Two Steps Forward, One Step Back. Where are we heading with gender equality?

United Nations Development Programme (UNDP)
19 followers
1 Video View·Dec 9, 2024
Hello everybody. Welcome to our conversation today. This conversation is part of a celebration
of 30 years of the UN Development Report, the Human Development Report. We are looking at
lessons learned from the past and then how do those lessons get applied to the future
via a conversation. What is essential in this conversation? We have a politician,
we have an activist, we also have an academic, we have you of course. So at the bottom of your
screen you will see a little box which says Q&A. I am looking forward to hearing your questions
for our lineup and you can put those questions to the lineup at any point during this conversation.
I'm not going to silo you right to the end because we have learned many things over the last 30
years and siloing is one of them that we would like to avoid. My name is Femi Okay. I will be
your moderator for the next 15 minutes but first let me introduce you to your lineup. Let's start
first with the politician. Hello Madam President. Hello Laura. Please introduce yourself to our
audience. Tell them why you're important in this conversation. Hello Femi. Hello everybody. Thank
you for being with us and first let me say some words about the Human Development Report Office.
I want to congratulate them for drafting the most relevant report on development issues for
30 years and I want to say that this report alerted very early that gender inequality was
one of the most significant barriers to human development. Well I am a political scientist,
a politician from Costa Rica who had the honor to break the glass ceiling in two occasions in
my country 25 years ago when I was appointed as the first female minister of security and in 2010
when my people elected me as the first woman president. I have been concerned about gender
equality for many years and during my government we were able to achieve parity at all levels of
education, reduce femicides by 70 percent to provide early childhood care for working mothers
and some other kind of measures. Although I already retired from politics in Costa Rica,
I am still very active on issues concerning the global agenda such as multilateralism,
sustainable development, women empowerment and other things. It is a pleasure to be in
this panel today. Thank you. It's a pleasure to have you. I want to tell everybody that Madam
President said I have to call her Laura, so don't send me comments about me not respecting her title.
I am under orders and I cannot disobey. Hello Kalyani, it is so great to have you in this
conversation. Tell our audience why you're in this conversation. Good to see you. Hi, yeah it's great
to be here. I'm Kalyani, I'm a feminist activist and I am based in New Delhi in India. So I'm one
of those feminists who got drawn into the global development sector by the promise of the human
development framework that for a complete rethinking of the meaning and purpose of
development. It was actually the 1995 HDR, the gender HDR that made me think that I could play
a part in that transformation. Whatever questions might be around that original promise of
transformation, I still feel that the human development framework can be a powerful platform
for those of us who believe that the dominant paradigm of development is itself the problem
and has to be created something new. So I feel very privileged to be here in such distinguished
company and I want to thank the host for bringing me to this conversation. It's good to have you
and Michael, welcome to the conversation. Please tell everybody who you are. I will allow you to
humble brag, go ahead. My name is Michael, I'm a researcher at the Queensland University of
Technology in Australia. So it's one o'clock in the morning here. I do research on men and
masculinities, on gender and violence prevention, but more than just only producing good
knowledge, I also try to contribute to social change. So I participate in social movements, I
tweet, I provide public commentary, I give away the books I've written and so on. So, you know, I try to
be a researcher, an advocate and an educator. And look, it's an honour and a privilege to be part of
this conversation. Audience, you know who your panellists are. So get ready with your questions,
your comments. Looking forward to seeing them in the Q&A box. But before we start our dialogue,
our conversation today, I want you to meet Pedro Conceição. He is the Director of the Human
Development Report, 30th anniversary. He's very busy. Thank you for making time for us, Pedro, go ahead.
Thank you, Femi. I just wanted to thank everyone for joining us on the panel and online.
And just reiterate that we chose the challenge of gender inequality for this dialogue because
this has been a recurrent theme in human development reports from the very beginning.
Kalyani mentioned the 1995 report, which has this very important phrase, in my view, it said that
human development, if not engendered, is endangered. And that is as relevant today as
it was in 1995. Last year, we had the Human Development Report that focused on inequalities
in human development, but had a spotlight on gender inequality. And we introduced a new
index of social norms on gender inequality. And today, we celebrate the International Day
for the End of Violence Against Women. I want to remind all of us of one of the most shocking
findings of that index. We found that almost a third of people around the world
think that it is justifiable for a man to beat his partner. We also found that nine out of every
10 people around the world harbors a bias against gender equality. And more shocking of all,
perhaps, we found that in many countries, there is a backsliding in terms of social norms that
support progress towards gender equality. And I'll just conclude by saying that the moment
we're living now with the COVID-19 pandemic is actually exacerbating not only patterns of gender
inequality, in part because the economic sectors are more affected by the pandemic,
ones in which women are often overrepresented, but also because going back to social norms,
we see some evidence that traditional views on women's role on household responsibilities,
childcare, education, are reasserting themselves. And so there's evidence that women are actually
pulling back from the labour market, not only because jobs are being lost, but because of
the social norms. And in times of crisis, social norms tend to become harder, more entrenched.
And I think this is a reason for concern, because it builds again on this backsliding
of gender norms, of social norms against gender equality that we documented last year.
But it's not a destiny. We have a choice. We need to continue to shine a spotlight
on the challenge, but also to discuss what can we do all to make improvements
or gender equality. That's what human development reports will continue to do going forward. And I
very much look forward to the discussion to help us in that regard. Thank you.
Thank you, Pedro. Where are we heading with gender equality is the headline for this conversation.
Kalyani, Laura, Michael, I know you all have thoughts on this. Kalyani, can I start though
with you and then other panellists, you can talk and bounce backwards and forwards with your ideas
as well. But Kalyani, this idea of where we are with the Human Development Report, we were at 30
years, marking its anniversary, during a global pandemic. And our focus today is gender equality
or gender inequality. Same conversation. COVID-19, if you draw the link between COVID-19 and gender
equality, where do you want to take us?
I agree with Pedro and Penny. I think COVID really has been the crisis. It's kind of
jerked the carpet out from under the denialist, the status quo, those who've convinced themselves
that a rising GDP will lift everybody's vote, who believe that rights and justice are impediments
on the road to prosperity. COVID has actually left them all clueless. So put simply, what I
think COVID has done is to make visible the connections between the climate crisis, the
economic crisis and the crisis of democracy. So this is really the triangle of crises, which is
within which we are kind of operating at this point. And I think what COVID has done
is to make these crises and the connection between these crises evident in a very stark and
undeniable way. Now, my point is that feminist analysis has actually made these connections
visible. And at least for the last 30 years, feminist thinking has developed a conceptual
framework to unpack them. And women's movement, feminist activism over these last 30 years
has actually exposed the alliances between patriarchy and other hierarchies of power and
privilege. So it's these intersectional hierarchies that have created these interlocking
crises. And the most terrifying symptom of this crisis, as Laura said, and as Pedro said,
is really the global resurgence of violent, masculinist, exclusionary political ideologies.
So I think this is a moment that COVID has focused and shown us exactly what peril we are all in.
Michael. Yeah, look, I'm really pleased to hear Kalyani's account, and she's absolutely right,
that really feminism could have told us for three decades that pandemics like COVID play out in the
context of gender inequalities and often make those inequalities worse. And we've seen that
very clearly in countries around the globe. And I think that part of what's gone on here
is about masculinity. Look at the resistance to mask wearing in some countries, particularly among
men. Look at the kind of tough man or strong man leadership we've seen from some countries that's
led to hopeless or disastrous responses to COVID. Look at the way that some Western governments
prioritise male-dominated areas of industry in terms of economic recovery, manufacturing and
construction, rather than recognising the value of care and health and education and so on.
Pandemics are never gender neutral. We saw that with HIV-AIDS, and now we see that
in really challenging ways with COVID as well. Some people say that COVID also potentially opens
up new opportunities for change, that large numbers of men now finding themselves at home,
perhaps caring for children or seeing the work that's involved in running a household,
may take that up. I'm not sure if we'll see that or not. But certainly there's no doubt that
COVID takes place in the context of, and has made worse, systemic gender inequalities.
COVID's impact globally has been huge. It didn't seem as if we were prepared for a global pandemic
and what it would do to us, what it would do to women, what it would do to families.
Well, yes, I will say that nobody was prepared for this kind of pandemic. However, at the same
time, I will say that this pandemic has treated, in a very different way, those who were more
vulnerable to those who had more access to opportunities and resources. And in the case
of women, it is very clear from a policy perspective that there is still many things to do
to support women's agenda in many fields, economically speaking, socially speaking,
and also politically speaking. Just let me give you some data to illustrate what I am saying.
First, informality in the labor market is mainly in the hands of women all around the world.
It goes from 60 to 80 percent, depending on the countries. So that means that the pandemic
puts women at a greater risk of falling into poverty or not having access to social protection
mechanisms. Secondly, women are working, when they are formally employed, working primarily
in the sectors that are among the first to be affected by lockdowns. So that was another kind
of message that we had to receive from a policy point of view. Third, most of the health workers
are women. So that means that they are more exposed to the effects of the pandemic. And finally,
to more issues, women have less access to the use of technology tools than men. So that means that
the pandemic will probably result in more women losing their jobs. And finally, what Christine
already mentioned, and that is that the confinement measures expose women to higher levels of gender
violence. So when we analyze the global agenda, we can see very clearly during the pandemic
how behind women are in terms of human development.
Paolo, let me put this question to you. This question comes from Professor Mohsin Abul
Naga, and you can answer it in different ways. Where are the highest gendered inequality versus
equality recorded rates in our globe during the age of COVID-19 crisis? We haven't even had a year
of COVID. We've had enough, but we haven't had a year. So this is going to be very new in terms of
what data do we even have? So I'm okay if you answer in the way of examples, anecdotal, because
to have data from, say, March for many of us, maybe from December if you're in China, that is
tricky. That's a hard question to actually answer. But how would you talk to the professor about that?
Where's the higher gender inequality? Where have you seen it? For instance, Laura, you brought up,
and I have seen this, and I've seen the numbers, that women are leaving the labor force faster
than men are leaving the labor force. There's an impact economically that COVID-19 is having
on workforces, but women are leaving in bigger numbers than men. That is one example that I
am seeing, and there are stats, certainly for the United States, for that. Kalyani,
what do you want to add? I was thinking about what you said, that we don't really have data to be
able to say this in a huge way. I think what we can say definitely is that in every place where
certain disparities existed, or certain gaps existed, those gaps have widened hugely. And
in places that have been worst hit by COVID, as well as where democracy itself is shattering,
and where authoritarian, masculinist governments are in power, in those places, these violations
and disparities have increased at a much faster rate. So I'm just thinking of the
sort of global understanding now, that countries with women leaders, New Zealand is the country
most often quoted. Countries with leaders who have a different approach, who may or may not
identify as feminist, but who have a different approach to managing the crisis, have been able
to contain its social impact, particularly in terms of violence, and in terms of inequality,
much better than countries that have taken a top-down, command-and-control kind of non-consultative
approach. So I do see that it's not just the impact of COVID, but it's also the impact of
governance structures, and the way in which the crisis is conceptualized. In many countries,
the COVID crisis has been conceptualized as a law and order problem. So in my own country,
we've seen the government enforcing some really draconian measures, using the police to implement
these measures, rather than having a dialogue or a conversation with the public, to make sure that
everybody understands why certain things have to be done. And Michael gave the experience of
mask-wearing. I think in the US also, we've seen the same thing, just kind of sharp positions,
polarized positions on mask-wearing, with very little understanding of why this is important.
So Dr. Rakhia is watching as part of our conversation today. He is watching,
and he said, rightly said, ma'am. Michael, please.
I really like what Kalyani said. There's a number of countries, I think, where
COVID has been used by governments to kind of intensify backlash, to intensify backlash
against reproductive rights, against more social democratic agendas to do with care,
and to intensify a kind of militarized police and security control over the population and
authoritarian rule. And I'm not necessarily thinking of countries outside the West either.
Threats to democracy is certainly visible in the US, which is a country that
my own country pays lots of attention to. The other thing I'd say is, it would be great in
some ways if governments and others recognized the way that COVID is intensifying gender
inequalities, and therefore this pandemic were an impetus to more social democratic and more
feminist-informed political agendas. But in fact, we sometimes see things going precisely the other
way, even when that involves a sort of massive cost in terms of deaths and illness in the population
concerned. Speakers, our conversation, the headline, which is a really interesting headline,
Two Steps Forward, One Step Back, which speaks to the 30 years of the Human Development Report,
the gains and then the losses, and where are we right now. If we're talking, Laura, and staying
obviously with gender equality or inequality, if we're talking about society's norms and how
they have changed or maybe stayed the same, if we're looking for wins,
where would we look to? What have you seen that's given you hope?
Well, this is a very important issue, an issue that was highlighted by the Human Development
Report last year. And I would say that according to the research included in the report, there are
four concerns in terms of social norms, because we have to recognize that many good things have
happened during the last years in favor of women's rights, but there are still many concernings. And
most of them are associated with the role of social norms. So let me just mention some of
the concerns that they highlighted. I was part of the board, so that is why I speak in third
person. The first concern is that progress in gender equality is slowing, and this is linked
to an apparent backlash against greater gender equality in many countries and due to the role
played by social norms. The second is that the bias against gender equality intensifies
in areas where more power is involved, either at home, in the workplace, or in politics.
The third concern is that the problem is widespread, since, as Pedro mentioned in the
introduction, only one in ten men and only one in seven women show no bias at all against gender
equality. And finally, the problem is far from diminishing. It tends to grow, since the
proportion of people having a bias against gender equality has grown in recent years. So that means
that we have to do much more in terms of policies. For example, working with the socialization of
boys and girls within the families, in the education, try also to see what is the role
that both traditional and social media are playing. And finally, we have to be more,
you know, we have to do even more in accessing to power. That is very critical if we want
to fight this kind of obstacles that we still have in the world.
Michael, your work is very practical. Your work is with men and boys and changing the sort of
gender norms that exist so that there isn't gender-based violence, so that there is more
awareness. As you're working with them, what have you learned about how gender norms are changing or
maybe staying the same? Sure. Look, I mean, the Human Development Report is actually a great
piece for taking that temperature of both men's and women's attitudes around the globe. And as
Laura summarized, it shows a slowing of progress towards gender equality. It shows that, you know,
most people, particularly most men, have some kind of sexist bias. They agree that men make
better political leaders than women or that, you know, a job should go to a man rather than a woman
and so on. What that report also tells us is that there's been stagnation and backlash. It's got
this amazing chart, actually, that shows where overall attitudes towards gender equality improved
over the last, I think, decade or decade and a half and where they went backwards. And so it's
not a story of even progress or of even backlash around the world. But certainly what's very
troubling is large numbers of men and fewer numbers of women opposed to gender equality,
supportive of patriarchal arrangements where men dominate. But in terms of gender norms to do with
men in particular, there's one thing I'm really pleased to see is there's growing awareness of
how harmful masculine norms shape men's lives, including shaping men's own health and well-being,
but also shaping the violence and abuse that some men perpetrate against women and girls. And if we
focus on that, again, we see that there's been some improvements over the last decade or two.
Most surveys in most countries show that fewer men these days agree that a man has a right to
hit his wife. Fewer men these days agree that a man should be the head of the household or dominant
in the relationship or family. But what's very troubling is it's still reasonably substantial
numbers. And also that's what stood out when Pedro said a third of men. Yeah, that's right.
A third of men right now think it's okay. Yeah. And look, it's not just about norms.
One of the reasons that harmful masculine norms, a belief that violence is okay, for example,
stay in place is because of other social systems and social structures. The norms in a community
or a society, what we think other people do, what we think other people expect, they don't just
float around like clouds. They're linked to our social institutions. They're linked to how boys
and girls are raised. They're linked to patterns of power. So if we want to shift those social norms,
we're going to have to make other forms of social change as well, because social norms are embedded
in social institutions, in hierarchies of power.
Kalyani, can I give this question to you from our audience? How can gender-sensitive
policymaking contribute to better socioeconomic prospects in developing economies?
For me or for Kalyani? That's a very hard question to answer off the top of my head.
I want to pick up on what Mikey was just saying and talk about this whole notion of gender-sensitive
policy. I want to go back to your original point, Temi, about the game and what has been achieved,
and I want to look at the development role. So there's definitely been a huge, huge achievement
in the sense that the way that gender has been put on the map in the development world
is very powerful. It's kind of been accepted as a non-negotiable condition for development.
So no document, no declaration, no policy is acceptable unless it accepts and kind of
pays homage to gender equality as a developing world. But the point is that we have not been
able to ensure that these words become reality on the ground, and I want to link back to what
all of us are saying about the persistent gap and the definite decline in indicators of equality.
So we've made gains, but these gains have been achieved at a very high cost.
The citadels of power within the institutions of development are intact. Sexism, racism,
homophobia, colonialist, majoritarian worldview, biases, all of these are deeply embedded in the
system, and the control of global policies and decisions, whether at the global level or whether
at the national level, remains in the hands of a very small and very exclusive club. So at one
level, I even see the focus in the development world on shifting social norms as shifting the
attention away and the responsibility away from institutions of development. Now in such a
situation, to ask what would be the best way to influence policy, I would say it really is
sweeping the map clean and starting again from scratch, because as things stand now,
the transformative goals of gender equality...
Right, Kayani, you just dropped a verbal grenade in our conversation. I just want to pick up,
what would you sweep clean? What needs to go?
I think the development industry needs to be asked to retire.
You know Pedro is sweating, right? You know Pedro is sweating right now.
I think Pedro may well agree with me. I mean the way that patriarchal binaries, gender hierarchies
of value, are really enmeshed in the language of development and the practice of development,
and this is what human development reports have been raising in different ways. So the goals of
gender equality and women's rights have been absorbed, but they've also been diluted, they've
depoliticized, and they've been converted into interventions that actually fit very
neatly into the dominant paradigm. So that transformative goal of human development and
of a changed paradigm has been subverted. So my gut feeling is that Pedro would probably
agree with me that it's time to stop saying we want to change the rules of the game.
I think we need to change the game.
Can I ask, who are the agents of change there? I mean should development agencies be,
should they be throwing their lot in with grassroots feminist and social justice movements?
Is it those movements and actors like that that will be able to make the kind of real political
or social change that is necessary? It's Kalyani I'm asking.
I would like to say something else, because yes, I think what Kalyani is saying is very important,
because at this time, for example, international financial institutions
are offering many resources to respond to the crisis, but at the same time, according to the
UNDP tracker, only 20% of the nations or the governments are putting in place gender-sensitive
kind of measures to respond to the pandemic. So the question is, why do we don't ask the
international financial institutions to condition the resources so we can be sure that part of those
resources are going to be allocated to respond to these very complex issues that women are
suffering all around the globe? So I think that we have to move from the words to the facts.
Kalyani, I'd still love to hear from you.
Yeah, I want to say, Michael, I'm just thinking how we need to really break our own conditioning
of thinking that there's some kind of small tight set of solutions that can be
adapted and applied in various situations. I think what we learned, what you and I and
Laura and everybody else who's worked on gender equality has learned that the complexity of
these different experiences of oppression, of resistance, of submission, of solidarity,
so all of these multiple systems of privilege, whether it's sexism, racism, classism,
casteism in my country, ableism, homophobia, whatever, you name it, religious bigotry,
the way these play out in the situations they create, the actors they enable, it's so different
and it's so completely grounded in a particular context. I think we have to find ways to allow
those contexts to find voice and that's where the experience of New Zealand is really interesting
because what seems to be happening there, and I speak as somebody who's just reading about it,
but what seems to be happening is a genuine effort to give voice to each group or each
community or each local formation to articulate its own positions, its own analysis. You see a
lot of this happening in Latin America also, especially in countries where indigenous
movements to save the environment, movement for a different model of development.
Some countries, there are spaces being created to at least acknowledge that there can be no global
solutions. There is no central headquarters that has some special wisdom that tells us
what is best in multiple places. It's that notion that got us into this.
The final part of our conversation takes us back to the beginning of our conversation. Where are
we heading with gender equality? I had a look on Laura's website and she is on the website shaking
hands with female leaders. I know this is not an accident. I'm getting the messaging. There's
Laura and Angela Merkel. There's Laura and Hillary Clinton. There is Laura and who else
was there, Laura, did you shake hands with? Hillary Clinton, Angela Merkel, Michelle Bachelet.
Big, powerful women. Where are we heading with gender equality? I'm going to ask you
via Veronica who has this question. Veronica says when you have political party leadership
consisting mostly of men, they are the gatekeepers to elections and changing power
structures. Laura, I know you are deeply passionate about this. You are messaging
about women leadership. Help us get to where are we heading with gender equality with women's
leadership? Start us off. Again, I think that we should try to move,
not abandon at all because we still have many things to do, but we have to move from the
concerns about women's rights to the concerns of women's access to power again. If we are not there,
it's going to be more difficult to change the course of the events. Let me just use the pandemic
and Kellyanne already said something about this, but I want to use the examples of the pandemic
to justify why I understand that more women leadership is needed now. Because when we
see that despite the fact that just a few governments are headed by women, according to
the data, those few governments, 40 percent of the cases are having very successful handling of the
pandemic. I think that this is not casual. The good results have largely relied on the quality
of female leadership because there are some common features of leadership. Women first tend
to display a distinct approach to power. It is a less arrogant attitude, much more willing to
listen and to conform policy with respect and discipline to technical and scientific criteria.
And this is a moment when politicians have been forced to abide, like probably never before,
to science and experts. Secondly, women have an ability to be empathetic, to identify with other
people's feelings and needs. And this is also a moment where the conditions of leadership,
such as compassion and solidarity, are being put to test. And finally, women's collaborative
leadership style is well suited to coalition building and dialogue, much necessary conditions
in moments in which leaders need to bridge social divides to build political cohesion and consensus,
as opposed to polarizing and devising approaches to governing. And so, in my case, I can't find
a better way to explain than using the examples we have at hand during the pandemic. Most heads
of states, female heads of states, are doing a very good job, and this is not casual. This is
because there is a different style of leading in the case of women. And I've seen those articles.
So, New Zealand was cited as doing a good job with COVID. Germany, although there has been a
peak with COVID, was also cited as doing a good job with COVID. And these are places where they
have women leadership. Let me just go back to Veronica. She's got a very specific question for
you. Can we see differences in countries with higher percentages of women in legislature as
being fairer than countries with less? Do women in power make a difference as far as gender equality
policies are concerned? Those two things don't always go together, Laura. Quick answer to that,
please. Yeah, go ahead. Do we see a difference in equality with more women in power? Laura's
quiet. Maybe she cannot hear me. All right, let me just move on a little bit. Laura, can you hear
me? Go ahead. Yes, yes. No, excuse me. Can you repeat the question? Sorry. Yes. What Veronica
wanted to know is, if you have these women in power, women leaders, do you see a difference
in gender equality policies? Are the countries better? Yes, yes, of course. I had the opportunity
to talk to some of them. I have been in contact with many of them for many years. And it is very
common to find that women are more concerned about the social conditions of people. So,
in a certain way, we decide about economic policy, about infrastructure policy, about technical
policy in terms of the social impact on the different sectors, and even the most vulnerable
ones. So, you can find differences, but also you can find important problems in terms of
more political participation of women in politics. Look at the case of Latin America. After we had
seven women leading different governments, now we don't have, that is true. But after that,
most of the Latin American countries, you were able to get 50% or parity in Congress. And that
was because those women in power, those presidents, were supporting the new leadership.
So now, although we don't have women presidents, we have 50% in many countries of young women
in Congress, and they are the future, probably, presidents of many Latin American countries. So,
the answer is yes, there is a difference. The answer is yes. Excellent. All right, Michael,
I want to come back to you and your work, because when we talked earlier, it was your work that you
felt would help in terms of making progress towards gender equality. And your work is working
with men and boys to reduce gender-based violence. Can you capture what it is that you're doing and
how you would share that philosophy with our audience? For this forum, I suppose I'd say
that the most surprising thing that's happened in terms of gender and gender equality over the last
two decades, I think, has been the resurgence of a backlash, the kind of intensified,
male-dominated movements and even governments that really show a kind of hyper-masculine
set of beliefs and authoritarian, patriarchal understandings of gender.
No one predicted that in the 80s, the idea that things would go backwards in such a significant
way. And I think that engaging men and boys in productive discussions about gender and in
fostering healthy masculinities is a key preventative strategy there. So, I and others,
yes, my work is in part to prevent men's violence, but part of that is also about
lessening resistance and backlash. Because I think if we leave, for example, young men to
their own devices online and elsewhere, then growing numbers of young men will continue to
be radicalised, not radicalised into violent extremism, but into sexist extremism and,
in fact, forms of violence as well. So, I think that to make progress towards gender equality,
one strategy, it's not the magic solution, but one thing we will have to step up is to engage
men and boys in ways that can address the anxieties and insecurities that some men feel,
but can offer alternative healthy models of manhood or personhood that can be part of
gender equality. Yes, one of the things that I've noticed from the questions, thank you everybody
for your questions, they're excellent. Several questions on supporting grassroots activists,
civil society movements, scaling bottom-up approaches and engaging in marginalised groups
of women. It's always concentrating in a very similar area. Kalyani, do you want to start with
that about what you would advise, because people are coming to you because you're all
brilliant in your different fields, but if we're talking grassroots up, what advice would you give
people? I feel completely unequipped to give advice, but I just want to say that what we are
realising, and when I say we, I mean the women's movements in India, which I'm aware and I'm a part,
many of us are realising that what we need to do is to build bridges between different movements
and between different streams within the women's movement. So we need people in dialogue with each
other to really understand the way in which the system works. So we've got a very powerful
environment movement, a very powerful climate justice movement, we have powerful women's
movements, we have movements for civil rights and political rights, but I think the ways in which
we talk to each other has been, I mean if one was being really mean, one would say transactional,
but we have not been able to work together to develop our understanding of what needs to change
and how we can work together to change it. So at the grassroots, this is a powerful
impetus now and it's not just in our country, but across the world, the connections between
movements are growing stronger. So if you look at the Green New Deal, the groups that are coming
around, coming together around the Green New Deal, you have people from all different movements and
not just women either. So there are trade unions, there are workers' movements, there are women's
rights movements, there are masculine men's rights and men for pro-feminist men's movements
are all coming together because I think really what all of us are understanding in our different
ways is that we need a different paradigm. How do we get to that paradigm? How do we get to a point
where we articulate that paradigm? I mean we are clear on what we want. We want a development
system that acknowledges, that respects the connections between land and life, between the
market economy and the economy of nature, the economy of care, between the home and the outside world,
between economic relationships and relationships of care. We want a paradigm that sustains these
relationships and that puts equality, justice, peace, well-being for all and survival for the
planet at the centre. So how to get there is really the challenge and I think all of us grassroots
groups in our different ways are trying to advance that convocation, widen that dialogue.
I have a challenging question for you guests for the very end of our conversation. So it's a
thought, the first thought that comes into your mind, I will accept that because then we're going
to wrap up. The inspiration is Christina Boylan from New York Polytechnic Institute. Thank you
Christina for the inspiration. Christina was wondering what action plans can we take to
rebuild economies and societies post-Covid that do not recreate gender inequalities?
Like this can be your wish list, it can be fantastical, it can be, if only we use this
opportunity of this global pandemic to do this, what would this be? It is a sentence, so it is
really projecting what is possible, the future, bearing in mind where we are with our global pandemic.
Laura, what would you say? It is not an easy question but I would like to say two things,
one about human development and one about democracy. Concerning human development,
it is very clear that we need to allocate more resources, more attention to women issues in
every country, in every nation. We are talking about having access to these kind of advanced
capacities and not only capacities as the Human Development Report very clearly explained last
year. And concerning democracy, which is at the stakes during this year, I would say that if we
want more women in power, we must defend and protect democracy. Autocratic and populist
leaders undermine democracy and this works against women's leadership. So the cost of
democracy is deeply ahead. All right, thank you so much. I really appreciate your presence in our
conversation today. Michael? I really liked Kalyani's succinct, passionate manifesto. It reminds me of
those notions of feminism for the 99% and I think that's a very inspiring vision.
We need a human rights and social justice agenda, it has to be grounded in community
and whatever we do, it has to be done in partnership with or led by women's rights
groups and movements. Thank you Michael, really appreciate your participation today. Kalyani,
your sentence, what would it be? Projecting into the future. It could be something you've already
said. I think it might be. Go ahead. Develop and call for a policy framework that
dissolves the separation between the monetized economy, markets and production on one side,
and the maintenance economy, that is natural resources, care and human life on the other side.
Just dissolve. Thank you so much. Thank you so much guests, thank you so much audience for your
excellent questions and engagement. Really appreciate you. This has been a UNDP production
and if you want to follow the 30 years anniversary of the Human Development Report,
look out for it on social, hashtag 30 years of HDR. This wraps up our conversation for today,
thanks for watching everybody. Bye.
