When the USS Kitty Hawk collided with a Soviet submarine.

Candel and Culture
30 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 21, 2022
There was a period between 1979 and 1985 when the Cold War became decidedly more heated.
Following with the international response to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979,
and the more forceful attitudes of U.S. President Ronald Reagan and British Prime Minister Margaret
Thatcher, both of whom largely rejected the policy of detente that had held sway in the
previous decade, both sides engaged in nuclear proliferation and there was a rise in the low
intensity conflicts called proxy wars at the time. And into this tense environment,
just a month after the death of Soviet Premier Yuri Andropov, an event occurred that could have
sparked all-out war. A Soviet nuclear submarine collided with an American aircraft carrier.
The 1984 collision between the Soviet submarine K-314 and the USS Kitty Hawk is history that
deserves to be remembered. It was March 21st 1984 and the supercarrier USS Kitty Hawk was in
the Sea of Japan. Commissioned in April 1961, Kitty Hawk was the first of a class of three
so-called supercarriers, upgraded versions of the previous Forrestal class. Capable of carrying 85
aircraft and with a crew complement of 5,624 officers and men, the Kitty Hawk could serve
throughout the Vietnam War and continued serving in the Western Pacific. In 1984 Kitty Hawk was
the lead carrier and flagship of the US 7th Fleet's Battle Group Bravo, operating in the
Western Pacific and North Arabian Sea. She had been sent to the Sea of Japan in March to participate
in Team Spirit exercises. Team Spirit was a joint exercise with the United States and the Republic
of Korea, held annually from 1976 to 1993. The exercise was designed to evaluate and improve
the interoperability of the ROK and US forces. Team Spirit was intended not only to improve
security cooperation and warfighting ability with US and ROK forces, but to deter aggression
and provocations from neighboring North Korea. Still the exercise was defensive in nature and
North Korea was given prior notification that it would be occurring. During the exercise ROK and
US forces stationed inside the country were augmented by US Army, Navy, Marine and Air
Force units from outside the ROK. Kitty Hawk along with eight escort ships was assigned to support
Team Spirit 84. Aircraft of the Kitty Hawk including F-14A Tomcat fighter aircraft,
A-6E Intruder and A-7E Corsair attack aircraft, and E-2C Hawkeye early warning aircraft have
provided air cover for simulated amphibious landings by US and ROK Marines. According to
its official report, high-tempo operations combined with adverse weather conditions constantly tested
the professional capabilities of aviators and ship handlers alike. The operation, so close to
the Soviet Far East, attracted the attention of the Soviet military. Kitty Hawk reported that over
the course of the exercise the carrier and its escorts came in contact with 43 Soviet aircraft,
six Soviet surface elements, and one Soviet submarine. The submarine was the Victor class
submarine K-314. Designated Project 671 or Scorpion fish by the Soviet Navy and given the NATO
designation Victor 1, the Victor class was a series of nuclear powered attack submarines designed
to counter enemy vessels, especially American nuclear attack submarines. Displacing 4,750 long
tons submerged, the 309 foot 5 inch K-314 had a crew complement of 94 and was capable of making
a speed of 25 knots. Although its exact armament at the time is still classified, the submarine
was likely armed with both torpedoes and missiles, including SS-N15 Starfish nuclear armed
anti-submarine missiles. The Kitty Hawk was aware there was being shadowed by the submarine since it
had left the South Korean port of Pusan on March 19th. Such behavior was not uncommon, as an officer
aboard Kitty Hawk explained to the New York Times, they play cat and mouse with us all the time.
As part of their tracking, the US had simulated destroying the submarine, that is had units in a
15 times. A former aviator who piloted a P-3B Orion anti-submarine and surveillance aircraft
explained, chasing Ivan was great fun, serious business but nevertheless great fun. The only
problem was that when you caught Ivan, you had to let him go. While the Kitty Hawk knew that they
were being shadowed by the submarine and had a general idea where it was, tracking submarines
was not an exact science. David Rogers, who was a captain of the Kitty Hawk, was quoted at the
time saying, sometimes we had him, we knew exactly where he was, sometimes he slipped away from us.
On the night of March 21st, the Kitty Hawk was leaving the Sea of Japan, heading south to the
Yellow Sea. As they deployed, the Kitty Hawk's escorts moved away, some 2.5 miles distant.
This in essence left the Kitty Hawk blind to the location of the K-314. The carrier did not have
its own sonar equipment, but instead relied on its escort vessels and aircraft to track the
submarine. If it were a wartime situation, the submarine would never have gotten within the
battle group, Pentagon spokesman Michael Birch explained in a UPI report. In peacetime it's not
required that the Navy keep 24-hour watch on Soviet submarines, Birch continued, these were
peacetime conditions, it's not unusual to lose contact. Still the pilot of the P-3B Orion explained
that he and his crew knew that the submarine was in the area of the carrier, and in fact speculated
that the submarine was attempting a maneuver where it tries to hide underneath the carrier to mask
the submarine's sound, a technique which the pilot said generally doesn't work. But the K-314 wasn't
trying to hide, instead the submarine, under the command of Captain Vladimir Evsinko, had lost
track of the Kitty Hawk. The most likely reason was simply the rough seas, an expert quoted in
observed that the Sea of Japan, which is relatively shallow and is teeming with commercial
and military ships, is one of the noisiest in the world, confusing the sonar that submarines use to
track other ships. There's an additional problem as well, as sonar, which tracks sound, leaves a
notorious blind spot in the baffles behind a submarine, where the noise of its own screws
makes it impossible to detect other ships across an approximately 60 degree arc. Some sailors
suggest that either the Kitty Hawk had made an abrupt course change, or was engaging in a
deceptive lighting exercise, so the ship would change its running lighting configuration to
appear like the guided missile cruiser USS Long Beach. While such operations would have been
intended to confuse surface ships, it may also have confused the K-314. In any case, having lost
his target, Captain Evsinko decided to bring the K-314 to periscope depth. When he looked through
the periscope, he was stunned to see that he and the Kitty Hawk were on a collision course. He
immediately ordered the submarine to dive, but by then it was already too late. At approximately 10
pm, some 150 miles off the coast of Korea, in rough seas in pitch black night, the nuclear-powered and
armed Soviet submarine K-314 collided with the nuclear-armed carrier USS Kitty Hawk. Captain
Rogers was on the bridge at the time, monitoring one of the ship's radars. He said, we felt a sudden
shudder, a very violent shudder. The radar was designed to detect surface contacts, it would
have not have seen the still submerged submarine. There was no indication that anyone on the Kitty
Hawk saw the submarine in the moments before the collision, and there likely wouldn't have been
time to make a response if they had. A sailor on the flight deck felt the shudder too, explaining,
that is something you normally don't feel on a carrier. A sailor in the mess room said,
his tray jumped up four inches. Others, however, seemed to barely notice,
writing the shudder off as rough seas. One sailor described acting shipmates in a TV lounge,
if they felt something, and they insisted that he was crazy. On the P-3 Orion, they could hear a
great scraping noise through their hydrophones. Sailors on the Kitty Hawk said the scraping noise
lasted five to eight minutes, as the submarine dragged along the keel. The K-314 apparently
rolled over as it dragged, losing ballast control. This would have thrown the crew around rather
violently, but might have saved the conning tower and communications equipment, which would have
been damaged or destroyed had they collided with the giant aircraft carrier. Ivchenko was quoted on
the website Russia Beyond, recalling that the first thought was that the conning tower had
been destroyed and the submarine's body was cut to pieces. They confirmed that the periscope and
antennas were still working, when they felt a second strike on the starboard side. The collision
could have been much worse, it was a glancing blow off the right side of Kitty Hawk's bow.
The second strike that Ivchenko felt was when the submarine's propellers struck the hull of the
Kitty Hawk, breaking off a piece that was left in the Kitty Hawk's bow. The submarine was forced to
surface. The Kitty Hawk immediately launched a pair of SH-3 Sea King helicopters to render assistance.
The submarine appeared to have a dent or crease between its stern and sail. It's reported moving
at a slow five knots towards the Soviet naval base at Vladivostok, while the guided missile
cruiser Petropavlovsk steamed apparently to the submarine's assistance. The submarine did not
answer the Kitty Hawk's offers of assistance, nor did it request any, and the Soviet government
refused to comment. News reports at the time said that the Kitty Hawk detected no nuclear leak from
the submarine, and that President Reagan was apprised of the situation. The Kitty Hawk remained
for approximately two hours in order to be available in case it needed to render assistance,
but then continued on its course. Other US Navy ships remained in the area. While the initial
reports were that the Kitty Hawk had taken only superficial damage, within a day the Navy reported
that the carrier was taking on water. The collision had ruptured a fuel tank storing aircraft fuel,
which was then becoming contaminated with seawater. The crew had to pump the fuel from the tank.
The Kitty Hawk had a hole in the bow and a gash from the submarine's propeller below the waterline.
Divers the next day brought up a piece of the propeller that had been lodged in the hole,
and the crew had it mounted in a hanger. The Navy described the damage as minor, saying that it could
be repaired at sea and was not significant enough to affect normal operations. Although crew members
aboard Kitty Hawk speculated that there was a significant risk for the crew of the submarine
after being rolled over in a collision, the Russian Navy has never provided information
on the extent of the damage to the K-314. Several members of the Kitty Hawk and other
US ships crews noted seeing welding sparks as members of the K-314 crew engaged in apparent
repairs. The K-314 was not able to return to base under its own power and was eventually met by a
tug. The report in Russia Beyond quotes Captain Evsinko saying that there was no loss of life
aboard the submarine. The general feeling aboard the Kitty Hawk was that the submarine had taken
more damage than the carrier, prompting jokes about the Kitty Hawk being the first anti-submarine
carrier weapon. The crew painted a red submarine on the ship's island near the bridge to mark their
victory, but the Navy later made them remove it. The Kitty Hawk underwent repairs at Subic Bay
Naval Base in the Philippines, which crew members described as filling the damaged voids with
concrete. During the repairs it was discovered that some of the submarine's specialized outer
coating had scraped off onto Kitty Hawk, could be analyzed, allowing the US a minor intelligence coup.
In the aftermath of the collision, the US Navy was quick to blame the K-314 for the collision.
They noted the K-314 was in violation of several elements of the 1972 Incidents at Sea Accord that
was specifically intended to reduce the chance of such collisions. The submarine was operated
within the American formation, did not use required navigational lights. Submarines are
also required to give way to other vessels when they are surfacing. Admiral James D Watkins, the
US Chief of Naval Operations at the time, described Ifsinko as showing uncharacteristically poor
seamanship and not staying clear of the Kitty Hawk. While there was no official response from
the Soviets, Russia Beyond noted that Captain Ifsinko was relieved of his post, suggesting that
they agreed that the collision was his responsibility. The USS Kitty Hawk continued to serve
clear into the next century and wasn't decommissioned until 2009, after an impressive nearly 49 years
service in the United States Navy. She was the last oil-fired US carrier to serve, and as of 2019
there's actually some talk of possibly recommissioning the Kitty Hawk as the easiest
way to achieve President Trump's goal of a 12 carrier fleet. There are also efforts to raise
money to turn the Kitty Hawk into a museum ship, a prospect that would be far less expensive than
trying to do the same with a retired nuclear aircraft carrier. In 1985 the K-314 was involved
in a nuclear accident. During refueling, fuel rods were removed improperly and caused the reactor to
melt down, caused radioactive contamination across a six kilometer area, killed 10 people that were
engaged in the procedure. In the end it's difficult to judge the impact of the collision in 1984. The
damage to both ships was eventually described as minor, and both fleets kept the event from
escalating into something much larger, but certainly a Soviet nuclear submarine running
into a nuclear-armed US aircraft carrier at the height of the Cold War was an event that was well
fraught with danger. And of course there could have been significant loss of life, especially
if there had been damage to the K-314's reactor core. Sometimes the story about what did not
happen is as interesting as the story that what did. The fact that an event was well far less
catastrophic than it might have been is history that deserves to be remembered.
I hope you enjoyed this episode of the History Guy, short snippets of forgotten history between
10 and 15 minutes long, and if you did enjoy please go ahead and click that thumbs up button.
If you have any questions or comments or suggestions for future episodes please
write those in the comment section, I will be happy to personally respond.
Be sure to follow the History Guy on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and check out our merchandise
on teespring.com. And if you'd like more episodes on forgotten history,
all you need to do is subscribe.
