China’s toilet revolution: five-star restrooms not to use but to be seen

Spotlight on China
2K followers
31 Video Views·Sep 24, 2022
Many commented the same when watching a video regarding a two-story luxury public toilet in the farm fields of Changchun city, Jilin Province.
However, these reflections seem too late because many luxury public toilets were already built under China’s Toilet Revolution program.
China’s toilet revolution
There is no explicit literature report on the origin of the toilet revolution in China. Actually, the phrase “toilet revolution” was first proposed by UNICEF in 1997 when UNICEF and the National Primary Health Care Conference (NPHCC) collaborated to promote toilet retrofitting in China. It specifically referred to the practice in developing countries.
Many commented the same when watching a video regarding a two-story luxury public toilet
in the farm fields of Changshang City, Jilin Province.
However, these reflections seem too late because many luxury public toilets were already built
under China's Toilet Revolution program.
China's Toilet Revolution
There is no explicit literature report on the origin of the Toilet Revolution in China.
Actually, the phrase Toilet Revolution was first proposed by UNICEF in 1997
when UNICEF and the National Primary Health Care Conference, NPHCC, collaborated
to promote toilet retrofitting in China.
It specifically referred to the practice in developing countries.
According to research by the University of Manchester,
the anthropologist Jiaming Zhu publicly called for a Toilet Revolution in 1988
creating a heated discussion on this topic in Chinese media in the late 1980s.
In the 1990s, rural toilet retrofitting became popular with certain achievements.
The ownership of sanitary toilets in rural areas rose from under 40% to 75% in six years.
China set a target of 85% for sanitary toilet coverage in rural areas by 2020.
Most recently, the Healthy China 2030 program is pushing this target to 100%.
In April 2015, Xi Jinping called for a renewed Toilet Revolution.
This was apparently prompted by Xi's experience with toilets in the countryside
and is concerned about the impact of their dismal condition on the tourist industry.
The stench and filth of many Chinese toilets is believed to horrify foreigners.
Since then, China's Toilet Revolution has spread from the countryside to the tourism industry
where the Toilet Revolution has been launched at major tourist attractions.
As reported by John Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies,
China built 68,000 public restrooms in urban areas by the end of 2017
and another 64,000 were planned by 2020.
The program was funded with more than $140 million from the Ministry of Finance
and about $3 billion from municipal finance.
Practice of formalism built to be seen.
In November 2017, Xi highlighted the importance of toilet issues again.
He said that toilet issues are not petty matters
but an essential aspect of improving infrastructure in urban and rural areas.
At that time, Nikkei Asia reported that Xi's purpose behind this initiative
was that he could be recognized as a caring leader.
It is believed that the emphasis on restrooms is an attempt to polish Xi's image
by depicting him as a great leader who cares about even the small details of people's lives.
His request has been executed beyond expectation.
Linfen was named an excellent city in Toilet Revolution in 2017
with 40 five-star public toilets, 12 four-star toilets, and 60 standard bathrooms.
It also planned to add Wi-Fi, ATMs, newsstands,
and electric vehicle charging stations to these facilities.
Chongqing built three luxury bathrooms in a park
with air conditioning, sound systems, and high-end construction.
Other cities across the country have also adopted the same practice.
They built expensive public toilets with high expenditure.
As DW News showed, a public toilet in Shuzhou, Yangzhou, and Guangzhou
cost 1 million yuan, about $140,000.
In Chongqing and Beijing, 800,000 yuan, about $110,000.
In Jinan, 700,000 yuan, nearly $100,000.
In 2018, Li Zhenjiao, director of the China National Tourism Administration,
said that it is a wrong approach to engage in the so-called five-star toilets.
He referred to it as the wrong practice of formalism.
China Travel News echoed this when listing out a public toilet on Wulin Road, Hangzhou,
with the cost of 940,000 yuan, $133,000.
This place has become a new check-in point for netizens.
Now come back to the luxury public toilet in Changsheng.
Although the construction cost is unknown,
it looks relatively a high-end building in the crop fields.
When asked about the reason for building such a luxury toilet,
the local official confirmed that it was a garbage transfer station.
For the sake of a long-term consideration
and for the convenience of local residents to go to the toilet when walking,
they placed the big character's public toilet in the front of the facility for everyone to see.
What a puzzling situation.
NetEase explained that, in the end,
these public toilets seem to be aimed at showing off the wealth of the local finances.
Other problems
The Toilet Revolution program has generated many creative ideas for building public toilets.
According to CNBC,
tourists can see the glass-walled toilets in the scenic Xiyanghu Ecologic Park in Changsha.
Frosted glass separates the cubicles from each other
while fully transparent glass is used for outer walls, floor, and roof.
Yang Lang, an employee of the park, says,
we want to make it something unique, exciting, and adventurous.
CNBC shows that this design doesn't give the user much privacy.
In fact, people tend to be reluctant to use it.
Moreover, this revolution is also a tool for local officials to make money.
In July 2019, CCTV said that each toilet renovation was awarded 500 yuan,
71 dollars, in Yingli Village, Hebei Province.
The local area inflated more than 100 toilets to defraud subsidies.
In some cases, toilets were abandoned or dismantled after construction.
For example, more than 80,000 toilets were rebuilt in Shen Yun, Liaoning,
but 50,000 were abandoned.
A public toilet near the intersection of Science Avenue and West Fourth Ring Road,
Zhengzhou City, was demolished after a short time of transformation.
The local government invested nearly 200,000 yuan,
28,000 dollars, in revamping a simple public toilet into a luxury one in June 2018.
However, another city plan of road construction left the newly renovated public toilets demolished.
As reported by Shenzhen Think Tank,
it is possible that the construction and demolition of public toilets
is a tool of local authorities to obtain more compensation funds.
Moreover, it is not only a waste of money,
but, above all, a struggle between urban planning and possible fraud of demolition funds.
