On a Sunday lunchtime over Florida, a Learjet 60 crossing the top of a storm told air traffic control it was picking up light ice. About three minutes later, it was on the ground.
This is what we know so far: how a jet built to cruise near the edge of the sky can lose its grip on it, what investigators are looking at, what they still need to find, and why the same physics matters for the business jets that fly out of Luton, Farnborough and Biggin Hill every day.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
A Learjet 60 carrying nine people crashed in Florida after encountering a severe thunderstorm at 35,000 feet. Despite initial reports of manageable ice, the aircraft entered a catastrophic descent of over 30,000 feet per minute, killing everyone on board. Investigators are currently analyzing the roles of ice crystals, airspeed instrumentation, and potential structural failure.
35,000 feet over Florida, on a Sunday lunchtime,
a small business jet is flying across the top of a storm.
The crew tell air traffic control they're picking up
a little ice. Light, manageable.
About three minutes later, the jet is on the ground,
in the middle of a busy road.
All nine people on board are killed.
It fell almost seven miles in around a minute.
Investigators say parts of it may have
come off before it hit the ground.
Around 430 of these jets were built.
Business jets like it come and go from Luton,
Biggin Hill and Farnborough every day,
flying at the same heights as the airliners above Britain,
through the same kind of weather.
This is what we know about those three minutes.
How a jet built to cruise near the edge
of the sky can lose its grip on it,
and what investigators still need to find.
The Learjet 60 first flew
in 1990
and entered service in 1993.
It's a stretched, more powerful development of the Learjet 55,
built in Wichita, Kansas.
Two Pratt & Whitney Canada engines mounted
at the back each give about 4,600 pounds of thrust.
It carries up to eight passengers,
and it's certified to fly as high as 51,000 feet,
higher than most airliners ever go.
That's the point of a jet like this.
Up there, the air is thin, drag is low,
and you're above most of the weather.
Most of it.
Because the one kind of weather that can reach those heights
is exactly what this jet met over Florida.
The jet took off from Austin, Texas that morning,
heading for North Eleuthera in the Bahamas.
Nine people on board, two pilots, seven passengers.
It crossed the Florida coast near Naples at 41,000 feet,
then stepped down to 35,000
as it headed east towards West Palm Beach and the open sea.
But south Florida that day was full of storms.
Forecasters were warning of
scattered to numerous showers and thunderstorms
and a flood watch was in place.
Storm clouds like these can tower to the cruising height of a jet,
and their tops are full of things you can't always see on radar.
Ice crystals.
A thunderstorm like this is a tower of rising air.
Warm, wet air off the Florida peninsula surges upwards,
cooling as it climbs until it reaches the top of the lower atmosphere,
around 40,000 to 50,000 feet, and spreads out sideways into an anvil.
Inside, powerful updrafts sit right beside equally powerful downdrafts.
At the top, almost everything is ice,
crystals smaller than the width of a human hair.
They reflect only a few percent as much radar energy as raindrops,
so on the weather radar in a jet's nose,
they can barely show up at all.
That's why pilots are taught to give storms like these a wide berth.
Long-standing FAA guidance says avoid
a severe thunderstorm by at least 20 miles
and treat any storm with tops above 35,000 feet as severe.
Violent up and down drafts, hail.
At around 12.47, the crew told Miami Air Traffic Control
they were picking up light, clear ice.
Manageable.
Moderate turbulence had just lifted the jet 700 feet.
Outside, the temperature was minus 47 degrees.
Then the crew reported precipitation
and asked to climb to 37,000 feet, perhaps to get above it.
The controller approved.
Less than 30 seconds later, everything changed.
The crew announced they were descending,
then they declared an emergency.
In the next transmissions they reported coming down
at 10,000 feet a minute,
then an overspeed, the jet going faster than it was designed to fly,
then 20,000 feet a minute.
Flight tracking data suggests that at times it
was falling even faster than that,
more than 30,000 feet a minute,
well over 300 miles an hour, straight down. Local reports
To put that in perspective,
an airliner coming into land usually descends at a couple of thousand
feet a minute. Ten thousand feet a minute is five times that.
Thirty thousand feet a minute
is five hundred feet every second.
More than one and a half Big Bens every second.
...say that by around 8,000 feet, the jet was spinning,
nose almost straight at the ground.
The last transmissions made it clear
the crew knew they had run out of time.
At about 12.50, it hit South Military Trail,
a busy road around four miles south of
Palm Beach International Airport,
close to the entrance of a mobile home park.
Florida's governor said it came down like a missile.
No one on the ground was killed.
Around 600 people from nearby homes had to be sheltered,
And the road was closed in both directions.
From the first call about ice to the impact, about 3 minutes.
The fall itself, around 1.
Investigators haven't said what caused this,
but they've said what they're looking at.
The weather at altitude, ice, turbulence,
and whether the jet started to break up in the air.
Each of those is worth understanding.
First, height.
The higher a jet flies, the thinner the air,
and the narrower the window between too slow and too fast.
Too slow, and the wings stop lifting.
Too fast, and the air over the wings starts
to behave in ways they weren't designed for.
A Learjet 60 normally cruises
at around three quarters of the speed of sound.
At 35,000 feet, that window is much smaller than it is near the ground.
Second, ice.
At minus 47 degrees,
almost all the water in a storm top is frozen into tiny crystals.
They don't usually build up on wings,
but they can block the small tubes on the nose that measure airspeed.
When that happens, the instruments can show the wrong speed,
and the pilots can lose the one number they need most.
In 2009, that's how the investigation into Air France Flight 447 began.
Nobody has said that happened here.
Third, the airframe itself.
If the airspeed does go wrong, pilots are trained for it,
and the procedure is about doing less, not more.
Keep the wings level,
hold a known nose attitude and a known engine power,
and the aircraft will fly at roughly the right speed,
whatever the instruments say.
Then cross-check everything else.
In Air France 447, investigators found
the crew never called for that procedure.
The airspeed readings came back in under a minute.
By then, the aircraft was already in a stall it never recovered from.
Every aircraft has a speed it must never exceed.
Beyond it, the forces on the wings and tail grow fast.
The crew of this jet reported an overspeed
and the NTSB has found signs that parts of it may
have separated before it hit the ground.
None of this is unique to Florida. Storms that reach
cruising height happen all over the world
and the same physics applies anywhere a jet meets
the top of one. Over the Channel, over the North Sea, over the Alps.
Britain is one of Europe's
busiest markets for business jets
and many of them fly just as high as this one did.
Britain sees far fewer thunderstorms than Florida,
where parts of the state get more
than 80 days of thunder a year.
But in summer, storms over the Channel and the
near continent can still grow tall enough
to reach the heights where business jets cruise.
For UK airspace, the Met Office issues warnings called SIGMETs,
formal alerts to crews about thunderstorms,
severe icing and severe turbulence.
Business jets out of Luton,
Farnborough and Biggin Hill cross those skies every day,
climbing to the same heights as this Learjet.
The physics doesn't change at the border,
and neither does the defence.
See the storm early, believe what you see,
and go around it with room to spare.
The NTSB hasn't determined a cause,
and it hasn't said anyone made a mistake.
What it needs to find is still a long list.
Why the descent began,
less than 30 seconds after the climb was approved.
Whether the jet actually flew into the core of a storm.
How the ice, the turbulence
and the rain affected the aircraft and its instruments.
And how much of the jet came apart in the air.
Some pieces were reportedly found miles from where it hit the ground.
There's also the cockpit voice recorder.
Maintenance records say one was installed.
Investigators still need to confirm it
was on board and that it survived.
Heavy rain filled the crater at the crash site,
which has made recovering the main wreckage harder.
The NTSB usually publishes a preliminary report about
a month after an accident.
The final report, with a probable cause,
normally takes one to two years.
When the preliminary report comes out,
we'll come back to these three minutes
and to what they mean for every jet that flies over a storm.