This video explores why so many Roman cities were abandoned in late antiquity and the Middle Ages.
Go to https://ground.news/toldinstone for a better way to stay informed. Subscribe for 40% off unlimited access to world-wide coverage through my link.
Check out my other channels, @toldinstonefootnotes and @scenicroutestothepast
Chapters 0:00 Introduction 0:57 Roman cities 2:00 Decline 3:24 Ground News 4:30 Geographic factors 6:01 Climate and landscape 6:40 Disease 7:14 Economic changes 7:58 The fragility of cities
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores why some Roman cities thrived into the modern era while hundreds of others were abandoned. It examines the transition from the prosperity of the Pax Romana to a period of decline driven by a complex interplay of political collapse, foreign invasions, environmental shifts, and economic disintegration.
London, Paris, Milan, and hundreds of other cities founded by the Romans are still thriving today.
But hundreds more, in every part of the former classical world, have been abandoned. I'm
standing in the ruins of Termesis, in what is now southern Turkey. This was a monumental street,
lined on both sides by shops with statue bases carrying bronze images of local benefactors.
But for 15 centuries, this street has been silent, save for the rumbling of earthquakes
and the scratching of scavengers. Today's video will try to explain how cities like Termesis
could flourish for centuries, and then, almost without warning, disappear.
The Roman Empire was a confederation of cities. Rome itself had begun as a city-state,
which annexed hundreds of others as it expanded across the Mediterranean basin.
Where cities did not yet exist, the Romans established them until a continuous network
of 2,000 extended from Britain to Syria. Each Roman city was responsible for administering
a fixed territory. Its leading citizens collected taxes on Rome's behalf and kept order in the
countryside. In return, they were offered a share in the prosperity of the Pax Romana,
with its unprecedented opportunities for political advancement.
To consolidate and commemorate their position, civic elites poured vast sums into public building.
Forms and fountains, aqueducts and baths and gymnasiums, amphitheaters and avenues lined
with statues—all the monuments, in short, that still define our image of the Roman city.
The Golden Age ended amid the invasions and economic crises of the 3rd century.
Along the frontiers, barbarian incursions damaged or destroyed hundreds of cities.
Even places spared by the marauders often withdrew within walls cobbled together
from disassembled monuments. Although stability returned in the 4th century,
long-term social changes slowed the process of recovery. The later Roman emperors had
increasing difficulty convincing local notables to manage their cities. The wealthiest magnates
often left for well-paid positions in the imperial administration. Those who remained
tended to become increasingly impoverished, less able and less willing to govern.
Cities with important roles in the government of the empire thrived as long as the empire did.
In Gaul, Arl and Trier grew larger than ever before in Late Antiquity. But in most parts
of the northwestern provinces, where the urban tradition had shallow roots, cities contracted.
Londinium, for example, began to lose inhabitants in the late 2nd century and seems to have been
completely abandoned after the Roman evacuation of Britain. We'll explore some of the factors
that affected the survival of late antique cities after a brief word about this video's sponsor.
For historians like me, context is everything. And when I need context in today's media landscape,
I turn to Ground News. Ground News is a website and app that gathers news from around the globe.
It indicates which media outlets are reporting on a story and tags them by political bias,
factuality, and ownership. To take a recent example, 480 news sources reported on the recent
presidential visit to Texas. The left-leaning Atlantic was broadly critical. The Trump
administration is violating the first rule of disasters. The World Socialist website,
much farther left, didn't bother to mince words. The perpetrator-in-chief at the scene of the crime
Head to ground.news slash toldenstone or scan the QR code on screen to subscribe,
and you'll save 40% on the Vantage Plan, which comes to just $5 a month.
Returning to our topic. In general, cities near the Mediterranean were likelier to survive the
collapse of the Western Roman Empire than those on the frontiers. Besides being closer to still
vital trade routes, they had a better chance of being peacefully incorporated into one of the
barbarian kingdoms that replaced the empire. In later centuries, however, cities on the
Mediterranean coast became subject to pirate attack. Even St. Peter's Basilica was looted
by Saracen raiders in the 9th century. To escape the danger, the inhabitants of some coastal
settlements moved en masse to the nearest defensible hill. Cities in parts of the Eastern
Roman Empire remained healthy until the early 7th century, when the Avars and Slavs overran
the Balkans and the Persians and Arabs took the Near East. The cities of Syria and Palestine,
close to the center of the newly established Umayyad Caliphate, survived and even flourished
after the Arab conquests. Eventually, however, almost every region was subjected to raids and
invasions. The Anatolian Plateau was ravaged by armies of Arab horsemen, driving the inhabitants
to abandon their cities for castles and caves. In the 11th century Maghreb, the migrating Banu
Hilal tribe destroyed so many cities that regions cultivated since the Roman period
reverted to pastoralism. Invaders were far from the only problems cities faced. The early
imperial era had coincided with a protracted period of exceptional warmth. As the climate
cooled in late antiquity, cities like Zagalassis, high in the Taurus Mountains, withered in response.
Sometimes, the landscapes around cities became inhospitable. The irrigated fields of Egypt's
Fayyum Basin were ruined by salination. The harbors of Ephesus and Miletus silted up.
Earthquakes caused much of Alexandria and Bayai to sink into the sea. Over the course of classical
history, falciparum malaria, the variety most deadly to humans, gradually spread westward
across the Mediterranean basin. The effects seemed to have been worsened by deforestation,
which filled rivers with sediment and encouraged them to form mosquito-haunted deltas. Previously
healthy places became dangerous. Malaria was largely responsible for transforming the Roman
Campania, once famous for its rich farms and sprawling villas, into the wasteland it remained
until the 19th century. Even where invasions were infrequent and the landscape remained healthy,
the disappearance of the Roman Empire was accompanied by profound economic changes.
These were most dramatic along the former frontiers, where many cities had depended,
directly or indirectly, on military spending. Cities everywhere, however, relied on dense
networks of exchange. On the limestone plateau of northern Syria, dozens of large villages
had emerged in late antiquity, supplying olive oil to Antioch and its neighbors. But after trade
routes changed in the wake of the Arab conquest, the villages were abandoned. Their gaunt ruins,
never again inhabited, came to be known as the Dead Cities. It can be easy to forget how fragile
cities are. They rely on sprawling networks of trade and transport, delicate webs of infrastructure,
critical masses of people and resources. Although invasions and natural disasters played their part,
most Roman cities were doomed by subtler changes, which slowly unraveled their reasons for being.
The world changed, people drifted away, and only ruins were left behind.
Make sure you aren't left behind by joining my trip to Greece this October. You'll find a link
in the description, along with a link to the Tollenstone Patreon page, with its myriad historical
delights. Don't forget my other channels, Scenic Routes of the Past and Tollenstone Footnotes.
And, as always, thanks for watching.