Why Didn't Rome Reunify, When China Did?

Cycle Nomad
1 follower
1 Video View·Nov 11, 2024
One of the perennial questions of history is why the Roman Empire never reunified, or at least why the former region of the Roman Empire never reunified into one state, when the Chinese Empire seemingly did. So what's the reason for this? Can we offer any sort of answer? Well, possibly.
one of the perennial questions that
comes up in the study of history is why
after the 6th Century or so the Roman
Empire never reunified the
Mediterranean and this is often paired
with an observation mainly being that
despite the fragmentations and the
period of
disunity China always seems to reunite
before we get into this I just want to
issue a brief caveat this is a question
that does not necessarily have a
specific onesize fits all answer after
all we're talking about opposite sides
of Eurasia and timelines easily covering
about 2,000 years or so in part because
China still exists and Rome does not so
I want to stress that this video is
looking at a particular argument and a
particular way of framing an answer you
do not have to agree with it and it is
not necessarily in each and every aspect
correct the argument that we're briefly
exploring here largely comes to us from
the work of Walter shidel a professor of
Roman history at Stanford University
whose research focuses on the Roman
economy and the comparative study of
ancient empires notably Rome and China
so I'm trying to condense a whole lot
into a short video it's not the only
thing his work discusses but it is an
important part of it
so with that said in Chinese history one
of the Main Stays of the historiography
is the dynastic cycle the rise and fall
of various dynasties and although it's
accepted questioned or rejected
depending on what scholar you're
currently reading it's one of the lenses
through which Chinese history has
traditionally been
viewed the history of Rome and perhaps
more broadly the history of Europe or
the Mediterranean does not have this
there have been attempts to reunify the
Mediterranean as Rome did and a
non-exhaustive list would take into
account the conquests of Justinian the
Arab caliphates and the Ottomans when
you compare this to China it seems that
there was a more successful run of
reunifying the core territory of China
which you could then possibly argue
means that the Romans either did
something correct or got really lucky
and then everybody else either did not
replicate that success or they tried and
then they did something wrong and this
is where we get into the argument being
explored in this video this has more to
do with the manner in which China was
continually reunified and then the
consequences for the eastern and the
Western extremities of Eurasia when you
outline the succeeding dynasties that
successfully controlled what would be
considered the core quote unquote of
China what you're looking at is the
following the key Point here in this
particular line of argument is that
after the sway Dynasty there was a shift
in where the military power during the
unification comes from in short it
begins to come from the step these
dynasties are not simple shift and
rulership from one to the next very
often Civil War and Imperial
fragmentation is the rule here not the
exception with competing Empires often
overlapping so with that in mind this is
less of a continuous rise and fall of
states and more of a competition of
States both ethnically Chinese and
non-chinese over a long-standing
political tradition and peace of
territory with historically claimed
justifications to rulership the tongue
Dynasty the Mongols the Ming and then
the Ching all either have familial
connections to the Eurasian step come
from the step itself or otherwise come
from the north of China in doing so it
sort of fits into this pattern you see
in medieval and early modern Eurasian
history where many of the large Empires
seem like they emerg from the Eurasian
step in part this has to do with what
the Anthropologist Thomas Barfield calls
Shadow Empires essentially there are
groups of political units that we call
peer States and these are cities or
small states that are just powerful
enough to compete with each other but
which aren't strong enough to fully
dominate the region on the outskirts of
that zone of competition is a political
unit that is to a degree related to
these peer States but due to their
position at the edge they are able to or
perhaps forced to establish a system of
political and military organization
which is slowly able to intrude upon and
then conquer and integrate the weakened
Court there are examples of this from
ancient history that do not come from
the Eurasian step the city of Rome and
Italy or the kingdom of Macedon would be
two examples but the point that this
particular argument is trying to make is
that after the Classical period the
unifying forces for China emerge from
the step and other large territorial
States tend to be dotted along step but
this doesn't really extend into Europe
all that much there is the panonian
Basin but the extent of that grassland
is not overly large and it's probably
not enough to fully support numbers
along the lines of say the Manu armies
during the mingqing transition period so
you end up with the argument that
essentially it's the proximity to the
Eurasian step along a wide Frontier Zone
that enables step-based political units
to impose eminy on at least the northern
half of China and then eventually the
southern half as well the Mediterranean
does not have this sort of Frontier this
isn't to say that China is simply open
to the step there are certainly plenty
of geographical barriers in place but
after Rome the Mediterranean is never
again able to come under the hegemony of
one power although it's not for lack of
Trion this is probably in chael's view a
good thing because the ensuing
competition among the European States
due to the general lack of a territorial
core that is continuously fought over
encouraged the growth of those
individual states and the ensuing
conflict eventually result in the very
late medieval and the early modern State
building projects with the result of
that being Europe and eventually the
world as we understand it today
