Underfermented Dough: The Shocking Results You Need to See

Cake Tutorial
508 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Experiment time. Many of you have asked me
to experiment on what happens when you underferment
dough. Will it ruin your bread or unlock unexpected deliciousness?
Let's dive into the dough and find
out. Hi, I'm Sune
and I'm not just a food enthusiast,
I'm a full-blown food geek.
I'm here to share my passion and knowledge with you.
Fermentation is crucial for bread, as it affects everything.
Rice, flavor, crust, and crumb structure.
But what if we deliberately under-ferment our dough?
Can shorter fermentation times produce better results,
or will it lead to disaster?
Well, typically, we'd expect under-fermented dough
to show moderate to high oven spring,
irregular crumb structure, and potentially
less flavor development compared to properly fermented dough.
For this experiment I prepared four identical doughs using
my standard experiment formula.
It consists of 80% bread flour, 20% whole grain rye flour,
20% starter, 2% salt, and 80% hydration.
I prepared all the doughs without stretch
and folds or any other agitation,
and they were stored consistently in my proofer
at 30 degrees Celsius throughout fermentation.
It is worth noting that the strength
and the activity of the starter play a considerable
role in these results.
Using a weaker starter could lead to significantly less oven spring
and potentially a tight or even gummy crumb.
That would make for a very different experiment
and perhaps one worth doing in the future.
I've amended the doughs for one hour,
two hours, three hours
and the last dough fermented until it grew by 50%.
After shaping each dough, spend up to 8 hours
in the fridge before baking under identical conditions.
If you'd like to support the channel,
please consider joining my Patreon.
You can also buy some merch,
use the super thanks, or check out the links
for tools and ingredients in the description.
Those were the words, this is the experiment.
This is an experiment, not a recipe.
My master recipe for sourdough bread is linked
First, I mixed all of the doughs.
After they were mixed, I placed them directly in the proofer
at 30 degrees Celsius, 86 degrees Fahrenheit.
Then I took out each dough at the appropriate time.
For the sake of keeping the video short,
I will show all of the shaping at the same time.
After shaping, the doughs were placed directly in the fridge
which is set to three degrees Celsius,
about 37.5 degrees Fahrenheit.
After around eight hours in the fridge, I started baking.
I used the two-stage baking process,
which means that one loaf browns while the other one is being steamed.
It's a great way to save
both time
and energy.
After they were all
finished baking,
they cooled down
a couple hours
to finish
the baking.
When they were cool, I cut
each loaf to reveal the crumb.
And let's just have a look
I'll look at a few more slices to get an idea of the resulting crumb.
Alright, this one, which only fermented for two hours,
has a very wild crumb.
It shows significant signs of under-fermentation.
The rise
in this loaf is
quite remarkable.
This one rose for three hours.
Already we're seeing that the crumb is relatively tame.
Still some signs
of under-fermentation,
but nothing like
the first loaf.
This loaf rose for four hours
and it's starting to look like we are in a good territory.
You still see some signs of undefermentation, but they're now minimal.
The last loaf rose for about five hours to get to 50 percent.
This crumb looks quite lovely.
Not very open, but that wasn't really the point of this experiment.
All right.
Let me compare
the smell
and the taste.
Mmm, smells good.
A bit of tang, lots of wheat and some rye.
Tastes really good.
That rye flour from Kornbyr Mølle is my absolute favorite.
Okay, so this one is also tangy, mild and enjoyable.
The taste is about the
same as the first one.
The third loaf also smells and tastes the same.
It seems like the rice doesn't affect the taste.
Well, let's try
the properly
fermented one.
Yes, quite the same.
The length of the bulk fermentation significantly affects the texture
and rise more so than the smell and the taste.
This experiment was eye-opening.
While we expected moderate oven spring and somewhat
irregular drum structure with shorter fermentation times,
the actual results were surprising,
especially the significant oven spring seen
in the least fermented dough.
Interestingly, despite these structural differences,
there were almost no noticeable difference
in taste between any of the loaves,
challenging our initial expectation about flavor development
and fermentation.
One hypothesis is that the extended time
in the fridge played a more significant role
in the flavor development than the bulk fermentation.
Could cold fermentation be the secret to unlocking authentic flavor?
Maybe that's a test we need to run.
What do you think? Have you experimented
with fermentation times in your baking?
Please share your experience in the comments below.
I hope you learned something today. See you next time.
