What is Writing For? | Writers Week Part 1

The Agenda with Steve Paikin
4 followers
Jul 4, 2023
Why do writers write? What inspires new stories? George Elliott Clarke ("Where Beauty Survived"), Elizabeth Hay ("Snow Road Station"), Vincent Lam ("On the Ravine"), and Thea Lim ("An Ocean of Minutes") offer insights on what it means to write a story, whether it can be a political act, and if success can be a form of selling out.
If I think back to when I was 11 years old, I think of a young girl who didn't know how
to do her hair, dealing with acne, really bad glasses. All I would do was read in my room and
it gave me an opportunity to just kind of escape the world that I was in. So to be able to sit here
at this table speaking to all of you authors that I admire, it's like a dream come true.
And so I'm really looking forward to this week's conversation of A Writer's Life. Thank you so
much for taking time and spending it with us. So Elizabeth, I want to start with you.
As a writer, what's writing for? It's how I live my life. You know,
writing has given me a way to live my life. So writing and reading, which go hand in glove for
they root me and deepen my life and kind of steady me. And by writing, now I'm simply talking about
keeping myself company as I write in my notebooks. The idea of writing a book or a story,
that's something else. You're working on making something. But it makes me feel more alive.
Writing does and so does reading. Well, I want to ask all of you about that. Vincent,
you have another life as a physician. And now you write, you've been writing for a while.
What does writing give to your life that being a physician doesn't?
Well, similar to Liz, it's a way of inhabiting this thing, which is my life. And so I do write
fiction, which is rooted in medicine, as well as fiction, which isn't. But to your question,
fiction, which is rooted in medicine, allows me to tap into, I think, some of the currents,
which are flowing beneath the surface. And sometimes we're obliged to live life on the
surface. And yet those deeper currents are always there. And it's a way for me to access those.
And Taya, what about you?
I think that writing is often a way to make a problem into a place, a place that readers and
myself can enter into to try to think through the paces of that problem. Though I often joke
that what I wind up doing is outsourcing my problems, just giving them to the readers,
so I don't have to solve them myself.
That's very interesting. I want to come back to that. And George, what about you?
For me, it's a question of recovering history and histories, plural, that are extremely essential
for understanding the composition of society, the functioning of society, the aspiration,
unfinished, unaccomplished aspiration for justice. And those are my motivations.
And I want to follow this up with a quick poem to exercise the prerogative of a poet
to always have a poem. This is Vision of Justice. I see the moon hunted down, spooked from hills.
Roses hammer his coffin shut, oh, stilled by stuttered, slander, judicial gossip.
And a killer's brawling bullet, bludgeoned men, noosed by loose law, swing from pines.
Judges chalked commandants, gavel, dour commandments, their law books yawn like
lime-white open pits, lettered with bones, charred gibberish of those who dared to love or sing
and fell to mobs. Language has become volatile liquor, firewater that lovers pour for profits,
whom haul from ear, tongues of Pentecostal fire. Poetry, come among us.
Well done. That was brilliant. Can we do?
Actually, how I began writing was through poetry. I had always been a big reader,
but had no notion I could write. And then there was this surprising moment that happened in an
English class where we were asked to read a poem, it was by D.H. Lawrence, and then turn it over
and write down whatever came into our heads. And it was a revelation to me that I had something
to come out, something to write about, but it was based on a poem, you know? It was the poem that
generated the language. Vincent, you said something that I thought was so interesting.
You've described the beginning of writing a book as the abyss, which sounds very dire.
Why do you describe it as the abyss, or is it still the abyss for you? Because
who knows, maybe it's changed. Well, I would stand by that description of the
gaping chasm into which one has committed oneself. I think before the abyss comes that moment of
hope, of resonance, the sense that, oh, there's this thing in my life which I'm really obsessed
about. That's usually how it starts for me, and which I want to explore. And so from that comes
the commitment to jump into it. Because of course, if one knew everything about it, then there
wouldn't be any sense in exploring it. But it's precisely because one, or at least in my case,
because I'm obsessed, and yet at the same time know that there's a lot still for me to learn,
that I commit myself to it and leap into that unknown, that yawning chasm, which is, yes.
So it's part of the chase, I guess, the curiosity, you want to learn more about a thing.
Yes, absolutely, absolutely. And you know, I think, and to draw from George's poem,
that language is this volatile liquid. I think that is so true in so many ways. I mean,
it's true in our modern culture, where language can be polarizing and divisive and quite harmful.
And it's also true in the sense that a chemical can be volatile. And so language can evaporate
and change states and have different forms and help us to see things differently. And this is
part of the magic of writing and of reading. I know, George, you want to come in on this,
but I want to go to Téa first. I can feel your energy. I want to go to Téa first.
Téa, what's it like for you when you do get an idea and then you start,
is it like the abyss for you? Yes, yes, it's terrible.
It's so nice to talk to other writers and realize our problems are shared. Yeah, I mean, I think
that I generally think writers only have two modes. You either think it's a day where you're like,
I'm a genius, or it's a day where you're like, oh, dear, is it too late to go to law school?
You know, can I go back to being a doctor? But if it's terrible, then why do it?
I know, it's interesting, isn't it? I think even when I have an idea and it's not working,
or I'm trying to get something out there and nobody wants to publish it, I think what I always
come back to at the end of the day is a little voice inside of me that says, but I have something
to say, you know, and sometimes I wish the little voice would go away. But often, I don't know,
often writing is more excavation than it is creation. Often it's you're tapping into something
that is you, but larger than you. And it's about sort of sometimes putting aside your own emotional
needs and getting it on the page the way it needs to be, which sounds super... Putting aside your
emotional needs, that's super interesting. What do you mean by that? Well, I think a lot of the
time, I've had writing instructors who used to say, the most important thing is the story. It's
not what your sort of moral obligation is. It's not what you want to say. It's not your own politics.
It's what does the story need to become itself, really. And the story will tell you if you tune
into it. And often I do think that politics and your own moral needs wind up getting in there.
But the more you sort of let the story lead and do what the story needs to do to, I don't know,
wind up being the best vision, the best sort of version of your vision. I think that's a good
guiding star. Well, George, Téa said something that I think whenever... I don't know about all
of you, but it seems like we live in a world when you hear the word politics, you just kind of like,
what's option B? But sometimes, you know, when the way you move in the world is itself
a political act. You can't change, you know, if you're a woman, if you're black or if you're,
you know, if you're trans, the way you move in the world itself is a political act. So,
would you say that writing art is a political act? Absolutely. I like to tell my creative
writing students that every writer is an intellectual. You can't help but be an
intellectual because of the fact you're dealing with words, words which, of course, communicate
concepts, ideas, and so on. But do you think when you use the word intellectual, do you think that
sometimes when I hear that word, it means that the other person, if you're not an intellectual,
then you're less than? No, no, absolutely not. That is not what I'm implying at all. What I am
implying, what I'm going to say explicitly is that because the writer, every writer is an
intellectual, you end up putting forward ideas, philosophies, beliefs that some may agree with
and others may not agree with. And that is why writers are the most dangerous persons
in any government situation, any government system. We are always the most dangerous.
We are the first ones to be arrested, the first ones to be jailed, the first ones to be exiled,
the first ones to be chopped up. That's happened to Khashoggi. And there's a reason for that,
and that's because we deal with ideas, and ideas are dangerous. You change a lot of people's minds,
you change everything. That's the history of printing. That's the history of this technology.
I mean, when you put out a book, even if it's a work of fiction, I'm thinking of 1984,
I'm thinking of Lolita. These are very dangerous books, at least for some people,
for some governments, for some regimes. And many books are suppressed. Many writers are suppressed,
even in North America, even in democratic constitutional government order North America.
Writers can run into all kinds of problems simply by trying to express our particular
vision of the world. So whether we like it or not, we are political beings. As soon as we decide
to put out a version, a vision of the truth, as we see it, as we feel it, and to narrate that
vision of the truth. And unfortunately, it does mean that some folks can become very riled up.
Well, as you say, if everything is political, then why do we shy away from the political?
So I come at it a bit differently. Of course, a different writer, different take on it. And
sure, art is political because our relationships feed on the world and are shaped and informed by
the world. And George and I would write differently, you know. So in my work, I don't
bring things to a narrow political point, right? I'm trying to bring all the aspects
of somebody's life and lives, life itself, to play and then leave room, you know, for the reader
to spend time with these characters and come to their own conclusions.
If I may say, though, because you've written about your relationship with your parents.
Yes.
And so how do you balance, I guess, living in your truth while interrogating your role in
those relationships? Because I think we, if you've grown up in a family, it seems as if everybody has
a different version of what life was like.
And I mean, it's dangerous writing about your family. So I wrote about my parents,
but I waited until they were dead. And even then, it was very fraught territory.
Would you say, though, because, and this I say respectfully, obviously, but would you say that
some people might say that's taking the easy way out by waiting until they've passed? Or is that
done out of respect for them?
I think it's done, you know, I can only tackle these things when I'm ready to tackle them.
And, you know, throughout my life, I've written quite a bit about my mother,
much less about my father's anger, for instance. And writing that I did do about his anger,
I put away, because it would have been too painful. I think, you know, this whole question
of what we have the right to write about and who we have the right to write about is perennial and
a great problem for writers. It's something you have to figure out on your own.
You said it was dangerous to write about your parents. And I guess from,
for me anyways, the things that I've gotten as a reader is it's helped me understand. And
there's also, as I've gotten older, the way that I viewed my parents is very different now,
since I've become a parent. When I was younger, my parents, I owned them, they were mine. But then
as I've gotten older, they were their own people before they had me.
Yes. And so I was in my 60s before I wrote that book about my parents. And I'm glad I waited,
because I could see things from their point of view in a way that I couldn't before. So you
come at things when you're ready for them. And then you take the consequences.
Vincent, you've written about your grandfather. How did that help, maybe,
how did that help you understand yourself, maybe, and your family? What did that give you?
Sure. So my novel, which was inspired by my grandfather, and I really feel it's an
important distinction that it's not about him, in the sense that a biography would be about him,
a book called The Headmaster's Wager, was also very much a political book, because it was and
is a book which is to do with the Chinese community in Vietnam, during the time of the
conflict in Vietnam. And it has to do with the role of a minority community within a very fraught
political context. And so that cannot help but being political. And I think that one of the ways
that we can understand politics is by inhabiting characters who are experiencing politics. And I
think also that sometimes the political significance of long-form writing, and I think this is probably
true for both fiction and non-fiction, but I think especially for fiction, is that it speaks to the
form of discussion. And when I think about the current form of political discussion, it's
reductionistic, it's polarizing, it aims to be very certain in its outcome whether or not there is a
basis for those outcomes, because that has a great deal of political traction. And I think one of the
things that we're doing when we write is we're giving room for doubt, we're giving room for
ambiguity, and we're giving room for a variety of perspectives. And so that speaks to the form of
politics, and doing so is absolutely political.
Thea, when we talk about politics, I think we've all kind of, whether or not you want to see it, the past few years, as we've navigated
the pandemic, something that was a health issue became very political indeed. And your book
was set in a time when we are dealing with a flu pandemic. When this whole thing was happening,
what went through your mind, knowing that you had written a book about it?
I shouldn't have written a book about it.
It's your fault!
If only I could manifest things through my novels. I think what really struck me actually was how
there's so many pandemic stories and so many pandemic narratives that all precede our most
recent pandemic. And I think what really struck me was a slight bit of disappointment with myself,
because the actual pandemic was so much stranger and more textured and more wild, I think, than
anything that any of us could have imagined. So I did feel a little bit like who would have
thought there would be so much making of bread? Who would have thought that all it takes for
an entire society to collapse is for the stores to be closed for four days? And I thought, wow,
I was really trying to tap in and be imaginative, but in some ways, maybe nothing is as interesting
as real life.
So did it disappoint you?
I was disappointed in myself.
In yourself. Okay.
I shouldn't say that too much. I feel like I'm proud of my book. But more that
I think I made things very dramatic to make things difficult for my characters. And because of the
nature of our political situation, you don't usually actually have to inject drama in order
to reckon with the fact that the rules of our world really determine how people move through
the world and there's no way around them. You don't sort of have to invent pandemics. You don't
have to do what I did in my novel, which was to separate a country into two to close the borders
to make the credit card companies go down. Like real life on its own,
it takes very little to sort of push people over the edge.
I just kind of feel disappointed by it.
So you would rewrite it?
No, no. I mean, I wrote it. Like I said, I'm proud of it. I think it's part of,
it came out of a particular situation in my life. It came out of a particular
time. We make the best decisions we can with the information we have,
whether as artists or as people. But it's interesting to look at it through that lens.
One thing I'm surprised by is that readers don't mind.
But I'm like, aren't you going to talk about how unrealistic it is? And they're like, oh, no.
And maybe we don't have to try so hard sometimes.
Exactly, exactly. I think, yeah.
Just like we have to invent.
Yes. I think that's what I realized, that in some ways, our job as readers,
as writers, is to pay attention more than it is to invent catastrophe.
And that within real life, there's so much catastrophe if you pay even closer attention.
I thought I was paying attention, but it was a good lesson in paying even more.
This kind of reminds me, I spoke to an Indigenous writer a few years ago,
and their novel was on dystopian future. And then she said, for Indigenous communities,
we're already living in dystopia. And I never actually thought about that before.
Yeah. Well, I would just add to the discussion the simple fact that, as an American writer said,
and I forget her name, we live our lives and we write our philosophies. So everything that we
write, whether we like it or not, does, in fact, put forward a philosophical and therefore political
perspective. And again, that is what makes us dangerous. That's why Plato had to expel poets
from the Republic in Book Three, because of the fact that we gather ideas, we gather inspiration,
we make up stories. But also you find a way to connect to people, right? It's not important.
So long as they can read. So long as they can read. Absolutely. And then the power of that is
that their imaginations basically liberate the text, liberate the story. So that they take from
it what they need in order to create that particular universe, that particular world,
that particular society, that particular family, its rules, its problems, its challenges,
successes, and so on. And to take lessons from what is written that they may be able to apply
to their own situations, to their own lives. And that is the power of creating any kind of narrative
that we are putting forward an alternative vision of order, an alternative idea of how you could
organize a society, a family, and so on. And again, that is what makes our works so potentially
dangerous as well as liberating. Well, I want to change gears for a moment because I remember,
I don't know if we're Gen X, millennials, boomer, but in my era, if an artist dared to sell their
song to like, you know, a soda company, sell out, you know, and all of a sudden their music kind of
devalued in itself. But we live in an age where it's important to monetize art. And Téa, your
work has been optioned for television. When you're writing, do you think of a way how your work is
going to be introduced to other audiences and maybe how you can monetize it even more? Because
I know it's hard to be a writer in this economy. Do I think about how to monetize? I wish I did.
I should think about it more. No, I don't. I mean, I think when you're writing. Well,
maybe I will ask you a direct question. Is making a living at your craft selling out?
I don't think I know what you mean by that. I mean, I think everyone has to pay the bills. I
think the problem that we have in our culture is an unwillingness to recognize that artists are
workers too, who have bills to pay. I think if anybody can make a lot of money off of their work,
which I haven't personally, sadly for me, good for them, right? Yeah, I think that's a great thing.
What I think I find stranger about our particular cultural moment is that like you, I remember a
time when sort of, yeah, you would be a sellout if you sort of made money off of your work. Now,
people are in such a rush to sell out, like they're in such a rush to put their most intimate
moments, I think, on a platform so that they can make money off of it. And again, like I said,
I can't entirely judge that because life is hard, but I do wonder about the effect that it has on
our interior lives, on having a space that is our own, which I think people need to be human.
Anyone want to jump in on this? I think it's really very true that it's quite hard to make
a living as an artist of any kind in this country, maybe it's fair to say in North America. And I
think one of the really unfortunate consequences of that is that it privileges who gets to make
art. And so if we accept that as being true, that it's really hard to make a living,
then it means that someone typically needs another means of earning a living, which is
not necessarily a bad thing. I love doing medicine, but it's a great privilege that I have
to be able to do both, to be able to do medicine and to write. And I think that this reality
probably skews the voices whom we hear from. Because for me, whether my books sell or not,
is, believe me, matters a great deal in terms of my vanity. But it's not existential. Whereas for
some people to devote a huge amount of time to writing a book would be, the question of whether
it's sold or not would be existential. And that probably means that we don't hear from any of
those voices, which is a loss in our landscape. I agree. I think it winds up being a taboo in a
lot of artistic communities to talk about the reception of your work. It means you're a brazen
careerist, you don't care about the work itself. If you love the work, that would be enough. And
again, that's almost, it's oddly in service of capitalism, because it sort of hides the fact
that everyone is a worker, you know, that we all need to sort of make ends meet. It makes it
impossible to talk about what we're doing within the physical terms in which we're doing it. It
sort of de-worlds the act of what we're doing. Does it impact your creativity when you're
thinking about deadlines and money? Yeah, but I mean, I think that's true for any kind of worker.
All workers are on deadline. You know, you never say to an accountant, is it hard to, you know,
get all the balance sheets done? You know, when it's around tax time, we don't think about it that
way. I think everyone has to work within those terms. And for some reason, within the cultural
industries, there's a real need to hide the fact that we work within those terms. And it does wind
up, I think, leading to the things that Vincent is talking about, where if you can't sort of
pretend that you don't need the money, then, you know, you wind up not being able to be part of
the industry at all. It's always been a struggle, right? The story of creativity and trying to make
is just a long, long struggle, historically speaking. And
so I'm not divided when I say this, that I think a guaranteed annual income is what
society needs. And at the same time, the drive it takes to actually produce a book
is kind of phenomenal. And having a guaranteed income is not going to give you the drive.
So it's a mixture, isn't it, of realities here?
But do you feel that the drive to make an income gets the books out? I have heard
Celia Moreno-Garcia say that, actually, that she says, when I don't feel motivated,
I look at my bank balance. Well, you know, I remember, I often think of Mordecai Richler and
his six children. I mean, he had to work like a dog to support his family. And so he did all manner
of things, including the movie scripts and so on. So I'm just always incredibly impressed by anybody
who manages to be prolific, who manages to actually reach an audience, because I think it
takes huge creative imagination and endeavor to reach an audience. And then I'm also very aware
that if an author doesn't sell books, the publisher drops them. So it really is a market,
it's a business market that we're never allowed to forget, of course.
Thank you again. This is just scratching the surface of all the things that we're going to
be talking about this week. Tomorrow, we're going to be discussing how to read,
and we'll learn more about our authors. So hopefully you can all join us.
The Agenda in the Summer with Nam Kiwanuka is made possible through generous philanthropic
contributions from viewers like you. Thank you for supporting TVO's journalism.
