Why do people say these MYTHS about BRONZE AGE SWORDS?

Rune Slicer
2 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 22, 2026
Here are seven things that people say about Bronze Age swords that I think need correcting!
AI Generated·May contain errors
So bronze age weapons and warfare really deserve far more attention than they generally get on
channels like mine and I'm trying to do my bit here to rectify that. Now not that long ago I did
a video looking at the possible reasons why bronze age swords usually don't have handguards
and based on the comments there and other things that I've been reading recently there have been
some absolutely wild and crazy ideas put across around bronze age swords. So in this video we're
going to look and debunk hopefully seven fairly common and some of them quite wild myths about
bronze age swords. Hi folks, Matt Eaton here, Scholar Gladiatoria and just quickly before we
delve into these myths that I see spread around the internet about bronze age swords I just want
to mention check out if you're curious to know why bronze age swords very often don't have
handguards check out my thoughts in that video. Clearly the primary answer is shields okay that
is the primary answer because a lot of swords you use throughout history with shields don't
necessarily really need big handguards that being said many of them did have longer handguards but
even as late as the medieval period some swords have really quite minimal handguards but we're
going to get into guards in a second. So let's have a look grab a different sword here let's
have a look at seven wild myths about bronze age swords. So something I see actually said
fairly commonly about bronze age swords is that bronze age swords because they were made of bronze
couldn't withstand couldn't sustain and weren't used in blade-on-blade contact impacts with other
swords whereas people I think assume maybe people who aren't that familiar actually with things made
of bronze people assume that iron and steel enables this kind of blade-on-blade contact
and for the blade to sustain that in a way that bronze doesn't. Well there's several things to
unpack there but I'm going to keep this concise first of all when steel blades even hardened steel
blades collide with other steel blades they take damage it just happens if two materials are the
same when they impact with a lot of force they are going to get damaged so two iron age swords
two later medieval steel swords two modern steel training swords I mean our training swords get
damaged all the time so if you've got two pieces of bronze the relative hardness of them usually is
in the same ballpark one might be slightly harder than the other based on the composition of the
metal and the way that it's been worked I'll get to that in a second but when these two things collide
yes they will take damage number one but so will all other swords but here's the really important
thing is that bronze is not as either brittle or as soft as some people assume it is so in fact
without going into the material properties of bronze we can also categorically state that from
archaeology we know that blades bronze blades did collide with each other because we actually have
blade damage we have edge damage on bronze age swords there's some famous examples for example
in the museum of London which I've documented and spoken about on this channel myself
so absolutely and not just swords also things like large spearheads and stuff we often see
edge damage sometimes it's on the flat so sometimes we see marks across the the sort of mid rib and
the flat surface there sometimes it's edge into edge sometimes it's from an oblique angle at 45
degrees or something like that so absolutely we know that blades either deliberately or accidentally
we can't say which were making contact with each other and were frequently hitting each other
either sometimes in warfare and sometimes I'm sure it was done for ritual significance to
destroy a weapon before it was discarded but the fact is we have surviving bronze age swords
with edge damage so it did absolutely happen and the swords could survive such impacts just
to caveat that with of course I'm not saying that bronze age swords were used in fencing like sabers
were in the 19th century they were predominantly used with shields at least most of the time I'm
sure some of the time the shield broke or the person couldn't grab it in time and they were
forced to just use the sword in which case they pretty much have to parry with the sword if they
didn't have something else to defend with unless they're just dodging but the fact is that yes
usually these were used with shields so these are not generally speaking going to come into as much
blade contact as later sword styles where a person only has a sword or a sword and a dagger
or a sword and a buckler however we can categorically state that bronze age swords
did have impacts with other bronze swords yes they did take damage but they did survive it
the next weird myth I see written about bronze age weapons was that they weren't very sharp
there's among some corners of the world there's a perception that a blade which is made of iron or
steel is inherently sharper than a blade made of bronze and of course that doesn't need to be true
they can both be taken down to absolute literal razor sharpness and people have made razor blades
out of bronze now indeed it's not quite as durable because of course the hardness you can get with
bronze doesn't achieve the levels that you can get with steel certainly modern steels but remember
that what came after bronze age blades were iron blades probably not steel blades yet so there was
a there was a period of time where most of the iron blades around wouldn't have qualified as steel
they wouldn't have been heat quenched for example and actually the difference in hardness between
iron and bronze is is not as much as you might think but the important point here is that bronze
absolutely having cut myself on bronze I can tell you it can be absolutely razor surgically razor
sharp so just because it is a bit softer than steel doesn't mean that it can't be as hard as
sharp as it can be absolutely razor sharp right the next myth I sometimes see said is that bronze
swords were harder to make than iron swords or sometimes flipping that on its head some people
say that iron swords were harder to make than bronze swords well look this is one of those
ones where it's more that they were just different it's not necessarily one is harder or easier
but it is generally speaking it's easier to get iron so iron can be found all over the world
many many places in the world there is iron in some cases you can even get iron off the surface
of the ground without even mining bronze is reliant on two principal elements that is copper
and tin what some of you might not know is that bronze age weapons made in the bronze age also
have other deliberate elements within such as lead which potentially helps the casting process
helps the molten material flow more easily in the mold but fundamentally the difference between a
bronze sword and an iron or steel sword is that this is cast in a mold and this is forged on an
anvil okay so you heat up a piece of iron once you've got the iron once you've smelted it you
heat it up and you hammer it whereas bronze is poured is molten is melted and poured into a
mold now that does mean you have to achieve quite high temperatures to melt the the bronze that
being said you also have to achieve very high temperatures to smelt the iron to get the iron
even though the forging temperature is not particularly high and you need to make the
mold and you'll notice that bronze age swords actually are far more complex in shape and cross
section than iron age or even early medieval swords in fact in cross-sectional shape in general form
iron age and even medieval swords generally are much much simpler than these multi-ribbed and
fullered and complex and that is because in the bronze age you're casting the blade and you can
make a very complex shape in a mold which is more difficult more laborious to forge so is uh is an
iron or a steel sword easier or harder to make it's just kind of different and it depends partly
on your access to the raw materials and one of the advantages of bronze is it can be recycled
more easily because of course it can be repeatedly melted and recast into new things so the next
crazy myth that i said at sea said about bronze swords is actually not entirely a myth it's a
little bit correct but not as correct as some people think it is so people go oh well bronze
swords are heavier than steel and iron swords so that's why they tend to be shorter and they're
more cumbersome and it changes the way you use them and everything else well how much heavier
is bronze than iron or steel do you know post down below if you do the answer is between five and ten
so it is slightly it is slightly heavier um sort of uh cubic centimeter for cubic centimeter
bronze is uh usually between five and ten percent heavier than iron or steel are or rather than iron
is steel is a debatably can be a little bit lighter than uh than iron but here's the point
the point is that that's not a lot okay between five and ten percent doesn't make an awful lot
of difference and the simple fact is that generally speaking the bronze age swords were
made within a very similar total mass weight if you prefer as um iron age swords so if you pick
up your typical gladius it's about the same weight as one of these bronze age swords yes indeed you
know pound for pound you can make a slightly longer or slightly broader iron sword for the
as a bronze sword between five and ten percent but that's not an awful lot and so the bronze
age swords themselves aren't really heavier because they tend to be somewhat smaller than
later iron age and certainly later medieval swords so are bronze age swords heavier well
the bronze is slightly heavier but the swords aren't necessarily heavier because they're made
smaller now the next myth is not uh particular to swords but to all bronze artifacts i see some
people saying that bronze in the ground doesn't corrode well i can tell you it actually does now
the reality of course is that it doesn't corrode anything like as quickly as iron or steel does so
you can put a steel sword in the ground and the blade will almost be gone after after a decade or
two depending what type of soil conditions and how moist the area you live in if it's a quite
arid environment or indeed very cold or indeed if it's anaerobic so in the banks of a river or
steel can survive for centuries millennia in some cases so yes in general bronze is more corrosion
resistant because it doesn't rust it doesn't get eaten away quite as quickly as iron or steel does
but it does corrode so iron in the ground is subject to the effects of corrosion from oxygen
moisture and also the acidity in the soil and particularly has an effect on the copper element
of the alloy the alloy of bronze which is primarily copper and tin and indeed it does
become more brittle and bronze age objects in the ground while we might get a bronze sword out of
the ground they're often very brittle and they sometimes are corroded through so bronze can
corrode just not as quickly as iron or steel researching for this video i found out that's
something called bronze disease which i'd never heard of before so the final couple of wild points
that i hear um so one of these comes straight from that previous video i did talking about why
bronze age swords often don't have or in some cases don't need hand protection here and some people's
assertion is that bronze age swords either just didn't need hand guards or they hadn't yet been
invented and both of those are kind of wrong okay so first of all we know that sometimes people
needed hand guards but we also know that sometimes people had hand guards because they did exist
so while i was making using these swords for that particular video and using these types of swords
found in mostly in northern europe there are types of bronze age sword which absolutely do have hand
protection on them which sort of debunks my own video i fully accept although i did mention them
in that video now while i mentioned if i just grabbed the shield while i mentioned that generally
speaking um when you're using a shield you don't need a hand guard as much as if you were just using
the sword by itself we have to remember of course that in later centuries as we go into the medieval
period and you know this viking era sword for example and obviously these cross guards got
longer and longer in the medieval period they were still using them with shields so clearly having a
hand guard when you've got a shield still serves a purpose not only to protect your hand but it
also protects your fist from banging into opponent shields or shield bosses or helmets or whatever
and of course it does protect your hand from their blade a bit more but here's the thing we know that
in the bronze age yes indeed some bronze age swords don't really have any hand guard to speak of although
you could argue that that is a bit of a hand guard but particularly if we look at mycenian or the
sort of bronze age antennae swords the early antennae swords we do in fact see some of those
bronze age swords do have deliberate hand guards they're not just a feature of the shape of the
grip on and that they are very obvious especially on the mycenian ones they are very obviously
hand guards to guard the hand um so there we go that's it's a sort of myth that um i think you
know i partly debunked some of the things i said in my video i guess um but the fact is that hand
guards had been invented in the bronze age and some people did think that they were worth having
and the last bronze age sword myth which is really wild and when i first read this as a comment
i assumed it was just a one-off comment and actually made me laugh actually which i don't
mean to be condescending but i'll explain why it's funny to me in a second but then i found that
numerous people had actually made the same comment so this comes back to the corrosion resistance of
bronze so some people had hypothesized that perhaps these bronze age swords did have hand guards
made of organic material like wood or leather or antler or something like this and that they had
decayed away much like the wooden grips usually do and left the bronze blaze and so therefore that
leaves us assuming that they didn't have hand guards when they actually did have hand guards
well here's the thing so first of all i've already mentioned that there were bronze age swords which
did have bronze hand guards as part of the the casting of the of the tang essentially of the
hilt but here's the thing we do have the organic hilts remaining so the reason that we're able to
recreate these organic hilts on these swords and you know neil burrage who made both these
swords is one of the leading sort of replicators of these these are based on organic finds so we
actually do have the organic hilt surviving from various situations in particular in very specific
situations they can survive in the ground sometimes they survive in places like bogs
in anaerobic conditions where organic material like bows and spear shafts and even bodies are
preserved sometimes but in addition to that we also have particularly fancy versions of these hilts
that sometimes instead of being made of an organic material like usually wood or horn or ivory or
some tooth or something like that are instead made of or covered in metal of some sort usually
bronze it has to be said bronze sheet but can be silver or gold kind of ornamentation so in
some cases we actually have metal versions of these hilts surviving so we know exactly what
the hilt looks like because in that particular case it wasn't made of organic material which
rotted away but we do also have the organic hilts so quite simply when we're dealing with something
like this leaf bladed sword here the wilburton sword as it's known or one of the ewart park
we do know what the hilts looked like on these things so we're not we're not completely lacking
in data just because organic material usually corrodes anyway i'm going to wrap it up there
do you know of any other bronze age massive myths which are spread around about bronze age swords i
have to say overall i think that sometimes people who aren't familiar with bronze age swords think
of them as being especially different or other from iron age or or kind of you know later kind
of steel swords like in the roman era and actually fundamentally they're not that different this isn't
very different to a gladius hispaniensis and if my opponent had a shield and a and an iron gladius
for example and i had a shield on one of these i wouldn't be at a disadvantage this can cut really
well it can thrust really well it's got the same amount of hand protection it's about the same kind
of size it's about the same kind of weight these bronze age swords are not really that different
actually to certain iron age swords i mean that for example is functionally really similar to a
hoplite xiphos for example using one of these is not really materially any different to using a
xiphos so there we go bronze age swords i think they're fantastic there's a huge variety there's
actually quite a lot of research and stuff to read about them what we really don't know is very
much about the wider types of warfare and indeed the protective equipment if if any was worn in
some cases but i'm sure some was we don't know much about the the armor of quite a lot of the
bronze age unless we're looking at the mycenaean stuff for example so it's a really interesting
period and bronze age weapons really deserve a lot more attention than they get and because they are
corrosion resistant if not completely anti-corrosion we do have some wonderful examples
surviving from thousands of years ago in amazing condition in museums around the world anyway
thanks a lot for watching i have been matt easton i will of course continue to be please make sure
you're subscribed i'll see you back on the channel really soon cheers folks thanks for watching we've
got extra videos on patreon please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't
already cheers folks
