In 2005, a damaged, heavily repainted picture of Christ sold for about $1,175 at a small auction in New Orleans. Twelve years later, as Leonardo da Vinci's Salvator Mundi, it sold at Christie's for $450.3 million, the most ever paid for a painting at auction, and then disappeared. This is the story of the restoration that revealed a hidden thumb, the private sales that led to years of lawsuits, the 19-minute bidding war, and the questions about where the painting is today. Masterpiece at Auction, episode 1.
Photo credits (Wikimedia Commons, CC BY / CC BY-SA): Adoc, Ray in Manila, Leonard J. DeFrancisci, Claus Hoppe, MHM55. Video clips: Pexels. Music: Gnossienne No. 1 by Erik Satie - performed by La Pianista (public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)
The *Salvator Mundi* experienced a meteoric rise from a $1,175 auction find in New Orleans to a record-breaking $450 million sale. Once dismissed as a copy, the painting was restored and attributed to Leonardo da Vinci, sparking intense scholarly debate and a series of high-stakes transactions before disappearing from public view into private ownership.
These are two photographs of the same painting.
In the first, Christ's face is smeared and flattened,
his hair a muddy mass, the wood split down the middle.
In 2005, at a regional auction in New Orleans,
it sold for about $1,175.
In the second, the same face looks back at us,
soft and calm, one hand raised in blessing,
the other holding a clear crystal orb.
12 years later, it sold for $450 million.
This is Salvator Mundi, savior of the world.
And how one picture made that journey
is the strangest story in the modern art market.
The buyers in New Orleans were two art dealers,
Robert Simon and Alexander Parish,
who hunted for overlooked old masters.
They thought it might be a copy of a lost Leonardo da Vinci.
Fewer than 20 paintings by Leonardo survive,
and records suggest he did paint a Salvator Mundi.
An etching by Wenceslaus Hollar, made in 1650,
shows the composition, and scholars link the
original to the collection of King Charles I of England.
After that, the trail goes cold.
In 1958, this same panel, then dismissed as a copy,
sold at Sotheby's in London for £45.
Simon took it to the New York conservator, Diane Modestini.
The walnut panel had split, and earlier repairs had made it worse.
Under layers of overpaint,
she found something no copyist would leave behind.
The faint outline of an earlier thumb.
A change of mind made while the picture was being painted.
Her restoration took years.
Critics later argued that what we see today
is partly her work, not Leonardo's.
In 2011, the National Gallery in London hung it
in a major Leonardo exhibition, labeled
as his own work.
Not every scholar agreed,
and some still believe it came mainly from his workshop.
But the label changed everything.
In 2013, it was sold privately for $80 million to a Swiss dealer,
Yves Bouvier, who sold
Sold it on almost immediately to a Russian billionaire,
Dmitry Rybolovlev, for 127 and a half million.
When Rybolovlev found out, years of lawsuits followed.
Then, on the 15th of November 2017,
Christie's in New York put it up for auction,
promoted as the last Leonardo in private hands.
For 19 minutes, anonymous bidders
on the telephone pushed the price higher,
until the hammer fell at 400 million.
With fees, it came to 450 million,
the most ever paid for a painting at auction.
The buyer, according to reports,
was acting for Saudi Arabia's crown prince, Mohammed bin Salman.
The painting was due to be unveiled
at the Louvre Abu Dhabi in September 2018.
The unveiling was cancelled without explanation.
In 2019, an art dealer claimed it
was hanging on the prince's superyacht.
In 2024, a friend of the prince said it was in storage in Geneva,
waiting for a museum still to be built in Riyadh.
None of these accounts has been confirmed.
Since the night of that sale,
the public has not seen the painting at all.
Somewhere, behind closed doors,
Christ is still raising his right hand in blessing
and holding up an orb of clear crystal
that nobody is allowed to look into.