Why Top Gun: Maverick Action Scenes Feel Unbelievably Real

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
This video is sponsored by Squarespace,
the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful website for your business.
The runaway financial success of Top Gun Maverick that makes it, at the time of this video,
the sixth highest grossing movie in US box office history,
coming out ahead of even an Avengers movie, can be boiled down to numerous factors.
It was built on existing copyright and boosted by the success of the original Top Gun.
It starred Tom Cruise.
It pulled at the sentimental strings of a huge audience that missed the big
Hollywood blockbusters of old while still revitalising it with something fresh.
It was directed with a deft handling of emotion.
And what we'll talk about in this video,
it was executed with amazingly filmed aerial action sequences
that keep audiences right on the edge of their seats.
But what is it that differentiates these moments of action
from many of the other blockbuster set pieces that we've become used to?
I'd pinpoint it to an effective use of in-camera photography,
in other words using real effects more than visual effects.
I think when you see the film you really feel what it's like to be a Top Gun pilot.
You can't fake that.
Much of the appeal of what makes up a blockbuster comes from the sequences
which feel larger than life and offer a spectacle,
whether that means large choreographed dance routines,
car chases, bank heists or displays of superpowers.
Every scene like this requires a filmmaking solution
beyond the realms of just shooting two actors talking.
On the one end we have practical or in-camera effects.
This is where real world filmmaking,
engineering solutions and optical trickery are mixed,
such as shooting miniatures or using forced perspective.
At the other end we have CGI,
where computer software is used to manipulate and create those images.
Almost every big budget movie nowadays including Top Gun Maverick
uses a combination of both practical photography and computer generated imagery.
However some films, like Maverick,
prioritise in-camera effects in order to achieve shots with a greater tie to reality.
You can't fake the g-forces, you can't fake the vibration,
you can't fake what it looks like to be in one of these fighter jets.
We wanted to capture every bit of that and shooting it for real allowed us to do that.
Once director Joseph Kaczynski and cinematographer Claudio Miranda
had the shooting script in their hands,
they had to start making decisions about how they would translate the words on the page
into awe-inspiring aerial action set pieces.
Shooting aerial sequences is a large practical challenge.
First they broke the aerial shots that they needed into three types of shots.
One, on the ground shots.
Two, air-to-air shots.
And three, on-board shots.
To execute the many aerial sequences in the movie they turned to David Knoll,
a camera operator and specialist aerial director of photography
who had worked on the original Top Gun film.
If you analyse the first Top Gun about 75% of all the aerials we actually did from the mountain top
because you can get stuff on a 1000mm lens that you just can't quite get
when you're filming air-to-air and I brought that forward
to Joe Kaczynski saying you have to do this on this movie,
this is the difference it makes and so we did.
We spent almost a week on the new Top Gun just on the mountain top
getting all the different shots that they needed.
Cinematographer Claudio Miranda selected the Sony Venice as the best camera for the shoot
for reasons we'll get to later.
This digital footage was warmed up a lot,
given deep shadows and had artificial 35mm film grain added to it in the grade
to give the footage a similar feeling to the original with its warm bronze skin tones.
To further enhance the original Top Gun look,
Miranda consulted with Jeffrey Kimball, the cinematographer on the 1986 film
who passed on information about the graduated filters that he shot with.
Grads or graduated ND filters have a gradient level of ND that is strong at the top
and decreases at the bottom,
either softly or with a hard definition.
Usually grads are used to shoot landscapes or skies.
When the darker ND part of the filter is placed over the sky,
it produces a more dramatic, tinted look.
To capture all the angles that they needed for these scenes
meant that a massive camera package was used.
Six cameras could be used for the on-board action,
four cameras could be mounted to the plane's exterior at a time,
the air-to-air shooting was another camera
and a few cameras were needed for the ground-to-air unit.
Like the original, they decided to shoot on spherical lenses
and crop to a 2.39 to 1 aspect ratio.
This was due to spherical lenses having better close focus abilities
and being smaller in size than anamorphic lenses,
which allowed them to be placed in the tight plane interiors.
To get shots of the planes in the ground,
a camera unit was equipped with a Fujinon Premier 24-180mm
and a 75-400mm zoom.
They also carried two long Canon still lenses that were rehoused for cinema use,
a 150-600mm zoom and a 1000mm lens.
When this wasn't long enough, they used a doubler from IBE Optics.
This 2x extender attaches to the back of the lens via a PL mount
and doubles the focal length range.
So a 75-400mm zoom effectively becomes a 150-800mm lens.
Tracking fast moving objects so far away is very difficult,
so the operators ended up using modified rifle scopes
mounted on top of the camera to help them sight the planes.
The on-the-ground scenes captured an F-14 Tomcat,
which was reskinned or made to look like an F-18 with digital effects.
This is a great example of the kind of intersection between practical photography
and digital effects which I talked about earlier.
Although very useful, on-the-ground cameras are unable to physically move the camera
to track with the aircrafts, beyond using pans and tilts.
For dynamic in-the-air motion and a raised point of view,
the camera team shot air-to-air footage.
This required shooting with a Cinejet,
an agile Aero L-39 Albatross jet that has a shot over F-1 stabilised head
custom built onto the front of the nose which houses the camera.
The camera can be operated while the position of the plane is also adjusted
relative to the other planes they were shooting by an experienced pilot.
Since the shot over is primarily designed to be used from a slower moving helicopter
and on Maverick they were shooting a fast moving Boeing FA-18F Super Hornet fighter jet,
they needed to come up with a technical solution.
The one big change for Top Gun is that the shot over systems that we have used for years
was never fast enough to go any faster than what a helicopter would do,
but then shot over they updated the motors in that that could take the high torque needed
to be able to pan and tilt while flying 350 knots, it's close to 400 miles an hour.
For certain sequences that required a shot looking back on aircrafts,
they used an Embraer Phenom 300 camera jet that had both front and back mounted shot overs.
The Venice that was mounted on the shot over was paired with a Fujinon Zoom,
either a 20-120mm or an 85-300mm zoom.
Some helicopter work was also done with a larger shot over K1
that had an extended case that could house Fujinon's larger 25-300mm zoom.
Some of the most incredible shots in the film came from the interior mounted cameras,
but before we get there I'd like to thank the sponsor that made this video possible,
Squarespace.
Every business nowadays needs a website and because as a filmmaker you are your business
you can't be without one.
You need an online presence for clients to browse your work,
a page to bring all your social accounts together and a contact point for collaborators to reach you.
Squarespace is an all-in-one platform that you can use to easily create a stylish and
functional website.
Every week I use their blogging tools which allow me to categorise,
schedule and integrate my YouTube videos along with a written article on my site.
You can also use Squarespace's libraries to display any of your creative works such as
photos and videos to show the online world examples of what you can do.
So head to squarespace.com for a free trial
and when you're ready to launch go to squarespace.com
slash indepthcine to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Arguably the most engaging and jaw-dropping footage in the film
comes from the cameras that are hard mounted onto the plane itself.
There are two ways that this kind of footage can be shot.
The most common technique involves placing actors in a stationary car, spaceship,
plane or whatever kind of moving vehicle it is on a studio soundstage.
Outside the windows of said vehicle the technical crew will place a large blue screen,
green screen or nowadays a section of LED wall.
The actors then pretend the vehicle is moving,
do their scene and the crew may give the vehicle a shake to simulate movement.
In post-production this blue screen outside the windows
is replaced with either footage of the background space that they want to put the vehicle in,
such as highway footage or with an artificial computer generated background.
The two main reasons for shooting this way is that 1.
it's usually a cheaper way of shooting and 2.
it offers a far greater degree of control.
For example, it allows the actors to easily repeat the scene,
the director can monitor their live performances and talk to them between takes,
the sound person can get clean dialogue
and the DP can carefully light so that the scene is exposed to their liking.
Instead of taking this more conventional approach,
Top Gun's creative team made the radical decision to shoot this footage practically,
in real life.
To prepare the actors underwent three months of training, designed by Tom Cruise,
so that they could withstand the extreme forces that would play out on them during filming.
Along with the difficulties involved in the actors giving complex emotional performances
while flying at extremely high speeds,
rigging the onboard cameras to capture these performances was no easy feat.
The main reason that Miranda went with the Sony Venice was due to its Rialto system.
This effectively allows the camera to be broken in two,
with one small sliver that has the sensor and the lens
and the other which has the rest of the camera body and the required battery power.
These units are tethered by a cable.
First AC, Dan Ming, along with a team of engineers
came up with a plan to mount six cameras inside the F-18.
They custom machined plates that could be screwed into the plane that the cameras were mounted to.
Three Venice bodies and a fourth Venice sensor block
were mounted in front of the actors in the back seat of the jet.
These were tethered to a body block and battery rack
that they placed near the front seat where the real pilot was.
Two additional sensor blocks were also rigged on either side of the actor
to get over the shoulder shots.
Again they were tethered to body blocks at the front of the plane.
As I mentioned, fitting that many cameras into such a tight space
meant that the lenses needed to be spherical,
have a good close focus and be as low profile as possible.
Miranda went with a combination of 10-15mm compact Voigtlander Heliar wide angle prime lenses
and Zeiss Loxia primes.
Earlier I mentioned that this method of hard mounting the cameras came with a lack of control.
This was perhaps best seen by the fact that once the plane took off,
not only were the actors responsible for their own performances,
but they even had to trigger the camera to roll and stop when they were up in the air.
Ultimately when they're up there, it's up to them to turn the camera on and play the scene.
I mean the biggest challenge is not being there, you know, to give feedback obviously,
so you're putting a lot of responsibility and trust in our cast.
So that was a unique way of directing the film for those particular scenes,
but it's the only way to capture what we were able to get.
Filming in this way meant that they'd do a run,
come back and sometimes find out that parts of the footage wasn't usable because of the lighting,
or the actor's eyeline being in the wrong place,
or even because an actor didn't properly trigger the camera to record.
However the footage that did work looked incredible
and gave a feeling of being in a real cockpit,
complete with all the vibrations, natural variations in light
and realistic, adrenaline filled performances from the actors.
These images wouldn't have been the same had they shot these scenes in a studio.
Four cameras were also hard mounted directly onto the exterior of the jet.
Again they used the Rialto system with wide angle Voigtlander primes.
Another advantage of using the Venice is that it has a wide selection of internal ND filters.
This meant that they didn't need to attach a matte box with external NDs to decrease the exposure,
which would have made the camera's profile too big for the interior shots
and would have probably been impossible to do safely
on the exterior cameras due to the extreme high speeds of the jet.
Top Gun Maverick brings us back to an era of filmmaking
where real effects are used to tell stories and the CGI that is used is done subtly
and largely goes unnoticed by the audience.
For years now, by and large, I've been nonplussed watching most action in films.
The overabundance of CGI effects triggers something in my brain that tells me that
what I'm watching isn't real, which makes the action feel less exciting.
By putting us in an environment where each and every manoeuvre is physical,
real and visceral, it makes the stakes real.
This leads to a real emotional connection and immersion in the story.
There's a reason why you often hear some auteurs sing the praises of in-camera effects
and disparage the overuse of CGI.
Maverick uses the best of both worlds.
The crew executed most of the action with bold, practical photography which was safe and innovative.
Subtle digital effects were then brought in later when necessary
to make up for those shots which were practically impossible.
I can only hope that Hollywood executives take this away as one of the reasons for
the film's financial success and encourage these kinds of filmmaking decisions going forward.
There's always a time and a place for great VFX in cinema,
but sometimes shooting things practically is the best way to go.
Let me know your thoughts on Practical Effects and the film.
Otherwise a special thanks to all the supporters of the channel on Patreon
or anyone who supported the channel by buying merch.
Until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
