, genuinely, genuinely thrilled. As some of you
know I was there at the Lowry, I'd managed to jib my way into the Lowry the night he signed
and cuddled him and told him I was excited for him coming back. My son got a selfie with him,
had a brief conversation with him for about 15 seconds and just said you know I'm absolutely
delighted that you're back and it was genuine happiness and he said I'm so happy to be back,
I can't wait to get started and it never started. It never really started. There's been some good
moments and to say that they wouldn't be just big lies but it's been underwhelming and I think he
goes down as a massive flop of a transfer. Someone that we had on the books for free,
someone that we paid 90 million to return plus the wages over the last six years. It's a flop.
Cavani, one of the best terrorist songs in my life. Cult hero, looked like he loved
playing for the shirt whenever he turned up and actually played. Routinely injured,
heart isn't in England, had a terrible start with the misunderstanding over what he had
put on Instagram. If we'd have got him 10 years ago he would he would be a massive,
massive cult hero at United. A throwback number nine centre forward, just can't be arsed this year
for whatever reason, just does not want to play for us. I can almost not blame him but he needs
to go. If we can find someone that's just a younger version of him we need to snap him up straight
away but Cavani, gone. Lingard, he turns 30 this year. The best thing for him would have been to go
last year. He didn't for whatever reason, I was quite shocked at that. Then he was told he could
go in January and then he didn't for whatever reason, possibly the Mason Greenwood stuff
and he's stuck around and had a couple of substitute appearances since.
His wages are too high, he isn't a first team player, he would have been a decent squad player
if he'd have been utilised I think but forget it, it's not happened, move on, go play somewhere
else and enjoy your football. The spell he had at West Ham has shown what he's capable of
but he's not showing at United. Nemanja Matic, best centre mid, defensive midfielder of the club
but legs are shot. Well past his best at the moment, already confirmed that he's leaving.
We need to find again another younger version of him like we've got him and Cavani. Genuine
world-class players at one point in their career but it ain't now. So yeah, laters.
Juan Mata doesn't fit into the dynamic sort of footballing system that we're going to be playing
for sure. We need a system that's based on energy, dynamism, fitness, intensity and for as much as
Juan Mata brings, he doesn't bring those things. He's a big wage, he almost looks embarrassed to
play I would say at the moment even though I think he's actually looked pretty good when he
comes on lately. Will go down as a wonderful footballer. I can't believe how long he's
actually been at Old Trafford. Some sensational moments, lovely bloke but it's time now and that
is that. Bill Jones, he needs a new chapter, we need a new chapter. He's never going to take us
to the next level. Having him around I don't think represents anything positive for Manchester
United. He needs to go. A big wage off the bill, seriously unproductive as a centre-half because
he's just never available. We need to move beyond the sentiment and just say you're not fit for why
we need you so off you go, go and rebuild your career somewhere. Harry Maguire. Some people
obsessed with stats and progression, not fully understanding the different types of progression
that you can have as a centre-back. For some reason I've got a massive Harry Maguire fetish
but he's not a good defender. He's not a good 1v1 defender. He's a liability when he's played
high up. He doesn't scan enough, he's error prone. I think his confidence is also shot to ----.
Unfortunately the price of him means that it's going to be difficult to keep him on the bench
so I think the best thing for everyone involved would be to move him on.
Don't think he has the character to be a Manchester United player, certainly doesn't have the
character to be a Manchester United captain. If United want to win things you're not going to do
it with a player that's been relegated I think more than once. You need people who are proven
winners so move him on. Wamosaka, I think he has actually improved since he arrived but he's not
improved at a rate that justifies him being a £50 million signing that gets to stick around.
He's no longer first choice, he is a non-factor going forward. He's a target to be pressed,
he's a target in the air. He is more suited to a team that's going to sit back and defend
with their lives and I think his ceiling was found at Manchester United and it isn't
a Manchester United hype. So cut your losses on him and Maguire, it's going to be costly
but I think more costly if you kept them around. Luke Shaw, there's a reason once that Ragnicks
said he wasn't good enough for United. Jose Mourinho also said he wasn't good enough for United.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer preferred Brandon Williams over him and signed another left-back over him.
He's had one good six month in about eight years at the club. It's not good enough, it's absolutely
not good enough. He's talked like he doesn't love the game, he isn't built of the right stuff,
his decision making I think is awful and again because he's got good progression stats people
think he's a good footballer. He's a terrible footballer, he doesn't get beyond the edge of
the box. He's almost like he limits himself to working between the two boxes. He's always facing
our goal because he's never in the right position in the first place to deal with any threats that
are coming towards him. He's got a defensive instinct of a paper bag in the wind and I just
don't think he offers anywhere near enough and with the importance, same with Wan-Bissaka,
the importance of modern day full backs in the game, this isn't acceptable to have both of these
two playing at Manchester United. He's on a serious, serious wage. There's better out there.
Eric Bailly, I love chaos. Eric Bailly delivers chaos in buckets. He's never available, he's made
of glass. The best ability is availability, hence why Harry Maguire plays week in, week out.
You know, to give Harry some credit, he's actually bulletproof. He plays week in, week out.
The Eric Bailly experiment hasn't moved on. I like him. I think he's a good defender. I think
he's got a lot of good qualities but he can't stay fit. You've got to go. Too many injury prone
players and they never switch it around. Anthony Martial, does he deserve an opportunity
to redeem himself at United? Not for me. He went to Sevilla and all he had to do was impress for
six months and probably get himself a contract there and even they're sick of him. He's not
even got to the end of his six month yet. He's gone to Spain and not being able to put the ball
in the back of the net on a consistent basis. Two goals all season. He's probably one of United's
best chances at a transfer fee to recoup some of the money that we're definitely losing on
everybody else on this list. Sell him. And in all honesty, that's not everyone. I'm just trying to
keep this video under two hours long. There's others that I don't think are going to cut it.
I think you can probably only keep one of Garner, Levitt and Galbraith considering their age.
I don't think you can keep both Menge and Bernard on ice. I think some of them need
to probably be moved on as well. But who stays? Jadon Sancho. Massive investment last summer.
Started off poor. Has finished a bit stronger. Looks like he's probably now started to adapt
to the Premier League. You've got to remember he might be English. He's never played Premier
League football before. He has grown into his role. I think finding the correct role for him
and seeing how Tadic plays for Ajax, I think Sancho fits that bill very, very well.
Still got serious potential about him. Seems to have a pretty decent head on his shoulders.
I think he'll be fine. I think he'll be very suited to the style of play that
Tem Hage is going to bring and I think he'll be a star for us next season.
Rashford. I think he stays because I don't think United sell him.
I think that would be a massive PR and I know people are going to say everything about Marcus
is PR. It's not the case. I don't think United can sell him from a PR point of view because
it would be a massive kick in the teeth if one of the stars of our academy was to be moved on,
especially with the controversy surrounding one of the other stars of the academy at the moment.
His performances this season have been awful. I mean genuinely awful. We've seen half of the
players on this list have had more than one awful season at the club and people are still
fighting to keep them here. I'm going to put this down to the injuries for sure,
kick back over what's happened in the summer and the operation, but it can't continue.
By six, seven weeks into the season next year, Marcus Rashford needs to be back to the Marcus
Rashford that was putting 30 goals and assists down. Otherwise the writing's on the wall for
him as well. But everyone's allowed one bad season. People forget some of the seasons Ronaldo
had. People forget some of our best players have had really, really off seasons. People forget
Alan Shearer once scored like five Premier League goals. Drogba scored five Premier League goals.
People are allowed to go through a dip. It's can you come back from that though? This season has
been a one out of ten for Marcus. He's really been bad. His confidence looks gone. And the
difference between Marcus and Maguire, because some people are going to say Maguire's only had
one bad season. It's systematic. Marcus I think definitely was more suited to being a counter
attacking player as was Maguire. I think Marcus can also work in a team that holds the ball
because of the runs he makes off the ball. Whereas I'm not sure that that's the case
with Harry Maguire. Ronaldo, really on the fence with Ronaldo because on one hand I think United
could move into a different direction and bring in a younger, fresher forward. On the other hand
I go I don't think we're going to have that budget. I don't think we're going to invest that level of
money into a striker. And there's probably other areas of the pitch that need desperate surgery
more than the guy that scored 20 goals for us this season. Especially when you've got some other
players in the periphery as well. I think United need to go and pick up an absolute bargain. If
we're going to be playing Europa League football, I don't want Cristiano Ronaldo playing it. Let
Ronaldo play in the Premier League. Let him go watch ******* Amadeo or something on Thursday
nights. And let's have a Europa League footballer. No, I don't care who it is. Whether that is a
Tammy Abraham. Whether that is a Danny Welbeck even. Or even worse, someone like a Mitrovic. I don't
care. Just someone to lead the line to allow us to play a certain way that's going to be happy
playing 12 games a season. And I'm sure that's getting clipped up and misconstrued somewhere.
But it's on a basis that I don't think we will bring in someone that's going to cost 70, 80
million that could be our Haaland that's going to lead the line for us for every game of the season.
So I don't think Ronaldo can play every single game. I would prioritise the Premier League for
him. And I would get someone that can do the midweek stuff. Maybe even give someone like
Charlie McNeil or Hugo the opportunity to do that. Varane, underwhelmed this year. Disappointed with
his injury record. But he does have winning credentials and DNA. And he's probably the
best defender that we currently have at the club. People were talking about his injury record like
he's been like this for five years. But the past three seasons he played 40-odd games.
I'm hoping this is a one-time thing and let's see if he can get over it. Otherwise, yeah, United
probably gonna have to start looking at another centre-half to bring in. Lendelof, he stays with
Bailly and Jones leaving the injury concerns over Varane. You know, I don't think Maguire leaves,
I think he should. You can't let every centre-half go because you're one and two injuries away from
just having nothing to play at centre-half. Certainly good enough to be the third choice.
And as third choice, you're playing a lot. And I think that would be fine. He makes the cut.
Deleuze, another one that I'm very much on the fence with. I actually think he's more suited
to Ten Hag football than Wan-Bissaka. Age is on his side. He did have a really good loan spell
in Serie A. I think that probably gives him a little bit more in the tank compared to Wan-Bissaka.
He's still not the starting right back, but if you bring in a starting right back,
he's not the worst backup in the world to have. Alanga, he brought energy and he brought fire.
I think he's got a limited ceiling. I don't think he's ever going to be called world-class. I don't
necessarily even think he should be starting week in, week out. A little bit like McTominay.
I think when those players, as academy graduates, are your squad players to a world-class or first
choice, whoever, I think the club's in a really good spot there because I think you get a real
vibe of some of the academy players when they come in and perform that task.
He could develop into a really good squad player. Maybe he needs a loan where he's going to play
week in, week out, possibly in the Premier League. That would give him some confidence
and add some more tools to his game, I think. Bruno Fernandes. I've seen some people kicking
off about him signing a contract. He was always going to be given a contract. He just was.
The numbers that he puts up, there's no manager in the world looking at all the problems that
United have got and being like, whoa, get rid of him. It was never going to happen.
Obviously, he's just been given his new contract. Statistically phenomenal.
This season aside, or even you add this season in, it's still statistically phenomenal.
He needs to improve his ball retention, for sure, but I think the way Ten Hag plays football,
there's definitely a way that he can fit in that system and he'll be one of our key players going
forward without a shadow of a doubt. Donovan De Beek. Probably one of the happiest people
at Ten Hag being appointed. He's going to have a manager that he knows has played him.
Now, what's going to be massively interesting is if Ten Hag doesn't play him, clearly he's not
suited to English football, but I'm sure he's going to get given the opportunity to prove
himself. Maybe even come back with a little bit of a chip on his shoulder because I felt
Donny's been a little bit passive at times and a little bit accepting of his treatment.
I would like to see him go out there with a little bit of fire in him. Technically, he's great.
And I think knowing how Ten Hag plays football is going to be a massive help having him in the
squad. It's at least someone that knows what he's looking to do and it's an extra hand for Ten Hag
on a training pitch when someone's like, hang on, where do I go when they've got it here? Oh,
all right, I got it. So I think he's definitely going to be one that sticks around. Certainly
don't think he'll be given the bullet. He'll get given an opportunity. Simple as that. Fred.
Fred has confused me this season. When he's played as a six, sometimes you just want to
headbutt a table. When he's played in the opposition half, he's impressed. We've seen
someone that plays with guile, with energy, with bravery, with skill and ability. I don't know what
happens when he crosses the halfway line and he becomes a defensive midfielder, but he falls to
pieces. I don't, again, a bit like McTominay and Alanga. I don't think Fred's a starting midfielder
for Manchester United and the day that he moves to be someone that you bring on for a bit of
energy, maybe to shore up a game, maybe to change the pace, United are in a really good spot. So I
think he probably stays. And with the turnover of players that we've got, it'd be a bit dramatic to
get rid of Fred in the middle of all that as well, I think. Unlike McTominay, the last one,
McTominay, again, like Fred, like Alanga, squad player. That's fine. You need different levels
of abilities in the squad. You need the people, like your Ronaldo's, who turn up and go, I'm
******* playing, right? I'm playing. Obviously I'm playing. And you need the people that are just
going to sit there and be happy to be 15 games a season, 12 games a season, coming off the bench
more than they start. They're very vital players within a squad. I reckon that's another reason
you're going to see McTominay kept around. From what I hear, he's got a really good attitude
and he's one of the fittest players in the squad. Those are the things that make a massive
difference. It's a thin line between someone that you want to keep and someone that you want to let
go. I think with the mass turnover that we're going to have, I think having someone like
McTominay with the character that I'm led to believe he's got would be a real good thing.
He could find himself surplus to requirements after 12 months, though. I just think the
mass turnaround that we're going to see means that he's probably going to be one that has to
stick around. Now, we'll definitely do a video in the coming weeks and months where we look at
exactly what Manchester United's squad looks like, where we've promoted youngsters into,
where we've let people go, what our 25-man squad looks like. We'll get into that over the next
weeks and months, obviously. But I want to know, do you agree or do you disagree?
Let me know in the comments because there's some holes in this squad that we're going to have to
fill and not all of them are going to get filled with the checkbook. So, cheers for tuning in.
Make sure to subscribe. I'll catch you in a bit. Hey, thank you for watching the video. If you are
new around these parts, then don't forget to subscribe. My channel is proudly supported by
my community on Patreon. If you'd like to get a little bit of extra content, a Discord group,
meetups, five-a-side games, weekly podcasts, behind the scenes and even an occasional bit
of transfer news as on when I get it, then for the price of a pint, you can show your appreciation
for the content that we make and get some goodies for doing so as well. Check the link in the
description or click the button right here. You'll also find all of my socials here too,
if you want to follow me on any of those platforms. Nice one.
