Why Fiction? Why Non-Fiction? | Writers Week Part 4

The Agenda with Steve Paikin
4 followers
Jul 7, 2023
Do writers prefer to write fiction or non-fiction? Is one more difficult to write? How does one choose their genre? In another instalment of our writers on writing panel, George Elliott Clarke ("Where Beauty Survived"), Elizabeth Hay ("Snow Road Station"), Vincent Lam ("On the Ravine"), and Thea Lim ("An Ocean of Minutes") talk to Nam Kiwanuka about the art of writing real and fictional stories, and explore the question of whose stories can they tell?
Yesterday, we were talking about who gets to tell what stories and I thought that we
could stay there for a little bit, but I just wanted to share something.
When I was younger, my favourite book was Are You There, God, It's Me, Margaret, Judy
Bloom, and of course, the movie's coming out.
And that book really, really helped me, obviously.
She wasn't writing it as a young woman.
Téa, I wanted to start with you.
When we talk about writing in someone else's voice, who gets to tell what stories?
I mean, to some degree, you always have to write in someone else's voice.
I'm a mixed-race Chinese and white woman who grew up in Singapore and in Toronto, and if
I were to only write books about myself, it would be very narrow and I wouldn't enjoy
it either.
So I think we always have to write in other people's voices, but of course, there's always
the question of how can we do it respectfully.
I think I don't generally write in the voice of a character unless I've had enough real-life
connections to that community to feel like I can do it in a way where I'm not telling
the whole story, as we say, that I'm doing it in a way that, I don't know, doesn't cause
harm, let's say.
A lot of the time, though, I think sometimes people want to tell other people's stories
and it's worth attending to the voice within you to ask yourself why you want to do that.
Often I teach creative writing a lot, and sometimes I'll meet students, often white
students who will come up to me and ask me, well, how do I write a character of colour
in a respectful way because I want to write about racism?
And I always say there's so much to write about the point of view of white people on
racism and often authors don't want to take that on, but I'm like, you know that, that's
an interesting point of view.
People don't often write overtly about whiteness.
Like I think sometimes when we don't want to write our own story because we think it
is more imperative or more interesting to write someone else's story, we're maybe not
always being the best witnesses to our own story.
Well, I'll just go around the table and get everybody's viewpoint on this.
Vincent?
Well, I think about the separation that you're alluding to, this sense that we're always
writing about someone who is not ourself, and that's inherent to everything we do as
fiction writers.
And so just as a thought experiment, when I think about writing about physicians, for
instance, I feel like there might be a greater separation between me writing about physicians
and say, engineers, or physicians and lawyers, physicians and teachers, for instance, than
there is between me writing about a physician of one ethnicity and a physician of another
ethnicity.
And yet I don't think that anyone would ask any questions for a moment if I were to decide
to write a novel in which I had lawyers and teachers and engineers.
And yet if I were to write a novel in which there's a person of the purple ethnicity,
and the purple ethnicity features very prominently in their narrative, I think I would receive
a lot of questions.
Because one is charged in a way that the other isn't, right?
Yes, you're absolutely right.
Because it's charged.
And I think that is a feature of the discourse.
But I'm not sure that it's something which the writer always needs to be subservient
to.
But when you write about an engineer, you probably want to do some research into what
it's like to be an engineer, right, to get it right.
So I think it's the same thing.
One is charged, I think, in a way that another isn't.
But it's always about trying to get as close to the texture of real life, right, to have
the resonance of the real on the page.
And except that when we're writing about people from different political identities
than ours, then it does become charged.
It becomes something that we have to, I think, be more careful and respectful about.
I think that's right.
I think that's absolutely right.
I think if what we're going to do is we're going to write about any world, whether it's
a professional world or a world that's charged in an ethnic sense, that we don't inhabit
personally, then absolutely it's our responsibility to really write from a place of knowledge
and a place of insight.
But I'm uncomfortable with the notion that there would be certain voices which should
not or could not write from other voices.
Why are you uncomfortable?
Is that leading into censorship?
Well, I think it's leading into censorship, right?
And I think ultimately the act of both writing and reading fiction is the act of taking a
leap beyond ourselves.
And that's the magic of it.
And that's also where hopefully we gain insight into human beings whom we see and recognize
as human beings, and yet who are in many ways different from ourselves.
So to me, because the very act is this act of imaginative inhabitation of another, I
think to go and start prescribing in absolutes who can or cannot inhabit the imagined act
of writing someone else is completely at odds with what fiction offers.
And I think that's why in the end I would say do it.
Just don't do a bad job.
Because I think in the end that's where people are getting into trouble.
I think if you were to read, you know, a hundred books that were published in the last year,
you would find all sorts of authors inhabiting, for example, ethnicities that didn't belong
to them.
But it's not raising flags if they're not doing it in a way that's a problem.
Let's hear Liz side of the table.
You two have been very quiet.
Liz, what do you think?
So the big dilemma in my life as a writer was actually not, it came about from taking
too deep a leap into myself.
So I wrote a collection of stories some years ago that were very personal, autobiographical,
about friendships gone wrong.
And I got into very hot water with certain friends and also with members of my family.
Even though I thought I'd taken great pains at inventing, still, I mean, it was clear
to me what I'd invented and clear to nobody else.
So then the question became, all right, and even as I was writing these stories, I knew
how close to the bone they were.
And they were difficult to write.
And at one point, I, who's a sort of a fictional Beth, if you like, that was the name I used
for her, said, well, it's my life, too.
These things that are happening, that's my life, too, and I have a right to write about
it.
Nevertheless, the consequences were severe for me as a writer.
And that's what drove me into writing novels, which was something I, it forced me to make
a leap of the imagination that I hadn't been able to make before.
But we're even in hot water when we're writing about ourselves because our lives overlap
with these other important people, our family, our friends and so on.
And some people take great offense and others take it in stride.
That's why earlier in another segment, you said that it was dangerous to write about
families.
That's what you meant?
Of course, it's dangerous to write about families.
Yes.
You know, you're airing dirty laundry or you're telling things that didn't happen or I didn't
see it that way or what business is of yours to use this material.
But of course, it is the writer's business.
And that's where a certain ruthlessness has to come in.
If you're going to be a writer, you can't just be holding back, afraid to offend.
Do you think that there's a way that you could have fictionalized those stories more, like
maybe set them in a different country or something like that, that would have made your friends
able to read them and not think they were about them?
Or was there no way to tell the story?
You know, you either have a hard-hitting story or you have one that's that is semi-concocted
to protect yourself.
The emotional need.
But do I wish I'd been better at fiction?
Of course.
I didn't mean that.
No.
Very much so.
I mean, I say that as somebody who wrote a time travel novel about migrant workers journeying
through temporal zones in order to write about my own life.
Like, you know, people never ask me if this book is about me.
It's 100% about me.
But no one guesses that.
I was actually going to ask you that today.
I honestly was going to ask you if it was about you.
So I was driven by cowardice.
Did you feel like you couldn't write the story from your point of view?
I think I felt like, so for example, as a mixed-race person, the question I used to
get all the time is, what are you?
And so it felt like my whole life, people were asking me about my identity and had their
own stories that they wanted to tell about my identity.
And so I didn't want to write about it.
But of course, in my heart, I did want to write about it.
And I was like, you know, it came to me that, like, migration is a form of time travel.
And I thought, well, I'll write an immigrant novel about time travel.
And then, of course, halfway through, I was like, oh, this is about everything that's
ever happened to me.
But then it was too late.
You know, but I was lucky that, yeah, no one ever is like, oh, so how is this inspired
by your life?
I had written a realist novel before, which, of course, everyone was like, oh, that's you,
right?
That's such a whole—you know, when people ask you what I am, I'm like, I'm a human being.
But George, what about you?
Well, I think that—I think the older I get as a writer, the more of a liberal I become.
And what I mean by that is I don't mind saying that I am far left in terms of my political
sympathies, very far left, but I'm also very, very deeply now especially a liberal, small-L
liberal, in terms of favoring freedom of the imagination, freedom of speech, freedom of
opinion, freedom of conscience.
And I can't see any reason why anybody would want to be a writer and then put limits on
themselves and put limits on what they can say and put limits on what they can think
and what they can express and so on.
I think that the great joy of being a writer is being able to put forward alternative ideas,
alternative stories, to use your imagination, informed by research, to imagine particular
situations, political, historical, artistic, and so on, and then to bring them to life
for the reader.
I mean, right now, this year, God willing, I should finish my epic poem, which I began
in Zanzibar in February 2008.
It's called Canticles.
And the first two volumes of Canticles, which are already 1,000 pages, just the first two
volumes of Canticles deal with history, specifically of slavery and antislavery.
Imperialism and anti-imperialism.
And to write those poems, which are mainly dramatic monologues, I had to revive, so to
speak, dead characters from history and infuse them with my language.
And I'm following Walt Whitman, who says in the preface to Leaves of Grass, the greatest
poet, pulls the dead out of their coffins and stands them up on their feet.
So I write about Caesar.
I write about Hannibal.
I write about Cleopatra.
I write about Marie de Gilles.
I write about the black woman who was accused of setting fire to Montreal, Marie-Josephe
Angélique, and burning a good chunk of it to the ground, as she was right to do.
And never do I say to myself, I can't say this.
I can't say that.
I can't mention it.
The whole thing starts with the Odyssey, but I pretend that Ulysses is actually Ulysses
X, who's a character from the autobiography of Malcolm X.
And so I retell the story of the Odyssey through this African-American voice and so on.
And then I move from that, so the whole work begins with that.
Actually, no, it begins with Dante.
It begins with Dante, and he's at the tomb.
I have Dante visiting a tomb in Ravenna, and he's visiting a cemetery, and then he begins
to speak about all these historical personages as he's getting ready to write the Divine
Comedy, right?
And then the whole work ends, 1949, those first two volumes, Canticles 1, 2016, 2017,
ends in 1949 with Mao's triumph in China, which I believe actually has set the course
for world history into this century, well into this century.
I think we're seeing the consequences of that victory in 1949 playing out right now.
I love this conversation because we're talking about history, we're talking about learning,
and there's no better place to be than here, frankly.
But Vincent, you know, we're talking about non-fiction and fiction, and you've said,
quote, there's no better place in exploring lives than through fiction.
What did you mean by that?
Well, it's really an observation that comes from the sense I have that in so much of modern
political discourse, it's meant to be reductionistic, it's meant to simplify things, ideally to
polarize them.
Polarizing is very nice because if you polarize a group of people, then you can sort of pull
them to this side or that side and claim them as your supporters and win elections and fund
things, so it's very convenient.
And polarization is also very convenient because it means that people don't ask uncomfortable
or difficult questions.
And also, too, you have a villain, I guess.
That's right.
You've got a good guy, a bad guy, you know, we the virtuous, and the rest who are, if
you're in a good mood, they're ignorant, and if you're feeling nasty, then they're just
evil, bad people.
So that's kind of the form of political discourse, but you can't really either write good fiction
or, I think, read good fiction attentively and stay in that space.
Well, Liz, you've said that writing fiction is freedom.
What did you mean by that?
Did I say that?
You did.
I've done my research on all of you.
You actually said it right here in studio when you were talking to Steve Bacon.
Good Lord.
Well, I actually love it when fiction and nonfiction meld, so I love the real.
I mean, I'm an old journalist, and I love concrete detail and how things happen and
what happens, and melding that into a story using whatever other elements are available
to you.
So for a long time, I have to tell you, I hated the word fiction.
I didn't really understand it.
I didn't know how to do it.
So you hated it because you didn't understand, or why did you hate it?
Mainly because I couldn't do it.
I had no clue how to enter fiction.
I would write a page, a so-called fictional page, and be, you know, bored to tears by
the end.
I'd rather sell pizza than make up this fake, concocted, meaningless drivel.
So it's in the loosening up and trying to find a way to write what really matters to
you that kind of got me going.
And then, as I say, I did have to finally make that leap into novels to protect myself
from my family and others who were annoyed with me.
I think when I was growing up, anyway, I thought that people who wrote memoirs had lived these
incredible lives, and they wrote it at a certain point in their lives, maybe when they were
looking back at it.
Can you write a memoir at any age, at any stage of life?
Yes, absolutely.
And as soon as I say that, I've got to start thinking, OK, which one would I point to or
choose, and so on.
Well, I already mentioned the autobiography of Malcolm X, which, of course, is finished
just before his assassination in 1965.
He's 39 years old.
So if he had lived beyond February 2165, I'm sure he would have had a much longer
autobiography and maybe somewhat different as well.
If he hadn't to write it as a senior citizen, for instance, or rewrite it as a senior citizen.
Imagine if he hadn't.
Yeah.
Yeah, well, we are so blessed, in my opinion, that he did manage to get that work completed
at the time that he did.
And I'm also thinking of the French writer Violette Le Duc, who's actually the inventor
of Écriture Feminine.
Écriture Feminine.
She invented it with her great memoir, published in 1964, La Batard is the title in French,
and of course, in English translation, The Bastard.
And it's her memoir about her life.
And I think she, by the time she got that book published, she was probably in her 50s.
So it's not, you know, the memoir of young, but I could think of other memoirs written
by persons much younger, and which have a great impact or great effect.
So I don't think it's really age that matters, so much as it is the vigor with which one
has to tell the tale of one's life, and what the lessons of that living might be.
One of the great things about the dead, I gotta say, not the Grateful Dead, but the
dead in general.
The story?
Yeah.
Or the dead.
The bandit?
Not the story.
No, no.
But yeah, not the story either.
The great thing about the dead is they have all this wonderful lived experience that we
get to mine, if we choose to.
And then they can't criticize you.
That's right.
And what I also love about the dead, Liz, is that they have absolute freedom of speech.
They have absolute, they can say whatever they want.
No, they say whatever you want them to say.
I don't like that.
Based on research, Liz.
Based on research and imagination.
I have great trouble with fiction writers putting made-up dialogue in the mouths of
real people.
I have trouble with that.
It's fiction.
George, I have trouble.
I just want to know what's real and what's not real, to a certain degree.
Okay, but you have to suspend disbelief.
I don't always do that.
I know, but that—
I'm a resistant reader.
Okay.
You named it right there.
But these forms, though, that we're engaged in, where nonfiction can be looser than people
think and fiction looser than people think.
The memoir about my parents didn't start out as a memoir at all.
It was short stories.
I had this collection of short stories.
And it was the editor, God bless her, who saw in that wobbly collection of short stories
a memoir about my parents.
So, you know, forms shift around, and we make use of them as we can and will.
Form is as form does, as far as I'm concerned.
And so, the work takes the form it has to take in order for the story, whatever it is,
to be told.
Yes, and often it's the editor who sees the shape.
I'm just thinking of something that, Liz, you were talking about memoir, and I'm thinking
about how you said that was based on your life.
When we're writing memoir, is part of the reluctance to maybe write memoir that you
And I think it's kind of, I think it is hard to look at yourself and to see maybe the role
that you played.
So is there a little bit of that?
What you've reminded Liz that she said, that she said writing is freedom.
No, fiction is freedom, apparently.
I said fiction is freedom.
Well, that is even more apropos my comment, because I think for myself, certainly,
there are different types of freedom in the act of writing fiction.
And there is one source of freedom which comes from knowing the world which one has
fictionally inhabited.
And I've written both contemporary fiction as well as historical fiction which happened
in places and times where I've never lived.
But nonetheless, I had to research and understand that world until I convinced myself that I
understood it well enough to write it.
So there's the freedom that comes from knowing those tether points to the real world.
But then there's another type of freedom which comes from shedding all that.
And saying, well, yes, you know, I believe this could have happened because I know the
world well enough and now I'm going to make up what happens for my characters.
And I'm free to do that.
And I'm very hesitant to give up either of those freedoms.
But I think in memoir, and I've never written memoir, but I think one would feel some sense
of obligation to not avail oneself of the second freedom because it's supposed to be
stuff that actually happened.
Now, of course, memoir is about interpretation and is about understanding events from a particular
light.
But I do think you lose a kind of freedom, or I feel I would lose a certain kind of freedom
by writing memoir.
Or in doing real justice to the characters, your mother, father.
Actually, you never could.
Well, I think you can.
Okay.
You're better writer than I am.
That's what you can do.
Or at least you give the appearance of it.
You make a big effort to do justice to them.
And you get to know them far more.
Is one harder to write, nonfiction or fiction?
I think the act of writing both of them is not that different.
Nonfiction always has a lot in it that's not true.
Like, for example, we're creating nonfiction media right now, but there's going to be so
many cuts and changes.
You're going to make me look smarter than I am.
And when you're writing fiction, obviously, as we've talked about, so much of it is true.
So in either way, you're kind of handcuffing yourself to certain terms.
Like, when you say something is true, think of how it feels in your body when you see
that card at the beginning of a movie that says, based on a true story.
There's a slight change in your brain, and you approach it differently, and you expect
it to be true.
And that's the contract a writer is entering into with the reader.
And then when you say it's fiction, you're saying, this isn't true, but I better make
it feel like it is true.
So either way, they actually don't seem that different to me.
Obviously, in the end, the consequences are different.
But the act of doing it, it's both.
With both of them, you're shaping a story.
You're taking material, and you're making it into something cohesive.
Anyone else?
Well, time for me, once again, to exercise my prerogative.
It's his prerogative.
I am answering the question.
I would say that they are equally delightful to write.
And I agree with Taya that there's always a mix of fiction and the nonfiction and of
nonfiction and the fiction.
So the poem I want to share is titled Hammond's Plains African Baptist Church.
And it deals with a historical incident which did happen, truly did happen.
But this is my depiction of it in free verse.
Drunk with light, I think of maritime country.
I cry birchtown blues, the stark, sad beauty of this Camerion land.
I dream of a faithful dory battling the blue, cruel comers of a feral, runaway ocean.
A Trotskyite ocean in permanent revolution, turning fluid ideas over and over in its
Leviathan mind, turning driftwood drums and conundrums over and over.
Then, crazy with righteous anger, I think of Lydia Jackson, slave Madonna,
soon rich with child, whose Nova Scotian owner, the distinguished Dr.
Bowman, kicked her hard in the stomach, struck her viciously with fire tongs,
and then went out upon the ocean in his dory to commune with God.
And with that, we'll wrap up this discussion.
And tomorrow, we will be discussing with our writers how to build a literary canon,
which is kind of a controversial topic.
So we'll be talking about that tomorrow.
And George, thank you so much for that.
I appreciate it.
Damn, thank you.
The Agenda in the Summer with Nam Kiwanuka is made possible through generous
philanthropic contributions from viewers like you.
Thank you for supporting TVO's journalism.
