Manchester United Are Finished. | Howson IMO

First Athletic
10 followers
10 Video Views·Oct 18, 2022
Manchester United are finished, which is potentially a bit of a dramatic title, but
unless something changes, I do believe that is the case. United fans currently are going through
an absolute meltdown on social media. Once again, this is a regular occurrence, but it is happening
once again. One transfer in after absolute months of playing Futsal with Jadon Sancho and probably
countless other players, as well as being linked to a ton of players that we were never going to
get, that we were never interested in, and we never even probably looked at. There's so much
wrong at the Football Club at Manchester United that it's hard to see the real positives, and
there's been some real, genuine positives of late. The group of players that we've got at the moment
are probably the most likeable we've had in years. They seemingly want to play for the manager,
they seemingly want to play for the Football Club. Solskjaer has transformed the culture at
Manchester United. He's bringing in players who want to play for the club, and I'll be honest with
you, I really wanted Thiago Alcantara. Seems like he's literally just about signed for Liverpool at
the moment, and it seemed like United was umming and ahhing over wages, and I'm torn on this because
on one hand I completely understand the business side of the Football Club needs wages to be under
control. We allowed ourselves to go above and beyond with Alexis Sanchez, but we also currently
allow ourselves to go above and beyond for the likes of Phil Jones. One matter for as much as
he's the loveliest guy in football, he's on an absolute fortune at Manchester United, as is
Jesse Lingard, as are a lot of the fringe players that I'm not going to be getting any time. And when
you look at the likes of Reguilon, and the rights and wrongs over the the supposed contract clause
that Real Madrid wanted inserted into the deal, Reguilon would probably come in on somewhere
between 80, 90, 100 grand a week. You know you've got Luke Shaw, supposedly understudied to him,
on 250 grand a week. So on one hand I understand United's frustration with bringing in footballers
for money, and supposedly United met with Thiago and they thought he wanted a large
amount, or what they considered to be a large amount, possibly because he was never as keen
to join United as he was to join Liverpool, which is, it is what it is, I guess. And I wouldn't want
United to change back into that culture of, we'll just get people because we're paying money, we want
young lads that are going to come and work for us and work hard. But I find the football club to be
poorly run. We offered Phil Jones, not long ago, a new deal, four or five year deal, on an astronomical
wage. You probably can't give Phil Jones away at the moment. He could go to a championship club,
probably be a good performer for them, play every week, but that would probably mean they're more
than doubling their wage budget. Even if he was to take a pay cut, he's not value for money for any
other club to take him. He's certainly not value for money for Manchester United, but when you're
a club who's maybe spending 200, 250 grand a week as a total on wages, like a lot of clubs in the
There's just absolutely zero justification in bringing in Phil Jones, with his injury record,
on around about half of that. So, you can understand why it's difficult for United to
get rid of some of these players. And you see people go, why don't United have a recouper
transfer fee? Because once United have decided that they're done with the player, they let them
go for a cut price deal, so they can still get good wages elsewhere. Otherwise, clubs plain and
simple cannot afford to buy Manchester United players. It's this level of mismanagement which
has allowed, I mean, the extension happened under Solskjaer's watch, but it almost felt like Solskjaer
had no say in it whatsoever. I don't know if that was the case, but it just felt like that.
And there's been other contract negotiations that have been handled as well.
I think it was the start of Solskjaer's reign, there was 9 or 10 or 11 players that had
contracts that were all due to expire that season or this season, which is a nightmare because
you're looking at potentially half of the squad going. And it seems to me United prioritised the
wrong players, just to get them checked off, right? We've sorted them contracts out. Ashley
Young was one, Phil Jones was one, and you're almost thinking, why can't we just let these
contracts just expire? For what you would recoup in transfer fee for some of these players,
you would save by not paying a wage, if you just allowed them to leave on a free transfer.
We've seen Brandon Williams given a new contract. Why? It's a young lad that just broke into the
first team. You don't need to sit down and renegotiate a contract with someone in those
circumstances. He was doing well in the first team. He was pushing hard and become a first
team squad member. He got a new contract very soon after doing that.
Why does he then need another new contract before the season starts? There is no justification in
doing that. Now, I'm not saying, oh, Brandon doesn't deserve a new deal. I'm questioning
the requirement for us to sit down with a local teenager, who's probably not going to kick up a
fuss, and probably is going to be happy just to be part of the first team squad for the time being.
Mason Greenwood signed an extension, or his proper first pro deal really, after pre-season
last year. That's why he played, and that was the issue was Angel Gomez wouldn't and wasn't.
Mason Greenwood, the contract was put in front of him, he signed the contract. I would not be
shocked now to see Mason Greenwood given another contract extension just 12 months after his last
one on the back of one season. He signed, I think, a four-year deal. That four-year deal should not be
touched until at least two years. And if he's earned a massive pay rise, then he's earned a
massive pay rise. But after one year, he was on decent cash. United are probably going to give
him another extension. I wouldn't be surprised to see that in the coming months. Another extension
for Mason Greenwood, and then tell everyone that they're investing in the youth, they're doing this,
they're doing that, they're doing the other. But they set themselves up for failure, because no footballer
and no agent ever walks into a contract negotiation and asks for the same money. They always ask for
more. They always ask, can you double my wage? Can you do, I want more, I think I deserve more.
The problem is, when you start, if Mason gets an extension now, he's probably going to be put
into somewhere like the 100, 120, 130 kind of range. If he goes into that at 19,
where the **** do you go when he's 25? Lionel Messi had a contract extension about every year
for the last nine years. I get it, it's Messi. Messi's managed to get himself up to 1.4 million
euros a week. You can't run a football club effectively doing that. And when you've
got one player that's earning that amount of cash, the reason why Sanchez upset the apple cart at
United is because the likes of Ashley Young could walk in and say, I deserve 100 grand a week,
because he's on five times that. I'm not even asking for half his money, I'm asking for a fifth of his
money. And how do you deny that? I shouldn't be able to share a picture of him if you think I'm
worth less than half, a fifth of what he's worth. And then everybody gets a pay rise, because you've
got people that are not deserving, that are earning crazy money. And this isn't me saying
that Mason isn't going to go and do madness for Manchester United and isn't ultimately deserving
of it, but it's the way the football club is run. I remember the absolute bedlam caused by Roy Keane
for trying to break United's pay structure. He was the ******* club captain at the time,
and Martin Edwards held firm repeatedly on it until he eventually broke it and got 50 grand a
week. This is on the back of when he won the treble. If anyone can walk into an office and
demand a pay rise, Roy Keane, 99-2000, was the best example of that. But the PLC at the time
held firm and we had a structure in place. There's no structure now. Many of you watching this video
probably think that Dean Henderson's the best goalkeeper at Manchester United. You're entitled
to that opinion. How can you have Dean Henderson, who's just signed a deal worth 100 grand,
be sitting with an understudy in David de Gea who's going to be earning somewhere in the region
of 400 grand? We'd all like to sit here and say, manager picks a team, Steve. Football is way more
political than that. People get matches, starts, bench appearances for political reasons. People
get dropped for political reasons. I'd love to know what Solskjaer's team sheet looks like when
for him to put it in. If they're trying to sell a player, Ollie, we're going to have to play him
for a couple of weeks to prove his fitness, to see that he can actually fulfil a game.
------- hell, I don't want to play him then. What justification is there of,
I want to play Dean Henderson, I think he's better than David de Gea. Okay, well, no one's going to
take de Gea off our hands if he's not playing, so we'll try and get him a move, but you need
to play him. You're being very naive if you think those conversations aren't happening all the time.
All the time. People get a new, sign a new contract and they're on the bench that week
as a youngster. Sometimes that's a reward for signing a new deal. The contract situation at
United is a microcosm of how poorly the club is run elsewhere. On the transfer front this summer,
as we said, we saw Donny van de Beek come in. Great player, great price. Added depth and competition
to a very important part of the pitch, and potentially this weekend you might see Donny
play rather than Paul Pogba, who's not been rushed back after contracting the coronavirus,
and that to me is excellent squad management. Excellent. And it's something we've not been
able to do this season, or last season I guess really, because of the thinness of the squad.
Donny van de Beek, great capture. Not enough. We don't have that level of competition at centre
half. We arguably need that competition at left back. We've got a gaping hole on the right wing.
We saw Marcus Rashford have to try and play through a ******* broken back
at times last season. There's not enough competition. Now, if you have signed Jadon
Sancho, Marcus, how's your back? It's not right, you know. Why don't you sit this weekend out and
we'll go over front three of Martial, Greenwood and Sancho. I ******* like that. You see how
suddenly everyone's like, well where would he play? Like when we were talking about Thiago,
when would he play? So many ******* times he would play. It's not an 11-a-side sport.
Over the course of a season, a 25-man game. The game of chicken United are playing
over transfers is not working. United don't seemingly have the capability
to go and make deals happen. There was clearly a willingness at Ajax to do a deal with Manchester
United and whether that was through Van der Sar or the efficiency of Ajax as a football club
because there's football people involved there. We managed to get the Donny van der Beek one done in
seemingly a day. Rapid. We've been playing the no you hang up game with ******* Dortmund for
over a year. The price is the price. If you want this footballer, you're gonna have to pay the
price because a slow start to this season, we are never gaining that ground back. I'm not overly
arsed on who United bring in providing they're the right fit. And if Oli was like, no, do you know
what? Thiago didn't quite sit with me. If he was being honest with that, I can live with it.
It's if Oli's covering up for the owners. Now I've seen people call him a glazer puppet because he
says he's happy with his squad. You're a ******* idiot if that, if you take what he said at face
value there and think what he means by what he's saying is I'm happy with my squad. His actions
tell you he's not happy with his squad. Clearly. We're not going out negotiating for fullbacks and
some right wingers and midfielders. If he's happy with the squad, his message, when he says I'm
happy with the squad is being the opposite of what Jose Mourinho was who caused an absolute
******* stink in that dressing room. Let me tell you that last preseason of Jose Mourinho, when
he's like, I've got to play all these ******* kids did not go down. Well, players are sensitive
little snowflakes, right or wrong. They are. And their agents are in there is right or wrong.
They are. So when a manager comes out, think about this. Agents can cause an absolute *******
kerfuffle in a football club. Solskjaer comes out and goes, you know what? I hate all of my
centre-halves bar Maguire. I wish I could ******* launch them all for free. You weaken your position
in negotiation. And if you don't manage to sell those players that summer, you've now got five
unhappy centre-halves who know that you hate them. It's just not a good idea to do that. I don't know
why some people expect him to come out and criticise players and be honest in press conferences.
Sir Alex Ferguson protected the Glazers. The whole look at Fergie's entire reign. He broke
records from the minute he got it, you know, for Gary Pallister onwards. He was breaking that
British transfer record like it was a bet with himself. He broke it for Andy Cole, I think.
He broke it for Roy Keane. He broke a record for a defender with Yap Stam. He might have even broke
the record. No, it wasn't for, I was gonna say for Dwight York, but it wasn't, no, because it was less than
Alan Shearer. He broke it for Rio Ferdinand. He broke it for a teenager with Wayne Rooney.
Sir Alex Ferguson's entire reign up until 2005 was about him absolutely going balls deep on big
transfers. Then suddenly from 2005 onwards, the man with one of the best teams in football suddenly
decides that there's no value in the market, at a time when there was some outrageous value in the
market. Some of the players at Manchester City got Vincent Kompany's six million pound, no value in
the market. There was a lot of value in the market if you knew where to look. I personally
think that Sir Alex was hampered by the Glazers and United had a negative net spend from 2005 to
when Sir Alex retired. A negative net spend. That means we made money on transfers. Biggest club in
the world making money on transfers. Do you think Fergie really wanted that? Not a chance.
With what happened following the retirement of Sir Alex Ferguson, United have over invested
because they divested it in the eight years prior. In that seven years since, because there's been a
complete lack of direction and we've lurched from one manager with one style of play to another,
there's been a lack of cohesion in the signings. Louis van Gaal's signings would have been great
assets for Ole Gunnar Solskjaer to deal with. Daley Blind with Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, perfect.
Daley Blind, Jose Mourinho, getting a ******* bid. And that's what happened. Because there wasn't a
clear strategy, because there wasn't a clear, this is how we want to play as a football team and we
will hire managers that fit that philosophy, we just lurched from one guy to the next guy because
he was the biggest name that was available. We've had a scattergun approach to transfers and money
has been wasted in outrageous amounts. The Di Maria one alone irks, but there's been tons of 30-40
million buys that just haven't worked out. Some because of a lack of patience, some because of a
lack of confidence. Memphis Depay is just about to sign for Barcelona. He was ---- according to a
lot of United fans. I don't think he got the opportunities regular week in week out. Because
we've not got a clear plan and a clear strategy, we have our pants pulled down when it comes to
buying players, we have our pants pulled down when it comes to selling players and as fans we have our
pants pulled down because we're not able to strengthen the team now. Some of that might be
down to willingness from the owners. We saw in Jose's second season once he achieved Champions
League qualification, they went cool. Here's Lee Grant, Fred and Diego Delo. Not exactly the sort of
transfer window that's going to take you from going second to becoming title contenders and it
almost feels like the exact same thing has just happened. Oh we've got a rotational midfielder
brought in and promote some lads from the academy. Obviously something that Jose Mourinho is never
going to do. Where is the ambition? As fans we want to win everything but in the *******
toss up kickoff. But our owners seemingly don't match that ambition.
15 ******* years and I see the hashtags and I get the frustration of a lot of fans.
It's got to be better than a hashtag. The Glazers outfingers trended so many ******* times.
It's affected nothing. I was on the flash mobbing and all the protests marched from 2005 onwards.
I've been ******* Glazer out since day dot. It was nasty and violent and ******* very very very
very well supported in the early days. Very very very well supported in 2010. Even our David Beckham
in a green and gold scarf. That's always gonna have done more than trending on Twitter. Which
they clearly don't give a **** about. They clearly don't give a **** about all the replies to every
single post that United put out. It almost feels like they're trolling us at times. I'd love some
action to be done. But at the minute it's a private company and they own all the aces. Unless
someone's got five bill in the bank. And even that's not a guaranteed thing because it ain't Tesco.
They don't just walk in pick us up off the shelf and take us to the checkout. They have to accept
that offer. And I don't know if they'd be willing to accept the offer of anyone who had the money
either. And sometimes you can go out the frying pan and into the fire. We're seemingly stuck with
these shithouse owners for the time being. And is it gonna get better? We seem to take one step
forward. Things start to start going right. You start to see the patterns of play. You start to
see the ambition of the manager and the players and things. This is making ******* sense. And then
they shoot themselves in the foot. Footballers I think need to be viewed like investments
in property. No one really loses money in property. You bought property in the 80s,
probably spent about seven or eight grand on something that's worth in excess of 100 grand now.
The way inflation works in football, I don't think there's any risk involved whatsoever.
Even with the coronavirus and the global recession that's going on. If anything, I think TV revenue
is going to still increase because of the sheer amount of people that are going to watch it.
They've started removing things like the 3pm blackout. You're starting to see so many different
people now getting kick-off times, moved around all over the place. So many more slots have opened
up for different ways to broadcast football and different matches on the same day even.
I think the revenue won't go backwards. I think it's going to diversify. You'll probably be able
to get it on Amazon Prime, probably on Apple. Google will probably get their own thing soon.
And I still think the TV revenue increases. If you look how much players were costing 20 years ago,
10 years ago, I think you can look back after five years and say, Jadon Sancho,
that was a bargain at 100 and whatever million it was. If United have got capital now, and I don't
know if we have, it could be either way. If United have got capital now, they need to act and they
need to act right now. Because if we don't, we are going to be overtaken. Clubs like Everton,
who've been fucked for 30 years, have started to get their act together. Clubs like Leeds,
who hilariously have been fucked for 20 years, have started to get their act together and
seemingly start to support the man who's in charge. If Arsenal manage to get their act together,
Chelsea seemingly found the checkbook again. Top four, and I predicted us coming second a
******* week ago. Fresh off the hype of signing Donny Van Der Beek, ******* buzzing. We'll link
with this guy, we'll link with that guy, get one of them done next week, won't we? Buzzing.
If Donny Van Der Beek's our only transfer, we are going to ******* struggle really badly.
Where's the ambition? If United don't start acting like a big club, we are finished.
