POUGHKEEPSIE – The four men accused of killing 46-year-old Carl Chambers from Marlboro in Ulster County were arraigned in Dutchess County Court this week following their felony indictments. Chambers was killed at a well-attended soccer match at Stitzel Field in Poughkeepsie on April 19. Hyde Park resident Sharnado Green, 29, and Poughkeepsie residents Peter “Butter” Green, 31, and Paul Green, 34, and Tyrese Hall, 21, were .
Tyrese Hall, Paul Green, and Peter Green were arraigned in Dutchess County Court on Tuesday; Sharnado Green was arraigned Wednesday morning.
Sharnado Green, Paul Green, and Peter Green are brothers. Hall is said to be a cousin of the Green brothers.
A Dutchess County Grand Jury indicted the four men for the murder of Chambers on June 11, 2026.
According to the indictment, Peter “Butter” Green and Tyrese Hall drove to Stitzel Field in one car, with Paul and Sharnado Green following in a second vehicle. Arriving at the soccer match, Peter “Butter” Green allegedly stabbed Chambers in the torso before Sharnado Green exited the second vehicle and shot Chambers several times with an assault rifle. Tyrese Hall then allegedly stood over Chambers, who was lying wounded on the ground, and shot him with a pistol.
The four men then allegedly fled the scene in the second vehicle.
District Attorney Anthony Parisi stated, “The allegations contained in this indictment describe an extraordinary level of violence and a complete disregard for human life and public safety. According to the investigation, this attack unfolded in a public area where community members had gathered for a soccer game, placing countless innocent people at risk. No one should have to fear that an afternoon at a neighborhood park could become the scene of deadly violence.”
Comments