What did the Romans think about the Nuragic ruins of Bronze Age Sardinia?

Cycle Nomad
1 follower
Oct 19, 2024
The Nuragic Civilization of Bronze Age Sardinia is one of the most mysterious of all the Bronze Age civilizations to exist, in large part because we have plenty of archaeology, but no writing. Their structures & megaliths--the Nuraghe--exist today, and they existed during the time of the Greeks & Romans. So, what did the Romans think about them?
Perhaps one of the most fascinating cultures of the Mediterranean Bronze Age
is the Nuragic civilization of Sardinia, taking their name from the eponymous Nuragi,
the stone towers and structures that dot the island. The total number is difficult to calculate,
and current estimates are something like 7,000, although specialists on the Nuragic civilization
place the original number around 10,000. Oftentimes, these take the form of towers,
but larger structures resembling fortresses or at least complexes of towers, walls, and courtyards
are also known. Of these, some of the most well-known are the Nuragi Adani, the Nuragi Sirachi,
the Nuragi Genna Maria, and the Nuragi Santuantini. It's still not entirely certain where the Nuragic
civilization originated. We do know that the construction of megaliths took place on Sardinia
over the 4th millennium BC, including the construction of a massive temple, the Monte
Diacati, associated with the Auseri culture, and we know that the bell beaker package showed up
on the island around 2000 BC, during which the Monte Diacati was apparently abandoned.
Around 1800 BC, weapons and other artifacts began arriving in increasing numbers alongside people
from the Italian peninsula, and after that the Nuragi began to be built, which perhaps suggests
that it was due to the influx of new people and new ideas. Indeed, some archaeologists have gone
so far as to suggest that the Monte Diacati temple represented some sort of an older religion or
political ideology, and its abandonment and the establishment of the Nuragi reflects the dawn
of a new order. In any case, there are tentative suggestions that the Nuragic civilization is
connected to the Sea People that attacked Egypt and the Eastern Mediterranean during the Late
Bronze Age Collapse, circa 1177 BC. Regardless of whether or not that is indeed the case,
it does not appear that migrations and attacks by groups like the Sea People led to a full-scale
depopulation of Sardinia, because the Nuragi were still being constructed around 500 BC,
although the Sea People hypothesis is intriguing, because many of the Nuragi appear to have been
actually deconstructed around 1200-1100 BC. So, dates for the ending of the Nuragic
civilization span about 500 BC to, apparently, 500 AD. In other words, it was still going during
the era of Roman colonization and the incorporation of Sardinia into the Roman state. The Nuragic
civilization was not a literate one, or at the very least, they did not leave us any writing
that we know about. But, the Greeks and the Romans were literate, and we do have some of
their surviving writing. So, what did they think about these massive structures and the people who
built them? This is potentially a difficult question to answer, due to the fact that,
unfortunately, only something like 2-5% of Greek and Roman writing has survived to the present day,
depending on which historian is doing the estimations. So, much of what could have
been written about the Nuragi in a Greco-Roman context has thus been lost. That being said,
there are some references in surviving sources to Sardinia, and probably to buildings on the
island that are very likely of the Nuragi, although that's not entirely certain.
Our earliest description comes from the writings of Diodorus Siculus, an ancient Greek historian
dating to the early 1st century BC. So, relatively close, as far as surviving ancient sources go,
to the incorporation of Sardinia into the Roman state in 238 BC. And this is what he tells us.
Adjoining Corsica there is an island, which is called Sardinia, and in size it is about the
equal of Sicily and is inhabited by barbarians who bear the name of Aeolus, and are thought to
be descendants of the men who settled there, along with Aeolus and the Thespides. For at the time
when Heracles was accomplishing his famous labors, he had many sons born by the fifty daughters of
king of Boeotia, and these Heracles dispatched to Sardinia, in accordance with a certain oracle,
sending along with them a notable force composed of both Greeks and barbarians,
in order to plant a colony. Aeolus, the nephew of Heracles, was in charge of the undertaking
and taking possession of the island. He founded in it notable cities, and when he had divided
the land into allotments, he called the folk of the colony Aeolus after himself,
and he also constructed gymnasia and temples to the gods, and everything else which contributes
to making happy the life of man. Memorials of this remaining even to this day, since the
ferrous plains there derive their name from him, and the whole body of the people preserve to the
present the name which they took from Aeolus. So, this potentially mentions the Neragi,
and it's generally how these buildings and structures were contextualized in Greco-Roman
writing. The Neragic civilization left us no writing that we know of, so the history of Sardinia
gets worked into the broader mythological outlook of Greco-Roman culture, incorporating the islands
and buildings there, which the Romans and Greeks could not explain, into the legend of Heracles
and his famous twelve labors. The Geography of Strabo, dating to the end of the first century
BC, essentially gives us the same mythological information, but it also does potentially touch
on the Neragi. The text notes that after the Romans took over possession of the island,
Sardinia was not exactly fully in their control. It appears that the Neragi were still used, as he
notes that the Romans engaged in slaving operations on the island, and Roman military commanders
routinely attacked the strongholds that the natives lived in. And we do know that, although
the Neragi eventually stopped being constructed, many of them were apparently still occupied during
the period of Roman colonization. So this is presumably what the Geography is talking about.
Our third and last text, On Marvelous Things Heard, written by Pseudo-Aristotle,
essentially, it's not clear who wrote the text, but it is attributed to Aristotle,
and which dates probably to the first or second century AD, does appear to directly mention these
buildings. On the island of Sardinia, they say that there are many fine buildings arranged in
and among others domed buildings carved with many shapes. These are said to have been built by Aeolus,
the son of Iphicles, when he took the Thespians, descended from Heracles, and sailed to those parts
that colonized them, on the grounds that they belonged to him by his kinship with Heracles,
because Heracles was master of all the country towards the west. Apparently, the island was
originally called Ichnusa, because its circumference made a shape like a man's footstep,
and it is said before this time to have been prosperous and fruitful, for the legend was that
Aristaeus, who they say was the most efficient husbandman in ancient times, ruled them, in a
district previously full of many great birds. Now the island no longer bears anything, because the
Carthaginians who got possession of it cut down all the fruits useful for food, and prescribed
the penalty of death to the inhabitants if any of them replanted them. So then the Greeks and Romans
appear to have been aware that there were large megaliths and other structures on the island of
Sardinia, but their sense of chronology was evidently confused. Much of their conception
of the deep past, what we today would consider truly ancient history and even prehistory,
was marked by the belief that at some point you leave the here and now and the tangible past,
and recede into a time when everything fades to myth and legend. The Mediterranean was a sacred
landscape, full of places where legend told of heroes and gods walking the earth and accomplishing
great deeds, and sometimes, as in the case of the Sardinian Neragi, structures were built by those
heroes and gods, like Heracles or Cyclops or other figures from their mythology, and that was how the
Greeks and Romans understood these ancient works. The Neragic civilization appears to have been no
exception in this regard, and for them, it stood as evidence that the sons of Heracles did in fact
colonize the island.
