US Election: 4 Things an Italian Guy Finds Weird #election

Marco in America
1.3K followers
865 Video Views·Oct 19, 2024
It's almost time for the US Presidential Election.
Coming from Italy there are a few things that I find kind of weird about the whole process.
I'm not saying they are bad or wrong things, it's just that they are fairly different from what we have in place in Italy
I'm gonna have a chat with 2 friends to see if I can get a better understanding.
Presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump meeting on the debate stage for
the first time.
And in many states you only have a few weeks left to get signed up to vote in November's
election.
We're going to make America great again.
Now many states are already opened up for early voting and actually a lot of votes are
coming in.
To talk about the importance of democracies, rule of law.
Our new Wall Street Journal poll surveyed the seven battleground states, the states
that are going to decide this election.
So it seems it's already time for the United States presidential election.
Here we go.
Good show.
Here we go.
I would like to share with you guys four things that this Italian guy finds bizarre about
the United States presidential election.
Now you have my attention.
I'm going to have a chat with two friends of mine.
They're very knowledgeable about the whole process and I want to ask them what they think
about these four things.
Let's do it.
In the United States, there are basically two major political parties and they've been
these two since forever.
It's not like that in Italy.
In Italy, when it's election time, there are so many different political parties and some
of them, they have fairly bizarre names.
In his farewell address in 1796, Washington had a long speech.
He warned the American people not to have political parties.
And I think he could tell that they were forming, even then, between the Federalists, Anti-Federalists.
Some political parties at all, nothing, zero.
Don't create it.
He said, don't.
He just said, stay away from them.
They will breed animosity and really mean spiritedness.
He also said, though, we need a virtuous population.
We need to respect religion.
This can keep our country together.
He said, the different sections have different needs.
We should be one unified country.
That's what he was saying.
Don't kind of have more pride over your state than your country.
That was his message.
There's really just two main ones, right?
So actually, when I first voted, I voted for one of the ones, you know, not one of the
two major ones.
I voted for the Libertarians.
I was a young man and, you know, I wanted to be different, so I voted.
I didn't feel comfortable with the two major ones.
So they are there.
They're just, you know, everybody kind of knows they're going to lose.
Chances are near zero, near zero.
In the United States, there can be different rules for different states when it comes to
voting.
I find this fairly bizarre because, you know, you would say it's the president of the United
States.
Every single state should have the same rule, but it's not like that.
In certain states, they allow the so-called mail-in ballot, so you can mail your vote.
Certain states allow those electronic machines to be used.
In certain states, they don't require an ID.
When you go in person and vote, certain states you can vote in advance, certain states you
can vote later, certain states they take forever to count the votes.
Part of it's just it's written into the Constitution.
Article 1, Section 4 of the Constitution says each state shall have to decide the time
and the means and the manner, the location of voting.
I think it stems from the founding fathers being so cautious about there could be such
a strong central government that a tyranny could happen.
They really didn't want what they felt was the tyranny of King George III of England.
They should have, for in-person voter ID, for in-person voting, if there's going to
be absentee voting and mail-in voting, they should have ways to strengthen the voter identification
system.
I think if there's going to be drop boxes, they need to be secured and monitored all
the time.
I think it is a concern, and you can't have a strong democracy without people who are
confident in the system.
Sounds like a deal.
The so-called electoral college.
Now, I understand the meaning behind when it comes to the Senate and representation
of different states, but when it comes to the President of the United States, I would
say personally, it makes more sense to use the so-called popular vote, which means you
count all the votes and whoever gets the most votes wins.
That's it.
Done.
Some people today might say it's antiquated, but there's a lot of benefits to it, which
is that once you have these representatives, you can't have the popular people actually
go out of control and decide something that's totally bad.
It goes back to this idea of just being a good person, just having a kind of noble spirit.
This gets to the core of what makes America, America, which is just being good, being a
noble spirit, and kind of looking above the division between people.
I have to remember that America was kind of like the first modern nation.
Huh?
I admit this is cool.
So when they were trying to do this whole country with democracy, it was something that
hadn't really been done before, without a king, without a queen, without a monarchy.
In some ways, America is like the oldest country.
So there's almost like a feudal element that's still left over in the American democracy
that's kind of retro.
There's something kind of weird about it and ancient.
It's like each state is almost like its own kingdom, and then the president is a little
bit like the emperor, and each state has a governor who's kind of like a king.
So if you think about it that way, it starts to make sense.
So if you want North Dakota to join your empire, you've got to give them something, right?
You've got to give them two senators like you gave everybody else.
I understand.
Major mainstream media, they publicly endorse a candidate, which personally, I find it fairly
bizarre.
Those media, they're not part of the electoral process per se, but we know they have a lot
of power when it comes to influencing public opinion.
How am I supposed to trust you in your reporting when you publicly endorse a candidate?
He's got a point.
For newspapers, you're going to have a certain, usually, region or area where they're based,
and then the majority of those people will belong to a party.
So ultimately, the newspaper is looking at their subscribers, right?
And they want to keep their subscribers happy.
It makes sense from that perspective, because they're just kind of, in that sense, the newspaper
is kind of a representative.
And in America, we usually say that the media is the fourth estate.
So they kind of feel like they have this important role in the American kind of process.
And they do.
So they kind of participate and use that.
Now, when you're talking about media that applies to the whole nation, like, you know,
it's called the New York Times, for example.
And so in theory, their area is New York.
But now they've become like a national newspaper.
So when they endorse someone, it is weird.
It is weird.
It's true.
Right?
I knew it.
I knew it!
So now you're getting into ideological conflicts, right?
The reason why they're able to do that is because America has this history where it's
like, ultimately, the party, you know, it's more like we're going for this team, you know,
and the other area is going for this team.
You know, at the end of the game, we're going to shake hands.
And we're all on the same team.
We're on Team America.
That's how it's able to happen, is to actually not take political parties too seriously.
All right, that was a great conversation.
I have to say, I'm still not very clear about how useful the electoral college can be.
But that's just me.
I mean, it's been around for a while, so I guess they'll do just fine.
Anyway, see you next time, guys.
