@Secessio Did Leonardo da Vinci secretly leave his mark inside The Portrait of Luca Pacioli? For more than 500 years, historians have debated the mysteries hidden within this famous Renaissance painting. A remarkable glass rhombicuboctahedron, an unidentified young man, and a strange inscription have led some researchers to question whether Leonardo da Vinci may have played a role in its creation. In this video, we explore the history of Luca Pacioli, Leonardo da Vinci, Jacopo de' Barbari, and Albrecht Dürer, along with the hidden geometry, mathematical symbolism, and cryptographic theories surrounding one of the most fascinating paintings of the Renaissance. Was the mysterious inscription really a signature? Could the fly painted on the cartouche be hiding a coded message? And why do some scholars believe the impossible glass polyhedron points directly to Leonardo da Vinci? This is the story of The Portrait of Luca Pacioli — one of the greatest unsolved mysteries in Renaissance art.
0:00 Introduction 0:50 Detail 2:05 Luca Pacioli & Leonardo da Vinci 3:20 The Rhombicuboctahedron 4:30 The Unknown Man 5:30 The Greatest Mystery : A Signature 6:30 Fly : A Coded Message
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing."
AI Generated·May contain errors
This painting may contain the work of Leonardo da Vinci, not entirely, not officially, but hidden
in the upper corner of the image is a glass geometric solid rendered with such extraordinary
mathematical precision that some art historians believe it could only have been painted by
Leonardo himself. And yet, the painting is not attributed to Leonardo, it is attributed to
another artist entirely. The work is known as the Portrait of Luca Pacioli. It was painted
around the year 1500 and for more than five centuries scholars have debated three mysteries
hidden within it. Nobody knows for certain who painted it, nobody knows exactly who the young
man standing beside Pacioli really is and nobody fully understands how the remarkable glass object
suspended above them was rendered with such astonishing technical accuracy. A Franciscan
friar stands behind a table, beside him a young nobleman watches quietly as a lesson unfolds.
But if you look a little closer you begin to realise that almost the entire intellectual
world of the Renaissance has been gathered onto this single table. A compass, a set square,
ink and quill, a slate covered with geometric diagrams and calculations. In front of Pacioli
lies an open copy of Euclid's Elements as he demonstrates one of its theorems. Beside it
rests a red-bound volume believed to be Pacioli's famous compendium of arithmetic, geometry,
ratios and proportions published in 1494 and on top of that book sits a geometric dodecahedron.
And then your eye moves upward, suspended from the ceiling by a thin red cord,
hangs a transparent geometric solid partially filled with water. Across its surface distorted
reflections shimmer through curved glass with a level of optical accuracy that seems almost
impossible for the Renaissance. Some art historians believe an object like this simply
should not have been painted with such precision, which is why another name eventually entered the
discussion, Leonardo da Vinci. But to understand why this strange object matters so much,
we first need to understand the man standing beneath it. Luca Pacioli was not simply a monk.
By the end of the 15th century he had become the most important mathematician in Italy.
He had studied under Piero della Francesca, the artist who helped transform geometry
into one of the foundations of Renaissance perspective. Later Pacioli wrote the Summa
di Arithmetica, a work that became one of the most influential mathematical books of its age.
In 1496 he arrived at the court of Ludovico Sforza in Milan and there he met Leonardo da Vinci.
The two men became close collaborators almost immediately. Some accounts even suggest that
while Leonardo was working on The Last Supper, he regularly consulted Pacioli. Their shared
fascination with mathematics soon led to a much larger collaboration. Together they began work
on a book called De Divina Proporsione, a study of geometry, proportion and the mathematical order
believed to underlie both art and nature itself. Pacioli wrote the text, Leonardo created the
illustrations. But among all the geometric forms Leonardo drew for the book, one shape mattered
more than any other. The very same shape now floating inside this painting. It is a rhombicuboctahedron,
a geometric solid composed of 26 faces, 18 squares and 8 equilateral triangles.
To Renaissance mathematicians shapes like this were far more than exercises in geometry.
They believed such forms revealed something deeper, a hidden order beneath the visible world.
To them the universe was written in the language of mathematics and geometry was the language
through which that text could be read. And yet there is something unusual about this particular
example because it is not made of wood, not stone and not metal. It is made of glass and it is half
filled with water. Light bends through the water, reflections move across the transparent surfaces
and within those layers of refraction and reflection appears a triple image of the
ducal palace of Urbino. More importantly, it feels less like the work of Jacopo de Barberi
and more like Leonardo da Vinci. One scholar described it by saying,
we surely see the ineffable left hand of Leonardo da Vinci.
But geometry is only part of the story. Standing right beside Pacioli is a young man
whose identity remains unknown. No one knows for certain who he is. Some art historians believe he
may be Guido Baldo da Montefeltro, the Duke of Urbino and a passionate patron of mathematics.
Others have suggested that he is Francesco Archinto. Yet another theory proposes something
far more intriguing, that the young man in the painting may actually be Albrecht Durer.
At the time, Durer had travelled to Italy to learn the mathematical secrets of Renaissance art.
During that journey he encountered Jacopo de Barberi and through Barberi he was introduced
to the work and ideas of Luca Pacioli. And if that theory is correct, traces of that influence
may be visible in Durer's own work. Less than a decade later, he created one of the most famous
engravings in the history of art, Melancholia I, an image that also features a mysterious
geometric solid at its centre, a work I explored in a separate video on this channel.
But perhaps the greatest mystery of this painting is hidden neither in the suspended
glass solid above, nor in the identity of the unknown man standing beside Pacioli,
but in a small piece of paper resting on the table. And yet it may conceal one of the most
intriguing puzzles in Renaissance art. Most art historians interpret it as an abbreviated
Latin signature, Jacopo de Barberi Vigenis Pinxit, 1495, meaning Jacopo de Barberi painted
this work in 1495. For centuries that explanation seemed perfectly reasonable. The problem is that
the signature does not fit the evidence particularly well. The word Vigenis usually
refers to someone in their twenties, yet Jacopo de Barberi appears to have been older than that
at the time. Other details in the painting raise questions as well. The addition of Euclid shown
on the table, certain elements of Pacioli's clothing, details that some scholars believe
point to a date later than 1495. And then there is the fly. Painted directly on top of the
inscription is a small black fly, a detail that raises an obvious question. If the cartouche was
only meant to record a signature, why place a fly precisely there? In Renaissance painting,
flies often served as displays of artistic skill, trompe l'oeil illusions designed to blur the
between image and reality. They could also symbolise decay, mortality and the passage
of time. But some researchers have suggested another possibility, that the fly is drawing
attention to something, as if the painter wanted viewers to look more carefully at the words
beneath it. And it is here that one of the most controversial theories surrounding the painting
begins. In 2020, Italian researcher Carla Glory published the results of more than a decade of
investigation. According to Glory, the inscription is not a signature at all. It is a Renaissance
cryptogram, a coded message. Even the fly, she argued, is part of the puzzle. Starting with the
Latin word musca, meaning fly, Glory combined its letters with those of the inscription and began
searching for hidden patterns. Among the many possible combinations, one name emerged, Vinci,
Leonardo's surname. Eventually, Glory arrived at a Latin phrase,
a sentence that can be translated roughly as, you seek answers from the abacus without Vinci,
or perhaps, are you doing your calculations without Vinci? Glory believed this may have been
a private joke hidden inside the painting, a message connecting Leonardo and Pazioli.
As if Leonardo chose to leave his presence here not through a conventional signature,
but through a puzzle hidden in plain sight. A possibility that remains impossible to prove.
And perhaps that is precisely why the painting remains alive,
because some images survive not by giving us answers, but by continuing to generate questions.