Why Oxtail Is More Expensive Than Ever | So Expensive | Business Insider

Ancient Cuisine
62 followers
259 Video Views·Dec 21, 2024
In the US, oxtail was once considered a cheap and undesirable cut of beef. That's because it's mostly bone and fat, with only about 40% usable meat. But as it's become more popular in recent years, its price has jumped to $14 a pound. Now, oxtail's longtime fans are fighting to
This bony cut of beef has become a hot commodity.
It's called oxtail and it goes for around $14 a pound.
About the same price as a pound of sirloin steak, but for a lot less meat.
I'm selling out of oxtail like every week. I can't keep up.
But that wasn't always the case.
For a long time, oxtail was considered a throwaway cut of beef in the United States.
As recently as two decades ago, it only cost a few dollars per pound.
Back then, in like early 2000, nobody wanted it.
So what changed?
The reputation of oxtail is as high as it's ever been.
Now, prices have skyrocketed for everyone.
And some who've been eating oxtail all along aren't happy about the hike.
Oxtail prices are just getting out of hand, man. We're not about it.
An online movement has started to make oxtail cheap again.
Business Insider even found itself in the middle of the viral controversy.
So why is oxtail suddenly so expensive?
And what does the increasing price mean for people who've been eating oxtail for generations?
Finding oxtail on menus in the United States was rare just a couple decades ago.
Pat LaFrieda's family's butcher shop in New Jersey has been selling the cut since it opened in 1922.
He says that in the past, the cut of beef never got much attention from restaurants.
Most of his oxtail sales came from Latin American,
Asian and Caribbean communities who have cooked with it for generations.
There are many cultures that focus in on the oxtail because at one time, it was an economy cut.
One big reason oxtail was considered a throwaway is that it has a lot less
meat than other cuts of beef.
That's because it's mostly bone and fat, with only about 40% usable meat.
To get the same amount of meat as one pound of another cut of beef, like sirloin steak,
you'd need two and a half pounds of oxtail.
So when you really calculate how much meat you have for a poundage of product, it's not much.
Still, those eating oxtail back then knew it wasn't like any other cut of beef.
The flavor is so distinctive.
You can close your eyes, probably put your blindfold on, you will know that it's oxtail.
Oxtail is high in collagen and is more gelatinous than most other cuts of beef.
The collagen breaks down when it's cooked and gives the meat a buttery melt-in-your-mouth texture.
I love oxtails.
If they cook correctly, not everybody can cook oxtails.
And if you season it right, oh my god, it'll last in your mouth for days.
It really is the pearl of the animal.
But because it's so succulent and because it's so spoon-tender once cooked,
there's no mistaking that for any other cut in the animal.
And while oxtail wasn't widely in demand in the U.S.,
the story was much different in Jamaica,
where food lovers have long known the value of the bony beef.
I don't know if it's a bone or something, but most overseas,
they come to Jamaica just for the oxtail.
O'Shea Williams learned how to cook traditional Jamaican oxtail stew when he was a child.
It's not to be pippy like any other way.
Today, it's one of the best-selling dishes at his seaside restaurant,
O'Shea's 876 Kitchen in Port Antonio, Jamaica.
The dish dates back to the island's colonial era,
when enslaved Africans were given unwanted animal parts like oxtail to eat.
Using their ancestral cooking techniques and local spices,
they turned it into a flavorful stew that's now a staple of Jamaican cuisine.
The oxtail is typically chopped into one-inch pieces and seasoned with fresh spices.
The meat is then slow-cooked over an open fire for hours until it falls off the bone.
While oxtail was always somewhat of a luxury in Jamaica,
the prices O'Shea is seeing today are way higher than before.
That's because there's more demand in the U.S.
41% of meat imported to Jamaica comes from the U.S., including oxtail.
So if prices are up stateside, they're up in Jamaica, too.
Oxtail's popularity in the U.S. has been on the rise since the mid-2010s,
but it really spiked during and after the COVID-19 pandemic.
As supply chain issues drove up beef prices in America,
consumers searching for cheaper meat turned to cuts like oxtail.
But oxtail was never meant to have such a high demand.
Oxtail only makes up four to six pounds of a cow,
compared to the hundreds of pounds of the other beef cuts.
This limited supply, combined with growing demand,
has more than doubled U.S. oxtail prices over the past decade, from $6 in 2015 to $14 in 2024.
Today, Pat says oxtail is the most expensive he's ever seen it.
The demand for it is as high as it's ever been.
To understand just how much the price has jumped,
we visited chef Judith Abel at Swirl Wine Bistro in South Florida.
She makes an oxtail ravioli that costs more than double what it used to.
When we first opened Swirl on the menu, it was under $20 for the dish.
Today, it costs $48.
Oxtail was one of Judith's favorite dishes growing up as a child in Jamaica.
I can remember maybe around maybe 10 having oxtail.
It was so good, oh my goodness.
It's always an upscale family meal.
For better holidays, you'll get some oxtail.
People are coming over to your house on a Sunday, you know, you'll cook oxtail.
It wasn't until she moved to the U.S. in 1986 that she realized
just how inexpensive the cut of meat was outside of the island.
It was like a dollar and change.
We were cooking oxtail at my sister's house because,
oh my goodness, oxtail is like, it's like so cheap here.
But as the price of oxtail rises, she can barely make a profit from it.
There was a point where we were like, yeah, we're not putting it on the menu.
So we had stopped serving it for a while.
Right now we have to cap it because how much can you sell, you know, ravioli for?
But for now, I'm just making it out of love.
With a $48 oxtail ravioli dish, it's safe to say consumers are feeling the impact.
Oxtail prices are just getting out of hand, Pam.
That's Jamaican comedian Marlon Palmer.
In 2016, he sparked an online movement bringing awareness to rising oxtail prices
with the hashtag Make Oxtail Cheap Again.
It all started when he saw the price of an oxtail entree
at his local Jamaican restaurant in Toronto start to rise.
I went to Albert's and I looked at the price and I was like, this is not the normal price.
And so I made an Instagram story or like a Snapchat or something,
and I was like, could you look at this?
$20 for a large oxtail in a tin?
What is that?
And at the time, Trump was running on his Make America Great Again campaign.
So I was like, Make Oxtail Cheap Again.
This is what we need to be campaigning for.
The hashtag quickly garnered thousands of mentions all over social media,
with longtime oxtail lovers sharing their experiences.
Through doing it, I realized how many people felt the same way
but just weren't saying anything.
It's that sense of community.
We're all in on the joke.
We all know what's at stake here,
and we're treating it like this dire situation.
It's not dire, but to our community, it's dire.
Business Insider found itself in the middle of the controversy.
In 2023, our food page reposted a video about oxtail on Twitter,
garnering over 36 million views and thousands of reposts.
In the replies, oxtail lovers like Marlon tried their best
to steer people away from their favorite food,
jokingly claiming that consuming it could cause severe ailments and even death.
I kept putting the vomit emoji and telling people yucky.
Anytime someone would bring that up, I was like, You eat that?
And just making it seem grotesque.
Because at a certain point, propaganda is the only thing that's going to save us.
We got to start lying to these people.
I'm pretty sure that worked on a couple hundred people.
Any little bit makes a difference, man.
Any little bit.
But behind the jokes, there's still some real concern among OG oxtail fans.
I think there's anger that it got out.
Because we found a way to make what other people think was trash treasure,
I think that's what really connects us to it.
Like, we had it in-house for so long, nobody knew how great this was.
And then the internet just propelled it to new heights.
But the debate isn't only about price.
There's also the question of the right way to make oxtail.
Feels like a trend.
Because you see it in oxtail tacos, oxtail syrup, oxtail cereal.
And they have now remixed it 500,000 times into different concoctions that I do not approve of.
I just, it's a mess now.
It's gone overboard.
And that's part of why I think the price has gone up as well.
This way of thinking puts Judith and her oxtail ravioli in an awkward position.
Because I'm Jamaican chef, they have this expectation.
Oh, we're going to a restaurant that is a Jamaican chef.
Oh, they have oxtail on the menu.
They're expecting it to be on the bone the traditional way.
I worked in England, Wales, Switzerland.
All of these experiences influence how I cook.
How could I come, you know, just cook oxtail in the same old way?
Of course, I'm going to find another way to cook it.
To make the dish, she starts by trimming excess fat from the oxtail and browning it on all sides.
The key to making oxtail tender is cooking it slowly at a low temperature in a flavorful stock.
Once it's done, the meat is fall-off-the-bone tender.
Due to oxtail's long cooking time, making a batch of ravioli takes Judith two days.
But Judith says she can't achieve the same flavor with any other cut of beef.
It had to be the oxtail.
Judith cooks the oxtail again for another four hours in more wine and beef stock.
Now that's going to cook down.
And the reduction of this oxtail is what we're going to use as the filling for the ravioli.
When Judith first considered adding oxtail to the menu at her restaurant,
ravioli wasn't her first choice.
Her goal was to pay homage to her Jamaican heritage
while also distinguishing herself as a chef.
I mean, there's a lot of Jamaican restaurants that you can go and get traditional Jamaican food.
We want to set ourselves apart.
It took years of trial and error to come up with this dish.
Today, the oxtail ravioli is a customer favorite at Swirl.
We had to put it on the door, home of the oxtail ravioli.
I'm selling out of oxtail, like, every week.
I can't keep up.
While she is concerned about the price hikes,
she says it shouldn't stop her or other chefs from creating innovative oxtail dishes.
There would always be a chef who's going to try to take it to the next level.
I've seen chefs smoke it and then braise it.
I've seen chefs who slow smoke it for days and so it's falling off the bone.
I've had it, you know.
Be creative.
Today, Pat La Frida delivers oxtail to all kinds of chefs and restaurants,
including high-end ones.
Despite many people's fears, Pat insists there's still plenty of oxtail to go around.
Unless there's some evolutionary issue with cattle, it's never going to disappear.
As long as the demand for oxtail is there,
people are going to buy it and people are buying at a higher price anyway.
You know, they may not buy as much,
but they're still buying it because it's like it's in our system at this point.
