In this episode of Leadership Insider, I continue the conversation on emotional autonomy — a leadership skill almost none of us were taught, yet one that quietly shapes confidence, decision-making, morale, and trust.
Emotional autonomy is the ability to know what you think, feel, and want without waiting for permission, reassurance, or agreement — and to hold that clarity even when others disagree.
When leaders lack emotional autonomy, it shows up as hesitation, over-collaboration, decision paralysis, people-pleasing, and constant reassurance-seeking. Teams feel it immediately. Confidence erodes. Momentum slows. Morale drops — often without anyone being able to name why.
In this episode, I unpack how emotional autonomy gets lost, why many capable leaders confuse adaptability with self-abandonment, and how clarity stabilises teams rather than dominating them.
I also share practical ways to rebuild emotional autonomy — including tracking unnecessary apologies, setting one-sentence boundaries, delaying reassurance-seeking, and learning to tolerate discomfort without collapsing.
This is a direct, honest conversation for leaders who are respected, well-intentioned, and capable — but who sense something invisible is holding their leadership back.
Key takeaways * Emotional autonomy is not dominance — it’s stability * Reassurance-seeking quiets anxiety but weakens leadership * Over-explaining and apologising erode authority * Clear preferences create psychological safety * Leaders who trust their inner world create teams that feel safe, confident, and decisive * Stay connected, share your thoughts, and subscribe@paulscanlonuk
Hey everyone, welcome back to Leadership Insider, the second part of this conversation I wanted to
have with you guys on emotional autonomy, a skill no one taught to us, is the best way I think to
describe it. Certainly no one taught me it and probably not you either because as I mentioned
in the first episode on this topic, we are not taught emotional autonomy. We are not raised to
have that or very few of us were if you like. So we grow up not knowing that we lack it and we grow
up not knowing how to find it. We admire it in others but don't know what it is that we're
admiring so we don't know what to call it. We envy it when we see it working but we lack it in ourselves.
We've loved the bosses and leaders that we've worked with that have it and we have really
struggled when we have worked with people and bosses that don't have it, who we rely upon to
have it, whatever it is. We don't know what to call it and I'm calling all of it
emotional autonomy. It's a beautiful thing. It doesn't come easy to any of us, unnatural I don't
think. You have to work at it which is why this conversation I wanted to have with you is taking
place. I want to equip you. I want to raise your awareness. I want to give you a language for it.
We need to leave the podcast today with a lot of things to think about, with a lot of language for
you to access this topic in yourself and in your leadership team. If you're the leader I want you
to be honest and open and vulnerable about where this lands for you. Are you lacking emotional
autonomy? Are you guilty of all the things I mentioned in the first episode? Some of the
things in this second part now and what can you do to work on those because your team desperately
want you to. They like you. They appreciate you. They respect you in lots of other areas but this
area that now I'm languaging that you didn't know what to call it is what's killing you and costing
morale and costing your staff. Some will not stay because this doesn't get better and so at the
outset of this new year this would be a good thing for you to think about doubling down on paying
attention to having a talk with your team about and hopefully the language of the podcast here
gives you some way to access the conversation and begin to identify what it is.
You lose emotional autonomy as a leader when you are waiting for reactions before forming opinions
and we all can see that you're doing that. This is the decision paralysis thing I mentioned
in the first episode on the topic. You're waiting for sometimes certain people's reactions.
You don't want to cross or don't want to upset or don't want to have them feel disempowered or not
consulted whoever they may be and we in the room know who they are for you and it drives us nuts.
It could be a family member. It could be an older person who you have got into some
mixed up sense of loyalty and respect for because they're older and they've been there
longer than you or whatever it may be. All these dynamics get in the mix but the outcome is you
are waiting and we are all waiting for your reaction, for your opinion rather on something
but you are waiting to see how it lands for others and sometimes waiting for how it lands
for them can be days or weeks seriously during which time your competitors aren't waiting.
They're not doing that. They're making decisions. They've found some degree
of emotional autonomy you haven't and they're pressing go, pressing send, pressing start,
pressing let's do this and they're taking the business you could have had as it were.
That's how serious this gets when leaders lose emotional autonomy. It's needing validation
after every decision that you make which is exhausting. It's reframing your experiences
that you're having in your work situation to match dominant voices so you're taking a hold of
something and trying to reframe it to force some sense of a match with the dominant voices to make
them feel that they were heard and really what you're saying is agreeing with them so it's kind
of forcing something to fit into an agreement space that doesn't exist because you are wanting
to keep the dominant voices happy because you don't have emotional autonomy from the dominant
voices. Their status and their emotional climate as I mentioned in the first episode
is so affecting you that you reframe stuff to make them feel that their opinion is taken on board
and that their dominance is really ruling the day anyway without saying it. It's just nuts.
It's confusing therefore adaptability with self-abandonment because that's really what
you're doing and at some point emotional intelligence turned into emotional
self-erasure as I mentioned again in the first episode. At some point all your EQ turns into
abandonment of your EQ because the dominant voices you perceive aren't happy or being served
so we go back into this cycle of hesitancy and paralysis and so on. Let's just align is
what non-emotionally autonomous leaders and humans say. Let's just align. Can we just align?
It's like an appeal for people to just align to make you feel safer and more comfortable
that the outcome wasn't on you as much. Can we just kind of align this sense of what do you think
everyone wants? I'll go with the room. I'll read the room and then go with the room
is often leadership cultures that I am observing and been part of helping and so the question
becomes I suppose for anybody in leadership listening to this watching this when's the last
time you checked inside yourself before checking the slack channels because that's a telltale sign
that you are looking for an alignment that's not there that you are looking for validation
that's not coming enough for you to feel comfortable in your own conviction this is
the right thing to do and again it goes on and on and on and it erodes our confidence in you
it erodes your confidence in your self-confidence takes a blow the whole morale of the team begins
and eventually we realize that we're stuck as a business because of you
we're stuck because you're stuck we're stuck because we're all dancing around your lack of
emotional autonomy because of this need for external approval and validation and coming
back to this I mentioned in the first episode of what do you want for dinner if you can't decide
what you want for dinner then you will struggle in the boardroom making decisions when stakes are
higher when things matter more than what you're going to have for dinner in strategic meetings
in important hiring decisions in making calls on product launches
in changes to policies and systems in financial decisions
it shows up all that the boardroom stuff that matters that's essential to move a business
forward and you can't decide what you want for dinner without saying to someone else well what
do you fancy what do you want and then transfer that to the boardroom where you do versions of
that but it tends to hide as I mentioned in the first episode on this topic it tends to hide to
become invisible around a nice friendly playful happy kind personality you get away with it for
that reason but I'm isolating it now I'm taking it out so that you see for what it is I'm trying
to I'm trying to remove it from its camouflage of an otherwise nice kind good personality we
like you we get on with you without working with you generally but there's this thing what's this
thing this thing is this it's your lack of emotional autonomy I'm bringing it to one
side to say look how awful it is look how dysfunctional it is emotionally look how
problematic it is for those of us that rely on you as a leader to leave for crying out loud
to leave and so in strategic meetings and for hiring and product we get this hesitancy this
it's the it's the boardroom version of I don't know what I want for dinner what do you fancy
and it is a huge huge weakness in your leadership as I define it like this
it's hiding in plain sight and I'm calling it out because it's killing the morale in your team
um let me say this as well to help you guys that are worried about this idea because I get this
pushback sometimes when I talk this versions of this to people listen preference is not dominance
and naming your view actually gives others clarity not pressure stating your preference in something
with clarity and conviction isn't dominating the room guys if that's what you're worried about
that's what we want leaders to do leaders are supposed to make clear their preferences
are supposed to bring clarity and let us know what they're thinking in a confident clear way
doesn't mean you're right all the time and it doesn't mean that's not then open to conversation
of course that's part of what we should be building into our teams but when you are hesitant
to state a preference because you think certain people often is certain people you think certain
people in the room will accuse you of being dominant because they have in the past someone
said to you that you're dominating the meeting and that stuck with you because you are you have
a people-pleasing element and you hate to think that they think you're being dominant in an
unhelpful bossy kind of domineering way so that's gone in you remembered that and now you are
nervous and triggered around the idea that you could be accused of being dominant and so you are
hesitant with your preferences even when you share your preference of what you want for dinner
metaphorically it's still with well yeah but i'm open to what else um you guys think would be good
idea to eat it's that it drives us crazy one of my pet hates is going to dinner with people
they can't make a freaking decision about what they want and they get the menu and the like
examining the menu like it's a forensic document that their life depends then when the waiter
waitress comes it's a complete conversation with them about the ingredients and how it's cooked and
and and all the nuances and i get people have allergies and all of that stuff people often
say to me when i'm at dinner do you have any allergies i say yeah i'm allergic to drama
that's all if there's no drama around here i'm gonna enjoy my dinner but when people are uh uh
agonizing over the menu and what to have and and then make a decision and then change their mind
then change their mind again i'm like for god's sake that's drama at the table that's why i'd
eat alone there's a there's a problem in the bible that says i'd rather you know eat a crust
of bread on the corner of a rooftop than have a banquet around people that do your head in that's
my version of it but you know what i mean i went off on a rant there but it was therapeutic for
me i feel better now i'm back anyway your preference isn't dominance okay so get that
out your head to help you get back into some emotional autonomy change that mantra preference
is not dominance okay and naming your views and giving clarity is not is not pressure it's it's
what we want you to be doing um here's a good practice another good practice to work on your
emotional autonomy um track your apologies track your apologies stop apologizing for your opinions
i do do that a lot do you say i'm sorry um but what i think is i'm sorry if you know this isn't
going over popular i'm sorry if this seems to be dominating i'm sorry but track your apologies
literally i mean apologizing for your opinion um or softening your authority when authority is what
um or preemptively shrinking back from where we want you to step up to you preempting how you
think people may experience your clarity so internally you dial down step back and it
comes out different to how it should it comes out weak and diluted because in real time on the spot
you watered it down based on something in the room someone in the room or something said five
minutes ago and you preemptively strike against yourself by diluting it and so it comes out again
in this non-emotionally autonomous way and we're all thinking what the hell is going on what are
you really saying so track your apologies this is something really good to do um and you'll realize
when you track your apologies that you're doing it far more than you think you are and it's not
necessary because every every unnecessary apology is kind of a small request for permission to exist
that's what it becomes every time you're apologizing and it's just not necessary
and most of it isn't at all it's coming from your lack of emotional autonomy your lack of
internal stability and security and self-confidence is coming from that so they're not necessary
it comes across like you're constantly asking for permission for people to take a space to exist
which is horrendous just as a human particularly in leadership um so practice some replacement
phrases instead of i'm sorry practice saying things like you know thanks for your patience
i'd like you to think about that or here's my view and then leave it as your view or try this
this will scare the hell out of some of you silence you express your view and then you go quiet
and say nothing it like excruciating at first because in your mind your lack of autonomy
emotionally is going crazy with what it's telling you they're all thinking and they're looking that
way because and they looked across the room and poor eye contact with their people because
and they lean back in the seat because and they put their head down a row on paper because
and your lack of autonomy from that separateness from that is so affecting your climate like the
thermometer that you can't be quiet afterwards you have to qualify and soften it and apologize
and over explain and put caveats in and and tell them what you really think stop it and the
transition from doing that all the time to not doing it anymore is going to be so painful that
transition space you're going to say wow what's wrong with you today some are going to think
some are going to say to you well you know i don't think that was good how you said that yeah
they're going to say that don't retreat into um emotional outsourcing just say no it's fine i'm
and see how that goes another good practice to back this up is what i would call a one sentence
boundary in your leadership decision making this is gold particularly at executive level
um try saying things like i'm not taking that on when people say things that are trying to play on
your lack of emotional stability and autonomy try something like i'm not taking that on right now
i want to stay in this space in this realm of thought and this conversation that we're having
or you might want to say um that's not a priority for me right now it's a boundary one sentence
boundary um or i'm saying no to that oh that doesn't work for me right now but i don't want
to participate in that right now try practicing these one word boundaries without over explaining
yourself um leaders over explain themselves all the time often certainly this kind of leader
this kind of human with lack of emotional autonomy because their fear being seen as unreasonable
i know i've gone through that in my life because i'm a reasonable person you are too
so to think we led in a way that makes them think we are dominating or we are unreasonable
bothers us so much that we then over explain are are what we think they're perceiving
as unreasonable behavior in them see how complicated it gets so we get in their heads about us
we get into their version of us and we respond to them based on what we think they're thinking
about us i know it's all pointing to a lack of emotional autonomy where you get to say what you
want to say you get to have a one sentence boundary one liner and leave it at that practice it it will
be painful at first odd at first feel like it's not you because it's not you the the you that
you've been is the conditioned play it safe outsourcing for opinion and feedback and validation
and self-erasure that's the condition you that's not you it's not who you are it's the condition
to you so when you stop doing that it's going to feel hypocritical and fake and false and unless
you push past that you'll run back to the familiar you for safety but none of that was working
anyway so heads up transitioning from this non-emotional autonomous being that you've been
conditioned to be and all that goes with that that i've talked about to this emotionally
autonomous confident person that i've talked about the space between those two versions of
you is going to be messy and uncomfortable and feel hypocritical and two-faced and confusing
and rude and insensitive and unreasonable still feel all of that but if you can push past that
and get i don't know one or two good people around you that can see the process and encourage you in
the room and privately say to you i know it was so tough for you to do that today but thank you
thank you for not over explaining thank you for not going into paralysis thank you for not
apologizing get one or two good people around you that support you in this transition in your
personality in this change of your values and how you operate in life emotionally get one or two
good people that say to you thank you that was brilliant thank you for not saying anything
thank you for not apologizing to the person across the room who you always do thank you for
not second guessing and outsourcing if you can get one or two voices that applaud you for that
that's going to be gold for you and keep you going not looking for approval and fear of losing
approval if you can get rid of all that stuff and get some of your team on board seeing that and
celebrating that you make the transition space all the more easier to get through because it can be
difficult and lonely and most people go back and finish it with a mixed version of the old them
and the new them but it's never really getting to the other side which is what i want you guys
to get to remember explanations are often disguised permission slips that's what they are
and when people think you are giving permission slips they will take control of you with their
permissions that they know you are relying on without telling them that because your explanations
are the veiled disguised versions of seeking permissions and some people love you to seek
their permission let me tell you some people thrive off you being dominated by their permissions
and they are killing you and they are destroying your leadership they are eroding your authority
and when we see that happen to you when we see that you are outsourcing your permissions to
other people in the room and some of these people could be family or friends or people you're
intimidated by and we see that we lose respect for you as a leader and we realize you are leading
from a committee and you are leading from outsource validations and we do not have confidence in your
leadership we might not tell you but it will present as as not feeling safe around you
which presents in all kinds of weird and wonderful ways um in human relationships friendships
romantic relationships business partnerships without you telling you what it is i'm telling
you what it is it's some version of this so work on all of that stuff another good practice to have
is to develop your emotional autonomy is stop revising your reality um in real time um
stop being talked out of your instincts on the spot learn to go with your instincts your intuitive
knowing that this is right this is one of the but this is one of the gifts of outstanding leaders
from even good leaders and very good leaders outstanding great leaders have the ability
to intuitively know when something's right and a right way to go doesn't mean that isn't obviously
still open to discussion and so on but it's not being outsourced as is this right that i'm feeling
and a good practice is to stop revising your reality in real time you really know
this is the right thing to do intuitively you know but you are allowing others to talk you
out of that instinctive knowing so you finish up not trusting your own instinct which is
the death knell for leadership um or been in post meeting doubt and we can see that you are we had
when you're riddled with doubt and the doubt presents itself again as some degree of looking
for emotional validation and it's this post meeting doubt or this maybe i overreacted
maybe i dominated maybe i shouldn't have said stop it it's killing us um because when you do that to
your instincts um our instincts start to disappear we start to not trust our instincts because you
don't trust yours forget the idea the the invisible unspoken memo goes out don't trust your gut
because the boss doesn't the leaders don't um and the values around that get diluted
and it has this knock-on effect to everybody in the business especially at executive level
you don't need agreements for your experience to be valid for your intuitive knowing to be
valid for your instincts to be valid you don't need agreements with people learn to do without it
learn to be autonomously independent from the need for these agreements that you seek out and
around for it's going to be uncomfortable but you'll get there these are the best leaders and
leaders we all want to work with and be with our leaders who get this um another good practice is
delaying your reassurance seeking don't text people particularly people you see as mentors
after decisions have been made don't privately text them for their opinion um
about the decisions that were made um don't poll your peers you're doing sort of this
polling your peers for assurance reassurance seeking about what was just agreed
or obsessively checking reactions to get reassurance build in a delay
um between the decision being made and you're looking for any reassurance build in a gap between
any between the decisions being made and any behavior from you that looks like reassurance
seeking build in a delay start with i don't know a few minutes because reassurance is addictive
because it quiets anxiety not because it improves judgment did you get that reassurance becomes
addictive which is why we seek it because it has some sense of quieting anxiety it's not because
it improves the outcome on the judgment we made reassurance isn't sought because it makes the
outcome better it's because you're looking for some self-indulgent form of quiet in my anxiety
you know because if phil thinks it was okay then i'll feel less anxious if it goes wrong
so build a delay between what's been decided and you doing your usual seeking reassurance
seconds later um try this experiment guys try building a five minute delay i dare you
between the decision being made and you looking for any feedback about it five minutes will feel
like five days of you know sometimes because you're so used to quickly seeking reassurance
validation and opinion polling but try the five minute experiment make a decision one decision
leave it alone sit with the discomfort for five minutes before you seek any assurance reassurance
then let that five minutes become 20 minutes and an hour and a day and three days and never asking
for reassurance is where we're going start with five minutes sit with the discomfort extend it
next time 20 minutes half an hour before you asked anybody what do you think about the meeting
the decision and then you'll get used to that space not being as bad nothing bad happened nobody
died you're fine and then stretch it out to hours and days and the new pattern begins to bed in
where you don't seek opinions and reassurance seeking after the decisions i made decisions
i made you don't do it anymore and people are like yay we don't do that anymore we just make
a decision and we get on with it oh gosh all right let me talk a little bit finally about
emotional autonomy i suppose at scale really zooming out a little bit on it for us um what
emotionally autonomy leaders create for their teams their staff their businesses is psychological
safety which is hugely important for people especially in the workspace today when people
feel psychologically safe um they don't feel fragile anymore if they feel you as the leader
with your emotional autonomy are less fragile they will feel safer psychologically around you
and psychologically safe people tell you what they think give you honest responses
um offer ideas to move the organization forward and are confident in their contribution is seen
and heard don't think their jobs on the line because they spoke out of turn
or on a different opinion because they feel psychologically safe because you are autonomously
emotionally independent of other people's influencing you and you have that autonomy
in your emotion makes us all feel stable around you um it leads to clearer decisions
in the organization um less emotional contagion as a fallout um from lack of emotional autonomy
um fewer politics are involved because when less people are involved in dissecting it all
and affecting your stability because of their dissecting it gets less political make a decision
you leave it and it stands there's less room for politics because no one else is allowed to be
seeing that space is where they get to you know sabotage what we agreed because you're not allowing
it anymore you've allowed space it got used to it as i mentioned a moment ago um and so what happens
is um that you start to not need anymore uh constant validation because of your emotional
autonomy now he's being scaled up everybody can see that at scale you don't need validation
anymore um you don't need emotional triangulation um everyone to agree be on board you're done with
it you're beyond it yes now it can be scaled now we can operate at scale now everybody can
get in the sleep stream of that beautiful emotional autonomy that you bring as a leader
now it can be scaled it can become cultural it can be in the dna of your leadership team now
that you've got it nailed it can be scaled and i think this matters because um emotionally
autonomous leaders in case you're worried about this again let me say they don't dominate rooms
they stabilize them and that's what we want but in your emotional autonomy stabilizes the room
it doesn't dominate it we're not thinking of dominating us we're thinking you're stabilizing
if it's psychologically safe you're going to get the best version of your team
when that's the space that you're in and that's what you who you've worked to become
closing thought the cost of not doing this work the work of emotional autonomy is uncomfortable
because it asks you to tolerate disappointment disagreement and uncertainty without collapsing
that's why it's uncomfortable but the cost of not doing the work is that all that stuff
comes back and the truth is this the alternative is spending your life negotiating your inner world
in public that's the alternative to not having emotional autonomy you spend your life negotiating
your inner world in public and never quite knowing who you are underneath all that adaptation
that you're doing you never come home to you emotionally because you're always a reflection
of other people's emotions and opinions final question to leave hanging with you who would you
be as a leader if you trusted your inner world first and foremost that question alone can be
game changing for this next season the stage of your leadership all right hope all of that was
helpful to you guys again let me know in the comments um your feedback uh on the podcast
again let me appeal to you because we're in early stages of this podcast please subscribe and follow
and help me with the ratings for the podcast i appreciate that i'm sure no one is a new podcast
in their life but here i am with launching mine so if i'd appreciate your support i hope you find
your leadership inside helpful i will see you next time cheers all the best go strong