Gioachino Rossini, the Great Silence After “Tell,” and the Question,
Why Superstition Outlives the Rational World.

A Friday in Passy

There are dates you have to double-check because you don’t trust them. November 13, 1868, is one of those. I did so, and the result was what the biographers claim: a Friday. On that Friday, Gioachino Rossini, the most famous opera composer of his century, died at the age of seventy-six in his villa in Passy, which at the time was still a village on the outskirts of Paris. He had undergone two surgeries that fall; then came erysipelas, followed by a fever, and finally, the end.

A year later, a biography penned by the journalist Henry Sutherland Edwards was published in London, and it contains a sentence I’ve been unable to get out of my head for days. If it is true that he, like so many Italians, considered Friday an unlucky day and thirteen an unlucky number, then it is remarkable that he died on a Friday, November 13. The sentence is written with typical British nonchalance. But it has a punchline that its author could hardly have foreseen: It is considered one of the earliest written records of someone merging the two ancient fears—of Friday and of the number thirteen—into a single one. Friday the 13th, as a date of dread, is younger than one might think. It bears, so to speak, Rossini’s death certificate on its birth certificate.

This column appears—and I’ve checked this as well—on a Friday, November 13. One hundred fifty-eight years later. Forgive me for not seeing this as a coincidence.

Eighteen Birthdays

Rossini had an ironic, but by no means indifferent, relationship with the calendar. He was born on February 29, 1792, in Pesaro—a leap day—and he consistently celebrated his birthday only when it occurred. In February 1868, he invited friends to his eighteenth birthday. The math even adds up: Since the year 1800 was not a leap year according to the Gregorian calendar, the seventy-six-year-old had in fact only experienced eighteen “real” birthdays. A man who measured time in bars got back at its pedantry by taking it at its word.

Anyone who plays with dates like this takes them seriously. Superstition and irony are closer to one another than the Enlightenment was willing to admit. Both know that the date itself means nothing; one fears it nonetheless, the other laughs at it nonetheless. Rossini, as his contemporaries agree, was both: superstitious and mocking, fearful and possessed of a biting wit. He feared illness, he feared death, he feared the railroad—and yet he was one of the wittiest people in Europe.

The Great Silence

One must keep in mind the scale of this life. Rossini wrote nearly forty operas, most of them in less than two decades. He premiered *Il Barbiere di Siviglia* in Rome in 1816, claiming to have composed it in thirteen days—there’s that number thirteen again; scholars, however, tend to estimate it took about three weeks. On August 3, 1829, “Guillaume Tell,” a work of monumental proportions, premiered at the Opéra in Paris. Rossini was thirty-seven years old and undisputedly the most popular opera composer in the world.

Then he stopped.

Not after a failure, but at the height of his career. He lived another thirty-nine years and never wrote another opera. None of the often-cited reasons suffices on its own: the July Revolution of 1830, which nullified his Paris contract; the death of his mother; a long, agonizing illness that afflicted both body and soul; the shift in taste toward Meyerbeer’s pomp and a louder vocal style. Perhaps he simply knew that he had said it all.

He called what he wrote afterward “Péchés de vieillesse,” sins of old age: some 150 salon pieces, songs, and piano miniatures, including a “Petit train de plaisir,” in which a pleasure ride by train ends in catastrophe—the phobic man composes his phobia. And then there is the “Petite messe solennelle,” which is neither small nor particularly solemn, but rather both at once. He prefaced it with a dedication to the Lord, one of the most beautiful self-revelations in the history of music. He asks whether he has written sacred music there, or merely accursed music—after all, he was born for opera buffa, as God well knows. A little science, a bit of heart—that’s all. May he be blessed and granted paradise.

Whoever prays like this is negotiating. And whoever negotiates is counting on an interlocutor who cannot be fully calculated.

A Visitor from the Future

In March 1860, a German stood at Rossini’s door in Paris. Richard Wagner was in town to push through his “Tannhäuser” at the Opéra, exhausted, in debt, and—not without reason—suspicious. In the salons, malicious witticisms were circulating about the “music of the future” attributed to Rossini. The Belgian music lover Edmond Michotte, a friend of both men, persuaded Wagner to pay the visit and transcribed the conversation; he did not publish it until 1906, nearly half a century later.

What Michotte records is a curious encounter. One had already stopped, the other had not yet truly begun. One stood for the “number opera”—for arias, ensembles, and cabalettas—for the joy of a form that is self-sufficient; the other for the “total work of art,” for the infinite melody, for a musical drama that seeks to redeem the world. Right from the start, Rossini distanced himself from these jokes. Then they spoke of melody and declamation and the future of opera. Rossini recounted his visit to Beethoven in Vienna in 1822 and the profound impact that this deaf man, living in poverty, had made on him.

Wagner never forgot that moment. In his essay “A Memory of Rossini,” written shortly after Rossini’s death, he confesses that Rossini had struck him as the first truly great and venerable person he had encountered in the world of art up to that point. Coming from a man who, in “Opera and Drama,” had judged Rossini’s indifference to dramatic truth rather condescendingly, this is a remarkable statement.

I have often thought of this scene in Bayreuth, in the darkness of the Festspielhaus, when time seems to stretch on. Wagner wanted it all: the stage, the nation, salvation. After 1829, Rossini wanted almost nothing—good food, good friends, a few sins of old age, peace. And yet it was the man of “less” who inspired awe in the man of “more.” Perhaps because Wagner sensed that this renunciation was a form of sovereignty he himself would never possess.

The Absolutism of Reality

But what does all this have to do with Friday the 13th? More than one might think. For superstition, viewed philosophically, is not a relapse into stupidity, but the response to an imposition. In his 1979 work *Arbeit am Mythos* (*Work on Myth*), Hans Blumenberg called this unreasonable demand the “absolutism of reality”: that primal state in which human beings have no control over the conditions of their existence and, worse still, do not even know what threatens them. Against this unnamed, overwhelming force, humans set names and stories; myth keeps the monstrous at a distance by giving it form.

Superstition is the small, feral brother of this endeavor. Those who fear Friday the 13th have at least put a date on their misfortune. They know when to be on guard. The diffuse fear is condensed into a single box on the calendar—and on all other days, life goes on untroubled. This is not rational, but it is economical. It is a bookkeeping of fear.

Rossini, the hypochondriac, the man who avoided railroads, was familiar with this accounting. Perhaps his silence after 1829 was also a retreat from the realm of the unpredictable—the theater, the audience, success, which can turn on a dime at any moment—into a realm he could control. The kitchen. The salon. Those who no longer write operas can no longer experience a fiasco.

Calculation and Enchantment

In his 1917 Munich lecture “Science as a Vocation,” Max Weber coined the phrase that has since accompanied every discussion of modernity: the “disenchantment of the world.” He did not mean that modern humans know more than so-called “savages”—Weber explicitly denied this—but rather that they believe there are no longer any mysterious, unpredictable forces, and that, in principle, everything can be mastered through calculation.

A good hundred years later, we live in the fully realized form of this confidence. Our world has been calculated down to our sleep cycles; algorithms predict what we’ll buy, when a train will be delayed, and the probability of rain in Zurich tomorrow at 2:00 p.m. And yet hotels still do without a thirteenth floor, some airlines omit the thirteenth row of seats, and horoscopes are flourishing in app stores like never before. Friday the 13th has not only survived this disenchantment; as we have seen, it actually emerged in the very age of disenchantment.

Hartmut Rosa offers a compelling explanation for this. In his 2018 essay “Unavailability,” he describes modernity as a program of expanding reach: the world is to be made visible, accessible, controllable, and usable. Yet the more completely this program succeeds, the more the world falls silent. Resonance—that response from the world which we experience in love, art, and nature—requires precisely a moment of the unavailability.

Superstition, then, would not be the opposite of the thoroughly calculated world, but rather its symptom. It is the small window we leave open so that the world can still speak to us—even if it is with the voice of a threat. Anyone who avoids ladders on Friday the 13th is rebelling against the imposition that nothing should have any meaning that cannot be expressed in terms of probabilities. They insist that not every day carries the same weight. That is irrational. But it is an irrationality that knows something true.

I don’t want to romanticize this. Superstition has burned women as witches, and the line between harmless ritual and dangerous delusion is thinner than the advocates of the indecipherable are willing to admit. But we can hold fast to the fact that the incorrigibility of superstition tells us something about the limits of reason.

Five Hundred Performances of “Tell”

On February 10, 1868, nine months before his death, Rossini received an honor bestowed upon few living people: the Paris Opéra staged “Guillaume Tell” for the five hundredth time. A bust of the composer was unveiled in the vestibule, and he was presented with a golden laurel wreath. It’s amusing that, for many years, the Opéra performed this four-hour behemoth only in fragments. When an admirer once proudly told him that the second act of his “Tell” had been performed the previous evening, Rossini is said to have asked in return: “What—uncut?”

For Swiss readers, this “Tell” is no ordinary subject. Based on Schiller’s 1804 drama, Rossini set the story of the marksman from Bürglen to music that is probably more familiar to people today than the text of the Federal Charter itself: the overture with its solitary cello opening, the thunderstorm, the English horn’s “cow dance,” and that galloping finale, which later found its way into countless animated films and Western series. An Italian in Paris, based on a German from Weimar, about a man from Uri who may never have existed: European cultural history in a nutshell. And it is an opera about the right to resist external coercion. Rossini claimed this right for himself after 1829.

Incidentally, “Der Apfelschuss” itself is a scene of uncontrollability. Tell can aim, can practice, can control his hand—but whether the arrow hits its mark, whether the child lives, depends on a margin of uncertainty that no art can fully control. Rossini set precisely this margin to music: Before the father takes aim, he asks his son, in one of the work’s most poignant arias, to stand completely still. That is all he can do.

Coda

Rossini was buried at Père-Lachaise; in 1887, his remains were transferred to Florence, to the Basilica of Santa Croce, where he now rests in the company of Michelangelo, Galileo, and Machiavelli. We do not know whether the old man in Passy thought of the calendar that Friday. Perhaps Rossini had long since moved beyond such calculations.

What remains is a constellation that is too beautiful to be meaningless, and yet is meaningless nonetheless. A man who counted down his birthdays according to the calendar dies on the very day he is said to have feared, thereby providing the first piece of evidence for a superstition that had scarcely existed until then. This is how every superstition arises: A coincidence becomes a story, the story becomes a rule, and the rule becomes fear.

Today, on this Friday the 13th, I won’t do anything special. I’ll listen to *The Barber of Seville*, perhaps the *Petite messe*, and order a tournedos Rossini for dinner. I won’t walk under any ladders. Not out of fear, of course. Out of courtesy toward the Unknowable.

Sapere aude!

S.

Your support keeps ideas alive — and stories in motion. 👉 https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=5NGG6XB67BZ4N 🙏

🇩🇪 My lyrical thoughts between two book covers: blau pause zimmerlautstärke - lyrik über die zeit - zurzeit

BoD Bookshop: https://buchshop.bod.de/blau-pause-zimmerlautstaerke-stefan-noir-9783695118779

Amazon-Shop: https://amzn.eu/d/1TvOBUO

🇺🇸 / 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 / 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 My lyrical thoughts between two book covers: blue pause room volume: poetry about time – currently

Amazon (English edition): https://amzn.eu/d/3b3GUF4