What Does a Trump Presidency Mean For Your Student Loans
1 Video View·Nov 25, 2024
"CFP® Professional and Certified Student Loan Professional Meagan McGuire is sharing what a Trump presidency means for your student loans as well as for your other debts, taxes, inflation, employer benefits, and more.
"
What does a Trump presidency mean for your student loans,
your other debt that you have in the mix, your investments, your taxes, inflation,
or your employer benefits? That's what I'm going to talk about here.
I'm Megan from Student Loan Planner, one of the senior student loan consultants.
So I'm going to give you my take, and we'll have a little student loan twist on it,
of course, because we're the Student Loan Planner YouTube channel.
Like and subscribe if you like this type of content, or if you'd like insights from
student loan experts. Let's jump in.
So what does a Trump presidency mean for student loans and debt?
Let's start with student loans first. So I think it's probably pretty obvious,
but there's not going to be any mass student loan forgiveness.
There was a lot of talks about mass student loan forgiveness during the Biden administration,
with the up to 10 or 20,000 of loan forgiveness that came out the bat in 2020 and 2021,
and that was struck down. It didn't go anywhere. It's not coming back.
I think the SAVE plan was meant to kind of be that loan forgiveness, the backup plan,
the sneaky backup plan for loan forgiveness there.
Not that sneaky.
We'll talk about that one next. But I don't think we're going to see any
mass student loan forgiveness opportunities under a Trump administration.
Next up, I think SAVE is going to get repealed. We've had multiple videos on this,
talking through why. Definitely go check those out if you had missed them.
But in summary, the SAVE plan was brought about not through a legislative process,
so it is easy to poke holes in it at this point.
And the third thing I was going to mention about what probably also is at risk during
a Trump presidency with student loans is the PAY and the ICR plans.
These were part of the same ICR statute that's being argued with them repealing the SAVE plan.
So it's possible that they could be looking at those two plans
a lot closer than they were originally because of this SAVE situation.
And I'd rather you didn't.
Worst case scenario, that could mean all of these plans are out the door.
Good case scenario is PAY and ICR stick around or they come back because technically they have
been sunset because the SAVE plan was replacing them. So best case scenario is they come back.
Worst case scenario is that they are dead and they're not going to come back.
And people who are on those plans outside of Parent PLUS people on the ICR plan
won't have access to them anymore.
With the repeal of the SAVE plan and possibly the PAY and the ICR plan going away,
that could mean higher payments next year for a lot of borrowers if they're having to switch to
the IBR plan. SAVE was going to be really inexpensive. It had a very generous poverty
line deduction and interest subsidy. And it was supposed to drop to 5% for undergraduate students
loans. But if the SAVE plan is repealed and we're having to revert back to IBR because maybe worst
case is coming to fruition where PAY and ICR are at risk, IBR could be a higher payment than what
folks were used to paying in general. Another thing with Trump in the presidency seat, we could
see more restrictions with the borrower defense to repayment. This program was protecting folks
that were defrauded by their universities or by schools that closed while they were in the
program or pursuing the program, weren't able to transfer credits to a different school. Lots of
issues regarding private schools. And that could be something that's more restricted in the future.
Trump could have a more school friendly vibe. Business, always business.
So that means folks will really have to argue their case for why they feel they were misled
or mistreated at their school experience to really advocate for themselves for that
borrower defense to repayment program. The future of Department of Ed is also uncertain.
They just announced Linda McMahon is going to be the head of Department of Ed.
There's only been talk so far about K-1 through 12 and what her plans are for that, but not much
mention on the student loans yet. But that is something to come as well that we'd want to watch
out for to see what's maybe in the pipeline. So that's what a Trump administration might look like
for student loans. Other debts could also have an impact. Interestingly, it could have a positive
impact as far as borrowing goes. Trump does have a problem with the federal reserve rate,
and he's wanting to lower that as much as possible. And if that's the case,
borrowing or going and refinancing a debt or purchasing a home, for example, could get
cheaper. The interest rates could go down. That's also going to increase demand. So we'll talk a
little bit about that later on as we work our way through different financial topics here.
So what does a Trump presidency mean for your investments? Let's think about how we're invested
and what our funds are made up of and dive into this. Market volatility. I think market volatility
is probably inevitable. It's always inevitable, right? The market is volatile regardless over
time. But Trump sometimes does have pretty unpredictable policies or political styles when
it comes to announcing things that he wants to do. You don't say. So this could lead to sudden
market swings driven by some of these announcements or fast shifts in policy change. Tax cuts is a big
part of Trump's agenda. So potential tax cuts may favor corporations, and that could lead to
potentially boosting earnings and that could in turn boost stock prices, which is good if we're
already invested. There could also be a focus on deregulation. I think that's going to be a
common theme as we talk through some of these other things. But deregulation might be reducing
government regulations that could benefit businesses, stimulating growth, particularly
in industries like energy, finance and health care. Trump is also very pro-business, of course, right?
Trump's agenda typically leans more towards stimulating growth and wanting to reduce
corporate taxes and wanting to make more business-friendly environments for the corporations
in America. Also, defense industries. Increased defense spending might benefit defense contractors
and companies that are involved in military production. But maybe something that could
negatively affect investments in a certain sector are trade tensions. Trump has a very America First
approach that could lead to trade wars, especially with China and impacting global supply chains and
international markets. So this could affect international investments. This could affect
inflation and a number of things that we'll talk about a little bit later. What does a Trump
presidency mean for my taxes? A Trump presidency could mean lower taxes for corporations and high
income individuals and maybe potential changes to tax rates in general or the standard deduction.
So number one, I felt like it was important to note that there could be massive corporate tax
cuts. Trump's administration previously pushed for corporate tax cuts and was successful.
Corporate tax rate is now down to 21 percent. That could get pushed even further or reduced
even further, I mean, which could lower business taxes and potentially offer higher after-tax
profits. But it's not just about the corporate taxes. Individual tax cuts may happen as well.
Higher income individuals may benefit from lower tax rates on income and capital gains. Capital
gains taxes are paid when somebody realizes a gain or a loss on something that's invested in the market
or something that's not within a tax preferred or deferred account. And there generally are more
favorable tax rates for these already. You're either going to be in the zero, the 15, or the 20 percent
tax rate for capital gains taxes. But there could be some maneuvering around those percentages to
make them even lower. That helps even our folks when we're investing and saving for the potential
tax implication that may come with student loan forgiveness. And just generally folks who are
saving additionally in those brokerage accounts to maximize their income potential in retirement
and have more assets on hand. Saving money. Now there may also be some changes to deductions and
credits. Potential reduction in certain tax deductions or credits as part of simplifying
the tax code has been part of the agenda of Trump. This is something that may actually impact middle
income earners versus maybe the corporate taxes and the higher income earner tax rates and capital
gains taxes. But going back to favoring maybe the rich, estate tax is something that's on the agenda.
There could be efforts to reduce or eliminate estate tax and that benefits wealthier individuals
when they have large estates and they're transferring money, allowing money to go from
generation to generation. There's been talks of changes to state and local tax deductions.
Changes to those deductions or caps on the state and local tax deductions could negatively impact
taxpayers in higher tax states. Now with taxes out of the way, what does a Trump presidency mean for
inflation? A Trump presidency could lead to higher inflation, believe it or not, driven by the tax
cuts that he wants, increasing spending, government spending, military spending, and potential trade
policies. So let's talk about the increased government spending. Higher spending for defense
and infrastructure can increase demand in the economy and potentially contribute towards longer
term inflationary pressures. But also tax cuts. The tax cuts that are wanted could stimulate consumer
spending and business investment, right? And boost, that also boosts demand. So when we're boosting
demand, we're also driving up prices potentially, which could cause some inflation in the future.
But I mentioned also the trade policies, the issues between possibly increasing the costs
for imported goods, wanting to keep manufacturing and production in house as much as possible.
This could really cause for higher inflation if the demand is not able to be met here in the
states. Regulatory rollbacks could also be something that causes inflation. Deregulation,
especially in sectors like energy, could reduce production costs and potentially
make for longer term inflationary pressures. Federal reserve relations. We know that there's
tension with the Federal Reserve over interest rates right now. And that can lead to inflation
if monetary policy is too accommodating or if rate hikes are delayed, for example. If they're cut and
then rate hikes later on to even things out are delayed. And then lastly, in regards to inflation,
labor market tightness could be a real thing because if we've got policies that are boosting
jobs, they're lowering the costs of taxes for corporations that this may lead to wage growth,
which is a positive thing. But that also increases the higher costs for businesses,
which could be passed on to customers. Now, lastly, what could a Trump presidency mean for
your employer benefits? A Trump presidency could really result in change to health care benefits,
tax treatment of employer sponsored plans and potential reductions in the workplace regulations.
So let's talk about health care benefits first. There's been a lot of effort to repeal the
Affordable Care Act or the ACA plans, and this could reduce employer obligations to provide
health care coverage, which is not a good thing for us consumers out there. This could really
alter your benefits or increase the costs overall. Now, tax treatment of benefits could alter how
employer provided plans like health insurance and retirement contributions are taxed.
This could either benefit us or it could reduce their value. So that's something to keep in mind.
There have been proposals for retirement plans to reduce or eliminate taxes on certain retirement
types of accounts and encourage employers to offer more robust retirement benefits to make
them more tax advantaged, such as ESOPs, employee stock ownership programs and equity compensation.
But then let's get into some negative with maybe workplace regulations.
Deregulation efforts could really reduce the requirements of employers to provide certain
benefits like paid leave or paid overtime, potentially affecting worker protections
overall. Deregulation means less protections for the worker. There could be wage growth,
though. Like I mentioned before, pro business policies might lead to job growth,
but tax and regulatory changes could also affect how employers allocate resources to employee
compensation and benefit packages. And I think I should say it again. Labor protections will be
reduced. A Trump presidency may reduce labor protections, impacting those benefits related
to unions, minimum wage and workplace safety and rounding it out with health care costs.
Reduced regulation on the health care industry might lead to lower health care premiums,
but could also lead to less comprehensive coverage options. If shorter term policies
are more popular or if it's lower cost, what kind of quality do we have?
Cheaper doesn't always mean better. What's the second cheapest?
So those are some general thoughts on what a Trump presidency could mean on our student loans,
on our debt, on inflation, on investments, taxes, employer benefits.
I don't know if this is good or bad.
If you're concerned about what finances could look like for you in 2025 or in the next four
years of this next presidency, make sure you got a plan together. It starts with your student loans.
You're here at the Student Loan Planner channel. Make sure to like and subscribe for more content
on this type of material and how student loans can be integrated with the rest of your finances.
This is more of a general financial conversation.
Our flavor is always going to be student loans. So if you need help, please seek out our website,
studentloanplanner.com. Check out our podcasts, get on our newsletter where we send out details
every Thursday about what's going on in the student loan world. That way you can get that
elephant taken care of, the elephant that's in the room, those student loans, so you can focus
on the rest of your finances and make smart decisions with your money. Thanks for hanging
out with me. I'll see you in the next one.

