Why did Europeans think ASIAN SWORDS WERE BETTER?

Rune Slicer
2 followers
1 Video View·Apr 18, 2026
MANY historical European sources describe how Asian swordsmen, whether from Japan, India or elsewhere, were able to achieve results with their swords that Europeans didn't. So WHY were Asian swords rated so highly by historical Europeans?
Have you ever wondered why some swords have legendary sharpness like the mythical Japanese
katana which obviously can cut through machine guns and tanks? And in fact this ridiculous bias
is so pervasive even in modern society that it's even affected some of the laws that some of our
countries have devised. But actually if we go back into historical European history,
go back to the 18th century, the 19th century, and in some cases earlier,
we equally find that in some cases that kind of idea that certain types of sword from certain
places, usually far off, sometimes hot, often exotic places, have sharper swords that can
magically cut far better than our swords and perform far better. We must get some of those
swords as quick as possible. So why did this idea last for so long and why was it so pervasive in
society? We actually have some historical sources which can help answer this question.
So I'm going to be delving into some of the historical sources, many of which are featured
here in Swordsmen of the British Empire by DA Kinsley with an intro by me, by yours truly,
and we're going to look at some original period sources. First of all looking at did they actually
believe that certain types of Indian or Japanese or Chinese swords were sharper and did perform
better? And secondly, why they might have thought that. Hi folks, Matt Eaton here,
Scholar Gladiatoria. So it is absolutely a truth, and I've looked at historical sources in the past
to demonstrate this, that it was agreed that Japanese swords performed very well at cutting
for numerous reasons, and the question really here is why? And even in the modern world we
find this idea is still very prevalent and obviously promoted by things like anime and
stuff. If we go back to the 19th century, another type of sword which we find often described as
cutting formidably is the Indian Talwar or the Afghan Polwar, which are really two versions of
the same sword, but essentially it's a saber. Now before we get into those in a second and
looking at period sources, I want to point out that this was in fact such a strong idea,
it was such a good bit of kind of marketing, that in Europe swords did gradually, certainly
in countries like Britain and France and Austro-Hungary and various other places, did
copy and emulate types of design and formats of design, I'll talk about this specific one in a
second, from places where they considered the swords performed particularly well. So they
absolutely bought into this, so was it actually a real thing? I want to give a big thanks to today's
sponsor for this video, Incogni. Have you ever tried googling yourself or a friend? It's absolutely
crazy what's out there, from old email addresses, family members, phone numbers, postal addresses,
frankly it's a bit creepy how much information is out there. Sites and services you access are
harvesting this data all of the time, sometimes accidentally leaked to people with bad intentions,
or sometimes deliberately sold, for example through broker sites. That's your data and it could be
used by anybody out there with bad intentions. To be honest I'm actually pretty naive about this
stuff myself, I had my account taken over for 24 hours and I can tell you no armour in the world
prepared me for that. So the first thing that Incogni can do is it can remove your data from a
whole bunch of sites. Incogni works through hundreds of online data broker sites, finding
your information and removing it on your behalf. Incogni is a hands-off system, so once it's been
set to work it keeps working in the background for you. In fact Incogni is the first and only
data removal site to be verified by Deloitte. And the Incogni team have now expanded their
capabilities with a new feature in their unlimited plan called custom removals. This allows you to
submit an unlimited number of websites which are hosting links to your personal information,
you can just paste the link into your dashboard and if it's eligible then their experts work to
get it taken down on your behalf. So right now Incogni is offering a special deal for viewers of
Scholar Gladiatoria channel. Use the code SCHOLAR on the link down below and you'll get 60% off the
annual plan. So go and visit incogni.com slash scholar that's incogni.com slash scholar and use
that code scholar to get your 60% off right now. Thanks again to Incogni for sponsoring this video.
So thanks for sticking with me now. It's absolutely clear that Europeans did emulate
swords from other places and it wasn't just Europeans as well. If I just put these sabers
down which obviously were inspired by Central and Eastern European sabers but also within the
British and French spheres they were also influenced obviously by North Africa, the
campaigns in Egypt, the Mamluks, but also the particularly the British were influenced by
Indian and Afghan swords as well and some people have asserted that certain sword designs in Britain
were influenced by the Talwar. I think yes and no to differ in differing degree. They definitely
were a bit but maybe not as much as some people state. Equally in other places we find influence
from places like the Philippines as well and I have seen it asserted the 1796 pattern light
I have seen it asserted that these are emulating Indian Talwar blades and I would completely
disagree with that. The nature of the filler and the shape of the tip and everything else.
These are very clearly modelled on earlier Austrian swords and ultimately sort of Polish
and Hungarian sabre and shabla but as I say it wasn't just Europeans. In fact we actually find
in China in the Ming dynasty various types of Chinese sword being influenced by Japanese sword
and of course we can flip that on its head because we know that earlier certain Japanese swords were
influenced by Chinese swords. So it went back and forth and we're going to look at those comparisons
here from some historical sources but before we do I just want to remind you that sometimes people
attribute a sword's quality when they should be looking at the swordsman. So here's an example
which actually typifies a lot of the points which often come up in these numerous and when I say
numerous into the hundreds of British sources talking about swordsmanship. So it says this is
from Cold Steel and Indian Swordsmanship in the Journal of the United Services Institution of
India 1899 by P.B. Bramley incidentally and it says the swords of the Indian irregulars are always
of a keenness that contrasts wonderfully with the blunt reaping hooks of the English dragoons.
In one manoeuvre the oriental horseman is inimitable. He keeps his horse with a murderous
bit so well in hand that an English dragoon charges him. He wheels off in a pivot and deals a cut
across the back of his enemy's neck that generally puzzles the surgeon. I myself remember a Sikh
cavalier who cut down three European troopers, two dragoons and a lancer whose lance was cut through
as well as his neck. And I saw the fellow killed by a native trooper who outwitted him
at his own game of back blows. So this is a as I say there are hundreds of these accounts
which talk about two things the sword and the swordsman. Again generally speaking the
overall opinion is that the Indian swordsmen are better than the average British cavalry trooper
but also that their swords are if not necessarily better, we'll get to that in a second with some
other sources, sharper. Now just to look at a couple of antique examples before we delve back
into more sources. My own experience having sold at this point literally thousands of swords,
you can see those on the East Atlantic Arms website down below incidentally you can see the
sold archive. So this is a service sharpened 1853 pattern sword. So this is a model of sword that
was used from about 1854 all the way through into the 1880s by which point it was starting to be
replaced. And this is service sharpened in fact it's got two or three little nicks in the edge
and it's got a fairly decent edge on it. Now obviously this edge has suffered from age and
being in and out of the scabbard and rubbed against things and everything else so this isn't
as sharp as it would have been but it's fairly sharp. With five minutes of work this would
easily cut through water bottles or tatami mats. However it is a general observation and a general
truth that when you get antique Talwar they tend to be sharper and that's the product of a couple
of factors. Number one they are kept sharper, we'll go into the details of how that is achieved in a
second. So they're kept sharper generally speaking than European swords but also the edge bevel is
kept in a slightly different way. So without getting too technical the edge bevel on most
European sabers is about 40 degrees whereas on a lot of Indian swords it is closer to 30 degrees
or even less. So it's a more shallow angle which gives a finer edge and is therefore going to cut
with less resistance. Now briefly on the subject of edge bevels you will notice that this Indian
sword here you'll see with the reflection of the light has a single bevel on this portion of the
blade but it is essentially a secondary bevel so we've got a lenticular section blade with a
secondary bevel just there. If we just switch over to the Japanese sword, Japanese swords are unusual
I would say globally speaking in that the entire edge bevel is this entire section of blade here
okay up to the spine. Sometimes that can be niku which means apple seeded however that is sometimes
an even more shallow angle so at least to some degree part of what we're talking about here
the sharpness can be how fine the actual meeting of the molecules is at the final edge but the edge
bevel is also important and can give the perception of sharpness and the more shallow you make the
edge bevel for example kitchen knives usually or something like a filleting knife or a razor is
usually a very very thin angle and as that angle gets bigger you're going to experience more
resistance cutting through a target. So here's a nice concise source it's actually quoting an
earlier source so this was written in an article called Our Cavalry in the United Service of 1879
and it says an English officer after his first combat in India observed with astonishment
among the slain by some allied native cavalry many heads and limbs desevered and evidently by single
strokes he inquired into the secret of such execution expecting to find sabers of fabulous
eastern excellence not eastern Matt Easton but eastern Asian excellence but it was all done
with condemned British sabers we're just going to pause there for a second to explain something
so in Europe we've got various types of sabers here this is actually an officer infantry
officer's one but let's go to the cavalry one because this is the best example for this point
the 1796 Light Cavalry Sabre very often these blades were refitted with Indian Talwar hilts
and in fact allegedly those made by Gill well this one's actually this is a Gill that is a
pure coincidence this is made by TGI Gill anyway those made by Gill were apparently the most prized
from what I've read sometimes you know Craven and others were very good as well but anyway
these were refitted on Talwar hilts why because the Indians liked the Talwar hilt for their style
of swordsmanship it's far more confined but has a very distinctive disc pommel as we talked about
in many videos but the blades themselves were good they were made of good steel they were well
hardened heat treated and sharpened up and kept correctly they could perform very well and so this
was actually done quite a lot in India and so this officer was surprised to find these weren't even
Indian blades they were actually British made blades mounted in Indian hilts anyway it was all
done with condemned British sabers in other words ones that had been sold off as scrap essentially
the natives had sharpened them like razors and to preserve the edge had changed the metallic
for leather scabbards they had also attached longer wooden handles now that last one is a
very strange point and I'm not really sure exactly what they're talking about longer
wooden handles but let's focus on the scabbard for a second so it should be patently obvious to
anyone that if you've made the world's best and sharpest edge on here continually having it go in
and out of a iron or steel scabbard is going to blunt it potentially now these did often have
wooden liners sometimes leather liners the troopers ones usually have wooden liners inside
for that very purpose to preserve the edge however you have a what we'll call a throat
at the top here and even if the liner is inside protecting the edge when you draw the sword out
there is a good chance that some of the edge particularly the bit that you're most likely to
be cutting with rubs against that iron throat and removes the razor sharpness of the edge now in
contrast of course medieval European swords and most Asian swords are kept in wood and leather
scabbards whether it's just leather or whether it's wooden leather they're usually wood and
leather that means like this um kyber knife here afghan kyber knife that the edges are there's
certainly some degree of friction with the wood but they are far more protected um now it should
be pointed out that some European swords were also kept in wooden leather scabbards and as we go by
in time they actually replace the the steel scabbards in many cases why did they have iron
scabbards and steel scabbards that's a whole topic in itself purely economics and durability
and there were debates about this literally in parliament um and the the fact is that they wanted
to issue the cavalry with a scabbard that would last as long as the sword and it was noted that
Indian talwars during their use would go through dozens of wood and leather scabbards because not
only would they perish from weather and just being knocked around but particularly if your cavalry
and they're knocking against your stirrups and everything else they're more likely to break so
quite simply wood and leather scabbards are great for keeping your edge sharp and of course the
Japanese use lacquered wood scabbards um but they are less durable than iron and steel scabbards
of course the main point here is no matter how well designed your sword is and how sharp it is
the fact that you're using an iron or steel scabbard will always to some degree even if
you line it will some degree potentially compromise the sharpness of the edge so we've
talked about um edge sharpness and how it interacts with the scabbards but let's talk about edge
shape so uh William Forbes Mitchell who was a former sergeant in the 93rd Highlanders
he says for cutting our English regulation swords are too straight the eastern curved blade is far
more effective as a cutting weapon this is an idea that is not unique to him this is mentioned in
many sources our English swords are far too blunt whereas the native swords are kept as keen and
well stropped as a razor our steel scabbards are a mistake for carrying sharp blades in the wars in
the Punjab notably at Ramnagar our English cavalry with their blunt swords were mostly unequalled
matched against the Sikhs with their tolwars so keen of an edge that they could split a hair
so here we come back to the subject of shape now I won't go into a huge amount of depth because
this would be a whole video by itself but there is a perception that curved swords cut better than
straight swords and as described in 19th century sources this is to do with the fact that the
curved sword meets the target at an oblique slanted angle so much like walking diagonally
up a hill instead of straight up a hill it encounters less resistance and draws across
and through the target with a slicing action and of course in many books on Japanese swordsmanship
they will talk about the power of the drawing cut the pulling slicing cut of the Japanese sword
but equally the slicing effect of curved Indian and Persian and Arabic and Turkish swords is also
described and they even had certain training exercises to accentuate the curving the slicing
nature of the cut this is a somewhat complex point because experiments have shown that actually a
sharp straight sword like a Indian kanda or a straight Chinese jian or a European highland
broadsword or any other type you know a long sword or an arming sword these swords actually
in experiments cut just as well as curved swords now I'm not going to go into the physics and the
reasons for that there are reasons and it's really complicated but purely to say that there was
absolutely a perception that if you wanted a good thrusting sword you got a straight blade
if you wanted a good cutting sword you got a curved blade and if you wanted to be able to
cut and thrust okay then you got a compromised blade and that is why after the 1796 light
cavalry pattern which was a curved sword dedicated for cutting they wanted to be able to thrust more
and so they introduced new types of blade like this 1853 pattern which is a compromised blade
so it's got a bit of curve to it so you get a little bit of advantage from having a curve
but essentially it's in a relatively straight line for thrusting but the important thing to
note here is as shown there in Mitchell's quote 93rd highlander sergeant that there was a belief
in the 19th century that curved swords did cut better than straight swords why because it in my
opinion because it just so happened that the cultures who paid the most attention to the
sharpness of their swords the scabbards retaining the sharpness of their swords
and the methods of cutting and swordsmanship happened to also use curved swords mostly
but the elephant in the room is that indians for example the sikhs also used straight swords like
the patisa the pata and the kanda which are all straight bladed indian swords so although most
indian swords were towards and therefore curved some of them were straight so here's another
historical account as quoted in reminiscences of the great mutiny that's the indian mutiny of 1857
published in 1893 and says i remember reading of a regiment of british cavalry charging a regiment
of sikh cavalry during the sikh wars this is um this is pre the mutiny the latter war voluminous
thick puggeries or turbans around their heads which are blunt swords were powerless to cut
also they evidently knew that the british swords were blunt and useless so that they kept the
horses still and met the british charge by lying flat on their horses necks with their heads
protected by the thick turban and the backs of their leather shields and immediately the british
soldiers passed through their ranks the sikhs swooped around on them and struck them backhanded
swords in several instances cutting our cavalrymen clean in two in one case a british
officer who was killed in the charge i described was hewn in two by a backhanded stroke which cut
right through the ammunition pouch cleaving the pistol bullets right through the pouch and the
belt this starts to sound a little bit like the japanese cutting through machine guns
severing the officer's backbone and cutting his heart in two from behind this is full anime now
not to say that that didn't happen i'm just a little bit doubtful uh it it was um the same in
the balaclava charge they charge of the light brigade both of the heavy and the light brigade
their swords were too straight and so blunt that they wouldn't cut through the thick coats and
sheepskin caps of the russians so that many of our men struck with their hilts at the faces of
their enemy as more effective than attempting to cut with their blunt blades so as you might
imagine i've got some points to make about this one as well so first off i think we can dispel the
straight versus curved thing i think that's a 19th century and some cases 18th century perception
that doesn't necessarily hold water with one possible caveat right and that applies particularly
to cavalry swords at the time so one of the problems that happened with cavalry swords at
this time is they were prone to turning at the hand those of us who do modern hema and do cutting
of tatami mats or anything else would describe this as having bad edge alignment and we know
from various other sources that very often the fact that the cavalry troopers weren't cutting
was because they weren't aligning their edges properly they were just twatting you know bear
in mind i've mentioned this is a service sharpened sword but i'm happy to slap my naked hand with the
side of it because it's not going to cut it swords only cut when they move in the same direction as
the edge is pointing in with only a couple of degrees of kind of forgivableness either side
of that if you twist the blade at all you won't cut it doesn't matter how sharp the edge is and
that's even true of a super sharp talwar if you if you get the edge alignment bad you ain't gonna
cut through a thick turban puggery or a winter coat a russian's great coat or anything else
so i think the problem is a lot of these 19th century 19th century sources attribute failure
to a certain set of reasons when actually there's a little bit more to it than that and we have to
always conclude i think that very often when a weapon really fails it's down to human error
rather than weapon failure but not to say that in particularly in the case of balaclava in some
cases in india as well the swords weren't properly sharpened and we do know accounts of where one
regiment had their swords professionally sharpened another didn't and they had very different results
now a captain lang meesome of the 10th hasars an excellent regiment one that i'm a particularly
fan of incidentally makes a really good additional point so he says men by sheer strength of arm
have often knocked down an opponent with their swords as they might have done with bludgeons
or sticks and that is something not worth completely discounting we also find some sorts
of accounts a little bit like that from the american civil war as well where sometimes
cavalry savers were issued blood because they just the logistics fell down and they hadn't
been sharpened and we even get that in the british army at the time as well even though
generally speaking the british were probably more used to using swords than the americans were in
the middle of the 19th century but um absolutely if your job is to knock someone off their horse
or to put them out of action if you deliver a strong number five cut for example on horseback
bam across someone's face well you might not chop their head off but absolutely you're the man of
because who would want to be hit by a really hard swing from an iron bar across the face
um so that shouldn't be discounted um anyway he says yeah by sheer strength of arm they've often
knocked down an opponent with their swords as they might have done with bludgeons or sticks
but a fair effective cut with our present weapon um so he's writing in 1865 so it would have been
this in fact it would have been this model here um with our present weapon is in most cases an
utter impossibility i think that's going a bit far um i would pretty much say if i sharpened
this up i can cut all sorts of tatami mats chop them up just as well as a katana well
whereas european horsemen can always defend themselves well and in most cases
attack with quickness and vigor with their curved sabers so he's giving away his bias there he again
is clearly a fan of curved blades so in context he almost certainly preferred these the old 1796
light cavalry saber to these the at the time new 1853 saber which would have been regarded as more
or less straight but of course this comes down to two fundamental things again primarily sharpness
of the edge and the training of the swordsman now interestingly one of the places that we actually
find a lot of comments about the effects of weapons guns but also edged weapons is in the
accounts of doctors surgeons and particularly military doctors of course military surgeons at
the time and this is from dr james uh canterley who was writing in a manual of surgery 1886 so
this is still a time bear in mind the british have been involved in wars all over asia and africa and
even canada so so you know there was a lot of experience of the use of bench weapons at this
time 1886 as well is the year after the major sudan campaign but anyway he uh he writes the
cavalry sword let's go to this one again the cavalry sword does its work of destruction
bought more by its weight than its sharpness that is it stuns rather than cleaves the skull
the sharp sword of the seek on the other hand we'll go back to the indian talwar here uh the
sharp sword of the seek on the other hand will cleave the skull or shave off part of the cranial
or other bone in its descent and again this comes down to two things sharpness and swordsmanship but
in some cases europeans did make their swords really sharp i've quoted in a previous video
once before i can't actually find it now unfortunately but it's in a diary from the
crimean war of an officer describing sharpening his this is before one of the sieges on the um
on savastopol during the siege um and he describes sharpening his officer's sword so sharp that he
could shave with it and so you know some people were going to the extra effort but remember
there's a big difference here between a trooper's kind of regulation issued weapon owned by the
government and held in an armory and an officer's personal weapon which they buy themselves of
however much quality they can afford to to buy and they can sharpen themselves or have sharpened by
a professional cutler or a local indian blade sharpener and in many cases someone in an officer
in india in the east india company they could take this to the very same person who sharpens
this in the local indian town and get it sharpened up just as well as a towel but here's a couple of
interesting examples one from general napier i actually own a sword that was purchased by
napier from wilkinson maybe i'll show that sometime on the channel but he said the slicing of the
asian's sword a razor like scimitar is terrible but an english trooper's downright blow splits the
skull in both cases obviously they're going to have the same similar effect on the target so he
is saying that a the manner he's more talking about the manner of cutting i think and napier
knew a lot there was even a sword feat called the napier feat we'll talk about sword feats in a
second so he knew the difference between a drawing cut like this which would slice and a a downright
blow which is a chop essentially a hack and obviously they'll both have the effect of
putting the opponent out of action but through slightly different mechanics um and uh but then
there's another source here which is one arm of the service cavalry um and from the new monthly
magazine 1854 and they say we have seen dragoons cut a leg of mutton through with one sweep of the
sword and also a whole sheep at the level of the loins or a square of four inches long bar of lead
now what they're talking about here are the sword feats what are the sword feet well the sword feats
which are described very well in john musgrave weight's work also professor harrison's as well
both available online one of them on my own website as it happens they were essentially feats
like uh displays um showing your expertise with the sword sword feats um and there are numerous
different types of those we'll look at the sword feats in greater depth but this is a whopping
great uh number four wilkinson lead cutter and you can see it is a giant a giant cutlass the
original ones were ships cutlasses and then they started making them specially now i'll just show
you on the screen up close you can see it is a lead cutter number four by wilkinson now these
were specifically made for sword feats and they were sharpened very well this one's still got a
very good edge bevel on it although it doesn't have the final sort of um bite to the edge should
we say because it's obviously old um dates to about 1870 um but this these were used for cutting
through bars of lead through sheep legs of mutton all kinds of stuff so the fact is that when swords
were well sharpened well looked after and used by expert swordsmen in european contexts of course
they cut just as well as indian japanese chinese or any other swords and there are dozens and
dozens and dozens hundreds in fact of these sorts of sources it was a popular topic to talk about
particularly in military and sometimes surgeon doctor medical circles in the 19th century i
recommend that you get swordsman of the british empire by dakins it's available on lulu books
or was last time i looked anyway um i wrote a foreword for it many years ago now but there we go
maybe we need to do an update but here's the basic fact the fact is that some cultures paid a lot of
attention to the sharpness of their blades not just the japanese not just the indians but also
people like the filipinos were famous for it the sudanese were famous for it so various cultures
around the world particularly in asia and africa and some parts of europe it must be it must be
said paid a lot of attention to number one keeping their edges sharp and that is partly achieved with
certain types of scabbard and in fairness to victorian era europeans they did try to improve
the scabbards to make that possible particularly for officer's swords so make the edge sharp partly
through the manner of sharpening and the edge geometry keep it sharp which is a lot to do with
the scabbard it's housed in but also making sure that it's regularly maintained and learning how to
use it properly and an awful lot of these period accounts that i read when they describe what went
wrong with the troopers swords cutlasses and sometimes some cases even bayonets a lot of it i
look at it and go yeah that's user error and that's even true in some cases with modern military
rifles we often get fixated on criticizing military hardware when often the problem actually is the
training sometimes it's the hardware as well but sometimes the training makes the hardware problem
worse so sometimes it can be both things anyway i hope that's been thought provoking maybe in a
future video i'll dig out some of these specific sources talking about some of those specific
aspects there's some interesting extra things to be said about certain blade designs but also
scabbard designs and of course training methodology anyway thanks a lot for watching i have been matt
easton i will continue to be as well so come back for the next video make sure you're subscribed
and take care folks thanks for watching we've got extra videos on patreon
please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
