The Hittin' Season podcast returns as we look ahead to the offseason following the 2026 Phillies season.
Fans aren't enthused by Dave Dombrowski's news conference or his plan to keep Trea Turner at shortstop. Can he get the Phils back as one of baseball's elite teams? Also, we preview the World Series between the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays, and we talk Phillies prospects with Mitch Rupert.
Join John Stolnis, Justin Klugh and Liz Roscher for weekly Phillies analysis, and let us know in the comments what you want to hear about next.
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction and episode overview 01:50 - Dombrowski’s recent press conference and team outlook 05:02 - Discussion on Trey Turner’s position and performance 09:53 - Analysis of Phillies roster construction and future moves 14:51 - Phillies’ use of analytics and development challenges 19:56 - Managerial search and leaked discussions about Utley and Banez 25:09 - World Series preview: Rays vs Brewers 44:51 - Series expectations and team strengths
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The *Hittin' Season* podcast features a roundtable discussion criticizing the Philadelphia Phillies' management, specifically Dave Dombrowski's decision to keep Trea Turner at shortstop despite defensive declines. The panel also analyzes the team's failure to integrate analytics, the hiring of Don Mattingly, the Rays-Brewers World Series, and ownership controversies within the Baltimore Orioles.
From WHYY, it is Hittin' Season.
Hey there, podcast pals.
I'm John Stolness from The Good Fight.
You can follow me on Blue Sky at John Stolness.
Coming up, well, at least the Phillies didn't make Bryce
Harper fly halfway around the world with blood clots.
And so we can at least take that little piece
of joy away from the 2026 Phillies season.
But instead now, as we're getting ready to embark on the offseason,
we here on the Hittin' Season podcast are going to get you ready
for what's to come here over these next few months.
But first, we are going to take a look back real quick
at Dave Dombrowski's press conference.
When we last spoke, the Phillies had yet to fire
or to hire Don Mattingly.
It didn't fire him, but they had yet
to hire him officially as their manager.
And we were wondering, when's Dombrowski going to talk to the media?
It turns out it was right after we recorded.
So we're just going to give some quick thoughts on that.
We know you guys have already heard a lot about that news conference,
but we'll share with you just some of our general thoughts
and the direction of the offseason.
The World Series is now set.
And if you're a baseball fan, you love the World Series.
And so we're going to talk about the World Series a little bit.
And then at the end of the podcast,
we're going to talk a little Phillies prospects.
Interview Justin did with Mitch Rupert,
who follows the Phillies farm system really, really closely.
So we will dive into all that stuff here
and talk about prospects to watch this offseason in terms
of the Arizona Fall League and potential trades this offseason.
We'll get into all that stuff
on this roundtable edition of Hittin' Season.
And as we have every time we do the roundtable,
Justin Clue and Liz Roescher are both here.
Justin Clue from Baseball Prospectus
He's been covering the playoffs for Baseball Prospectus
He's also been doing some bonus podcasts
Over at the Hittin' Season Patreon
Absolutely hammered
And the Dirty Inning, of course
You can follow him on Blue Sky at Justin Clue
And of course, as we near the Christmas holiday season
Summer of the Cheap Wieners is available for you
And your little purchasing fingers
So hop on that computer and buy that gosh darn book
Justin, how you feeling, pal?
Great, I hope everyone's fingers are wrapped around
Summer of the Cheap Wieners this winter
as john uh just suggested uh i'll
also say that watching these uh watching these playoffs
and seeing the Dave Dombrowski press conference
and then the the topics that got covered there
and then discussed in the following days
that he spoke about i mean you know you're watching
the Brewers and you see Bryce Terang make
a great play at short going the other way
throwing across his body stops a rally has a key home run exactly
when they needed him
to step up and hit a home run you know just
as one of those depth guys the the Brewers has
and then you watch the Rays play the Guardians
and eliminate them you see Taylor Walls cut off
this grounder in front of second base
so he gets an extra second to nail the runner at first and
complete a double play in a key moment
and then you see Dave Dombrowski talking about how
Trey Turner's getting one last chance
on the narrowest narrowest little ledge in the world
to prove whether or not he can go out there
and functionally not do any of the stuff i'm talking
about just function as a short stop in today's major league baseball
and um yeah i mean you know
that it's just the contrast is never more savage than
when the most elite version of that position
is on display like the Dombrowski saying like
which you know i we're gonna get into it but
that just that that popped
into my head today watching Taylor Walls make that play in the last
game of the ALCS before the Guardians got eliminated was
just another eye-opening shortstop experience about what may not
be for quite some time in Philadelphia.
Yeah, we're going to dive into those
Trey Turner comments in depth here in just a couple of minutes
and get into all of that
too. But before we do that, let us introduce Liz Roescher.
Of course, she is the editor
of Sabers Baseball Research Journal.
You can follow her on Blue Sky at Liz Roescher. Liz,
how are you feeling now on this Tuesday night? I was going to say that
Well, at least Dave Dombrowski didn't shove his foot
in his mouth during the during the news conference.
But it turns out he did because he gave Troy Turner yet another chance.
I couldn't believe myself. I couldn't believe it when I heard that.
Like, truly. Yeah. What what what more does he have to screw up?
Yeah, no, I think that seems to be the biggest takeaway
from the Dombrowski press conference.
And I will say this, you know,
given the news of the Eagles over the last few days and Jalen Hurts,
there's there's I wouldn't say Dave Dombrowski
and the Phillies are happy to see what's been going
on with the Eagles over the last few days.
But it certainly knocked him off of the sports consciousness
of the of the Philadelphia fan base
with the Eagles going through what they're going through right now
with the blood clots and everything like that with Jalen Hurts.
So I guess the Phillies are able to lie a little bit lower here,
but not on this podcast, not on Hittin' Season,
because this is where you come.
This is where we come to hold people's feet to the fire, friends.
And this is what we're going to do for Dave Dombrowski.
Justin understands.
He knows.
He's nodding.
This is where that's done, right?
Truth to power.
That's right.
We're the straw that stirs the drink.
Okay, friends?
So that's what we're going to do here on this episode of the podcast.
um let's start with the with Dombrowski
and what he had to say about about Trey Turner because it
obviously is foremost on our minds
and you know from where I sit this is stupid um I don't get
because I mean look I here here's how
this went down I don't need to be in the room to know that
this is how this went down he went they went
to go talk to Trey Turner about his crappy season
and Trey who I mean this this franchise is they coddled
their superstars and they didn't want to
upset trey turner and so trey turner's essentially begging
for to stay at shortstop which i mean i
don't get it like you know are you why is it
so important you stay at shortstop like you're not
gonna lose any money you're
not losing any opportunities like what what is it it's just
an ego thing it's just a prestige thing
to be this to be the starting shortstop so you really
you can't do it anymore man
but you're gonna try you're gonna you're gonna kind of force Dave
Dombrowski to go out there and say okay give him one last shot
but here's where this doesn't make
any sense to me Trey Turner was already like
a a shaking puddle of goo at shortstop this year
stressed out it was clear like
the the everything snowballed kept snowballing on him as the season
was going on it was his his play at shortstop
was affecting his hitting and that was affecting his
fielding which was affecting his hitting
and he could never get out of it so now you're gonna
basically tell him okay you're
on the clock you gotta perform within the first four to six weeks
like a like a good defensive shortstop
or else you lose that spot and now you go into the offseason
unable to plan for any alternatives if Trey Turner isn't good
at shortstop like you could have gone
into this offseason saying we are going to put Trey Turner here
and now we need this here and
we need this here but no now you've just created more uncertainty
and the whole thing we heard
this season was how you didn't want to move Trey Turner
in the middle of a season but that's the
plan now for next year is to move him in the middle
of the season if he doesn't perform well
under this now immense pressure that he's going
to be under to perform at shortstop in what world
does this make any sense i'm not the first person
to say any of that but just the latest i guess
well uh justin well when does the clock start i guess like it
is what if he's like doing drills
over the winter and it doesn't look good does
that count against him or is it like when spring
training starts that's when you can start measuring it
is it his first error of the
regular season like what at what point does
does the one last chance begin because there's
simply you know no matter what you think
of trey there's simply no way it's going to last all
season you know if he's on that like skinny
of a ledge as far as shortstop goes then there's no
way he stays up there for an entire 162 game
season i mean you can't like you can't be thinking
that if you're going to him and saying hey how
would you feel about moving to a whole other
position you know out there in the outfield
and everything because you're just not you're just
not cutting it here at shortstop anymore i mean
the ego stuff there's part of me that's like
yeah i mean it's not turner's obligation to accept
the morbid reality of the passage of time
faster than he is ready to.
However, on the other hand,
as we've been talking about
in regards to what a manager would do with this team,
when does the coddling stop?
You gotta be responsible.
If he's not able to be like,
you know what, I can see it, then I'm done.
Because all you hear is that he's this great hard worker.
He's never gonna stop trying to be the shortstop.
And in his mind, any other position
is a demotion of sorts.
So I do understand why that would live in his head,
but at the same time,
how many last chances how many like season-long
chances does stranger get to stay at shortstop
and how much because you know again talking about him being
a hard worker that would be great if he
was some hard work away from being a functional shortstop
but we've kind of seen that that's not
the case so i'm not sure what this really i don't know i'm
not sure what this situation really does
for him i don't really know when it starts
or how long it will be i just know it seemed like the
perfect narrative and emotional time to to move
on offer people a change in an area where you're
not really gonna like turner's definitely going
to be on the team but you can change something
about his contributions
so perhaps you know the change people are looking for is still kind of
present in an area that's deemed you know unfixable you could
do all that it just felt like a natural
time to do it and instead we went to Turner we asked
if he was willing to do something he is not
and so we continue on and it's hard not to see
these kind of things as like fatal flaws for how
this team is going to operate moving forward yeah
and Liz one of the other aspects of this too is
that Dombrowski said when he does move
if he does move it's not going to be to the outfield like
Turner has basically said I'll play I'll move
to the infield if you guys if you guys want me to
move to the infield so i mean i guess there's
that much clarity that we can't does Trey Turner
go to the owners meetings i mean i don't i i realize he's the one
who makes these decisions
great question that's one of the big deals here one
of the big points is that Dombrowski's the
one that talked to him he's not the manager
but he makes some of these decisions but who makes a
decision during the season
and where the heck are they gonna move him where are they putting him
second or third maybe second
or third i don't understand how they can just how he could just
say i will not move to the outfield oh so what
then we're gonna play you in the outfield your
positions in the outfield and if you play
or don't play that's your own choice this is so stupid i'm
just so angry at this whole situation i'm really i
that they're just letting him run the table like
this is beyond to me if you're willing to admit
that he's having a rough enough time defensively
at shortstop that a conversation like
this is warranted how realistic do you think an effective
a move to like third base is going to be like he's going
to suddenly become a better defender
at third base he's still got to make those throws across
the infield and that's been one of his
vices yeah no i think the uh i think the idea with moving him to third
and i don't think it would be
third. I think it would be second. I think that's
the most likely place. It can't be third.
It's just counterintuitive.
I think the problem with Turner at shortstop
is the range, and that's really the issue
with him. He just can't get to anything. That's not
as important at third base. Just look at Alec
Boehm, but you do have to make that throw, and you
do have to be able to make some of those
throws a long way across the diamond.
Whereas at second base,
I think his range is still
going to be a little bit of an issue, but if Luis Arias
can hang at second base, Trey Turner can hang
at second base and and so i think that's end up
that that's where this ends up next year i think
this ends up with trey turner probably after a month
of the season month and a half of the season
moves over to second base i i don't i guess you're
starting bryson stott at second and then you just
flip flop them and put bryson stott back
at shortstop where he's not as good a defender
as he is at second base but i think he's
a better defender than trey turner at shortstop and maybe
you go out and you get you know an infielder
that can kind of play all three positions i don't
think they're bringing Edmundo Sosa back he's gonna
be too expensive to be as a utility infielder
I think it's time to move on I like Edmundo Sosa
but you know I wouldn't mind getting somebody
younger who's a little more dynamic
and can do a play a few more positions and do a few different
things um I know Mauricio Dubón from the Atlanta has
been one of the names mentioned as a as a
good fit for the Phillies and as in that role
but I mean you also got to solve third base I mean
maybe maybe you go out and you get a good second baseman
this offseason and you put Stott back at
But I just wish that they,
the whole point was not having to decide this once the season started.
And now the plan is to push this,
to punt this in the hopes that Turner,
they're basically giving Turner enough rope to hang himself here.
I think they feel like Turner deserves it.
I think that's what they think, that he deserves an opportunity
after having a good defensive season
in 2025 to prove that 2026 was a fluke.
But it's hope as a tactic,
and that's how this team just seems to always operate nowadays.
I mean, I think you can say he deserves the chance,
I guess, if you're the Phillies.
I think a lot of people would argue against that point.
But I think a lot of this also has to do with the fact
that he's on one of these forever deals
that's still got a lot of forever left on it.
And they're going to squeeze as much as they can out of that glove
because it's costing them a lot of money.
They'll do the same thing with his bat.
I mean, again, he's not going anywhere.
so if he gets an extra extra extra long look
at his original position just to make sure there are
no absolutely no more plays that he's going
to make at shortstop effectively before they move
on and have to come up with some other very complicated
and probably weakening other areas
kind of plan that's going to have ripple effects across
the roster they're going to see they're
willing to see if he has any kind of effectiveness left
in defensively at shortstop just because
that's that's the kind of position he's
in and it's the kind of position they're in
i have a prediction i say Trea Turner boots
a ball in the first game of the season
i think that's certainly possible certainly plausible
um i think it just works too well
with the narrative yeah of all
of this to not happen he's gonna he's gonna have a clear error
in the first game of the season if the Phillies
are starting the season at home
it'll be hilarious at this point i just can't even get angry
at it it will just be funny because
there's nothing we could do and and i just think
from a roster construction standpoint you're
tying a hand behind your back by going
into the by going into the next season like this but um
you know it's the only moves that Dave Dombrowski knows how
to make anymore he doesn't like to make
major decisions that he has to stick with he wants
to be able to hedge his bets constantly
because I don't know
if he has any idea what exactly a big move would be
or how to do something that would actually improve
the Phillies in one big sweep.
Yeah, well, I mean, that's not possible.
They can't improve the Phillies in one big sweep,
as you've said on this podcast in the past.
Well, I mean, improve an area by signing
a player that might do something that's good.
Yeah, and I think one of the things they're looking at
is they're looking at the landscape this offseason of free agents,
and they don't see much that they like.
They don't see a clear upgrade at shortstop,
And I can't say I necessarily blame them.
Dave Dombrowski doesn't do trades well.
He's not a trader.
He's not going to go out and he's not going to,
you know, he does, he got, I think for
a starting pitcher, he knows how to trade
for a starting pitcher because he knows what
that player's role is.
But, you know, getting Luis Arias was one of the,
one of the departures for him.
You know, usually he's just goes
and finds a platoon mate in left field.
And that's, that's the extent of what he does in terms of,
in terms of going out and trading.
So I don't, I'm not expecting a whole lot of creativity on that front.
And that kind of brings us around to like,
just generally speaking from from Dombrowski's press conference.
What was your what what did you feel was the vibe of his message?
You know, like, how do you see do you think that he sees
the Phillies kind of the way and the roster
and the way it is the way we see it right now?
Like, do you get a sense that like there was more of a sense
of urgency in this news conference maybe than, say, in in last year's?
And do you get a sense that he understands what
the issues with the team are up and down?
Because he you know, they talked about
analytics in this news conference.
They talked about wanting to make sure that the analytics
was was improved on, especially on the hitting side of things.
They fire Kevin Long.
But then they bring Don Mattingly back, who, you know,
If you're going to really lean into some of these analytics
and the information out there, but you're not going to go get,
you know, a new manager who might be really good at utilizing
that stuff, you know, and then Sam Fold's role in the organization,
this bright young mind that, you know,
you've been grooming this whole time.
He didn't go down with the A's, but your Dombrowski signs
an extension for an unknown amount of time.
Like, I don't know.
What did you, Liz, what was your thought
on how Dave Dombrowski approached this press conference?
Did you see did you get a sense that maybe he had more of a sense
of urgency of understanding that this roster is flawed?
I mean, he's not blind. And so he definitely has to.
It's hard to interpret what he was saying in any other way.
It's just the ability of the team to do those things.
It's sort of hinges here like that's what hangs in the balance.
And it's not that there was lack of confidence,
but there's just a sense of hedging all over the place.
Like, starting with the Trey Turner stuff,
it's hard to get a sense that anyone has any solid idea of what to do.
And I think that's not unreasonable
because it's a baseball team and these are human beings.
And it's tough to know.
There is no one solution.
There's no one thing that will fix things.
But it's not like he had any brand new ideas.
At least none that he was willing to share with us.
yeah exactly none that he was willing to share
this and that's always that's always an important
point but i mean he has to know he has to feel
the urgency that you know the fans were not happy
this season the notices they were getting
were not good throughout the season even when they were good
because everyone was waiting for them to be bad again
because they knew it was coming because
they knew that this offense is like a light switch it turns
on it turns off you know we saw it we've
seen it a lot in the playoffs
the offense you know offenses can be like a light switch and
there isn't much you can do but there has to be a way
to balance some of that out you know they
have to find a way to balance it out
and man I hope he figures out something because I mean I
don't want to keep harping on the Trey Turner situation
but he he's he's tying a hand behind
his back because there's just gonna there's
a question of roles yet again which was a huge
issue with Joe Girardi you know no one knew exactly what was happening
and where they were
playing and the big change that Rob Thompson made
is like everyone knew if they were playing the
next day or the day after you know relievers had some idea
of when they might play and that was a
big difference and so he's making it more difficult
for Don Mattingly to begin with which I don't
think it's fair to him like this is a chance for him
to actually do the Phillies in the way he wants
to he can he'll be able to start spring training
the way he wants to focus on whatever he thinks
is best and it's just sort of unfair to him
that he's gonna have to you know juggle a bunch of
infielders when you should just put one of them in the outfield
and leave him there whether or not
is happy like dude this is your job do your job
and do it wherever they tell you to in the military
you don't have a choice and they're being paid
a whole lot less than you are justin your thoughts
on uh dombrowski and his approach
at this at this uh news conference here well it wasn't the
smuggest i'd say dave dombrowski press conference i've ever seen
um i think the message was overall
a combination of hey we have the capabilities
and we have the resources to change as well as
we probably aren't going to change that much
and i think there's about kind of like tempering
expectations i think there's going to be more
of a running it back than people thought i think
oh this this um this little firestorm of desire
for change that happened at the same time last
year was again significantly quelled
by the press conference held by Dave Dombrowski i mean i don't
want to give any one sound bite um too much credit
but the stuff about saying he had
to fix the situation because he created it that uh
when he like kind of threw a little bit of a
challenge to Bryson Stott talking about what like
great individual months he had throughout the
season and then saying i don't know why he can't
be that good all the time i mean you know it can
sound harsh but at this who among us hasn't said the same thing
and wondered the same thing
he said um he told JT uh JT Realmuto that he his goal
was to reduce his playing time and you know
as far as like spending goes he's like yeah we've never had
the support we never didn't get support
when we needed it uh but the key here isn't going
to be signing a bunch of high salary guys it's
going to be and i'm paraphrasing it's going
to be um just having the flexibility to spend
so like individually these are all you know good
i think more well let's say productive things and
they qualify as change at a time where people want
to see that it almost kind of felt like he was
trying to throw some bones of change out there
for you to just get get get a taste of it the coaches
who were fired before the the meeting started
that you know people have been calling for Kevin Long's
heads kevin's long kevin long's head
at various times throughout the past few years you know
there were people who were very happy to see him go uh
so he i think he was kind of giving you a
taste of what change they could possibly offer
and i do think i mean i thought the same thing
last year but i do think that like you know
a a whatever their most significant change is is going
to be it's it's going to be it is going to be that it
is going to be significant like i think there
is more to come undeniably more so than last year
but probably not so much and i think this press
conference kind of reflected that yeah i i think he i think he went
into that press conference not
having a lot of answers and that's okay it's it's
it's mid-october there'd maybe not be a whole lot
of answers to have but i i'm i'm it just doesn't
feel like he knows what the blueprint is or what
the identity of the team is supposed
to be he knows he's got these veterans on long contracts
and they're declining and um doesn't really see
um a path i mean one of the ways you can remake
the team is to trade one of those starting pitchers
and he doesn't want to do that that's
understandable and that's understandable
but that's the kind of that's the kind of risky move
that some teams have made i i did this article last week
for the good fight and i was looking
at the brewers who you know we talked about
this on on the last podcast they've made the playoffs
eight out of the last nine years i mean you talk about
a team that's kind of had a ton of success
but never broken through until until this season
um if you look at their 2023 roster compared to
their 2026 roster almost the entire team is different
and this is a team that keeps making
the playoffs every year. Like Bryce Turang is, is still there.
Um, uh, Christian Yelich is still
there. William Contreras is still there.
And like everybody else is different. The entire stat
pitching staff is different. All of them.
Like there's, there's not a single pitcher that played
a major role on the 2026 Brewers that played on the 2023 team.
And if you compare the 23 Phillies
to the 26 Phillies, it's pretty, it's pretty darn static.
Now, a lot of that is because you've signed
big money free agents to long-term deals
and the Brewers don't do that they haven't done that and
i'm not advocating for the Phillies
to stop giving out big money deals to players i i this is a big
spending team the Brewers are not i would rather
be rooting for a team that is a big spending team
but you've got to also couple that with intelligence
and there was something that
Matt Gelb said on his podcast that really caught my ear
and and i think it's something that we've
talked about and and and at numerous different
occasions about like filling in the middle of
the roster right finding some of the guys
who can support Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber in in this
lineup who are one to two win players two to two two
and a half win players having more of those
guys on the roster it's like he says like you look at the Brewers
and you look at the Rays and teams
like that they obsess about every 40 man
transaction like obsess about it and I don't get
the feeling the Phillies do that a whole lot I get
the feeling they just throw some minor league
invitations out there to people and wait to see
who kind of shows up at spring training and has
a good spring training. And then they'll bring somebody
on a board. I mean, I just don't get
the sense that the Phillies do enough work
and enough digging to go searching for those players
on other 40 man rosters that may not be a fit
or players in other organizations, minor league
system where they they're,
they're going to have to be exposed to the Rule Five Draft or be traded
that you can go out and maybe find some of those guys
and then to develop those players it's one
thing to find them and then it's another thing to develop
and develop them in the way that the
Brewers and the Rays do and to utilize them correctly
and that's where the analytics come
in i mean there's just this this news conference opened up
a whole a whole cacophony of of things
that i think are happening behind the scenes
and not happening behind the scenes that matter a lot
between being a good team on the forefront,
a team that you can see is ahead of the curve,
and a team like the Phillies,
who still appears to be having trouble using analytics.
The largest R&D department in Major League Baseball
belongs to the Phillies,
and they can't figure out how to use the data
for their hitters, still.
That just jumped out to me.
Why are we talking about analytics here
in this press conference?
It's new.
like i get it's factoring into like oh well we got
to figure out how how to use it better you're to
to get in some of these um batter's ears about how
to change their approach i know we talked
about Caleb Cotham and then like their staff making use
of uh of analytics and everything
uh but i mean you just you bring
that up you're just inviting you're just inviting this this exact
comparison that you're just like why do they have
this huge r&d department and then they sit here at
the end of season press conference
and they're like trust us we know how to use this data and
you're like then why aren't we seeing that on like
the baseball playing side of things yeah
yeah yeah godless my one comment about this is like
the major difference between the brewers
and the phillies is money and money breeds complacency
because if you can buy yourself
out of a problem that means you don't have
to obsess over every 40 man roster position
You know, you don't have to obsess over, you know,
spring training invitations in that way.
You know, if you've got, you know, I think they have in the past looked
at their big money roster and said, we've got what we need.
Now we just have to fill in the rest.
And they don't necessarily feel that it's a huge of a problem
because they can sign a player here or there.
You know, they did it a few years ago
and they signed Nick Castellanos and then Kyle Schwarber.
That was the last time they did something like that.
they were both huge players at the time
and it's the type of complacency that money just brings and
the brewers have to obsess over every little thing
because they do not have the money to
buy themselves out of any problem
and most of their players they really count on most of the
guys in their minors they've got plans for and so trading
for one of them is something that they
also do very carefully it's just it's just
a difference that it can't be it's just a difference
that can't be fixed because the Phillies have money
that they're willing to spend and again
I'm not saying that's a bad thing none of us
are but it's just a recognition of the different way
teams are run
and how maybe the Phillies need to start treating their own team as
something a little bit more different
or urgent as you said they have to start
operating with a little bit more urgency
when you know there's a roster spot open or something like
that well and i'll say one other thing
their their top baseball decision maker is a 70 year old man
who had his greatest success in over the you know during
the course of a long career when baseball
was very different than it is now
but so if i mean you look at organizations like the dodgers the
dodgers are a big money team
but they do all the same things that the that the rays and and the and
the Brewers and the Guardians and
other teams do. Again, you
always want to default and say,
what are the teams that are in the
American League Championship Series now doing that the Phillies
aren't doing? When can we do stuff like that?
You're constantly chasing your tail if you're
thinking like that. But what the
Phillies are doing right now, and what's been reported in
The Athletic and other places, is that the Phillies have
a huge analytics department and they're not using it properly.
And it's one of the reasons why they can't
develop people. It's one of the reasons why the
farm system continues.
Because you have old people who have been doing this for forever
who aren't good at utilizing this information.
That's why.
Remember, they rearranged things in their player development system
because it turns out there was one guy with three jobs for some reason.
And that was impacting his ability to do any of them.
And as far as this analytics department,
after this press conference and then, yeah, like John said, this report
that they have this big department they don't know how to use.
It just makes you think of, like, a room full
of computers just constantly printing out sheets full of data,
and the room's just, like, filling with paper.
And Dave Dombrowski's like, oh, yeah,
we just, we don't go in that room.
And they just lock it from the outside.
Every now and then we send a couple of active paper shredders in there,
and we just let it do its thing.
They send in a couple of interns and notify their families, you know.
It's like Willy Wonka's candy experimentation room
where they make the job stoppers, you know what I mean?
Like, you know, there's just all kinds of machines in there
making interesting sounds and, you know, producing candy,
and it's really bizarre.
A bunch of old-school Philly scouts walk by the door, look in,
there's, like, little robots walking around,
performing calculations and, like, watching baseball on a big screen.
You know, what's so crazy to me,
and I want to move on to the World Series,
because, I mean, I realize we're kind of treading over ground
that a lot of people have already tread
on but the pitching side of the Phillies does do all of
this stuff it's night and day between like they have
this they have a Brewers like pitching
laboratory and that's why the pitching generally speaking
is pretty successful i mean they've
they remade Christopher Sanchez
when they got Jeff Hoffman they remade Jeff Hoffman
they seem to have figured out something
with Andrew Painter transforming him in the middle
of the season like they're having trouble
with getting some dependable relievers and I think
maybe there's a hole there or maybe that's just some bad luck there
but it seems that the pitching
they have a lot of pitching success stories
with this organization a lot of it is I think due to
Caleb Cottam who is a younger baseball mind
who I think is comfortable utilizing all this
information but it's streamlined from Clearwater all
the way up to the big league roster
And they admit that on the hitting side of things,
that's not happening.
So I just don't get that, how you can have all of this stuff lined up
for this pitching laboratory that you have
and not have a similar setup for the hitting.
But maybe it is like you said, they have one guy doing three jobs
and he just didn't have time for that.
I don't know.
And then they got to figure out the defense, you know?
I saw that the Phillies had
the second lowest batting average on balls in play
like since 2024.
Oh my God.
And a lot of it is because in an Athletic article said
that essentially, let me see if I can pull it up,
is basically the Phillies believe they have ground to gain.
This is Matt Gelb to gain by incorporating more data driven decisions
into their fielding instruction.
New infield coach Carlos Mendoza has
been directed to work closely with the analysts.
The positioning is only as good as the model creating it.
But the Phillies might be more rigid about where
the about the model suggestions than they were before.
In other words, the model is creating something.
and when it actually gets to the people in the dugout,
they're saying, eh, maybe,
as opposed to actually using the model.
That's what it means.
Hang on, though.
I mean, we've also seen the flaws
of trying to enforce a system
rather than manage players.
That's true, too.
And while you can say that this, you know,
obviously doesn't work as far as defensive improvements,
and there's aspects of the defense that you can't fix,
like aging players who can't get to a ball.
maybe they could have gotten to five, 10 years ago.
However, the analytics are there not to
completely replace that,
but to perhaps assuage the severity of a defensive drop-off like that
with positioning, with statistical analysis, with projections.
And that does make sense.
And what are we always saying?
This has to be part of your toolkit, but not the entire tool.
Correct. You're right.
So, you know, fair enough. But also, I think the problem here
is that when something's not working, it doesn't change.
And that's the wall they keep running into.
You can have all the tools in the world. You can clearly have
the biggest resource in the R&D department in baseball.
And it's still not going to matter if you don't have players who are,
you know, acquiescing to what you're telling them.
So maybe it's more of a communication issue.
And that's true, too. It could very well be that.
And maybe that's one of the things they're going
to streamline here is getting information to where it needs to be.
But it wasn't an encouraging news conference,
but no one expected it to be an encouraging news conference.
And it's going to be a weird offseason
with an impending lockout that we think is all going to happen.
That's going to make decisions harder to make.
They still have to hire a hitting coach.
We'll see who that is, and maybe that's a young analytic mind
that's going to come in and be able to help do that stuff.
And again, I don't want to get caught back up
into the analytics, analytics, analytics,
because we understood that we went too deep into that before,
and you do need to find a balance between those different things.
But clearly, I think there's some things falling through
the cracks here with the Phillies,
and we'll see.
We also didn't—I did want to mention one other thing.
Jason Stark reporting that Chase Utley
and Raul Laboy were
approached about the manager's job
before they officially gave it to Don
Mattingly
I want to ask you guys
your thoughts on, Justin, your thoughts
on Chase Utley, potential
Phillies manager, he turned him down, Raul Laboy
both turned him down
but the fact that they're going to Chase
and Laboy
to at least hear him out about this potential
position
uh yeah fourth choice Don Mattingly gets
to be the manager sorry i was trying to find the medal
that the fourth place medal is it's tin it's tin okay yeah uh
in any case a nice tin surprise
for Don Mattingly here finding out presumably
with the rest of us that the Phillies uh asked
asked multiple other people after Alex Cora
to also potentially be the Phillies manager uh first
I do want to say I never
understood analytics in my defense
even when I was advocating for
it and I think if a lot of people were
honest with themselves they would say the same thing
and secondly to get
back to the actual
question at hand
I mean come on is saying
they asked Utley and Abanez
just like basically when they
were around
to be the manager anything
other than just a defense
against the accusation that they didn't really
like look around like Chase Utley's not accepting
that job no Chase Chase Utley doesn't want
to manage has he ever said anything about wanting
to manage would you even consider him potentially even
a good manager no you know like the does i
don't think he's really had that kind of career
or or statements out loud or to himself that
managing was something he really wanted
to do i think he's doing the job he wants to do MLB
ambassador to England boy i'm sure it's just uh burning
the midnight oil over there so many
responsibilities and that job
and i'm sure that's what he was looking for too and then you know you
hire Chase Utley you gotta fire Chase Utley
at some point it's a point that other people have
made which is also gonna be something that's
a problem um but yeah ultimately i think at the end
of the day these were just two two people they asked
who they probably didn't expect to say yes
and who didn't say yes whose pedigrees as manager
are you know probably at least questionable
if not debatable and uh they kind of probably just wanted
to say what before they brought back
Don Mattingly something they knew a lot
of people weren't looking forward to seeing
was hey but we did we did ask these fan favorite players
if they would come here so look it's not
our fault they said no like we asked them
if they wanted the job they said no so that you know we
get we get points for that we didn't just turn
from Alex Cora the guy we already got rejected
by to the guy whose son already works here we did talk
to some other guys in between briefly
friend for no reason but you know we did do it
and that's ultimately what i think this was really
about was just racking up a longer list of names
to say they talked to before ultimately bringing
back bringing back Don Mattingly, my question here
is who leaked this to Jason Stark? Was it someone
with the Dodgers hoping to make the Phillies look silly
or was it someone with the Phillies thinking
this was a good thing to leak
because it doesn't seem like a great thing to have leaked or to have
done like ask two guys who do not have an interest
in it like Rawley Baez has an actual position
with the Dodgers, so does Chase Utley, right? Well yeah I
was just I was just going to say yeah that
Chase Utley, not in addition to his um England stuff has
a is like special assistant to uh the
GM or the head of baseball operations whichever it
is over at the Dodgers like they both have jobs
with the Dodgers that they honestly I think it says England stuff
on Chase Utley's LinkedIn page
as the title of his current position.
That would honestly make a lot of sense.
Yeah.
Yes.
He didn't turn in a resume to the Phillies,
but they made one up for him, and that's what's on there.
That's right.
That's really my question.
Yeah.
I didn't even think about the fact that you'd have to fire him someday.
Maybe soon.
That would be awful.
Nobody would be able to handle that.
What would Chase Utley's walking out of there,
what's his equivalent of the Wawa bag in Charlie Daniels?
Oh, my God.
And that picture of him sadly walking out of Citizens Bank Park
as we all watched our happiness leave Citizens Bank Park with him.
That was not a good day.
No.
All right, anything else from the Dombrowski press conference?
I'm surprised we haven't heard from Middleton yet.
Yes, no, everything buttoned up there, you guys think?
He doesn't want to talk to people.
Are you kidding me?
He knows how the fans feel.
As entertained as I would be by a John Middleton press conference now,
I think his handlers have him behind closed doors for the time being.
Remember last time he came out?
It was the old feud with the Callis family.
Oh, that's right.
I think they're going to keep him locked up for a minute.
That absolutely cursed the season.
Yeah, maybe that did curse the season.
Anyway, all right.
Let's shift and talk about this World Series
that is going to be beginning on Friday.
You've got the Tampa Bay Rays and the Milwaukee Brewers,
the best team in the American League,
going up against the team that finished
with the best record in baseball, the Brewers.
This is being billed as the small market series,
the salary cap series,
or the argument against the salary cap.
I mean, there's going to be a lot of narratives
that are kind of eye-roll inducing about all this.
The fact that it's the Rays and the Brewers, I don't think it's going
to have any impact on negotiating position or power.
But narratively speaking, if a lot of the importance
of negotiations like this is is fan support and fan opinion.
And it's you've got two teams here that don't spend a lot
of money that are seen as small market teams that have,
generally speaking, low payrolls.
And here they are from wire to wire this year
were essentially the two best teams in each league.
They have tons of talent everywhere. It should be there
two young athletic teams that can really pitch the baseball.
And it should be an absolutely amazing series.
Either way, some franchise is going
to have its first ever world championship.
The Brewers, it's only their second time ever in the World Series.
They lost a seven-game series to the Cardinals back in 1982.
And for the Rays, it'll be their third time,
of course, losing to the Phillies in 2008.
And then losing to the Dodgers
in the 2020 COVID weird postseason that they had that year.
So, Liz, first thoughts on this World Series
as you got the Rays and the Brewers getting ready
to get things going on Friday night.
I'm excited about it.
It's two teams that have never won a World Series.
I'm personally pulling for the Brewers.
I'm always partial to the NL teams just because.
But, yeah, the Brewers are a fun team to watch.
I don't feel the same way about the Rays.
I think they're sometimes fun, but like the Brewers
are a solidly exciting team and it will be so much.
It will be fun to watch them on the biggest stage like
they've I think we mentioned it on a previous podcast.
They have tried and tried and tried to make it there
and they've gotten close for so many years
and now they're there and they actually have the chance.
i can't wait to see their fans lose their minds
because even in just like the NLCS they
were they were in it it was really fun
and cool to watch them in the stands just losing their minds
and i think a fan base that has hung
on that long really deserves it you know they're there
they're supporting them they're not angry
or bitter uh and they they deserve all of this
uh so i'm excited to watch that and see what
the fan response is because they definitely
the Brewers fans seem a whole lot cooler than some
of the other fan bases we've seen in years past
i'm talking to you padres yeah yeah this isn't
this reminds me a little bit a little bit of the
91 world series between the braves and the twins
although they were like worst to first teams and
And this is clearly not what the Braves,
the Rays and the Brewers have both been pretty good.
But, Justin, it kind of feels like two kind of two teams
that just generally speaking fly under the radar.
And this I get the feeling this could turn into like another classic.
Last year was a classic World Series.
These two teams are pretty evenly matched.
I think the Brewers have the edge,
but I feel like this could just be a really, really good one.
Yeah, this was there were a couple of matchups in this postseason
that I felt were kind of meeting the same description.
but uh they all kind of crumbled in my hands
as far as quality goes uh as far as like the
yankees committing five errors in a game
and everything like there were a couple of times
i really thought two really good teams were just going
to play each other i kind of thought that
was going to happen with the brewers and the dodgers
but all that really did was contribute
to the brewers legend as they go into the world series
which i think will finally
finally be the kind of series that i've
been promising this entire postseason i mean with
the brewers they really do have the the parts
of their team that function best are the parts of
teams that you often hear them complaining about like oh we just got
to get better here we just
got to get better here and then you know we'll
be good the brewers don't have to worry about their
bullpen they've got like at least four
or five guys that you absolutely would trust to get three
outs at any time um obviously matchups
are gonna favorable matchups are gonna help them but really
at the end of the day every guy every guy
from Trevor Williams, DL Hall like that whole Aaron Ashby
that whole crop of guys can come in and get outs
and they also just have great at bats and that's
different from saying they have a great offense
because as we know they don't have there is no
superstar slugger type you know they can they can summon power
on occasion but for the most part
they're a team that loves getting on base
and getting hits when they need to get hits and as
far as like since halloween if i was going
to compare them to like a horror movie monster
they'd be the thing from it follows
and that it's just this constant threat and pressure just like
at all times walking towards you
and that's what the dodgers learned getting swept like that was
an absolutely jarringly dominant series by the milwaukee brewers
and it's because they're
relentless they're relentlessly good at the parts
of baseball that other teams have a hard time
getting right and so that's what makes them such a giant threat
and now they're going to face a
team like the rays who kind of complement them uh
as far as like uh threat counter threat goes
and that like the Brewers love getting on base
but Rays pitchers hate giving up walks and they're
starting pitching is a big strength
for them Drew Rasmussen man talk about talk about under the
radar yeah some of the numbers these guys have
been putting up this season it's stupid that we've
been talking about other people i mean his numbers
were incredible this year i know Cleveland just
got eliminated but like that's a team that it wasn't
as as strongly a bullpen first team as in
2024 but the guys in that bullpen Kade Smith
were absolutely staggering in 2024 but the Rays also
have Ryan Baker who again under
the radar nobody knows best closer no yeah nobody nobody's even
aware about this guy until the postseason starts
and the Rays have such uh exquisite pitching and
defense they can smother a team like the Brewers
who can score a ton of runs on you when you're
you know not even when you make one small mistake they can capitalize
so i really do think this is
going to be a spectacular matchup between two
of the truly best teams in baseball with the added
bonus that they're not teams we see in the World Series very often
and as we know aren't teams that
have ever won the World Series
so you're going to see a little bit of history here regardless of
what happens and you're going to do it
by watching two teams you're not sick to death of seeing
playing in prime time in October
so this is probably the most promising World Series
not non-Phillies edition that i've seen
in many years yeah just from it's not like you know
Yankees Dodgers in terms of like marquee matchups
but oftentimes those types of World Series don't
ever live up to the hype and and it's sometimes
these under the radar World Series sometimes
they're not great you know um you know Rangers Diamondbacks
was was a stinker um you know not
and not just from a Phillies perspective just
in general an objectively terrible World Series like
and that sometimes you get those but uh other times you get
these World Series that they just
surprise you with how good they can be and i think
that's kind of what we're looking for here these
two teams are the teams that almost kept
the Phillies out of the playoffs in the final week
of the season uh this was it was a it truly
was the gauntlet that everybody said it could be at
the end of the season and here those two teams
are uh we showed them a title oh yeah they were
they know how they got out of Philadelphia unscathed
and uh are thankful for it you know
we're able to avoid it
um so anyway fun World Series gets underway here on Friday night um
before we wrap up guys we're gonna go we're gonna throw it
to an interview Justin did with
Mitch Rupert here in just a second
but um let me toss it to uh final thoughts here and then we will
end the podcast uh with Justin's conversation uh with Mitch uh
so let me get into some final
thoughts uh Liz let me start with you uh
my final thoughts for my final thoughts i'd like to talk
briefly about the Baltimore Orioles and what an absolute mess
and embarrassment of a team they are
uh they recently according to the Athletic fired
more than 24 uh two dozen uh members of their
business side um operations including the Oriole Bird
and Mr. Splash these were salaried positions
that were then later reposted as hourly positions
which is just disgusting um and if you'd like to
know a little bit more about that,
you can talk to David Rubenstein, the owner, who is flapping his
jaw in a way that I bet Major League Baseball would like him to stop.
Per Baltimore Baseball,
he said recently, a lot of my friends were buying teams
and I realized they're making money. They're
making more money than I'm making in private equity.
Now, private equity is supposed to be
one of the most lucrative businesses in the world.
You hear about private equity all the time because
they are throwing money around
but in the in the time of when most the MLB's um narrative is that
owning a team is not profitable he literally just said i got
into this because my friends who owned
teams were making more money than me
so i just think that in and of itself is interesting also
paired with the fact that the Orioles
do not like to spend
any money, and mark my words, they will
spend very little this season,
and the fact that they just fired a whole bunch
of people to turn their jobs into
hourly positions, presumably without
benefits. They're
gross. I'm sorry.
I will go to their game.
I hate hoping a team is bad,
but I hope the Orioles are bad, if only so I can
buy cheap tickets and watch
them lose, because I
cannot take any joy.
in in the Orioles right now they are just depressing
and i keep remembering they traded
Adley Rutschman this season Adley Rutschman
who is not bad but was like sort of like a really
important part of the team for fans fans really really liked him
and they just got rid of him
for nothing essentially so i will say this generally speaking
when your owner is that bad
the team also remains bad so you'll probably get
your wish yeah i'm hoping but yeah i had to bring
that up David Rubenstein making more money than
his friends in private equity as a
team owner i was just sitting around thinking
the other day how could i make more money than my
friends and that was the motivation behind
the very huge decision that impacted a lot of people's
lives that i made so liz the billionaires play their games
and we are just their fun little pawns
and you gotta just learn to love it all right just you know let
the owners have their fun they're the
good guys they just wanted to own a ball team you know
and now they're the bad guy i know get out of
town Rubinstein also said that he bought the Orioles
to be part of his philanthropic uh to give back
philanthropically to baltimore
which he's doing by putting two dozen people out of work great job
doesn't sound great all right well justin yeah
go ahead final thoughts i forgot to uh i forgot
to close up my horror movie comparison
if the brewers are like the thing from it follows i
would say the rays are like the virus from cabin fever
and that a little bit gets on you and it
just eats you alive uh and then for uh from that note i
also wanted to say that tomorrow uh you
mentioned my coverage on Baseball
Prospectus as part of the overall coverage of Baseball
Prospectus of the postseason.
Tomorrow I'm going to have my season
requiem on the Cleveland Guardians
who just lost in the ALCS.
And I'm doing it in the style
of a slasher
movie in which Stephen Vogt
is the killer and the victims are
all his bullpen arms.
Man, I'm excited
about this.
So that will be out on Wednesday for all
of you folks who are tracking
tracking this. That's fantastic.
Worth the price of my BP
subscription alone.
100%. Folks, that's going to do it for this edition
of Hit and Season. This is, of course, the
roundtable edition of the podcast, so
this podcast, if you're listening to it,
can also be heard on, seen
on the WHYY YouTube channel.
Subscribe to the
WHYY YouTube channel, and you'll get every
roundtable episode of the podcast this
off-season. And, of course, we will take you through
the off-season. We'll take you through the lockout. We'll take
you through the World Series
and anything else that comes down the pike silly things that Dave
Dombrowski does we will chronicle it all for you here this off season
so make sure you follow us
on Apple Podcasts Spotify wherever it is you get
your podcast um follow the show also on X at
Hit and Season uh and of course you can follow us all
on the socials on Blue Sky as well thanks
everybody for tuning in we'll talk
to you next time right here on Hit and Season