VERITY! The latest int he Colleen Hoover cinematic universe and I have spent entirely too much of my brain power on it. We've covered the movie, the book AND the bonus chapter.
My Mike Flanagan and Summer H Howell interview: • Mike Flanagan and Summer H. Howell on Rein...
Verity review reacting to verity comparing verity book to movie booktok booktok movie colleen hoover anne hathaway dakota johnson josh hartnett worst movies 2026 #movie#review
AI Generated·May contain errors
Verity, the latest movie
in the Colleen Hoover cinematic universe, and the first one that
really feels like it knows what it should
or what it is and what it could be, and I
feel like that's largely thanks to director Michael Showalter.
To clarify, this isn't necessarily what I
would call to be a good movie, but it's
certainly an entertaining movie,
which means it's meeting all of the rules I have for
erotic thrillers in this type of genre.
You need to commit to the spectacle you
are trying to bring to the table.
It's like those after movies,
when those started getting boring and the books in the
In the middle, they started getting boring
because I think they thought.
Thought they could try to maybe make them good?
That's not what you're here for and that's not what you achieved.
Honestly, Verity could have gotten even more absurd,
but I still had a fantastic time.
I went with a friend and we had a, we were giggling, defying, reacting.
It was a fantastic time.
But on that same note, it ends up being
a mess in a way that feels frustrating by the
end of the reading experience
and the viewing experience as you try to piece any of it together.
And unfortunately, it just feels like an idea
that was brought to life by someone not quite
proficient enough in the suspense
and thriller genre compared to some of the other stuff
They're putting in the book so that it doesn't.
It doesn't always feel fully satisfying
while trying to keep readers on their toes and always
guessing.
The movie does streamline a lot of it to maybe try
to pull out some of that confusion but
largely suffers the same issues by the time you get
to the end and I feel like some of
the stuff they pulled out of it actually takes away
from the intensity and the emotional
impact of some of what the story actually
puts forward because it gets crazy.
It gets batshit because Verity really
is trying to be a mindfuck thriller.
The name even means truth.
So it's clearly something that we're supposed
to be looking for in the story.
What's real and what isn't?
Who is the real Verity?
What is the real truth?
So I'll be going through the movie, the book, and the bonus chapter,
which just makes the whole thing messier than it already was.
But the basic premise of the story
is that author Lowen Ashley is hired to finish a popular
book series by Verity Crawford, yes, again,
that is actually her name, and it's not
implied that it is a pen name,
after she suffered a car accident, leaving her unable to finish
it herself.
While staying at the Crawford house
to put together any of the notes that Verity might
have started for those books,
Lowen comes across a hidden manuscript that may reveal
some heinous truths, while her connection
to Verity's husband, Jeremy, also starts
to push outside the boundaries of what is professional.
Fun, maybe not good.
Good, and sometimes I will have
to read things I don't want to read, but fun!
Which, again, is so much more than I can say about
the last two Colleen Hoover movies.
Yes, this one will feature a lot more sexual moments than
the last couple, nowhere near
Uh, to the degree that the book dishes out.
Colleen kind of mentioned at one point that her mom read this one,
but there are entirely too many moments describing
his length entering a mouth for that.
But alas, it happens.
Outside the plot and what's happening,
I think everyone's giving the performance required here.
I love all these people in good movies,
and I love them in overly dramatic bad movies too.
Dakota's simultaneously pulling off dramatic overreactions,
while also getting that monotonous delivery that she's known for,
and it's perfect for this character who is self-described.
I'm just having a resting bored face.
That's just my face.
I have resting bored face.
And you're being outperformed by a dead corpse, mama!
Because of one of the framing devices in the story,
we do actually still get a lot from Anne
Hathaway in her past before the accident and her voice narration.
And Josh Hartnett manages to juggle
the wholesome troubled dad-turned-sex
object well enough while leaving you wondering
if something else might be going on underneath.
And the kid is creepy. He's adorable, but I don't trust him.
Honestly, as long as you know what you're
watching and you're looking for some fun
fun twists and thrills and some ambiguous storytelling, I think it's a
It's a decently fun ride.
And while this movie might not be the most filling,
you can get on a better path to nourishment
with today's sponsor, Nourish,
a nutrition counseling platform
with over 9,000 registered dieticians
who specialize across a variety of conditions
and health goals.
I have mentioned it so many times,
but I can really let my focus on food and nutrition
go out the window.
I always thought it was because I just felt too busy,
was traveling too much, or just too drained from work
to want to take the time to cook,
and it honestly really stresses me out
to have to think about.
Every time I cook something, I'm like,
I'm like, I have to do this two more times today.
So while I initially signed up to get some quick
and basic meals that would hit my micro
and macro nutrient needs to stop ordering in so much,
my registered dietitian Lindsey
pointed out that my general lack
of energy around all household tasks outside my work
probably had more to do with the way I was eating during the day.
She pointed out that my daily schedule
of waking up to water and coffee until I ate
some kind of protein in the early afternoon
and concentrating most of my eating on dinner
was not optimal.
So she gave me some different tips on foods
that would be easy to have ready in the morning
Like overnight oats, which are perfect.
Perfect if I'm planning on having a morning workout
because it gets me the fiber, the carbs, the protein
when I add it, which I do,
which instantly made a huge difference on my energy levels
and my snacking habits later at night.
Then she got me set up with more dinner options
for convenient meals or things that won't go bad
when I'm traveling or that can be prepped and frozen.
Sign up takes under five minutes.
94% of nourish patients pay $0 out of pocket.
There's no surprise billing
and you get one-on-one support via Zoom.
I had recently had blood work done
that I was able to provide,
but they have basic panels available
for $19 so they can really get into your specific needs.
So if you've gotten yourself stuck in a rut
of ordering in or struggling with what to
make to keep yourself healthy,
check out my link in the description below and try out
Nourish for yourself.
So let's dive in, which means spoilers for the book and the movie,
full warning, full spoilers.
Unlike the book that literally starts
with a head being smacked into pavement,
then popped like a watermelon under a tire,
they try to ease us into this movie a little bit.
It starts with this comically short interview
with Verity where she says her career is a miracle
and the interviewer says it's a miracle built on villains,
before just cutting to a year later with Lowen,
our protagonist, at a failed book reading.
If they wanted to start on Verity,
I think there was a better way for it to feel more effective
Because I actually forgot.
That's how this started until I checked my notes.
It does kind of come around in the end
so I get why they made the choice,
but it's too abrupt to feel really effective.
In terms of the failed book reading start for Lowen though,
this makes a little more sense.
In the novel she doesn't do any kind of public author stuff
because she's so awkward and it comes across as standoffish,
but for the movie it's a very fast way
to let us know that while published,
she's not the most successful.
So when her book agent calls to say
that a big publisher wants to meet with her
quickly and privately, an agent she previously had a relationship with
then continued to hook up with after he
He realized that he just liked the protagonist in her book
and she wasn't like that.
She might have no choice
but to take whatever offer is on the other end.
But it's on the way to that meeting
that she witnesses the car accident.
She still ends up completely splattered in blood,
which had literally been the only
Still, I'd seen of the movie at all going
into it in this it's a guy hitting a windshield
so they don't do the whole head popping under
a tire bit and yeah that's fair.
Cowards.
It's already rated R. You might as well just commit.
And it's then that a handsome man checks to see if she's okay,
ushers her to a bathroom to clean up,
and she's a bit shell-shocked and she's panicked
because she's going to be late for this meeting
and she's tantalized in her shell-shocked state
because he takes his shirt off for her.
A lot's revealed in this bathroom and I don't just mean her bra.
He explains that the reason why he's not fazed by what he just saw
is because he had to pull his daughter's body out
of the lake not that long ago,
and Lowen's way to try to defuse the awkwardness
that she feels for asking about what the worst
thing he would have experienced than this was is by saying
that her mom died in her apartment last
week. Trauma bonding! I'm sorry,
but I do get that taking care of a parent that's dying is stressful
and horrible as hell, but I do think he wins on the tragedy front.
At this point, we know she's
headed to a meeting and he says that he's headed to a meeting,
so I am pretty sure that they are
They are headed to the same meeting because Colleen would love
love and does seem to love demented meet-cutes.
And yes, when she makes it up to that meeting,
Jeremy's across the table knowing exactly who she was
when she said her name in the bathroom,
because how many Lowens could there be?
He probably could have given her a bit of a heads up
and said that, hey, I'll call the people
and it's okay if we're late,
because we're the only two people
who super matter in this meeting.
But yes, we do have a completely normal name
in a Colleen Hoover story main character, Jeremy.
Needed at least one grounded thing in here,
because again, his wife's name is Verity.
And the offer placed in front of her
is to finish three books.
in the Noble Virtues series as a ghostwriter for Verity Crawford.
75k per book, the first one needing to be delivered within six months.
Based on Verity's star power, I feel like
this would be the equivalent of someone being like,
you gotta finish some Agatha Christie books, you've got to finish some,
honestly, in today's day and age, Colleen Hoover books.
So instead of an instant yes to what would
be a life-changing amount of money,
or at least something that would give
her enough time to work on her own,
Publishing.
She doesn't think she can do it
because of how dedicated Verity's fan base is,
that they'd know it wasn't her.
They'd just never accept the writing.
But Jeremy sought her out specifically
because Verity apparently loved one of her books
and he wanted to make sure that whoever took over this series
was someone that his wife would have respected.
Hard to say no to that.
And he also says that they are lowballing her
and that she could be asking
for more than double what they're offering.
A half a million.
Which even with the taxes and a 15% agent fee going to Corey,
it is difficult to turn down for someone who is currently getting evicted
Yeah, I guess her mom lied about having money that would be hers
when she died, convinced
Lowen to move into an apartment she couldn't afford
so she'd have more space so she could
die in dignity and then like, *******
Just left her debt instead.
So she agrees to do it and starts doing her research.
We get little tidbits about Verity's life,
like how Jeremy could only ever read the first book
because they started to freak him out.
That that first book is dedicated to him
as the one who taught her everything.
Is that foreshadowing?
Is it implying that he is actually the villain
because she writes her books from the villain's perspective?
Who knows?
That dedication is not included in the book,
but it seems like the movie maybe wants us to consider
that Jeremy might not be the best person.
And all too soon, she is on her way to Vermont,
To stay in their house and go through Verity's notes
to piece together what might have been the plan
for the last three books, courage, honor, and truth.
Really save those big virtues for last.
I thought they were maybe going in reverse order,
but I'm pretty sure like the sixth virtue is the fourth book
and not the third book, like it's supposed to be,
but that's okay.
Because if they were going out of order like that,
I kind of thought the truth might've been last
because of what Verity means,
but I guess it is the second to last,
which is where it would fall if they were going in order,
but...
I- it doesn't matter that's just- that's just me.
It also seems like truth was already done in the movie.
Which of those themes was the most fun to corrupt?
Truth.
I should also point out that she has never read
a Verity Crawford book. She's like literally
listening to the audiobook on her way to start doing this as a job.
When she gets to the house
she meets Crew in the book he's like kind of weird
and slams the door in her face and here he's just
Kind of sad and scared looking for obvious reasons
and this is the remaining child.
I wasn't anticipating being here
when you hear a story about a daughter being pulled out of a lake.
And they actually remove one of the kids in the movie
and make Crew and Harper fraternal twins
instead of there being two girls originally
that both die in separate incidents.
An allergic reaction for the first one
and then the drowning incident that we already know about
a few months before Verity had her accident.
A drowning incident that happened in their own backyard.
Verity apparently described them as chronics,
people prone to chronic tragedy.
The house is devastatingly gorgeous in a way that feels overwhelming.
The bed she's staying in has teeth marks on the headboard
because it's an erotic thriller,
of course, and I guess she is staying in what
was the master bedroom, but they had to move
up to the main floor for Verity because her injuries are very severe.
She's not paralyzed, but she doesn't move or talk.
Anything she does is apparently involuntary
or a muscle memory like eating when you put
food to her mouth.
So it's really not a co-writing situation like they implied.
It is just completely ghostwriting these books.
But the book does kind of present
Dakota presented as a co-writing situation
for her to the point that Lowen uses a pen
name to separate herself from it all.
The movie just makes it feel like they're
trying to completely keep it separate and
present it to the world as if Verity is the author.
I will say that Dakota has zero poker face
when they actually bring her to see Verity
and she realizes how bad it is.
She's just like full dramatic, aghast,
and doesn't try to recover from it at all for
way too long.
And seeing her is enough to make her want to leave,
but Jeremy again convinces her to
to stay by pointing out that Verity admired her work
so she is the best for the job.
job and the only one that Jeremy trusts with it.
So she stays and starts going through Verity's
office and quickly finds a thumb drive hidden
in a pack of cigarettes that has a manuscript hidden
in it. Not for a future book, but for an autobiography.
In the book, she finds it printed
out in a box of other notes.
Lowen still ends up printing it off here herself to read, but I do
find the method of discovery interesting
because a flash drive next to a desk seems hidden in a way
that you might want it to be found versus
it just getting tossed in a box by mistake.
So yes, even in the book we have a non-verbal character,
we are still getting these split character
perspective experience as Lowen reads that autobiography.
Are there any Colleen Hoover books
that don't go back and forth in some way
in time or perspective or both?
This at least ends up being interesting
in a lot of ways though.
It starts with Lowen just learning entirely too much
about Verity and Jeremy's sex life
when she's already feeling an attraction to him,
which she will go on to question
how much of that is influenced
by reading the salacious writing
of someone obsessed with him.
Because yes, Verity is obsessed with Jeremy
How their relationship started
at a party where she was looking for someone rich,
finding Jeremy and realizing that he was perfectly normal financially,
and that was still fine.
She was obsessed.
Leaving off with the fact that the story
is about to get much darker once Jeremy finds
something to love more than her.
The first reading session of this manuscript
is disrupted by horrible noises coming from
upstairs.
She goes to check it out, worried
that Jeremy's committing atrocities to his catatonic wife,
but it is just the medical bed moving her around.
So he's not that kind of monster, at least if he ends up being one.
Back to the manuscript, though,
it's kind of implying that Verity is the real monster.
Starting with her little deceptions,
like how she ended her lease without telling him,
So when he asks her to do that a couple months later,
and move in, he feels thrown off that she'd already done it
and they'd already been living together.
So she has to sexy her way out of it in the sense
of being the knight she bites the headboard.
The editing choices in this movie to have, like,
the text going across the screen in real time
about what, like, you know, Lowen's there,
she's reading about her riding his tongue.
Art. Horrific salacious art but knows exactly what it's doing.
Just for reference, Michael Showalter also directed The Idea of You,
which is another movie I have a big soft spot for.
At this point though, everything's perfect
in Verity's world until Jeremy has to go away
for work and that's when she started writing
to keep her distracted, turning Jeremy into
a character in her novels
so he wouldn't just come back to this sad, desperate, pathetic
But that ended up being another element
that had me wondering if he would end up being a bad person
because her books are all written from the perspective
of the villain and she said that she wrote
Jeremy into a character in her book.
Maybe not though, because he comes home,
reads the manuscript, adores it,
and asks her to marry him in that moment because of her brilliance.
He did have the ring already,
so it wasn't completely impulsive, but that night is also
the night they conceived, the night that ruined everything for her.
Yes, the thing that Jeremy
would love more than Verity is their children.
Man, I get that Loa needs to take breaks from
this for sleep, to actually work on the layout
for the future books, and because she feels like
It feels like she's invading some kind of privacy
with people she's supposed to be like.
Like, working around, but man,
I would not be able to put that ---- down.
Especially after it seems like Verity might be moving
and looking at her from outside,
played off as what might be just an involuntary movement,
but made to feel all the more unsettling
because Lowen's been reading her inner thoughts for a couple days.
Because if I'm reading about how dark she keeps claiming to be,
how bad things are going to get in this story,
knowing that this is a prolific thriller suspense crime author
that specifically writes from the perspectives of villains,
I might be-
Because weird things will keep happening,
like the kids seemingly acknowledging Verity
in the window.
Lowen thinks she sees her standing there,
but when she goes up to check, she thinks
it must have just been the fan moving the blinds.
Because how could she possibly be faking this?
Who could possibly stay still for that long?
The book even takes it a step further to point out
that Lowen wakes up one night because
she hears what sounds like walking and the cracking
and creaking on steps that wouldn't
match Jeremy or crew, then just chalks it up to old house noises.
I don't know.
around and even though she's getting nervous she
of course goes back to that autobiography
justifying it as research for getting
into the headspace of the person she's supposed to be
Mimicking. And it goes
on to detail how much Verity hated being pregnant,
hated how much Jeremy already loved the baby,
that ended up being twins,
girls to steal him away. And this is definitely
a thing that happens in real life to varying degrees,
misplaced jealousy in one of the parents,
that attention is going to be shifted in a different
direction. It's really sad and horrifying when it happens,
but for Verity, it's very serious
because she tries to take care of the situation
on her own by accidentally falling downstairs,
Drinking, taking sleeping pills before the most horrific.
At five months, trying to do it with a coat hanger.
Left out of the movie entirely for reasons I fully understand
and wasn't successful in the book either.
And Jeremy isn't catching any of this hostility in her.
Assumes that she must also love the babies more than she loves him
and might feel guilty about that.
But the reason she's upset is that she's
horrified that he feels that way.
That he feels like the love towards them is unconditional
and his love to her is conditional.
At this point, Lowen's just trying
to figure out how real any of this is.
do any of her online interviews.
Allude to resenting children.
Is this just some kind of like elaborate writing exercise?
Are these just horrible feelings she had until the kids were born
and then she really came back around?
Because in the book, they go on to have Crew as a separate child.
So Lowen wants to believe that Verity
must have come around on loving the twins
because why would she have a third child if she hated them so much?
But the more she reads, the worse it gets
because right out the gate, the babies disgust her.
Chasten has a scar on her cheek from her failed abortion attempt,
Ultimately leading into abuse by neglect.
Once Jeremy goes back to work,
Verity would just leave them in their cribs screaming and
crying all day while she slept more
and then did things until Jeremy got home so then they
were all like tired and ready for bed
because they spent all day screaming.
The only thing she was concerned with was making sure
that Jeremy still found her desirable
and having time to write at night
because she could go back to sleep during the day.
Yeah, pretty horrific stuff here,
even if it did end up being some like messed up writing
exercise to get yourself in a headspace for your work.
It's really hard to imagine writing
this about your kids who are now both dead or in the movie half dead.
Now one of the things that gets left out
in the movie is that Lowen sleepwalks,
something that she has a lot of trauma about
because of how her mom handled it.
She was essentially terrified of her once
the sleepwalking started getting worse,
But then omitting it...
from the movie means we don't get incredible moments like
the one where Lowen ends up in
Verity's bed.
Horrifying in so many ways,
especially if it does end up that Verity is faking things.
Like she just had to like lay there
while this like person crawled into bed with her.
But Jeremy hears the commotion, she ends up
explaining what happened, and he stays with
her until she calms down when she explains how scared she gets
by the sleepwalking because of
things that happened to her as a kid.
Literally managed to break her wrist in the middle of the
night and then didn't do anything until she woke up
the next morning and started screaming in pain.
So him staying in the room to comfort her means there's
at least a little bit more of like an
intimacy buildup in the book.
It still feels like it's moving too fast. On Loewen's side,
I at least kind of understand that she's reading
these deeply intimate thoughts about him that
that makes her feel closer to him.
But with Jared,
Jeremy, it's really just got to be like,
oh yeah, there's just like young attractive
presence in my house.
But the solution to stop Loewen
from feeling like she needs to leave immediately to keep
everybody safe and stop more awkward situations
is to put a lock on the outside of her door.
So hopefully Jeremy isn't actually a secret sociopath
and that's why he's listed as
one of Verity's...
You know, the one that taught her everything
for writing her villain series.
I would have liked to have seen that implemented in the movie,
but I guess maybe it would just kind
of add another layer to this feeling
a bit too much like The Housemaid, even though they are
quite different. And just to keep with the book
for a little bit longer, we gotta go over what
happened to Chasten, the daughter that died before Harper.
In the manuscript, Verity details a
nightmare she had of Harper smothering Chasten with a pillow
when they were about eight or nine
years old. At this point, they're like three.
And while she's wanted nothing more at this point than
than for these kids to be...
Completely gone, she suddenly feels this parental connection,
but only to Chasten.
Experiences actual grief from this nightmare
when she thinks she might be dead,
which just pushes all that anger and resentment onto Harper,
truly believing that she'd go on to kill Chasten
in the future, take her baby away from her,
even though they are both her babies.
So she decides she needs to suffocate Harper right now with her hands.
The movie at least toned it down
to her planning to do it with a pillow.
Here she's just shoving in one finger after another,
only stopping in both because Jeremy walks in.
Yeah, I see why you couldn't put that in the movie. Holy ----, Colleen.
Is this her writing exercise to imagine
the worst thing someone would do?
In the movie, without Chasten around,
we just have Harper naturally be the one that Verity
is less good at pretending with. She ends up being on the spectrum,
so it just comes across as her not having enough patience to deal with
with it in the way that Jeremy can.
Something that he specifically noticed
and confirmed to Loewen that Verity
just didn't understand Harper the way he did.
The book actually takes it a step further
with him actively getting upset with Verity
for not treating them the same
and only ever talking about Chasten
and her triumphs and her victories.
She manages to sidestep a lot of the anger
by saying that she's just approaching their needs differently.
She has to be different moms for both of them
because they have different personalities.
And of course she cared about Harper.
She even has an appointment set up for testing
recommendation of one of the daycare teachers.
Of course, it isn't set up yet, but she's gonna
get on it tomorrow. Then lying about being pregnant again
to really drive home the distraction and
keep Jeremy happy, thinking about how easy it would
be to fake a miscarriage. And as obsessed
as Verity clearly was with Jeremy,
he comments to Loewen that the only thing he ever felt was
truly solid in their relationship was the desire and the sex aspect,
that there was just some other
piece that never came together.
It's the only way he only ever felt like he truly knew her in
that way but then having kids is a great distraction from that.
I really assumed she would have had crew
to convince Jeremy to stay home more
because he was still really trying
to keep up with this very busy real estate
business and once her career took off it
wouldn't make sense for her to be the
primary caretaker. But Loewen's inner monologue just kind
of skips past all the crew stuff after
she said she was just going to fake an
abortion. She clearly gets a real pregnancy
in there somewhere. Loewen just
starts complaining about how repetitive
the manuscript starts to feel after his
his birth while it may have been the tantalizing details in the
manuscript that got her extra attracted to Jeremy initially,
it's now flipped to annoyance
because of the many times and ways Verity describes sucking his dick.
I guess you can only read that so many times.
I agree because I haven't even had to read all of them
and I'm already annoyed, but it
is starting to upset Loewen to imagine him
with someone else, even if she's not with
him, though I'm sure that is the direction it is moving in.
Because even Jeremy touching her face
on her driver's license turns her on.
Girl, get it together.
Back to the movie, though, this is where I got
a bit of a crazy theory that doesn't
really work in the book, but for the movie, it can.
And I think by the end, it still technically
can, even though probably not.
After Loewen asks what Harper was like and if she and Crew were
close, Jeremy comments that they were,
but that he never asks about her or mentions her. Obviously,
that can just be a child trauma response to try
and mentally handle such a massive loss,
especially in the book where it was like two siblings dying.
But it actually made me wonder
if he was the one who killed Harper
and his manuscript was just trying to create a cover
for him even though the police deemed it an accident?
Like I could see a mother doing that.
We will see though it is probably just a kid
who needs a lot more therapy.
Something Loewen probably also needs
because she's currently wearing Verity's
silk house coat and getting off to thoughts
of her husband in their crazy rock tub.
This is where you get the scene from the trailer where she's making
out with Jeremy and then it flips to Verity and the horror.
Of that also being the thing that gets her off
but then it turns sinister so she snaps awake from the nightmare.
See, we are steering into that spectacle with the movie!
Colleen Hoover would never, especially with the sapphics.
Her spectacles never include the sapphics.
Loewen's attraction towards Jeremy
and really feeling like they're building this deep connection
will become so solidified when they go out for dinner for her birthday
and he mentions how upset Verity would get
when he refused to read her manuscripts
because he just couldn't believe it all came from her brain.
While Loewen's sitting there knowing exactly-
Exactly how much his validation mattered to her
because his opinion was the only one Verity cared about
because of how obsessed she was.
Pointing out that she's never really had to worry
about anything like that
because no one's ever given her
that kind of praise or validation as a small author.
Which is when he reveals that he lied
about what he said when she was hired.
Verity isn't the one who read her book.
It was him and he loved it.
So now she's on the receiving end
of that validation from this man
that can make people feel so special
even though mentally I would think that
You would feel more special by this prolific author
liking your work more so than her husband.
But in this situation, obviously this matters more.
I also took it as a bit of a red flag
that he wouldn't read his wife's work anymore
and her thrillers, but was so into what Loewen wrote
that he hired her to finish his wife's works.
Bad vibes, just pushing that appreciation onto someone else.
The first kiss comes pretty quickly after this.
He makes her a cupcake when he realizes it's her birthday,
leading into the kiss which feels very abrupt
or at least lacking in tact for the situation.
I get that it had to ramp up though,
we're over the halfway mark of an erotic thriller,
but in the book it ramps up a lot
because he actually gets her nipple in his mouth
before she notices Verity watching them from the top of the stairs,
fists clenched, running back to her room when Loewen sees her.
In the movie she does see her walking towards them in the hallway,
but she is gone by the time Jeremy turns around.
But because in the movie we see her walk-
walking before Loewen clocks it,
I'm pretty sure that it was actually happening and it wasn't some
kind of psychotic break on her part.
Though they do keep showing her take Xanax and mixing it with
alcohol sometimes, which can cause hallucinations in very rare cases.
Regardless, I think that the
movie's implying that Verity was really there.
In the movie, he does have her up on the counter,
like, straddling him, but the clothing is all still mostly on.
But in a way, it almost feels
worse because they'd gone out to eat again for her birthday.
So she was wearing one of Verity's dresses
and she specifically went
She went out of her way to find the one
that best matched the description of the dress
Verity wore the night she and Jeremy met,
a night that Jeremy did confirm from the manuscript
as being what happened.
So that feels like some sick, twisted manipulation on Loewen's part.
I personally wouldn't want to remind
the person I want to hook up with of the first
night they met their catatonic wife,
but Loewen's trying to win some comparison game, I guess.
So she completely freaks out.
Thankfully, Jeremy takes this all as like
a guilt manifestation, which is good for Loewen,
but I start thinking of all the ways Verity could sabotage her life.
If she could actually drive Loewen crazy
and completely turn Jeremy against her.
Spoiler alert, it will not go interesting in that way.
For now, it's just Loewen telling Jeremy to take moments for himself
and do what he wants and what he wants.
Is her. Come on! So they start hooking up
and it's made all the worse by Loewen essentially trying to
repeat his moments with Verity by biting the same spot
in the headboard to like replace her teeth
marks. Girl! While she can't be as bad as the Verity
that is being described in the book, she is picking
up a lot of those traits the more this is going on.
This part hasn't happened in the book yet. We still
have to go through Chasten's death first,
that it was at a birthday party, they got hungry in the
middle of the night and went upstairs to get snacks,
and that she unknowingly ate something
And that if she had just tried harder
to kill Harper before,
Jeremy wouldn't be so ******* sad all the time.
Her words.
So in the book, it's after the makeout scene
in the kitchen that Verity ends up just being
around the house more, more awake at night,
so April just sets her up in the living room
instead of in bed, probably trying
to prevent future intimacy sessions between Lowen and
her husband, seemingly trying to unsettle
her by muting the TV, which just has Lowen
verbally assaulting her about the manuscript,
hoping for any kind of reaction but also
believing that she'd deserve it even
if she wasn't faking all this because of what
she's admitted to doing.
And all she really gets is Verity pissing herself,
which only makes Lowen angrier because
now she's realized how much Jeremy is going
to be spending the rest of his life looking after
this person who killed his child.
It's after P-Duty that they hook up in the book,
specifically acknowledging that there's
no contraceptive involved on either side,
and I bet no one's going to go for some
Plan B!
No!
It'll happen the next day, and she constantly tries
to make sure it all stays up there.
Brother, eww!
I'd mentioned earlier that he said that there
was just always something missing with Verity.
Well, apparently, anything that was missing
with her, he feels in Loewen,
felt it in the bathroom the first time they met, apparently.
Dude, you talked for like five minutes
while she was cleaning blood off herself!
And that's when the door lock comes back into play in the book.
He didn't lock Verity in her room last night.
He had put a lock on the outside of the door,
so Loewen would also feel comfortable that nothing was going on here
and just justifying it for Verity's safety.
But because he didn't lock it,
she snuck down while they were getting it on
and locked him inside that room, so he'd have to try-
to explain himself to Crew and Verity's nurse.
He, of course, assumes it was Crew.
Loewen points out that it might have been Verity,
so he punches out the window to get back inside
in case she was faking all this to steal him away.
Thankfully, everyone's still in their beds as April arrives, but damn!
He'll end up just thinking it's because he pushed the door too hard
so it latched shut, but really?
So now the movie
and the book are roughly starting to swirl back together.
There's like some different details,
but she's finishing out the manuscript
to find out what happens to Harper.
Jeremy was supposed to take them out on the canoe,
but they had to work, so he told them that mommy would do it instead.
So she takes that as an opportunity
to flip the canoe and kill them both,
not realizing that Crew could swim, so it was just Harper that died.
The book actually takes this a step further because at this point,
Verity has been harboring six months of animosity
and anger towards Harper
because she truly believes that she killed Chasten.
Starts grilling her about her reaction,
her cry because she didn't cry that her sister died,
asking if she even cared, and then went
through a delusional set of thoughts about
how everything would be better if Harper was
just gone now, too, that the grief could only compound
so much at losing a second child
after you lost the first one.
Surely all the grief has to mostly go into the first loss,
and then they'd be able to
pool their energy into just making sure that Crew was okay
and then just be stronger amongst
themselves.
It never really goes into specifics in the book.
It does kind of say that Crew was conceived in a canoe, and that's why.
They gave him the name Crew,
but I get the idea that she's not as jealous of him because
he's a boy, but it really does feel like there's just like
an entire section of why she decided
to like actually have that third baby
is just missing from this book. Because while in the
movie she does try to kill them both at the same time,
in the book she tells Crew to hold his
breath just before she flips it.
And obviously this was a huge misjudgment of the situation. Jeremy
was of course devastated.
The trauma of losing two kids in a single year would be absolutely
Absolutely devastating, especially
when the second one is the one that you feel like
Like you have a little bit of like a special connection to,
like you're the one who actually understands that one.
And then add into the fact that it happened
when he wasn't home
and that they were specifically in the water
because of his suggestion.
So this is when she realized
she completely lost him in the book.
He keeps grilling her about every choice she made
until he specifically asks,
Why did you tell Crew to hold his breath?
Knowing that at this point,
there is no way to convince him that it was an accident,
no way to convince him that she said,
no, I told him to hold his breath
after it was already flipping.
So now that she's lost him and might end up going to jail,
she'll just drive her car into a-
And here we are.
Now, after reading about how she flipped the boat,
Lowen's first thought was not to go talk to Jeremy, finally.
It is to quiz Crew on what happened that day.
He says that his mom specifically said not to talk to her,
as in not to talk to Lowen specifically about what happened that day,
biting into a knife when she asks if mommy still talks to him.
I really thought that was a fake out
when he was just like playing with the knife.
Hands up.
I like, I don't know why she didn't take the knife out of his hand,
but no, it just fully happens.
Jesus Christ, Lowen.
Jesus Christ.
Where is Colleen?
So when Jeremy rushes him to the hospital,
this is when she starts trying to get a reaction
out of Verity in the movie,
sticking her with a thumbtack for her reaction, calling her
a Machiavellian cunt that wasted her perfect life
that she's just going to take from her
instead.
And power to Verity, if she is faking, she doesn't even flinch.
So Loewen hooks up that baby monitor
so she can watch her from the office while she keeps
reading.
I will say in the book, she does actually
end up moving, but she can't get it recorded
fast enough because she yells,
so she very obviously scuttles back into bed in the movie.
Maybe she doesn't end up moving on camera?
In the movie the behavior at this point
is very much supposed to be reflecting the way that
Verity's headspace is in the manuscript.
Like Loewen is really taking on a lot of those traits.
Obviously not the ones that involve killing children,
but the attitudes, the manipulation,
just the cunningness to try to get what you want.
So in the movie when Jeremy comes home he notices
that the camera is set up on Verity.
He gets really upset and I don't know why Loewen doesn't
just go with like an easy explanation of,
oh I wanted to keep working down here and I wanted
to make sure that I could keep an eye on her.
But she just immediately starts spluttering out
about how Verity must be faking it, about how she killed the kid.
And at this point, I really thought she
was going to lose him, that he was going to toss
her out, that this was some like five degree chess type thing
to make it seem like Lowen
wrote the manuscript to set up Verity as the murderer of the children.
So then he would put her in like a care facility
so Lowen would have an easier time just stepping
into that life completely.
But no, he does just start reading the manuscript right
at the part about killing Harper and
just instantly believes it, which in some ways
is fair if you didn't want to keep reading
I'm reading your wife's work because you were
You were genuinely afraid of her mindset
and didn't want to consider it might be true.
And then you get some indication that it might be true.
It's fair, I guess.
He comes around on this explanation very quickly
for someone who doesn't have that like baseline.
But he rushes up the stairs
to try to make Verity say something,
saying that he'll walk out of the house with Crew,
give the manuscript to the cops
and that she'll never see either of them again.
And after like two seconds,
she just snaps out of it with a like, I can explain.
And for all the different explanation patterns
we're about to go through for why this might've happened,
I do think that Verity is like evil to some degree
and that this was way more about.
her concern of losing Jeremy, but we'll get there.
So instantly she's trying to explain herself,
but he is just on her neck so fast.
Lowen begging him to stop
because Crew would be left without anyone
and the way Dakota's like,
they'll know you've killed her
is so beautifully soap opera-esque.
Again, I must remind you,
I like good Dakota Johnson
and I like bad Dakota Johnson.
But with the look of desperation on his face,
she decides that he's just so desperate
for a way out of this that she just says,
you have to make it look like an accident
and gives him a tip right out of the manuscript,
suffocation that she died.
In her sleep, plug her nose and her mouth.
I will say, because of the struggle and the strain here,
the blood vessels would have still popped in her eyes
and burst in a way that would be indicative of foul play,
I'm pretty sure, but fine.
And honestly, even though he stopped strangling her,
I do still think the bruising would be on her neck
for how much he had already been going for it,
but whatever, for some reason,
they decide to throw her in the lake,
which almost makes it feel like more of a coverup,
like, hey, this person that's been catatonic for months
and just hasn't been moving somehow
wandered right down to the
the docks, ending with them giving a very similar performance
to the cops that Verity claimed to
have given after Harper's death.
Telling the cop that asks that the next Noble Virtue book is going
to be the best one yet. Bold, Lowen.
Now, you'd think that at this point, after murdering someone,
when you're taking over that person's extremely
popular book series means that you would just
completely disconnect from her husband after this mysterious death.
But nope, we cut to seven months
later and she's pregnant. In the book,
they're really trying hard to keep this a secret. They
move to North Carolina where no one should know who they are.
The books are coming out under
They're a pen name, so her work won't be affected
and she won't be tied to any of it.
But in the movie, it is her whole assed real name,
big on the cover, bigger than Verity's.
The book girlies would go feral.
The Reddit detectives would be relentless.
Movie's not gonna worry about that though.
They're at the house finishing the last of the packing
when Crew says, oh, I forgot my drawings
that are hidden under mommy's floor.
You know, where she hid them.
Along with a knife in the book
that had gone missing earlier in the book
and a letter to Jeremy.
Then hopefully he's the one reading this
and it's after she and Crew got away.
Pin the entire thing on him, but no,
she just starts talking about this thing
called antagonistic journaling,
writing real events from your life,
but with the worst possible twist
and the worst possible light of what was going on
in your head at the time.
Like her only being at the party
to take advantage of rich men trying to force an abortion.
That was all a writing exercise
to deal with the guilt of what happened
and imagine herself so much worse than what actually happened
so she could maybe find some peace
in the mistakes she feels she did make.
Also to sell as a book to help writers.
But then Jeremy found the manuscript
And was obviously going to believe it.
And the end of it gave him the perfect out.
She literally said she was going to drive into a tree,
so he made sure that happened.
But she didn't die, but she realized that by playing helpless,
he could buy her some time.
This is where I start to not super buy the letter.
Like, if he was that mad, he'd set her up in permanent hospice.
Instead, he could give the cops the manuscript now
because it's still evidence of her planning to kill herself
and that, like, they could just deal with it after the fact.
I get maybe not wanting to tarnish her legacy
now that her life is essentially ruined
so that they could just kind of
keep benefiting from that.
There's honestly so many reasons why team manuscripts seems to be
accurate and like team letter is just like another layer
of the manipulation out of her
and that she's writing this now because she realized
that Lowen found the manuscript and
now that would make two against one in this situation.
Where Lowen specifically seen Verity
moving around and could blow her cover?
But it being an added layer of manipulation really feels
like it only works with the intention of Lowen finding it.
If for team letter that means Jeremy
clearly read the manuscript otherwise it wouldn't make sense
for her to mention that in the letter
Unless she knew Lowen was going to.
going to be the one to find it and want to mess
with her an extra level. In the end it might just
turn into this thing with while there's chronics
and tragedy chronics to always suffer tragedy
they're both pretty fucked.
Like Jeremy seems like a great dad but maybe he did have it in him to
manipulate Lowen into finding this manuscript
so he would have an excuse to kill his wife even
though her being in this current state would actually make
for a great cover if something
happened to her. If she just kind of went
in her sleep like lost control of her throat muscles.
Like it really is something the more you think about it
the less any option really seems to
It's entertaining.
You can also go with my completely unsubstantiated
movie headcanon that might actually apply to the book.
In some ways, the crew tipped the boat.
That's why he doesn't ask about Harper
because he doesn't care.
Verity wrote the manuscript to make it seem like she did it
in case the cops ever plan to ask more questions.
But again, that doesn't really make sense
because they ruled it an accident pretty early on
before she would have started writing it, but still.
Then ended up writing the letter
as an added cover for Jeremy.
If she ever did run away with Crew to protect him,
so he might at least be able to take some solace
in believing it was all truly a horrible mistake.
And then maybe he would go find them
and they could have their beautiful life together again.
Again, that doesn't make sense either.
But there are enough little tidbits of this kid being fucked up,
which I will continue on in a little bit.
If you end up being team letter and wondering why she didn't take
the many opportunities to run with crew before that,
or even if you're team manuscript
and wondering why she didn't just escape on her own before that,
I guess it had to do with her money and how it was going
to be transferred or a big chunk of it was going to be transferred.
To Loewen's account, and then finding a way to have it move
to a new account that she set up somehow secretly.
Still not fully sure on the logic there.
It doesn't specify that, like, maybe she, like,
changed the routing information after she got Loewen
so that it wouldn't actually go to Loewen's account.
I'm not sure.
Either way, that's why she was waiting, I guess.
Kind of ignoring that that would be super easy to track.
But on the manuscript side, I could fully see
her wanting to stick around and have Jeremy just
Permanently taking care of her and then feeling guilty about it all
and then maybe finding a way
for recovery and making him believe she didn't do it
or that he would at least have to be taking
care of her and focusing on her so much.
Because I do believe that the Jeremy obsession is real
based on like the way she looked
when she came out of the room and looked at Loewen with her
her fists clenched. I do believe that obsession aspect is real.
I don't know if it's all a mess,
I also don't know if I believe that someone
who isn't somewhat unhinged could play catatonic
that effectively for that long.
Like if she wasn't this level of unhinged
Like even with the evening journeys around
the house to kind of move around a bit.
It doesn't, that's so crazy to me.
Maybe I'm just too twitchy and uncomfortable
as a person to imagine doing that.
I do know that in an interview,
Colleen said that regardless of what side you end up on,
because either can be true to her
because it's all really from Lowen's perspective.
So we can only know as much as she knows.
When Lowen was confused, I was confused.
And I know people don't believe that,
but I really was when I was writing that.
I was like, oh my gosh, what is real?
What is not?
But if I had to pick, I think Verity is evil.
I really do.
She thinks Verity is evil and I'm inclined to believe that.
The pretending to be catatonic thing
if Jeremy really had no idea only seems to make sense
if she was just really into having him take care of her.
Unless you end on manuscript is real,
that Jeremy did in fact actually find it
and now she's pretending to be catatonic
so that he doesn't do something to her.
Which means that he is manipulating Lowen.
I don't know, my head hurts.
In either scenario, Lowen is now completely tied to this man
that might have been manipulating
her so he'd have an opportunity to kill his wife.
And at best, now just stuck in a mindfuck.
loop to the end of her days.
The movie leaving us with her questioning which version of the truth
Verity was manipulating. Ending
with that Hot Ones video where she says that truth was her favorite
theme to corrupt. How certain I could make
the audience before showing them that maybe certainty
wasn't the wisest choice. So the movie does seem
to be taking the stance that the letter is more
accurate and that this was some kind of exercise.
And honestly while I was watching I did start to
wonder is this her book about truth but using herself as a character?
But then it gets even
Even messier and some of that crude
Verity theory gets maybe a little bit more substantiated
because there was a bonus chapter released
to the book.
It picks up like five months later after their daughter Nova is born,
Verloewyn is as expected
comparing herself to every piece of Verity's life
and everything she wrote in that manuscript,
comparing her relationship with Jeremy
to that every piece of it, what things might
be better, obsessing with being better,
literally becoming that insecure version of Verity.
She believes that regardless of which is real,
the manuscript or the letter, that Verity
was a dangerous mother for even being able to write it.
And because she at least somewhat believes that manuscript she's fixated
on it. She's worried that Jeremy
doesn't have that same like sexual passion towards
her that he had for Verity based on the manuscript.
Worried about how her body hasn't bounced back after pregnancy
the way that Verity described
hers as. He's reading the book of another woman writer
that she's gone out of her way to make sure
is married because she's just worried that that cycle
is going to continue. She's starting to
question her own place in this as she should have when he was like,
actually I lied, I was the one
who read your book, not Verity.
Really only comforted on the entire thing when he tosses
The book behind him when he notices.
She's wearing lingerie and Verity's letter never mentions
that Jeremy was this secret monster
like it could have been building into.
Like maybe he tuned things out in dinners with her editor,
which is actually pretty rude. Sitting there reading
an e-book while they're talking about
his wife's career. But it's still not hinting
at the level to which this ends up going. At this
point Lowen started working on Truth
and finding it particularly hard to get through with everything
going on with the various storyline
and I imagine that's what happens when your job is to finish
the works of someone you killed whose name means Truth.
So definitely not a happy paradise
There's a paradise situation going on here.
But they head to the beach
and then they run into a woman named Patricia,
a woman that they ran into at the grocery store earlier on in the book
when Lowen was first staying at the house.
Subtly grilling Jeremy about why he was out with this young girl
when Verity was held up in bed.
I need to clarify that no one knew the extent
of Verity's injuries at that time.
They were trying to keep it quiet.
So now this woman is here seeing Lowen with a baby.
That definitely implies that something was going on before Verity died.
The timeline is particularly unusual for an
An unusual death that ended up happening to Verity.
So Jeremy kills her, drowns her in the ocean
and leaves the body there to be found.
Colleen, you must know that this was a well-to-do white woman
in a fancy, nice area.
The cops would do a little bit more investigating
than just like, oh, I guess she like fell on her own
and drowned.
She was out walking a dog, not swimming.
Jeremy is just so hell bent on protecting them
and like not being exposed for murdering Verity,
which Lowen has at this point justified in her mind
as something that needed to happen.
He's killed someone objectively innocent just
to avoid the heat that would bring on them.
Like I'm sorry at some point people are going
to realize that you married the woman that was hired
to finish writing your wife's books even with the pen name.
Telling Lowen that they had to do it
for them but he's the only one who drowned a person.
Keeping Lowen even more trapped in
this situation not just in her own head competing with a dead woman
but with the person she's
competing with for. Wondering
when she might do something to be the next person on Jeremy's list.
That if she is not an accomplice, she's an obstacle.
Though then says she's simultaneously
feeling very protected by him.
That he never loved Verity like this.
I just gotta talk to Colleen real quick.
I get that Lowen is not reasonable here, but like,
Just gotta talk to you real quick.
And on top of an unraveling Jeremy,
who's essentially turning into Joe from the You series,
we've got Crew escalating in behavior as well.
First, it's just general standoffishness with Lowen,
which makes sense.
His mother is dead, his sisters are dead,
but then he's talking about how he doesn't care
what his sister's name ends up being
because she's just gonna die too.
More reasons that he should still be in therapy,
but then in his annoyance with his little sister crying,
he ends up putting her outside because she won't stop.
Furthering the supported idea
I have no idea that he may have been the one to-
Again, I don't think that's what's happening
and it just makes more sense in the bounds of the movie
more so than the book where there's like multiple sisters.
But I just think that there is enough evidence to mention it.
The baby ends up being okay, but still.
But that's pretty much everything to go over with Verity.
It just ends that they can't run away from the Crawford name
and that they're just a family of chronics,
which again, I'm going to link back to.
Chronics as in the tragedy comes to them
but chronics as in like they're chronically
fucked up people who do fucked up things.
But that is gonna do it for today's video that is entirely
too long for what it is. Like how did this end up being this long?
What is wrong with me? But let me
know what you guys are thinking down below.
Did you at least have fun with the spectacle of the
insanity here? Thank you all so much for watching.
Thanks as always to my Patreon supporters and
YouTube channel members. Subscribe to the channel
if you're new. Leave a like on the video if you're
into that kind of thing. All my other social media
is listed down below and also I got a chance to
To interview Mike Flanagan for Carrie,
which is over on the TIFF channel.
It's in my collaboration section here.
I will try to have it linked down below.
Check it out if you're interested.
I hope you're all having a fantastic day.
I'm mostly okay and we'll catch you all later.