You DON'T Need 8 Hours of Sleep in One Go (Here's Why)

Evidence Health
2 followers
#SleepScience #SleepTips #Silentnight
Does getting eight hours of sleep mean you need to get it all in one go? Not necessarily.
In this video, I explore the science behind split sleep, looking at what happens when you divide your sleep between the night and an afternoon nap. I’ll cover why we experience that familiar early afternoon energy dip, how long the ideal nap should be, and whether catching up on sleep during the day can make up for a shorter night.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Imagine two different people.
The first one goes to bed at 10,
sleeps right the way through the night, and then wakes up at 6.
Pretty normal, right? So that's eight hours in one go.
The second person goes to bed at 11,
they wake up at six, and then they have
an hour's nap after lunch every single day. So they've both
had exactly eight hours just done in completely different ways.
And the question that I want to
answer today is whether their bodies can actually tell the difference
and whether their bodies actually care
Now, we've all been told that the gold standard is...
Eight hours every single night in one big unbroken block.
But the thing is, scientists have now tested this properly
and the results are really interesting.
Although they come, as most things that I talk about,
they come with an important catch.
So I'm going to go through what actually happens when researchers
in this study split people's sleep into two different blocks
And why your body typically wants a little sleep early afternoon.
How long a typical nap should be,
whether a nap can make up for a short night's sleep,
and what napping actually means for your heart
and for your brain, and most importantly,
for how long you actually live.
Now, this follows on from my previous video a few weeks ago
about why eight hours isn't necessarily enough,
where I explained that the quality
and the structure of your sleep
is as important if not more important than the duration.
So if you're interested in sleep then
why don't you check that video out after you've watched this one.
Hello to all of you wherever
you're watching from I'm Dr Alex I'm
an emergency medicine doctor in the UK and if you want to hear
from me every single day then you can head over
to dralexnewsletter.com where you can sign up for
for my completely free day.
daily newsletter and also on the 25th of November
this year I'm launching what I'm hoping will be the
best recipe app and website for those of you
who want really delicious healthy meals and to also
learn a bit more about what that food
is actually doing inside your body. Okay so splitting sleep
into two this is actually being tested properly
and some of the best work comes from a research team
in Singapore of all places so I'll put the links below
because it's a really really interesting
study if you want to read this and others related to that.
Now in Singapore they took teenagers aged
15 to 19 and gave one group six
and a half hours in bed at night while the other group got five
hours at night plus a 90 minute nap in the afternoon.
So the same total time
just rearranged a bit differently and when they tested things like
Attention and memory and mood, the split group, they came out ahead.
And when they repeated that experiment with a full eight hours
for both groups, the two did equally well.
So splitting mainly helped when people were short on sleep,
if that makes sense.
Now, these were teenagers,
so we have to be careful applying it to somebody.
Thank
At the age of 60, for example,
but studies in adults typically tend to point the same way.
What counts mostly is the total sleep
you
that you get across the entire 24 hours,
whether it comes in one block or two.
very
There was one result that didn't favour
splitting at all, actually, though,
because they also gave everybody a sugary glucose drink,
much.
the same test that we use to check for diabetes.
And blood sugar went up higher in the split sleep group.
So what I'm really saying here after all
of that is that your brain seems fairly relaxed
about how you sort of package your sleep up,
but your metabolism might not be so relaxed.
I'll come back onto that a little later.
But first, it helps to understand why
an afternoon nap does anything at all,
which comes down to two things happening in your head.
across the entire day. Before we get
into that though let me just pause here for a second and
say that you know we put so much effort into what we eat
and how we exercise and for good reason
obviously but we hardly ever think about how we spend about
a third of our lives which is in bed.
Now in large studies people who regularly sleep under six hours
or who get bad quality sleep
these people have more hypertension,
more heart disease, more type 2 diabetes,
And ongoing insomnia, it roughly doubles your risk of depression.
Now, I've used Silent Night mattresses
and mattress toppers for, well, as long as I can
remember, all the way through university, even before then as well.
And I'm very grateful to say
that they're actually sponsoring this video today.
So this is the topper that I'm using at the moment.
This is the Silent Night Deep Sleep Mattress Topper.
It's 10 centimetres deep, basically double a standard topper with...
Fiber down fibers that actually feel like down
and it's got this boxed edge so you're not sloping
off the edge. It's a small change that a lot
of you can make that upgrades your mattress and the
comfort that you feel when you're sleeping without spending hundreds
and hundreds of pounds. After
years of night shifts in the A&E, I know, trust me,
I know what bad sleep does to your mood and
in your energy levels, in your concentration.
And one of the most overlooked reasons
for poor quality sleep is how comfortable your bed is.
And in small studies, people who swapped an old bed for a new one,
they actually slept better
with less back pain. And this is just a cheaper way to do that.
I actually do have one of these
on my actual bed at home.
This is just an extra one that they've sent me so I can show you
in this video. Remember
when choosing what mattress topper to actually use,
You've got to think about the quality.
And think about the depth as well.
And this one is honestly a really, really good one.
It is so, so comfortable.
And if you want to get your hands on this one,
then you can check out the link in the description below.
Okay then, so the afternoon slump that a lot of us feel around two
or three o'clock in the afternoon
that I used to feel on a regular basis,
this is mostly down to your body clock and the lunch you've just eaten.
That tends to play a much smaller part than we tend to think,
unless it's a meal that's sort of high in sugar, full of refined stuff.
But generally, if you're eating well,
then it's typically down to your body clock.
Now, there are two systems at work here.
The first one is called sleep pressure.
And the easiest way to picture this is a bucket
that starts filling up from the moment that you wake up.
Basically, as this chemical called adenosine
builds up in your brain
and the fuller that bucket gets sort of as you go through the day
the sleepier you feel.
The second one is your body clock which sends out a wake-up signal
through the day to keep you going against that bucket.
The thing is though that signal eases off
sort of a little bit in the early afternoon just
as the bucket is getting fairly full. So for an
An hour or two.
The sleepy side wins and the way
that a very short nap works here is that that nap tips a bit of
water out of the bucket which is why you wake up feeling a bit sharper.
It gets rid of some of that
sleep pressure. That's
also exactly how a nap causes some trouble as well because
whatever you tip out in the afternoon isn't there
to help you drop back off at bedtime.
And that's especially relevant if you struggle with insomnia
because the treatment that works
best for it, which is a talking therapy called CBT,
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia,
it usually means cutting out daytime naps completely.
So if you're lying awake for really long stretches at night,
Please don't take this video as a reason to start napping.
The best thing to do at this point
is to actually go to somebody who can establish
what your sleep pattern is like
and to do a thorough history.
But generally, whether a nap helps or hinders,
it typically comes down mostly to how long it lasts.
The length of a nap really does make a huge difference
to how you feel afterwards.
And one of the best studies on this particular point
Flinders University in Australia now they took 24 healthy young
adults they cut their sleep to about five hours the night before
and then on different days let them nap for 5, 10,
20 or 30 minutes in the afternoon or not at all.
Now the five minute nap did very little
as you might expect whereas 10 minutes gave
An immediate lift in alertness and thinking that lasted up to around,
say, two and a half hours.
A 20 minute nap did help as well.
But by the time you get to 30 minutes,
people actually started to feel worse after that nap.
Now, that sort of groggy, like,
where am I sort of feeling, that is called sleep inertia.
And it happens because the longer that you nap,
the more likely you are to slip into deep sleep.
And being woken up from deep sleep,
this is like being dragged out of a warm bath into a cold room.
If it's ever happened to you where you sort of startled up sort of half
an hour after you go to sleep, then, you know, it doesn't feel great.
So essentially the sweet spot for most of us
if you're napping is say 10 to 20 minutes finished by
mid-afternoon with an alarm set if you tend to drift off
and you won't you know trust yourself
to wake up after say 15 minutes.
If you do have a longer nap then give yourself a few minutes
before you drive and if you're a bit older sit on the edge of the bed
or the sofa for a minute or
Before you stand up because grogginess
Plus, getting up quickly,
this is how a lot of falls happen that we see in the A&E.
So, a short nap can sharpen you up a bit.
But that leads to a question
which a lot of you are probably asking right now,
which is whether you can cut your night short
and then make up for it in the afternoon.
And there's lots of reasons why you might want to do this.
Let's say family routine.
Busy evening, working after the kids go to bed,
or some other commitments like that.
Making up a short night with a nap during the day,
that only really works up to a point.
And the first problem is, well, it's just simple math.
So if we go back to our two people at the
beginning, seven hours a night plus an hour after lunch,
that's still eight hours, isn't it? But
But six hours at night and then a 20-minute nap during the day.
Well, that's just six hours and 20 minutes
and no clever maths or timing or whatever.
None of that is going to turn that into eight hours.
The nap, yes, it can take the edge off sleepiness
and poor concentration during the day so you
cope better that afternoon,
but feeling better isn't the same as your body getting everything
it needs.
Nighttime sleep happens when your whole body is set up.
for that sleep overnight with your melatonin going up
and your core temperature sort of reducing and
that's when a lot of the body's repair work happens
as well including the overnight dip
in your blood pressure
and this is where that blood sugar result fits in actually because
In the afternoon means sleeping
when your body clock expects you to be up and moving
and eating.
And one likely explanation here is that moving sleep
into the day nudges your metabolism
out of step.
After your lunch, typically we want to be moving to try
and be burning some of that
that glucose off.
But if you go for a nap, then the opposite is happening.
You are literally still, you know, not moving a muscle.
So what I'd say here is that if your life means
that you can't get enough sleep in one
go overnight, maybe you're a shift worker, maybe you're...
A new parent or a carer
then a planned nap during the day is a really sensible way of
protecting yourself or trying to reduce your risk of certain things
but cutting your night
short on purpose because you think
a nap will cover it isn't something that the evidence supports
and when you stop looking at how alert people feel
and start looking at their hearts and how
How long they live.
As always the picture shifts again.
Now the research on napping and long-term health it does
need handling quite carefully
because most of it is observational which means that researchers
follow people's habits over years rather than actually testing naps
if that makes sense. We're
not randomly assigning anybody
to a particular group we're just sort of following people over years
Now, a big review in 2022 found that long naps
Of an hour or more per day,
this was linked with higher blood pressure and diabetes and
heart disease and dying earlier,
while naps of under half an hour mostly weren't, at least
in younger and middle-aged adults at least.
A recent study from Boston tracked 1,300 older adults
with wrist monitors for up to 19 years,
And each extra hour of napping a day
was linked with about a 13% higher risk.
of dying so each extra hour a day 13% increased risk
of dying is pretty serious stuff isn't it
and people who napped in the morning had around
a 30% higher risk than afternoon nappers and there
were a lot of things that you could sort of try to infer
or interpret from this you know if you're
needing a nap in the morning after you wake up then the chances are
You're sleeping pretty terribly during the night,
which increases your risk of lots of different things as well.
People who don't nap at all probably have a great sleep routine
and probably exercising and eating well.
So, you know, there are lots of things
that are sort of possibly working together here.
And the researchers in these studies
were pretty clear that this is a link and not proof.
And the likeliest explanation according to them runs
the other way around because needing lots
of daytime sleep like I said is often a sign
of something that you know something that's already
going on like poor sleep at night
or sleep apnea that hasn't been picked up yet or heart problems
or early changes in the brain
or hormonal shifts as well or low mood or a side effect
Of a medication, there are lots of different reasons for this.
A huge international study of over
a hundred thousand people completely backs this up
because naps were only linked with more heart attacks and more strokes
and deaths in people already sleeping more than six hours at night.
Now that doesn't mean that a short night is fine
as long as you have a nap during the day.
What the study showed
is that in people sleeping six hours or less napping
Didn't add any extra risk on top
but the short night itself is still linked with higher blood
pressure and heart disease and type 2 diabetes.
In people who were already getting a full night
though regular napping went along with more heart attacks
and strokes and deaths and that fits with
what I said a moment ago.
You know needing a lot of sleep in the day when you're already sleeping
well at night supposedly is often
a sign that something else is going on.
So if that sounds like you,
then it's worth getting checked out, especially if you snore
loudly, somebody's been noticing
that you're stopping breathing in your sleep, which is
sleep apnea, or an older relative has
started napping far more than they used to.
On the brain side a UK biobank study
of nearly 400,000 people compared those born with genes that
make them more likely to nap against those without those genes
and because those genes are handed out
at random at birth I guess you know it works
a bit like a natural randomized experiment that
cuts out lifestyle differences.
Now people with the napping genes had slightly larger brains
On the scans, although...
Their memory was no better
and you know it's a really interesting study if you want to take a
read of it below. It's probably a bit too long
to go into detail in this video but it is worth a
read. So can I tell you that napping helps you to live longer?
Well the answer is no but what I can
say is that a short afternoon nap doesn't look
like it's doing you any harm. The thing to keep
is long naps or needing more and more sleep during the day
because that's usually telling
you something about your nights or your health in general.
I hope I haven't made all of this too complicated let me know
in the comments if I've not made this
clear but let me just say you know what does all
of this video mean then well
going back to the question I asked right
at the beginning about whether your body cares
how you sort of package up your sleep well
the answer is partly yes and partly no
Your brain doesn't seem to mind very much
because for alertness and memory and mood
it's the total across the 24 hours that counts
which is why you don't need
all eight hours in one go for sort of how you're feeling in yourself.
The rest of your body though,
it does seem to prefer getting most of its sleep
at night as close to eight hours on average if you can.
That's when your blood pressure dips
and a lot of the repair work goes on
and your blood sugar seems to be handled better
when your sleep comes in one block at night.
So, in a nutshell, what I'm saying in this video
is that the main block of your sleep should be at night.
I think most people would agree with that.
And it needs to be long enough, which for adults is generally,
on average, seven hours or more.
There will be some of you watching this who...
Say you function on six hours
and for some of you that will be true but for the average person
it's typically seven hours or more.
Now a nap during the day is something you can add on top
when you need it and it's best kept to be sort
of 10 to 20 minutes long. A nap can help you get
through the day after a short night
but it can't replace the sleep that you've missed. So
Going back to our two people just one last time,
the first person sleeping eight hours straight
through is doing exactly what their body needs.
The second person is getting seven hours at night
which you know is enough for most adults
so they don't actually need that nap to get by. If they
enjoy it and it's just part of their routine
and it doesn't stop them sleeping at night
And the rest of their markers are fine
and they're able to exercise okay
and their blood sugar doesn't sort of climb after the lunch
because they're sleeping then, you know,
then I guess that's fine.
But I would still suggest bringing that nap down
to 20 minutes or so
because they'll wake up less groggy
and less likely to eat into their night.
But, you know, if they find that they can't get through
their afternoon without that full hour,
Even after seven hours of sleep at night,
that's the kind of daytime sleepiness
that I would want them to get checked out.
So if you sort of sleep well at night
and you wake up feeling well-rested,
then there's no reason to start napping during the day.
So just carry on as you are.
If you enjoy a nap after lunch,
then keep it to 10 or 20 minutes
and finish it by mid-afternoon.
If your life means that you can't get enough sleep in one go,
maybe because you're a shift worker or a new parent or a carer,
then a planned short nap could
be a sensible way of protecting yourself.
But please don't cut your night short on purpose,
thinking that a nap will make up for it.
If you're lying awake at night,
then obviously just cut those naps out during the day
And go to your doctor.
Who will hopefully talk to you about CBT for insomnia
or other things like that.
Because naps can absolutely make that problem a lot worse.
And if you're getting a full night's sleep
and still needing more and more sleep during the day.
Or you're nodding off when you don't mean to.
Don't just keep topping this up with naps during the day.
Go and get it looked at.
Go to your doctor who can take a thorough history
and evaluate you properly.
Underneath all of this.
Basically are the same foundations as in the last video,
which is a regular wake time,
daylight as sort of soon as you can first thing in the morning,
moving during the day,
protecting the first few hours of the night as much as you can,
and actually having a comfortable
bed to sleep in. And so I hope that video was useful today.
If you learned something,
then please do give it a like and subscribe to the channel.
Both of those are free.
And it really does help me out an awful lot.
Thank you so much for watching.
Have a great day wherever you are.
And I'll see you next time.
