What's Behind Some on Right and Left Parsing the Israel Baby Murder Story, with Noah Rothman

Megyn Kelly
51 followers
Oct 15, 2023
There's been a disturbing debate online
about the photos of the dead babies
and about the claim that there are dead babies at all
in Israel who have been murdered by Hamas.
I mean, excuse me, this has gotten so bad
that Bibi Netanyahu felt the need to actually tweet out
some photos of the dead infants,
something that Israel historically never does.
They tend to be very respectful of their dead.
So for him to do it was an extraordinary move.
We've had the Jerusalem Post reporter,
we've had another reporter say directly
that they saw with their own eyes the murdered children,
including some decapitations, some 40 babies.
Now the reporter who originally reported it
after speaking with the IDF soldiers is taking flack
because they weren't all technically babies.
Some were two, some may have been three years old.
I don't know about you, but I referred to my children
as babies when they were that old as well.
Grab the baby.
It's insane that we've now gone
in some corners of the internet
and even mainstream discussion.
There was an LA Times reporter we talked about yesterday
on the show who have become obsessed with this
as though it's a lie
and therefore you can't believe anything about Israel.
By the way, it's not a lie, babies were murdered.
And even Tim Pool, who has been a guest on this show,
who is extremely popular on the right
and has an extremely popular YouTube show,
tweeted out yesterday, retweeted this guy
named Jackson Hinkle, who's got something
like 580,000 followers on Twitter.
And he's also a YouTuber.
He retweeted him suggesting that these are all AI generated.
These photos that Netanyahu and Ben Shapiro tweeted out
of dead, burned, mutilated babies,
that they're AI generated because they're pixelated
over the baby's faces where necessary.
It's incredible that somebody would be that irresponsible
and take that leap.
And actually, if you look at what Tim Pool retweeted
from this guy, Jackson Hinkle, it's as follows.
Holy shit, the image that Ben Shapiro tried to pass off
as a burned baby corpse was an AI generated fake image,
exclamation point.
They said they had a photo of 40 beheaded babies,
but the photo showed a single baby.
It was then revealed that the photo
was an AI generated image, but it didn't matter
because the lie about 40 beheaded babies
has already been heard by enough people
to justify a big war.
This guy, the same guy who Tim was retweeting,
Jackson Hinkle, had just tweeted out,
you're a pathetic Jew hater
if you don't believe the AI generated fake image,
says Ben Shapiro.
We don't have photo evidence of the 40 beheaded babies,
but we do have photo evidence of Israel targeting civilians
in their utter leveling of Gaza.
The US lied about Iraq, Syria, Libya, Kuwait, Ukraine,
and so on, but you believe they're telling the truth
about Israel?
Give me a brick.
This is what we're dealing with.
This is very close to mainstream.
Tim is, he's not entirely mainstream,
but he's extremely popular in the digital lane,
and he's retweeting this guy, and I'm not gonna lie,
it's deeply disturbing to me.
Now, today he updates it with, oh, huge thread.
The baby photo from Israel appears to be real.
It's crazy that this is the degree of warfare
we're dealing with.
I, I can't, I can't.
It's illustrative of a broader phenomenon
that Americans don't want to confront, but must.
I'm familiar with this guy, this Hinkle gentleman,
unfortunately, because I spend a fair amount of time
on the fringes of the internet for the job that I'm in.
And his professional lane is amplifying
and boosting the signal of anti-American regimes,
anti-American actors, people and institutions
that are dedicated to ending the peace and prosperity
that we have enjoyed for so long
that we hope to bequeath to our children.
And what happened in Gaza, and what happened in Israel,
in Southern Israel, is not all that distinct
from what happens on the battlefields of Ukraine.
The tactics that we've seen are very familiar.
Rape as a weapon of war, summary execution of civilians,
ethnic cleansing, en masse.
This is the images that we are seeing
of what the post-American world will look like.
Our enemies are not disunited.
They are not acting at cross purposes.
Moscow accepts high-level meetings with Hamas officials
because it supports their objective.
Moscow and Iran support each other's objectives
in their regions.
Iran supplies Moscow with weapons.
Moscow supplies Iran with diplomatic cover.
The objective is to embroil the United States
in conflicts that weaken it,
that hasten the post-American world.
China is supporting all these conflicts.
China provides Moscow with weapons components.
China supplies Iran with 25% of its weapons,
its major trading partner.
And it effectively negotiated a rapprochement this year
between Saudi Arabia and Iran.
Why?
In order to supplant American influence in the region.
China would be very well served by a conflict
that re-elevates, that makes central again
the Palestinian issue to the region's diplomacy.
It has been muted since the Abraham Accords.
If this war were to make it once again central
to how the Sunni regimes navigate their environments,
it would suit China rather just fine.
All of these conflicts are connected
and they are not observing all these careful distinctions
that Americans here like to say they observe
in order to justify the idea
that we can look at one over the other,
or we can compartmentalize them in some fashion.
Sunni and Shiite militias, Sunni and Shiite regimes
are not at each other's throats when the enemy is America.
China and Iran have decades of problems
going back to the 19th century with Russia.
All of that is subordinated to the need
to supplant the United States.
All of these regimes are engaged in one mission,
one goal, which is to hasten the onset of a world
that we do not want to see, a Hobbesian world,
a deadly, dangerous world,
and one in which the United States
retreats behind its borders.
We have to get sober and serious right now.
But we don't need to help them.
What's happening?
That's fine.
You expect the Russians to do something like this.
These are not Russians.
These are very popular online influencers
doing Russia's bidding, doing our adversary's bidding,
doing obviously Hamas's bidding.
Yeah, there's sort of an edgelord vibe there, right?
Where they're just so edgy and they're so provocative
and on the fringes and willing to say the things
that no other person is willing to say.
You know why no person's willing to say them?
Because it's crazy, because it's absolutely insane.
It makes you look like a ghoul and a lunatic.
But it's the sort of thing that it does attract
a particular psychology that perceives themselves
to be on the outside of polite society.
And once you perceive yourself to be that alienated,
that removed from the understood,
accepted humanity to which we all are supposed to subscribe,
it gives you a license to do a whole lot of things.
It's all fun and games when you're talking
into a camera for YouTube.
But the person on the other end of that camera
maybe takes you seriously.
Maybe doesn't think that this is all just fun and games
and we're just trying to be as provocative and fiery
and really test the bounds of polite society.
Maybe they do something about it.
Honestly, I look at this, I think-
That's the sort of thing that these people
do need to consider.
If you're watching what has gone on
over the past six days or five days
and you think Ben Shapiro is the villain, you're sick.
That's, you've got a serious problem.
You need to do some serious reassessing.
I wanted to ask you on the piece of paper
that I just crumpled up at the bottom was a tweet from AOC.
My team had to resend me the tweet
since I crumpled up my paper.
This is what she tweeted.
And I wanted to ask you about it
because I know you just dropped a piece
about her on National Review.
She writes, the level of misinformation,
speaking of this photos dispute,
the level of misinformation in all directions
at this moment is incredibly high,
especially on this platform.
If you see a claim photo or video
that triggers a strong emotional reaction,
take a moment to pause and check for veracity
or confirmation from multiple sources.
This is what she's basically saying,
the horrific photos you've seen of the dead Israelis,
be careful, may not be true.
Finding an honest doctor that is not following
the footsteps of big pharma can feel impossible.
That's why millions of men and women
have turned to one Texas doctor
and the seven reasons he said anyone over the age of 50
should be drinking this one thing.
It's not milk or another calcium rich drink.
It is a unique protein that naturally declines with age
and can significantly increase bone strength
and soothe joint pain.
He says it can minimize wrinkles and cellulite too, what?
Not to mention enhance hair follicle thickness
and even reverse nail damage.
What is it?
Users report results in as little as two weeks.
Now this guy's offering viewers up to 45% off his bone,
joint and ligament restoring formula
at nativepath.online.mk, nativepath.online.mk.
It has thousands of five-star reviews,
over 4 million jars of this stuff sold.
Every order comes with a 365-day money-back guarantee,
right, so try it for yourself.
And then you can get your money back
if you're not totally satisfied.
Megyn Kelly viewers and listeners
can visit nativepath.com, sorry, nativepath.online.mk
to get up to 45% off while supplies last.
Hey, thanks so much for watching.
If you like what you just saw,
hit the subscribe button for more clips and full episodes.
