It's OVER... | Manchester United 0-5 Liverpool | Post-Match Review

First Athletic
10 followers
10 Video Views·Oct 18, 2022
Righty then, put me on my solo, even though it feels me a bit more, yeah, that one, there we go,
oh what happened there, jebus, do you know what, that's just a ******* replication of what I've
saw this afternoon here, and you're going, Steve you just had a panic intro and everything, yeah,
because I'm down here, because I can't be house doing it up there, you know what I mean, right,
welcome to the post-match review, or autopsies, it might not well be known,
that was ******* double mega ----, wasn't it, it is members only chat, because clearly it's
going to be ******* wild in here, the Viva Ronaldo match day chat on discord, can we use that for all
the Patreon members, if you guys want to get some questions in on there as well, I'll talk about
some questions, I just caught the last five minutes of these guys being live on Paddock,
and I agree with a lot of what they were saying, Joe said he's not going to be distilled down into
a two-word ******* Twitter phrase in terms of Oli out, but I think I'll probably go a bit further
than what Joe's just gone in terms of, I'm now really moving towards the camp where I'm not sure
you can come back from this, and I'll tell you why, I've seen progression across what Oli's done
for a long time, and I've seen different things evolve, maybe not as fast, in fact definitely not
as fast as I would like, and I thought at the start of this season, once we ended up with our
squad, with the squad that we've got, I thought there was a problem, and the problem was Bruno
and Pogba, and the problem was Ronaldo and Cavani, and really only two of those four can play,
and you've got big egos in there, and politically big players that probably need to play, and I will
come to the members questions as well, so get your questions in, I will get to those, and I've just
got to get some ---- off my chest really, so when you take on the squad with the
Varane really, and you get the players that you get in, the pressure and the expectation has
changed from the day Oli took over as Manchester United manager, and that's correct, it should do,
the job he's done up until the end of last season was a good one, this last two or three weeks
though, the writing's really become on the wall, and I'll get back to what I just said about
not learning lessons, and the reasons why there's some things that haven't progressed,
about two years ago it was, it was around Christmas I'm sure it was, I think it might
have even been the League Cup semi-final at home Manchester City, was it Bernardo Silva's,
absolutely ******* levered us, what I saw in that game was United couldn't play out,
and I think it was Lindelof and Jones that played centre half, and it felt like they
pressed Lindelof, and they sort of left Phil Jones, and they occasionally pressed him, and
he would panic pass it back to David de Gea, and de Gea because he's not got the ******* biggest
kick in the world, was kicking it up towards the halfway line, and United could not get beyond the
halfway line, and I found it very interesting that City matched us man for man in a 4-4-2,
when you're trying to play out in a in a 4-2-3-1, you have a two defenders, you have your two wing
backs or full backs, and then you have your two sixes, and they just went man for man against
them, and was like ******* deal with that dickheads, and we didn't, Liverpool just did the same thing
to us, and we could not cope with any of it, the amount of times that we lost possession
in our box was abysmal, now some of that is individual players, and you know what that
first two minutes, we struggled playing out from the back, we went long a bit easy for me,
but then we we broke away, and we passed it nicely right across the face of the box,
you found Bruno, I don't know if it was just outside or just inside the box from the opposite
end of the ground, and he ******* smashes it into Salford somewhere, if that goes in you might have
seen a different game, but you know what it didn't, and these are the margins, from that moment
Liverpool had a couple of attacks, but more important than that, they were winning the ball
in our third, when it goes to Wan-Bissaka you ******* press him, and just he just gives you
the ball, when you, Marum did some brilliant analysis here the other day, and she was picking
up mostly on the David De Gea lack of involvement in our build-up play versus some of the other top
six sides, it's a great point, but there's another point on there which I think she missed a little
bit, and it's the fact that United's build-up play in terms of like hot spots kind of was like
here, and then here, and then here, and you know what was missing, ******* here, centre part of the
pitch, the number six area, when it goes into Fred and McTominay, all that happens is McTominay
passes it to Fred, and guess who Fred passes it to, McTominay, neither of those two players can
move the ball up through the thirds, when I was trying to analyse what I wanted to see about a
starting XI in this team, I wanted to see, I wanted to see a team that I knew would never play, and that
would have been Lingard, Cavani and Rashford, because that is how you take this game to Liverpool
and you beat them, and you beat them with running, and you beat them with work, but you need a Pogba
in a team that's going to be a counter-attack, you need a player that's going to be able to find
those speedy counter-attacking dangerous players in the opposition final third, when you're looking
to try and stretch in behind, you're looking at 30-40 metre passes, McTominay has got a decent
switch in him, but it's usually under pressure, and it's usually to someone who's standing still,
doing that to someone that's on the move is very ******* difficult, it's what Paul Scholes excelled
at, and we didn't have that, we went with the hard-working midfield, but the problem is who's
going to play the ball to the attacking players, United are so, we give the ball away in our third,
that is such a ******* disappointing thing to see from us, and for me that is on Oli,
that is on the coaching staff, and that's the lesson that in two years with different personnel
Manchester United haven't fixed, and not only have we not fixed it, to me it doesn't look like we've
tried to fix it, we don't look like you're rotating someone in or out, the most perfect
Manchester United side that I saw, it's a toss-up between 2008 and 1999, both of those teams played
out from the back, both of them, 1999 did it a little less, but they both played out from the
back, and I know it's different because you're now allowed your centre-halves inside the box,
with no opposition being inside the box, so that does slightly amend what you're able to do,
but it's supposed to make it easier to play out, we make it look like it's ******* harder for us,
do you know what United used to do, 2006, we played the same formation, carry course goals would peel
off to sort of right back a little bit, when you play completely symmetrically, and teams go well
I know exactly where you go, and they know you're not going to play it into Fred, because they'll
just ******* give you the ball back, they know that you're going to go centre-half, full-back,
try and play it narrowly, up the wings, and if you play into those, they're traps right,
I would love it if a team was playing against me that only wanted to go through the full-back and
into the winger with his back to goal by the way, that's the difference, if you're playing it to
your full-back, who then is going to put it in behind into the channel for someone to chase,
now that's an offensive move, but when it's just to be playing it back to the full-back,
well where does your full-back go now, he's not going to come laterally into Fred because we all
know Fred can't ******* handle it in there, and you press him and take the ball off him,
he's going back to the centre-half, when you're predictable you're not a threat, when you're
predictable you're not going to be successful, and Manchester United are so predictable playing
out, this is one of the biggest things that's on the management for me, Bruno missing that goal in
the first minute, that's not on the management, but some of these things are costing us games,
I mean I've just watched the goals, I don't obviously get a replay live at the game,
I've just watched the goals and I've gone, these are basics, Harry Maguire for whatever reason,
last season we give him the benefit of the doubt saying maybe his head was in Greece,
this season where the **** is his head, what's on his mind now, because he's defending isn't,
second or third goal whichever it is, you've got Mo Salah who's absolutely on fire at the moment,
he's ghosted into the sort of central zone, he's looking to finish, a cross has come in
which doesn't get stopped because why are we stopping crosses, why would we do that to make
it interesting, the cross hasn't been stopped and you've allowed him to get goal side of you,
it's ******* weak and it's just ---- defending, I said oh look at least they're in a line,
I mean the line was at 45 degrees to our goal, you're playing people on, you're not getting
tight, these are the basics of defending, these aren't even like, do you know what,
Jaap Stam might have dealt with that, no, Henning Berg would have dealt with that,
David, maybe not David, I might be getting a bit giddy, the goals we conceded against Leicester
were ******* schoolboy errors, the goals we conceded against Atalanta were ******* schoolboy
errors, crosses from just inside the box at the byline, you can't tell me that, this is some
revolutionary new football ----, oh my god, an attacking player is going to pass it to another
attacking player about ******* 11 yards inside the box, how are you not aware of how these
things go down and the goals today were schoolboy errors, unbelievably ----, unbelievably ----,
for me those things are part of, they are part of the coaching staff's remit, you've got to coach to
be a better, more effective unit but **** me, where is the professionalism, where's the leisure,
how is Harry Maguire Manchester United captain putting in performances like this,
the coaching staff are getting it, these guys are getting it, one sec Erin, can you just grab this
phone for us, just answer that, cheers, I'll put it to, I need it back though because it's got the
discord questions on, it'll ring back or it's upstairs, the lack of patterns of play is a,
I think it's an argument and a thing that people cling on to that I find highly irrelevant,
the biggest thing is our inability to play out from the back but not only is it the inability
to play out from the back, it's our inability to find a plan B or just to work an alternative
and that has been two years, that is such a fundamental thing of football, giving the
******* ball away, I mean it was at one point I think Fred lost the ball inside our box playing
out, what the ****, whether or not this hangover's from the Euros, fix it, give them the time off
and play somebody else, you've got Spurs away, Atalanta away, Manchester City away,
that could be three defeats on current form, ultimately football's a results business right,
if we were playing bad and picking up wins you'd kind of be like, do you know what, maybe it'll
start to click but we're playing horrendously and getting twatted, we are getting exactly what,
like this isn't even, there were some times under Louis van Gaal when we were ******* boring
but we would maybe be a bit unlucky and there's plenty of times under Ali that that's happened
by the way where we've played really well, been really aggressive and been unlucky, there's been
nothing unlucky about the last couple of weeks, we've been objectively ----, this week especially,
the two goals we conceded against Atalanta, I felt like we could come back because Atalanta
was such an open team, you were four ******* nil down at half time and honestly when they scored
the fifth it was kind of like, this isn't tactics, inability to play out from the back for two years
isn't tactics, that's not tactics, tactics can change, just a basic ******* structure to play
out from the back is something that you can ******* do, I don't necessarily agree that,
thank you, what Chelsea did is replicable because **** me Chelsea, Chelsea have fired all of the
coaches everyone's ******* clamouring for, they'll start Tuchel soon, he won't be there more than
two and a half years I guarantee it, even though I think he's absolutely belting, right get your
questions in, let's have a ******* look, see if we can see any of these, Josh Bissell, welcome to
Max says, really want to support Oli until the end, I really did, but if some don't well it's
over for him, worst night I can remember as a fan, that felt awful, it really did, felt awful,
it's hopeless, Mike Smalling, I've not seen you since Louis left, yeah that was the worst game I
can remember, love Oli as a player, wanted him to do well but don't see any way back,
Arjen Hendrik says defenders don't, didn't look motivated, if you can't motivate players for
the biggest game of the season there's no hope, this is not me defending the manager,
where's the ******* professional pride in some of the players to motivate themselves,
you know I've been fortunate enough to interview several United players and you talk about
motivation and stuff like that with them and they look at you funny if you go like, **** you didn't
need to motivate me for the biggest of ******* games, that come from me, where's the inner drive
and winners in this ******* team, there's a couple of people saying thoughts on Pogba's red card,
I'd not seen a replay of that, I will have a replay of that, some people saying it definitely was,
I haven't really seen anything, I had Tortsport in the car and they were saying his attitude's
all wrong but like I said you know that could be Tortsport so **** knows, I'm not going to comment
until I've seen it, Ethan says I really is, I've never been old out but this is unacceptable,
right I think he's just, yeah it's unacceptable, it is unacceptable, it is unacceptable,
it honestly felt like this week has really shifted a lot of things, Alex says I'm an Oli
fan and I want him to stay, I think to save the legacy of work he's done so far he needs to walk
away and save his pride, I've had quite a few texts from people saying do you think he might resign,
he might, Maguire knows he still walks into the team, Shaw was atrocious, I don't know what
Fred was thinking, this is from AM, Lindelof was quiet again, the players letting themselves down,
as for Oli he'll stay, that was something the guys on the fan channel were saying just as I
was coming in actually, I think John Maguire was saying it, that regardless of whatever we believe,
and that's why I never ask for a manager to be sacked but I think the writing's on the
******* wall here for Oli, if he doesn't pull out two wins out of Atalanta I suppose and City
I don't know how he stays, I'll never ask for a manager to be sacked because
I believe that people can turn it around and you know Jesus Fergie finished 13th,
you know how many of us would like to take that back, if we'd have been ******* demanding he'd
have gone and you know knowing what it eventually became, plain and simple there's no way back from
this for Oli says Ethan Stefano, welcome to the channel, Ross says back to Oli since he arrived,
he's a legend and since he's been here we've had some good times with him, now to see this stage
where we need to move forward, can't see him turn around, it might be that he's reached his ceiling,
it might be he was the palate cleanse that was needed and the ship steadying that was
needing to be done but you've still got to question some of the recruitment that's been
allowed to happen, I don't think Varane's an issue, I don't think Sancho is an issue,
obviously someone we've pursued for a while, I understand the signing of Ronaldo but was it a
mistake, has it upset, not the balance but like has it forced issues where there wasn't issues,
did we prioritise that over a midfielder, if we did then is that looking short-sighted perhaps,
not like that, one midfielder isn't going to mean that we're suddenly no longer
dog ---- playing out from the back, I mean it might help a little bit but it's just so bad.
Maguire's a ball-playing defender, Lindelof's a ball-playing defender and they look like they're
hearing about playing out for the first time as they're in the tunnel going out onto the pitch
and they'll be like yeah we'll give it a go, we'll see how it goes, pass it to each other.
Stefano says I haven't been Oli out at all but I felt it going wrong and the tide turning the
last few weeks, love Oli but can't see anything fixing this other than a change now. Phil says
words fail me, depressed and disappointed tonight but unfortunately not surprised.
Julio says been Oli in all the way since the beginning but the writing is on the wall now,
is anyone saying anything different, has anyone been like it'll be reet, I don't think it will
be reet will it, it don't feel like it's going to be reet at least anyway. Paying for watching today
that squad is good enough, we have so many flaws we won't fix by bypassing midfield because we
try to play out when we can't, De Gea is so passive unless it's shot stopping, yeah another
keeper maybe. Ethan says absolutely dejected, no hope or faith, I've got nothing left for the team,
the way things are looking, players are poorly coached, wrong players, wrong formation, tactics,
everything, no cohesion, it's bad, I can't really dispute any of that. Stefano, if he's not shot
stopping play Hendo, Maguire isn't fit but Oli should be strong enough to drop him for the team
and Vinicius says frankly I'll be surprised if Oli is there against Spurs, I mean that's only the
next game. Joga Benito, won't add where that was, United seem the most undercoached side in the
Premier League, either the coaching and tactics are just wrong or the players aren't responding,
both fall at the management's feet, clueless, without the ball, average positions 4-2-4,
coaching staff not learning from their mistakes, yeah I agree on that. Fred has dropped in a red
thanks to your recognition of helping fans like me with the ups and downs through tactics, history
and hopes, you are a true supporter and a bit of a legend, well just a fan with a YouTube channel
my mate. Up the Reds, Patreon member till I die, I'll get to you guys as well, I've got the discord
out on my phone here, I'm just going to get through these. This season feels like Jose's
third and Liverpool game was his last, will history repeat itself? I'd like to say it didn't feel
as bad as Jose's at Anfield but it did, the only thing is it doesn't feel as toxic but the
performance was equally as bad, equally as bad, we're so bad that it was quite enjoyable, you're
a ******* weird fella mate. I'd like to see Ole step down, I don't want him sacked but they're
simply not working, we need a shake up, done a good job to get us here but it's time to move on
I see, I'm not sure about that, I'm not sure about that, I think Wednesday night probably
says no to that but I mean it was awful. This 5-0 is more than a 6-1 against City,
Luke Shaw does not know how to defend, Salah didn't need to get into first gear. Today's
performance was worse than Burnley and City results in Jan, we can't play out from the back
and we are championship level without the ball. Let's get into the discord one and see what some
of these are, another super chat there from Ben and Dan says, got to the point where I wasn't
angry with the game, I was just sad, Ole has been positive for the club overall but the writing is
on the wall now and a lot more, exactly like that, alright see what you guys are saying on Patreon.
Tellers time, I mean Tellers defensively hasn't ******* looked like Prime Maldini himself has he?
Give it Bruce at the end of the season, well he is out of work, always support the manager but
clearly it looks like it isn't going to work but who do we bring in not to undo all the work that
Ole has but to elevate it, see that's a really, really astute point that, you can't just bring
in Conte because he's going to look at half of them players and be like get to ****, I don't
think so. You are going to have to have someone that builds on top of what Ole's done because if
you take it in a 180 direction when it doesn't work out with that guy and you flip it again
and go back 180 then it's just not going to work is it? Notch says inarguably one of the worst
spectacles in my 46 years watching us, is it that telling that Old Trafford was still more full at
the end than the Etihad, well I wasn't there because I fucked off with 10 minutes to go.
Thoughts on Popper's red card not seen, overall more sad than mad, yeah I'm sad, that's going to
be a meme now isn't it? Give it Tosk sucking Scolzi to the end of the season and also thoughts on the
defensive formation, ******* brutal is my thoughts on our defensive position, honestly it's like
watching under eights when you go go and just get after the ball and enjoy it, I didn't enjoy it.
Love you on the channel, we're the second, third best defence in the league last year,
same players in the defence started today, what's happening, how do you ship five against
your biggest rival, never happened in 127 years, I'm speechless, same mate, I don't know.
That was so bad, yeah I'm just sad rather than mad, that was brutal watching, right I'm gonna wrap up,
I think me, Alex and Joe are gonna go live so we'll have more of yous come and chat to us on there
and take it easy, listen don't ******* wind yourselves up about it, we ain't sacking him,
it's not on us, we're just there to support whoever's ******* there aren't we, so if it's him
he'll get the support, if it's not him they'll get the support,
as long as it's not ******* Brendan Rodgers though, because he can **** off.
