Gender ideology is a Marxist system meant to break children from families, and societies from traditions. This is according to Jay Richards, director of the Heritage Foundation’s DeVos Center for Life, Religion, and Family.
We speak with Richards about how children are being turned against their own bodies, how legal action is possible against doctors carrying out transition surgeries, and how gender ideology is a tool in the communist playbook. -------- ⭕ Sign up for our NEWSLETTER and stay in touch: https://ept.ms/EpochTVNewsletter
Gender ideology is a Marxist system meant to break children from families and societies
from traditions. This is according to Jay Richards, director of the Heritage Foundation's
DeVos Center for Life, Religion, and Family. We speak with Mr. Richards about how children
are being turned against their own bodies, how legal action is possible against doctors
carrying out the transition surgeries, and how gender ideology is a tool in the communist playbook.
Hey, Jay Richards. Thanks for being on Crossroads. It's great to be with you.
So, you know, we're here at the National Conservative Conference. You're talking about
gender ideology, and this is not just like transgender stuff. This is about the movement,
like the political side behind it. So what is gender ideology?
Okay, this, it's going to sound crazy. This is half my job is to persuade people this is a real
thing. I'm used to it now. I know. And so this is a real thing. And so gender ideology, to boil it
down, is a philosophical movement that denies the sexual binary as a real thing. So in other words,
this reality of male and female as a given biological category, and replaces it with an
entirely internal and subjective category of gender identity. So what you really are isn't
sort of defined or even constrained by your body. It's defined by this internal kind of subjective
view of your gender, which is itself a circular definition. And so that's the best I can do in
terms of giving it a coherent description. You know, I watched Matt Walsh's What is a Woman?
It was good. I was impressed by it. And he hit on something really interesting,
whereas he got people to say, well, if you believe that a man can transition to a woman,
then what is a woman? And they're like, well, it's whatever you want to be like,
well, you're obviously you're transitioning to it. So what is it that you are transitioning to?
And then people finally approach it and they're like, wait a second, that there has to be a
definition of what a woman is or what a man is, if you can transition to it, regardless whether
you believe in trans. I mean, how would you describe this, this question he kind of raises
in terms of what they actually believe? The great thing about Matt Walsh's question
is that it distills the fundamental incoherency of the movement. Because on the one hand, to say
trans woman is a woman is to imply that a woman is something and that it's also somehow different
from a trans woman. Or from a man in general. Or from a trans woman.
Trans woman in the terms, right, is a man that is transitioning to be a woman. And this is the
kind of fundamental incoherence, is that the truth of the matter is even to describe the movement,
even the term trans implies a sexual binary initially that you could move from male to
female. But now even the category of trans is in some ways obsolete because we have asexual,
a gender, non-binary, which denies that there's a binary at all. It just says like gender's on
a spectrum. But if gender's on a spectrum, everyone's non-binary because there's no
binary. And so you don't have to scratch this very long if you look at it philosophically
before you see its fundamental incoherence. But why it matters is because it actually
affects real people and it affects real kids and their own perceptions of their body.
So it's an idea that's just fundamentally unreasonable. It doesn't make any sense
even by its own definitions. Because even to suggest that someone is trans,
why would you need to be trans if you're already the thing? What would you be transitioning from?
I mean, there's, as you mentioned, an incoherence that is fundamental to the system.
But regardless of, and I think a lot of us argue on the incoherence of it, but regardless of that,
it's being used and it's being abused against kids, kids of all people. It seemed to be the
main target. I mean, is that the case in what you're saying?
Yeah. And so I think rather than thinking of gender ideology as this kind of coherent
thought system like Marxism, or it's got particular propositions you can test,
think of gender ideology as a cultural wrecking ball for destroying the fundamental cell of
society, which is the family. And so the very definition of family requires a sexual binary,
a mother and a father who can mate and can have a child, right, which they raise together.
That's what this is about. And so if you think of this as a kind of, it's a sort of utopian
cultural wrecking ball that's less interested in what comes after than in destroying the present
order. And as leftists have known for a century and a half, the family, the church, these
institutions outside the state, they're the main bulwark against a totalizing state.
And so they have to be destroyed.
You know, I had some interesting conversations with James Lindsay
before, and the way he described not just the trans movement, but also like the homosexual
movement as a political movement, not as a just preference, right? But as a political
movement was the same thing, that it's being used by these communist groups with the intent
to destroy the family structure.
Yeah, that's really what this is about. And James Lindsay is a very keen analyst of this
dynamic, because what we've got is this weird, it's kind of a toxic brew of a type of
neo-Marxism, cultural Marxism combined with postmodern French philosophy and some
critical theory from the Frankfurt School mixed in.
And so philosophically, it's easy to get lost if you follow the kind of intellectual
trajectory. But the key detail in terms of public policy and public life is that it
teaches children that they could be born in the wrong body.
That is probably the most toxic idea you could possibly introduce to a child.
So introducing that idea to a child, how does that destroy the family?
Well, so think about the first things that we learn as human beings.
Some of the most basic categories about the world are adult, child, male, female, good,
bad. They're boys and they're girls.
And so by the time you're five or six...
When you learn to categorize reality, in other words.
Exactly. And we're trying to capture, we want our categories to sort of fit at the
joints of reality. And so if you can take a child at an age before he or she has
actually formed those categories and dissolve it and say, well, some people are boys,
some people are girls, some people are both, neither, or somewhere in between, which is
a direct quote from a children's book, you dissolve that category that they use to
navigate the world and you can replace it with something much more to your liking.
Well, and that's a frightening concept.
You've got to think that a child's most basic grasp on reality is the recognition
of being able to differentiate things. Man, woman, person, tree, person, animal.
And they're even making it so you can identify as a tree or an animal at this point.
How do you categorize anything? What does that do to a kid's brain, I wonder?
We don't quite know yet. We're going to find out. I mean, this is history's first experiment
with this particular kind of radical ideology. This really is something new under the sun.
Sexual variation, to put it nicely, has been a part of human history forever.
But this idea that there are no males and females, or that a male can become a female
simply by self-identity, this is really a new idea. And we don't know what it is going to do.
We do know that, look, if children can't trust their perception that there are males and females,
what can they trust? Almost all of their cognitive faculties are now sort of up for grabs.
Well, and then they're told that their parents are feeding them this false information as well,
which is frightening.
That's right. So that's a key point. So you strike both at the categories by which
we can even understand the family, and then you pit children against their parents,
which is exactly what's happening. So you reach kids through social media,
you reach them in the schools behind their parents' backs, and you teach them that,
well, they're this thing inside them, and their parents are the primary impediments to them
realizing their true self. That is utterly toxic.
And that's frightening that the kids will believe that they've been basically denied
who they really are by their parents and by their religion and by their culture,
and that basically to become who they really are and break free of these shackles that have
been placed on them, that they have to turn against their parents, their families,
and their culture. And then who do they turn to?
Well, they turn to the social networks, the self-supporting social networks,
usually on social media, that will reinforce this ideology. And remember, it also
turns children against their own bodies, gets them on this sort of school to sterilization pathway,
which ultimately, I mean, if you follow through, you start with social transition,
you end with puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones and surgery, you literally sterilize
yourself. That's what we're talking about. And so we're talking about the sterilization
of children. It's hard to imagine something more sensational and more outrageous,
and also something that would be less appealing politically, I would think,
if people actually understood what's going on.