Why are betta fish raised in small bottles and jars? How are fancy bettas bred, and could these colorful aquarium fish survive in the wild?
Father Fish explores the commercial breeding of betta fish in Thailand, where he describes how young bettas are raised in individual containers before being shipped to aquarium markets around the world.
He explains how bettas are fed and maintained during commercial production, why selective breeding has transformed their appearance, and how elaborate fins and bright colors can create challenges outside the aquarium.
Questions explored in this video:
• Why are betta fish raised in bottles in Thailand?
• How do commercial betta farms raise and feed their fish?
• Can domesticated betta fish survive in the wild?
• Why do fancy bettas have such large, colorful fins?
• How does selective breeding change aquarium fish?
• Can selective breeding create genetic weaknesses?
• What happens when breeders introduce new genetics into established fish strains?
Father Fish also discusses fancy guppies, goldfish, angelfish, and other selectively bred aquarium species, drawing comparisons with the breeding of dogs and cats.
Discover the fascinating relationship between domestication, selective breeding, and the natural aquarium.
Lou Foxwell, known as Father Fish, is a pioneer of natural aquarium keeping and the creator of the Father Fish Method.
His approach to planted aquariums focuses on building balanced, self-sustaining ecosystems using soil substrates, natural processes, and minimal maintenance. The Father Fish Method draws inspiration from the Walstad Method and the natural aquarium philosophy of Takashi Amano.
Before entering the aquarium industry, Lou spent 25 years as a missionary, serving a congregation of deaf worshipers. He later opened a tropical fish store, where he adopted the role of Father Fish.
His passion for fishkeeping began in childhood, inspired by his grandmother from Berlin, Germany. He went on to become a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, where he helped shape its early development and leadership.
With decades of experience across the fishkeeping world, Father Fish shares practical knowledge on planted aquariums, dirt substrate systems, and natural ecosystem balance. He also provides plants, soil supplements, and tools to help hobbyists create thriving aquariums with less effort and fewer water changes.
Chapters: 00:00 Where Store-Bought Bettas Come From 00:19 Raising Bettas in Soda Bottles 01:29 Feeding and Maintaining Betta Farms 02:36 Generations of Domesticated Bettas 03:38 Can Fancy Bettas Survive in Nature? 04:40 Why Long Fins Create Challenges 06:30 The Benefits of Selective Breeding 08:09 Genetic Problems in Fish Breeding 08:30 Maintaining Fancy Guppy Strains
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only. Learn how the natural aquarium approach changed the hobby forever. This video explores the foundational book behind the method.
I'll tell you what they come from.
Welcome to Father Fish and the Natural Aquarium.
They come from soda bottles.
That's what they come from.
Any betta you buy in a store was grown out
in Thailand in a pop bottle about that big.
What's that?
10, 16 ounce, about a 16 ounce pop bottle.
They're not born in them,
but as soon as they hit about a third of an inch,
they put in them and that's where they live until they're bagged
and shipped to market there are i've
got a video of it somewhere i'll try to dig it out show it i have
a video of a betta farm in thailand
it is to pick a number 10,000 soda bottles all
stacked together and lined up in a row that's
six feet wide and a hundred feet long chuck
of bottles one up against the other here's how this
works they have children or young little people
young women maybe but mostly children who walk
on the bottles they have a container that has daphnia in it
and a hose with a little spigot
at the end a pinch spigot they stick it in loosen it
for a second close it back up do the next one
second the next one that's how they feed once
a week the water gets changed they go through with
another container that is filled with water.
Same deal. Stick it down in there. It runs for 10
seconds and the water is exchanged.
They do this for three months, feeding them two, three times a
day. Just getting them absolutely beefed up
so they can go to market as soon as possible. Once
they reach about an inch, they're dumped out into nets,
put in bags and shipped out. So how deep is
the water that your bettas are in at eight inches
and here's the thing about that those fish have
been living in that specific condition
for who knows a hundred
generations long enough for them
to have genetically adapted to that environment
so you can in addition to which they're selectively
bred for color and finish, so they no longer even look like
their great-great-great-great-great-great
grandparents. They are a completely transformed animal,
internally and externally. They cannot
survive in a wild environment.
This notion that somehow you need to create a natural environment.
here this is weird i'll grant you
this is weird what i'm about to say is weird doesn't make any
sense it needs to be clarified i'm going to say it
and then i'll try to clarify try to get myself
out of the hot water i'm putting myself
in these fish cannot survive in a natural environment now
that doesn't mean you can't put a betta
in your community tank your your uh micro community tank
or community tank of small fish, you absolutely can,
and they absolutely do brilliantly.
It works very effectively to do that.
I'm not talking about that.
I'm talking about putting that fish in a rice paddock
or in a ditch in Vietnam or in Thailand
or Cambodia or wherever.
It will not survive.
Number one, it doesn't have the wherewithal
to be able to swim out of the way
and keep out of the way of predators, number one.
Number two, its finnage is so extensive
that it's going to brush up against things.
It's going to get damaged.
It's going to get picked at.
It's going to have parasites and bacteria chewing on it.
It's not going to survive.
This is true of virtually all of the fish,
the common fish that we keep in our aquarium,
Whether it's guppies, platies,
mollies, tetras of all types,
bettas, angels, fancy goldfish,
the list goes on and on and on and on.
Flowerhorns, Oscars.
Now, I'll grant you, releasing a bunch of Oscars in a pond
in Florida will probably lead to a permanent population.
That would be an exception.
the color morphs would disappear.
It would get back to its original color pattern,
and any of the long fins would not survive
because they can't take care of themselves.
They can't swim as well.
So the morphology of the fish as it has developed in captivity
is not something that for the most part
is capable of existing in the wild.
It's a caveat on the natural system.
And it's one I'm happy to live
with because I believe very much in selective breeding.
I believe very much in the super fancy guppies and bettas
and goldfish and angels and everything else that's been developed.
Platies and mollies and just you name it.
By selectively breeding, we're able to create color,
finage, size, shape, all sorts of variations.
This is not something that is in any way obsequious,
to use a strange word.
It's common with other pets, primarily dogs and cats.
We don't even know what the original dog was,
or a cat, for that matter.
The morphs, the variations in so-called breeds,
which are nothing more than,
they're all animals that can interbreed.
It's the same species.
It just has strange lines of breeding that have produced
a certain morph that can be bred back within that line to be able
to keep that line clean, to be able to keep it healthy.
And there are problems with that, to be sure.
Interbreeding can create genetic anomalies.
It can create genetic weaknesses.
And it does.
It does in fish and dogs and everything.
So you breed back,
which means a change very often in the morphology.
A chain, if it's a guppy and you breed it back,
you breed it to an outside fish to get new genes in it.
It can look totally different than what you started with,
which gives you a whole new line to go down.
Four, five, six generations later, you're doing it again.
There are actually very,
very few guppy strains that have been able to be sustained long term.
The German half-black red is one.
I bred those when I was a teenager.
They're still around. One of the few that are still around.
There are a couple of others,
not many. Talk about rabbit holes.
There were six rabbit holes all in one attempt to answer
a question. Have a wonderful day.
Be sure to subscribe so you can get more of this
vast and vital knowledge for your hobby.
And hit the like button because we know you loved it.
and don't forget to share sharing is caring
the more you share the more we are able to reach out
reach out to the world beyond and touch many lives
with the great and powerful wisdom of Bob Fish bye
for now.