"Thucydides: The Great Historian of Ancient Greece (Thucydides, Pt. 1) "

History TV Epic
4 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 15, 2025
"New lecture series on Thucydides, author of The History of the Peloponnesian War. In part one, we will explore why many academics view Thucydides as the first scientific historian, owing, chiefly, to his empirical, historical method of evaluating and scrutinizing primary sources and mining for data and evidence. In this video, we contrast Thucydides with another great historian, Herodotus. Herodotus wrote on the Greco-Persian Wars; Thucydides wrote on the epic conflict between Athens (the Delian League) and Sparta and her allies (the Peloponnesian League).
Timecodes:
0:00 - Intro
3:42 - Historical Method
16:13 - Herodotus"
Hello everybody, Professor Barth is here, associate professor of history at Arizona State University. So today I'm very excited to begin a new
Playlist here on my channel entitled foundations of Western political thought
Over next year, maybe a couple years from time to time. I will contribute a four maybe five part
lecture series on a particular thinker that I believe to be especially
essential foundational
to
The history of Western political thought and I'm gonna begin this series with a look at Thucydides
Thucydides the great historian of ancient Greece who lived from 460 to 400 BC
Now who was Thucydides
Why should you take him so seriously why should why should you in?
2022
Pay any mind to to this man. Well, I think that you will find
That as we look at his famous history of the Peloponnesian War
That Thucydides has much to say
about
Transcendent themes that remain every bit as relevant today as they did back then and those themes include power
Realism pragmatism and human nature. This is a great work of history is considered one of the greatest works of the ancient world
But it's more than just a historical account of the war
It tells us a whole lot about the human condition and and and we'll have much to to analyze as we look through
Thucydides work
The Peloponnesian War was epic conflict. Obviously for 31 to 404 BC
The Greek city-states had just recently defeated the Persians the Persians earlier in the 5th century had invaded
The the Greek city-states the Greeks at the Athenians and Spartans together
push back the Persians decisively to feed them but
almost immediately division
rivalry between Athens and her allies known as the Delian League and the Spartans and their allies known as the Peloponnesian League and
One of the reasons why this was such an intense rivalry
Besides the fact that you know, Athens was a sea power a Spartan Sparta was a land power
But one of the great sources of this rivalry was that both sides had polar opposite visions of what we would call political
economy the Athenian vision
vastly
Monumentally different from the Spartan vision. We'll take a look at that in part three of this lecture series, but
Thucydides understood that this was a
Majorly important war a war like no other that the world had seen and
So he wants to work. He records this account. He wants to preserve
What happened for for people like us two and a half millennia later?
To to read and to to remember to understand and in this history of the Peloponnesian War
in the preface Thucydides says this I
Began to write as soon as the war was afoot
With the expectation that it would turn out to be a great one and that
More than all earlier wars this one would deserve to be recorded
This was certainly the greatest upheaval there had ever been among the Greeks
I am confident that nothing great happened in or out of war before this
quite a statement, but
what a war it was and in Thucydides gives us a very precise and
There's an accurate account of that war and for that reason
Thucydides is known generally today as the father of scientific history
Not the father of history that that title goes to Herodotus
We'll mourn Herodotus in a moment, but the father of scientific history and what made
Thucydides historical method so scientific
Well Thucydides was very careful that his his research his writing was empirical based in in
Observable phenomena
evidence based
Thucydides
Placed a lot of weight on eyewitness testimony. He interviewed participants. He consulted written documents
He was present for much of the war. In fact, he was a general more on that in a second
but Thucydides
Showed
Thucydides was very reluctant to include anything in his history that
That was unsupported. He just didn't want to do it. He strove for accuracy
precision objectivity and and also importantly
impartiality impartiality
He wanted us to be as objective and account of the war as possible now, he's a he's from Athens and so
In reality in the history there's a slight bias for Athens, however
It's very clear that he that he's sincerely and successfully
Delivered a a
Fair account of the Spartans from the Spartan perspective. He did not hesitate to point out the various weaknesses of deficiencies
The the inadequacies of the Athenian leadership of the Athenian military is very critical of Athens
and so
He desires this unbiased account. He wants to give a bird's-eye view of the war
He was very also very interested in cause and effect. What caused the war?
He said I want to know I don't want you know, I don't want to hear Athenian propaganda or Spartan propaganda
I want to know the actual cause of this event. He was interested in the effect of different of different actions poor decisions good
decisions
now
like I said
This is was a general during a war but he ran into some trouble
in the city of amphipolis the spark is a
part of the Athenian Empire
Northeastern Greece the Spartans invaded
The city news was called to defend the city, but he took his time getting there
He it it took a while to get there. This is in 424 BC and by the way amphipolis was
very important from a strategic angle
so
Didn't get there on time. And by the time he arrived the Spartans had captured the city and I did a
go-search on
battle amphipolis and these images came out found at this from Assassin's Creed so
Do what you will with it, but?
the cities was blamed for the loss of
Amphipolis now he he swore that that he had nothing to do with the loss, but he was recalled to Athens
Put on trial and then exiled for 20 years and during that 20 year long exile
Thucydides traveled freely among the Spartans and their Peloponnesian allies and had the advantage of viewing the war from their perspective
He says this in his history. It was also my fate
to be in exile from my country for 20 years after my command at amphipolis and
Being present with both parties and more especially with the Peloponnesians by reason my exile
Peloponnesians were the Spartan allies. I
Had leisure to observe affairs somewhat particularly. So this was a privilege that
Thucydides had in in writing this history that he had a rare privilege that he had was
Resided in both sides of the conflict now you could say perhaps he's biased against
Athens because of his exile and he was certainly critical of like as I already noted of many aspects of
Athenian democracy
but
What this allowed was
Okay, here's a Spartan perspective
Herodotus who writes on the Greco-Persian War more on him in just a second
He doesn't get that he doesn't travel freely among the Persians. Okay
Thucydides does in the case with the Spartans and so that gives him another additional advantage in writing this history
Another bit of
information on Thucydides method Thucydides was
Very careful to deploy what modern historians today call source criticism source criticism
So it's not just enough to as a historian
To mine the data and evidence and and to look at the written documents. No, you've got a
You have to analyze you have to evaluate those sources
With a scrutinous eye. He you have to you have to ask yourself. Okay. I've got the source. Is this credible?
Is this a reliable source is who is the author is the author bias?
Is there a possibility that?
The information in the source isn't isn't entirely
True okay right now. I'm writing my second my second book on
In the history of the continental currency during the Revolutionary War and the hyperinflation that resulted looking a lot of primary sources
I've got to ask myself
These same questions source criticism and Thucydides does this Thucydides is very careful to do that and in his preface. He writes this
Great quote from a historical method angle
Quote I have looked into the evidence as far as can be done
The reader should believe that I have investigated these matters adequately using the best evidence available
Even for events at which I was present myself. I tracked down detailed information from other sources as far as I could
It was hard work to find out what happened because those who were present at each event gave different reports
Depending on which side they favored and how well they remembered so Thucydides. It's not enough to just collect the sources
He's got to scrutinize those sources and he does so and he does so quite successfully because of that work
We have what we can a fairly reliable and dependable account of the Peloponnesian War, which we would not have had
Otherwise, he also says this in a preface
the search for truth
Strains the patience of most people who would rather believe the first things that come to hand and he's so right about that
But for Thucydides, it's all about the search for truth. What is the true cause of the war? What really happened?
During the Peloponnesian War and that is what most interest Thucydides and so
the war
the account of the war now
You have to back up a little bit
Two caveats one
Because Thucydides is so evidence-based and focused on
Sources and an objective account. There might be a temptation to think if you haven't read the book. Wow
This must be a really dry history. It's not it's a
Thucydides writes in a narrative style. He's deeply influenced by
The epic poetry of the day in Greece. And so this is a narrative history. He's a good he's a talented writer
But also another thing to know
This history includes some lengthy formal speeches
In which these might not be necessarily
exact quotations
For example, he gives us a lengthy speech of Pericles his funeral oration
Which we will look at in a in a future lecture soon
Thucydides was almost certainly present at this speech. So he was there
He may have interviewed other people who were there to refine his memory
But it's a lengthy speech. How exact is that speech in reality? Well
Pericles also there's also like the last speech of Pericles in the midst of the deadly Athenian plague prior to his death
Pericles delivers this last speech was to say is there maybe maybe even probably it's hard to say but
How exact is that speech and then especially the Melian dialogue? Whoa, what the Melian dialogue? I can't wait to discuss that one. It's a
fantastic dialogue between the Athenians and and the inhabitants of the island of Milos and
Thucydides was not there. He was not there for that. Well, how dependable is this dialogue?
Almost certainly interviewed people who were there
and so, you know, there's debate about how accurate these speeches are
but to Thucydides credit
he admits
That these might not be exact quotations. Take a look at this quote from his from this preface
What particular people said in their speeches either just before or during the war was hard to recall exactly
Whether they were speeches I heard myself
Such as Pericles of speeches or those that were reported to me at secondhand almost certainly a Melian dialogue. I
Have made each speaker say what I thought his situation demanded
Keeping as near as possible to the general sense of what was actually said now. That's
What we make of that sentence. I
Made each speaker say what I thought his situation demanded
Okay, so the question is how much of these speeches are Thucydides and not the actual
Not what was actually said
That's what one question and then but he does say keeping as near as possible to the general sense
Of what was actually said what does that general sense mean?
Two things on this I'm it's
So the question is how much of this is literary reconstruction these speeches is it Thucydides speaking here?
He's actually said
I'm of the opinion. Yes that there is some
Literary reconstruction here, but I'm of the opinion that this is actually fairly fairly accurate these speeches that we will take a look at
In the what in the upcoming lectures
These are fairly accurate speeches
Thucydides was there for maybe two of these three that we'll look at and and interview participants of the others and
Thucydides seems to
Strikes me as someone who genuinely wants to act what actually happened and the other thing to consider is that
The human memory was a lot stronger in the ancient world, okay today we're just bombarded with sensory information and
Actually, our brains have altered a bit. The brain is not to go off subject, but the brain is very malleable
You know that now science has discovered that the brain is
Their brains change
depending on the environment we're in in that the
Human mind human memories in the ancient world were almost certainly more capable of memorizing
lengthy
Speeches and
Passages than human beings today, so don't forget that the ancient, you know when we read when we consider oral sources
From the ancient world
Do not
underestimate the ability of ancient writers to remember
Lots and lots of information in an accurate manner. And so I'm more of the opinion that this is that these
That these speeches are fairly reliable that we can take them
And and I will in this lecture series take them
Generally at face value with with the the little footnote of there might be a little bit of literary reconstruction here
So there's two cities the father of scientific history, but I noted not the father of history that goes to
Herodotus in
His famous the histories and you'll know it note the dates of his life
Herodotus was in the belong to the generation preceding Thucydides
We know very very little about
The life of Thucydides we know quite a bit more about Herodotus
Herodotus came from a wealthy family when he was a youth. He traveled all around the eastern Mediterranean. He even went
Into the ventured into the Middle East settled in Athens, but in 430 BC
He authored this great work really a founding work of history
The histories on the Greco-Persian Wars and think
Because of Herodotus we know a lot more about the Greco-Persian Wars than we would otherwise
And
Brilliant stories just brilliant storyteller. He could he could tell he could tell a story like none other he's probably a great writer
I probably he was a great writer than Thucydides
Thucydides was a talented writer of Rochester. He takes it
Herodotus
Was not just interested in the political and military history because to be frank Thucydides
This is mostly political military history Herodotus also looks at cultural practices customs
Social practices of the Greeks and of the Persians
Here's some quotes from from Herodotus that are are worthy of
including in this in this lecture
Circumstances rule men men do not rule circumstances
Great deeds are usually wrought at great risks
Far better is it to have a stout heart always and suffer one share of evils and to be ever fearing what may happen
great quotes
but
Let me give you a couple others two more. I
Am bound to tell what I am told but not in every case to believe it
No, what does he mean by that? Well
Herodotus included in his work
Quite a few entertaining tales
For example, he included
oracles
The the priests who who prophesied certain events he included those in his in his history
He included tales that even Herodotus himself knew were likely
fables the mere rumor or
or a legend
Why did he include these? Well, they circulated among the people and so was Herodotus that I look
Again I'm not I'm bound to tell what I'm told not in every case believe it. I'm bound to know what I'm told
So he includes those
in the history
Herodotus
Here's another quote. There's plenty of convincing evidence that the gods play a part in human affairs
Now I agree with that. I believe in divine providence, but it's very very difficult to prove
when
divine intervention occurs how it occurs why it occurs at what point and in
Defense of Herodotus. He doesn't at no point in his history
Do the gods directly act in a way that but but the gods are in the background and and for Thucydides
They are not they don't play any role
Now I want again in defense of Herodotus
Herodotus was a scholar. He was a researcher. In fact, actually the word
History comes from the Greek word historia, which means research actually the middle name of my second daughter is
Historia
Research and so there is research here. He compiles data. He looks at evidence
To support his his narrative, but there's an entertainment
Component and actually works of this day
were
oftentimes recited at
festivals like the Olympic Games
Herodotus
Herodotus's work was almost certainly
In that category prizes were won for the most entertaining work and so he had an objective here
You wanted an entertaining history and it sure is
This is an entertaining work
The extremely valuable work and no doubt. There's a whole lot of truth in it, but there's speculation. There's fable
There's rumor. There's entertainment and there's also partiality
Herodotus does not
Pretend to be impartial. He makes no bones about it
He's impart he's partial he's partial to the Greek city-states
He's not afraid to admit it. He's not he's not ashamed of it
for
Herodotus the Greeks represent freedom democracy the independent polis the free citizen the Persians represent
Oppression slavery centralized government serfdom. Okay
And and he's not entirely
Incorrect about that, but it colors his history it impacts the writing. Okay, and and
Thucydides
Strives for the very opposite. He wants to give us impartial as accurate of an account as possible
Thucydides takes a bit of a shot at Herodotus in his preface. Take a look at this quote
This history may not be the most delightful to hear since there is no mythology in it
But those who want to look into the truth of what was done in the past
Which given the human condition will recur in the future either in the same fashion or nearly so
those readers will find this history valuable enough as this was composed to be a
lasting possession and not to be heard for a prize at the moment of a contest a
Lasting possession those who are interested in the truth now in truth
Both of these are lasting possessions. They're both classics in the literature excellent brilliant works
literary works works of history
but for this lecture series, we're gonna take a look at we're gonna dive into Thucydides the history of the Peloponnesian War and
For part two, we're gonna take a look at what Thucydides has to say about human nature
Oh, he has a whole lot to say about human nature. You get a better that here in this quote the human condition
And so lots to glean from that. So we'll check that out for part two. See you there. Bye
