We Blind Test Which is The Best Carbonara with Erwan Heussaff

Healthy recipes home making
138 followers
8 Video Views·Jan 8, 2023
We Blind Test Which is The Best Carbonara with Erwan Heussaff
Before we even start this video, this is my disclaimer.
We're only really making one carbonara
and the other two dishes are pasta dishes
that are inspired by carbonara.
But to be fair, we can only call one of them
a proper Italian carbonara.
The other ones are just creamy pastas.
I had to say it or else people are just gonna
start this whole thing again.
I'm about to do something that's gonna get me
a lot of hate, but sometimes that's what's necessary.
So today we're gonna be making one of my most
controversial dishes that we always
get in trouble for making.
It's carbonara.
But to put it truly to the test,
we will be making carbonara three ways.
The traditional Italian way, or as close to it as possible
as I can get, the American way, and the Filipino way.
And then we're gonna ask three different people
to come in here and blind taste all the dishes
and decide once and for all
which is truly the best carbonara recipe.
So let's start with the Italian one.
All we're gonna need is some guanciale.
We're actually gonna remove the tough skin part
and really just use that and cut that into chunks.
Some black pepper.
Some parmigiano, gran panado, or some pecorino
sometimes is acceptable.
Egg yolks, salt for your water,
and then obviously some spaghetti.
The spaghetti today we're gonna be using
is from Ideal Gourmet.
One of my favorite ones because it holds nice firmness
because it does have durum wheat semolina
as one of the main ingredients,
which does give it kind of like more of that toothiness.
It's available nationwide, so you can find this anywhere.
And finally some cream, no I'm kidding.
So we're gonna start with our guanciale.
Cut out the outer bark.
It does have some pepperiness.
And then just nice chunks.
So you see these layers of fat.
When you eat carbonara, it's never oily.
You never see kind of like a pool of oil,
and that's because Italians,
when they make this most of the time,
they cook it, they render down the oil,
and they just keep doing that until most of the oil is out,
and then the guanciale is nice and crispy.
So you start this in a dry pan.
And we're just gonna slowly render this out
and get it crispy at the same time.
Next, we're gonna finely grate our cheese.
I like using this, because it'll melt much faster.
So it'll give us a nice silky sauce that's homogenous.
Set that aside.
I recently saw this technique,
which I thought was really interesting from an Italian chef
that was doing a legit carbonara,
where he put his egg yolks here,
and he basically cooked them.
Why am I doing this?
Yes, he cooked them over his boiling hot water
to basically act as a bain-marie,
to slowly kind of cook the egg yolks
before shocking them with any heat from the guanciale
or from the pasta itself,
giving you a much smoother sauce
that doesn't look like scrambled eggs,
which makes a lot of sense,
because I've seen a lot of people
do authentic traditional carbonaras,
but end up getting the temperature wrong
and ending up with scrambled-looking egg carbonara,
which no one wants.
Two egg yolks, put that in our bowl.
Before you comment, egg yolks or whole eggs?
Well, different people, different techniques.
Whole eggs will give you a creamier, more watery texture,
while egg yolks really coat the pasta
and gives you a nice, tight sauce.
So if you see the sauce, I mean the sauce,
the egg yolks have pretty much thickened.
At this point, we're gonna add lots of Parmesan cheese.
And again, we're gonna wait for that heat
to soften everything.
At any point this happens to you, it's completely normal,
and that's why we actually didn't salt
this pasta water yet,
because we want that to basically help us
kind of melt the sauce.
So we're gonna add really a little bit only first.
Gonna remove as much of that oil as possible,
and then that goes back onto low heat
to render more fat if needed.
Now that we've already used that pasta water,
now we can actually salt it and cook our pasta.
It should take about 10 minutes to cook.
I prefer using spaghetti for this dish,
however, you can use all of Ideal Gourmet's other variants,
from fettuccine to linguine.
Now we can actually start on the American
and the Filipino versions.
One's gonna be bacon,
and the other one is going to be ham.
So for the bacon, we're just gonna chop that up,
and then we're gonna render that fat in the pan
with some water in a cold pan first.
For the Filipino, we have some sweetish ham.
Same, a little bit of water in the pan
to cook everything down.
So for the American version,
we are gonna be using some eggs as well.
Some Parmesan cheese, some cream, and some pepper.
And then for the Filipino version,
this is where things get interesting.
We're gonna be adding some onions, some garlic,
some canned button mushrooms, very, very critical,
some cream, and some cheddar cheese, and some pepper.
Garlic and onions for the Filipino one.
For our American version, we have our cream,
to which we're gonna add some egg yolks.
To that, we're gonna mix in some cheese.
Filipino mushrooms, American,
our cheese, egg, and cream mixture.
At this point, we're using residual heat.
The Filipino one is still cooking down.
For a few more minutes.
Black pepper on both.
So all of these are pretty much done.
Now for the Italian one,
all we have to do is take a cold pan.
We're not even gonna heat it up.
It's just to mix it all together
while we finish off these two pastas as well
by just adding the finishing ingredients
as well as the pasta itself.
Some cream for the Filipino one.
You could adjust with salt here for the Pinoy-style one,
even the American one, but for the Italian one,
ideally your pasta and your guanciale
and your cheese is salty enough
that you wouldn't need to add any salt.
You transfer your carbonara sauce to your pan.
Take a little bit of our hot pasta.
That goes in the pan as well.
In all three pans.
Now we just have to mix everything together.
Add back the guanciale to our Italian one.
♪♪
Our three pasta carbonaras are done.
We have the Italian, the Filipino, and the American,
not necessarily in that order,
and we're gonna have three people come in and taste it
and tell us whether or not they like it
and which they like the best.
So first off, we have Paolo.
Open your mouth.
That's number one.
Not yet, I'll tell you, I'll tell you.
Was he standing there with his mouth open the whole time?
Big, big, big.
Yeah, sorry.
Okay, which do you prefer?
One, two, or three?
The three.
The third one?
Yeah, weird.
I don't know.
It's not that sweet.
I don't know, that's how I taste it.
Did it feel less creamy, more creamy,
more salty, less salty?
Less creamy, but the one and two are okay,
but for me, the three.
Three?
Yeah.
The Italian one, so you like the traditional one?
Yeah.
Nice.
Thank you, Paolo.
Thank you.
Okay, jump.
No, I'm kidding.
That was surprising, to say the least.
I did not expect that.
Next taste tester, Cleo.
Don't be afraid, don't be afraid.
Oh, there's a hole there.
Nope, I'm kidding.
Number one.
A bit too creamy for me.
Okay.
Yeah, and I can taste the cheese.
Number two.
I tasted the meat here, and the cheese tastes more saltier.
Okay, got away from me.
There.
I feel like the other two ones, extreme sila.
Okay.
Like, the saltier one is the second one.
Very fair.
The first one is the creamiest, like the cheesiest.
Not, I think, too cheesy for me.
The third one is just right.
Okay.
So, take a wild guess, which is Filipino, which is American, which is Italian.
First one is Filipino, for sure.
Correct.
Uh, yeah.
Second one?
Yeah.
Second one is the Italian.
And third one is the American.
Third one is the American.
So you prefer the American?
The version of carbonara, yeah.
Okay, so in terms of preferences, the American one you prefer, that flavor profile.
Yeah.
Why would you go for number three over number two?
Uh, I think the meat, I mean, the bite I got was a bit too salty.
So the guanchao is very salty.
That's true.
The guanchao is quite salty.
Okay, fair enough.
Thank you.
You may depart.
I can't see.
Yeah, there you go.
Our third, our third taste tester is here.
We're gonna bring in Kashka.
Okay.
Number one?
It has like a weird aftertaste.
Interesting.
I feel like it's the cheese.
It's okay.
But it's kind of weird.
Number two?
Mmm.
This is better.
Really?
Yeah.
That's not super shocking, but...
I feel like the oil is different, no ba?
Mmm.
I like it better because it's a bit oily.
That's so baboy.
I feel like that's a...
Oh my gosh.
It tastes like bacon.
Okay.
It's a bit salty.
Moment of truth.
Decision time.
Which was your favorite?
The second one, for sure.
Really?
Yeah.
Okay.
The second one.
I don't know why.
And which was your least favorite?
The first one.
Like I love cheese, but then the first one was a bit weird.
Like the cheese wasn't that good, I think.
Wow.
That was the most expensive cheese.
Really?
Yeah.
I didn't like it.
Okay, so if you were to take a wild guess, which was which?
I think the second one was the Italian one.
Was it?
No.
No?
It was the Filipino one.
Really?
Shit.
I have no taste at all.
Yeah.
Okay.
The second was Filipino.
The third one was definitely the American one.
Correct.
And then the...
I guess the...
Oh my gosh.
The Italian one.
The first one was the Italian one.
I didn't like it.
Don't hate me.
You can walk away.
Oh, this way.
So, taste tester number one preferred the Italian one.
Taste tester number two preferred the American one.
Taste tester number three preferred the Filipino one.
If I taste them, they're very, very, very, very distinct in terms of flavor.
They're all good in their own categories.
The Filipino one, primary flavor for me is the sweetness of the ham and the quick melt
cheese, which really defines that flavor.
And so if you like that, you're going to gravitate towards that.
The American one is like what Kashka said, very baboy.
Feels like the creamiest one.
It feels like it has the most oil because of the bacon that was rendered.
And because it has the liaison, which is the cream egg yolk cheese mix and then cooked,
it does feel really creamy and really fatty.
So for people who look for heavy carbonara, this is probably your best bet.
And then finally, the Italian one.
I mean, and I don't want people getting mad in the comments saying I didn't cook it properly
because it tastes like the carbonara's I've had in Europe or in Italian restaurants.
And it's very clean tasting.
The parmesan really comes through, the guanciale really comes through.
And the pasta here is really kind of like not overwhelmed by any of the other sauces.
So I think here you taste more of the pasta and the parmesan and the guanciale.
But I think when you compare it to all of this, these feel more decadent and that's
why maybe someone would prefer one over the other.
So what is the conclusion?
I have none for you.
People at the end of the day will eat what they want to eat and what they like to eat
and this just proved it.
To be fair, this is the only one we can officially call carbonara.
These two we can only call like pastas that are inspired by carbonara.
So it just shows you why people change things in the kitchen to fit their taste buds.
I'll see you guys in the next video.
