"Thucydides on Nature & War "

History TV Epic
4 followers
5 Video Views·Jan 13, 2025
In this devastating episode, Casey tries to convince you that it could be so much worse. He quotes Thucydides and Tacitus and does a winding digression on Heraclitus. Is Wisdom the offspring of History and Theology? Find out on this episode!
You're here on Nature and War. I'm your host Casey and uh really this is episode one isn't it? I mean
we've done the uh awkward introductions. In fact the first time I get a review on iTunes, we're on
iTunes by the way now, the first time I get a review on iTunes that says you know cool it with
I will cool it but uh thank you for putting up with a bit of this at the start just to just to
break my just to wet my whistle. Thucydides. I am not an expert in Thucydides. I've read
the Peloponnesian War by Thucydides about once and a half times um but I love it. I wish I had
read it when I was younger so it could have settled in a little better but this is me trying
to do you a service. Here we go. Buckle up. One of the distinctive features of history as it's
reported by Thucydides and this is other than his famous unwillingness to include mythic and
supernatural events is his choice to quote generals and politicians and others even when the original
text of their speech is lost. What he does is a kind of literary writing I think but he pulls
it off so effectively that we or like I should just say I because I'm sure some people disagree
here. I generally accept that the speeches quoted are more or less what would have been said. That
is they make sense given like the context of what was going on at the time. The most famous example
in the book is the funeral oration speech delivered by Pericles. If any of you have ever read any
Thucydides it's probably that. Sometimes that little bit makes it as an excerpt into anthologies
and readers uh although generally I mean I have no I was never assigned anything by Thucydides.
Anyway so the speech the the funeral oration speech by Pericles is probably the most famous
chunk of this. He was an Athenian statesman and general but in another speech after Pericles
persuaded Athens to go to war with Sparta when the war turned ugly he then delivered another speech
and it's this one I want to quote up front. Listen carefully to what he says after I take a sip of
don't forget to hydrate. Quote certainly if all else is well and people have the stark choice of
war or peace it is great folly to go to war but if as was the case the stark choice is either to
submit and endure instant subjection to others or to face the risk risks and win through the greater
blame lies in shirking the danger rather than standing up to it and he continues about a page
later you must not let yourselves be seen as doubly inferior to your fathers they acquired
these possessions not by inheritance from others but through their own exertions and furthermore
kept them safe to hand on to you and it is a greater disgrace to be robbed of what you possess
than to fail in its acquisition you must tackle the enemy then not only with conviction but with
the conviction of superiority this is not the same as arrogance even the coward can be arrogant if
his stupidity is combined with good luck but the conviction I speak of derives from a reasoned
confidence in superiority over the enemy and that is what we have intelligent use of this confidence
makes bold initiatives more secure given equality of fortune it does not rely on hope which is a
resort only when there is no other but on a rational conclusion from the facts which affords
a firmer base for planning strategy man isn't that nice I mean my goodness pause here for a minute
before like I'm gonna I'm gonna even continue some of this speech in a second so you can put
a bookmark in your brain there but ladies and gentlemen this is the kind of deliberation
and thoughtfulness and articulateness we want isn't it from our leaders when considering
war and it's also that maybe even more importantly the kind of practical
realism that people need when dealing with their enemies yes Thucydides is very clear that every
people has enemies but if you have wealth and comfort and good health you especially have
enemies because of course they will want what you have listen to Pericles continue this speech he
says and see if this sounds familiar I love this he says you all take pride in the prestige the
city enjoys from empire and you should be prepared to fight in defense of it you cannot shirk the
burden without abandoning also your pursuit of the glory do not think that the only issue at
stake is slavery or freedom there is also loss of empire and the danger from the hatred incurred
under your rule you no longer have the option to abdicate from your empire should anyone out of
present fear affect this idea as noble sounding means of disengagement the empire you possess
is by now like a tyranny perhaps wrong to acquire it but certainly dangerous to let it go
I mean you might have to rewind that because Thucydides writes at a level that is extraordinarily
a big you know big verbal IQ to put it in fancy words right and so and of course we don't know
exactly what Pericles said you can read about Pericles he was supposedly an excellent orator
and you know gave great thought to the speeches before he delivered them so it's possible these
were almost his words but it reads you know it fits right into Thucydides's narrative and so I
like to give Thucydides as much credit as Pericles here but the point is this is this is the political
perspective that is I believe purposely hidden from people especially American people in public
schools and on television and so on we have all been raised to believe that there are no enemies
or at least that's how I was raised by MTV basically and no one who could possibly want
to subvert our country or undermine our empire right that's what we were sort of told I mean
I remember when I was a kid like people from Japan or China or wherever they just all wanted
like Michael Jackson records you know and it was in like McDonald's and so we felt like who could
possibly you know not like America we never thought of like having enemies when I was a kid
especially after the Cold War but Thucydides warrants I mean he is not into this he says
many I mean like I said many of us have come to believe that it would be good if we abdicated
from our empire and sort of fold it and let someone else rise to the top we've been taught
that it wouldn't harm us much or that everything would be better if America would pack it in
but Thucydides warns that that is not a realistic option if you do fold and give up and become so
weak as to let enemies take what is now yours they will not govern you kindly because they
do not feel that they have been governed kindly this is the zero-sum game and it tears the kumbaya
mindset that's taught in Sunday schools and public schools and everywhere else to shreds
do I wish that kumbaya mindset was the one that worked of course yes I wish children would
voluntarily share their toys with each other that isn't human nature is it and Thucydides knew it
and he put it at the front of his discussion of what was going on in this 27 year war that
took place between I think about 430 when was it four four might be 435 or so a bc right so
somewhere in the kind of second half of what would be the 5th century bc is when this war takes place
so we read Thucydides I mean hold on did I get to play my there was a clip I wanted to play there
here it is ready here's here's your clip that I should have played just a minute ago darn it I
missed it there comes a time when we heed a certain call when the world must come together as one
there are people dying oh yeah whoa oh there are people dying what is that that's uh we are the
world and if you're exactly 42 years old that song may have shaped your whole consciousness
like it did mine I was seven when it came out I knew every word I sang along to the music video
Kevin from the Wonder Years is seen standing there in the front row and singing or if it wasn't him
it was you know Lionel Richie somebody else so okay so that's the mindset that we are taught
and that I think our you know um our uh like legislators and rulers and elites kind of want
us to have it is not the one that Thucydides presents in the Peloponnesian War and that's
what makes this book so interesting and so uh important we read Thucydides because he gives
us a window into a world where and this is my thesis statement today it's really a hypothesis
hypotheses I guess where he gives us a window into a world where the logos doesn't reign
I will explain what I mean by that before you know this podcast ends if not before this episode
ends but this is a very big thought it's one I hadn't considered before I was about 38 years old
in fact it's such a big idea that it will be the idea that helps me organize this entire podcast
every episode constituting a tiny part of the big picture and after 100 episodes if you listen
carefully I hope you will understand what I think I'm starting to understand about this stuff which
is again the world where logos doesn't reign is brutal brutal much worse than anything we've seen
in our lifetimes before we get further into Thucydides there was something else I meant to
say at the top first of all we're on iTunes that's the one thing we're on iTunes now you can
find it in the podcast app listen there it's probably easiest like it review it rate it send
it to your mom do me those favors I'm not asking for your money yet okay the other thing is there
was a correction from episode one humiliating correction to have to make I was saying something
about the Presocratics and I said something about Parmenides and Heraclitus and quote
Xenophon what an idiot I'm sure you all knew that I meant Xenophones so embarrassing thanks for not
calling me out on it okay I don't think there's any other housekeeping stuff as Sam Harris would
say I'm not gonna do the Thucydides himself was a so-and-so guy born and so-and-so biography stuff
just because I'm on kind of limited time here but you should probably read his Wikipedia entry
but his main work was the Peloponnesian War which covers this terrible conflict between Athens and
Sparta which were independent city-states but really the alliances that formed around those
two city-states and that lasted as I said 27 years have you do see if any of you I mean I'm
not an expert in this but here's a little quick clip on what you know you've probably heard
referred to as game theory what makes NASA's theory of equilibrium so special is that it
presupposes that in each game there is at least one point of equilibrium and all players will be
better off trying to find it and form their strategy around it this momentous revelation
help people in disciplines like politics war economics business and social theory understand
the world better and form better strategies okay so this is the you've probably like I mean
I'm not an expert like I said but you've probably heard of this and it's the idea that like sometimes
if we kind of cooperate there can be a better outcome for everybody relatively and it involves
thinking about like the worst case scenario and the best case outcome and kind of doing that little
punnett square or whatever anyway okay so that's that but what I was going to say is
there are in my imagination now having read Thucydides two planet earths the one in which
logos which is essentially Christianity although perhaps we could argue about that later the one
in which logos has delivered us from constant war and tribal strife and then the one that goes the
other way right and you might say well we have lived through plenty of wars Casey you know come
on what are you talking about no no you have heard reports of war and seen images of military
theater and yes a certain number of real human lives may have been involved but the vast majority
of people weren't threatened by these wars and the social order may have even been reinforced by
these wars like I said I was almost 40 years old before I understood this and I don't see how a
modern person can understand this without reading Thucydides and Polybius or listening to this
podcast okay what didn't I see and what am I claiming you probably don't see well it's the
absolute horror of it quote the Thracians poured into the city and began sacking the houses and
temples and slaughtering the people they spared neither old nor young but automatically killed
every person they found children and women also and even the very beasts of burden and any other
living creature they could see these Thracians when they have nothing to fear are as bloodthirsty
as any other barbarian race even the worst and here in my solace they brought total panic and
destruction in every form including the invasion of the largest school in the place when the pupils
had just come in for their lessons they butchered the entire school whoa right now nothing like that
has really happened certainly not in America for centuries I mean people might claim that something
like you know September 11th was in a similar event or whatever a school shooting but really
the fact of these being one-off events is what makes them fall short the ancients lived in a
world where 9-11 was a commonplace it happened all the time piracy Thucydides says in the early pages
piracy was considered among the more noble ways of life like in this era or before this era
as soon as he this is a quote as soon as traffic in ships developed between them piracy was the
recourse of the ancient Greeks and of the barbarians occupying the coastal regions of the
mainland and the islands they fell for their plunder on unwalled communities with populations
scattered in villages and this was much of their livelihood such occupation did not yet carry any
stigma rather it even brought some glory end quote to me reading I mean this is kind of this I mean
this is all amazing but the really staggering part about reading Thucydides is that he himself
seems to have accepted these things as basically normal as natural and this is part of the I guess
title of this podcast right nature is brutal Thucydides sees and why wouldn't it be right
I mean ho hum but of course the toll it took on families was unimaginable here's another quote
he says throughout the seven days for which Eurymedon remained there after his arrival with
the 60 ships the Corcyraeans continued to murder those of their own people whom they considered
enemies the general charge was of conspiring to subvert the democracy but some were killed
out of private hostility and others by their debtors who had taken loans and owed them money
death took every imaginable form and as it happened at such times anything went and then worse still
fathers killed their sons men were dragged out of the sanctuaries and killed beside them
some were even walled up in the temple of Dionysus and killed there like whoa you guys right you got
to see it you got to picture it in your imagination the Peloponnesian war lasted 27 years with hardly
any interruption except to deal with a plague and it involved almost every tribe from Italy to the
Black Sea technically the Spartans won but the Spartans themselves were decimated by other wars
within a couple hundred years and it wasn't in greater Greece only that this inhumanity reigned
a minor digression here because I want you to understand sort of the bigger picture this
podcast is trying to put together and here I'm going to quote from Tacitus Tacitus is a what
five centuries later Roman historian and here he's describing the kind of not yet civilized
German tribes he says quote there is a practice sometimes which has become the universal custom
among the chatty as soon as they reach manhood they let their hair and beard grow long and do
not cut them until they have killed an enemy it is a vow and a pledge to valor to cover their face
when they are standing over the bloody corpse and the spoils they lay bare their faces
and say that they have at last brought back booty deserving of recognition and have shown
themselves worthy of their parents and their fatherland the cowards and the unwarlike retain
their unkempt hair wow the bravest also wear an iron ring like a manacle a mark of dishonor among
that people until they have released themselves from it by killing an enemy disavow needless to
say but the point is the whole world was more violent more tribal more aggressive more murderous
and still I know there will be listeners who are inclined to shrug and write off these examples as
anecdotal or by some sort of chronological snobbery they will believe that progress is
somehow a part of nature and that even if those humans back then lived like that we enlightened
modern you know iPhone using gentle people we would never behave in like manner the Roman historian
Appian records in his civil wars that in 71 BC the famous road leading into Rome the Appian Way
was lined with more than 6,000 crucifixes bodies of rebellious slaves hanging on each
I mean maybe you've seen the horrifying image of three or four bodies hanging from an overpass
outside Juarez Mexico you know the collateral damage of some drug war but can you imagine
6,000 of them lining I-95 as it passes through Washington DC and that scene occurred during the
a period characterized by relative peace where citizens were generally pleased to live in such
stable circumstances I'm trying to drive home this one point that world could easily exist again
and darkly I predict that it will unless we come to understand so that we can defend
a dynamic that gives rise to a different truly more peaceful way of living and so to clarify
my idea here is that we have been living in the luxurious afterglow the momentum
generated by the Logos by Christianity and that if sorry and that if we let go of that foundation
society will probably eventually return almost certainly eventually return to the kind of
brutality we saw before Christianity the kind described by Thucydides see if you remember
this quote from a movie what if no one goes for the blonde we don't get in each other's way
and we don't insult the other girls it's the only way we win that's the only way we all get laid
what is that a beautiful mind right what if no one goes for the blonde what if we cooperate we
don't go for her but together we will all be stronger all right so you get the idea right
my main claim is that Logos is real and divine and the only thing standing between a world where
we study things like this and you know the other world which is terrible and absolute horror
my purpose really in the Thucydides episode but also in many of these episodes will be to kind of
haunt you by that idea because I think it causes people to reflect then on like well what should
I mean is it possible like if imagine a child raised in an ice cream shop with unlimited access
to the chocolate and vanilla soft serve spigots is it possible to show that child so many clear
images of starvation of desert life of war infectious disease brutality that he finally
begins to appreciate his current situation so this is an attempt to tell a very old story
for modern times that's a line right out of the beginning of homer's odyssey almost
because of course homer was writing about the trojan war which happened sometime around 1200
bc but he wasn't writing it until 700 bc it was already an ancient story by the time he wrote it
down so the point is and like this story is much older than ancient greece I mean our next episode
I'm going to do the epic of Gilgamesh it may this story may be so old that like it's the oldest I've
heard stories of like a 21,000 year old cave painting depicting you know a cyclopean giant
and a hero in conflict right like this is this is war this is the shape of war the structure of war
and so again you know I'm trying to make us be realistic about how this this happens
and it's going to keep happening but we can minimize it maybe so anyway like so many stories
we begin in the middle of the action we zoom in on the greater mediterranean around the time of
the pyramids let's say in egypt when they were being constructed and we don't have perfect data
about what we see during that time this story becomes clearer around the time of homer's
writings but it seems that it was basically warfare warfare warfare okay and by the time we
get to thucydides the picture becomes clearer the picture includes the corinthians the
thessalonians the ephesians the colossians the philippians the galatians the romans and the
hebrews you recognize those i hope you do those are books in the new testament right those are
the locations that paul was writing to telling them about what the good news the logos is here
thucydides wrote quote what is now called greece was not originally a country of stable settlements
in earlier times there were constant migrations any group readily moving on from its present land
each time they were forced out by others who happened to be superior in numbers there was
no trade no secure communication with each other by land or sea each group grazed its own lands for
subsistence not building up financial reserves or farming the land as it was never known when
so like that's where we start and i mean there's so many i wish i could do many episodes on this
book and tell you about all the crazy war scenes the the uh the triremes battering each other with
the weird apparatuses and the men in their hoplite costumes and you know dying and just like it's
terrible okay men dying all over the place famines pestilence whichever side won thucydides records
raped the women and enslaved the children after killing all the men on the losing side
and such was life hold up a little water remember to stay hydrated
but simultaneously if you look a little closer you zero in slow your brain down a little bit
you see that in the sort of front corner of this stage there are a few thinkers tinkering with
heraclitus from ephesus which is in modern turkey the parmenides of elia which is located in what's
now southern italy you probably heard of them the presocratics meandering laboriously through purely
abstract labyrinthine arguments that seemed contradictory or absurd they were trying to
answer some question that perhaps hadn't even been properly formulated yet was reality changing or
static was it many or one was nature the essence of reality or only a reflection of reality
etc why were the presocratics so good at generating questions well i think it was related to the
situation in this strife filled world where meaning is up for grabs because values are only
established when identity and sovereignty are established and those are established in war
imagine samuel huntington's famous bit about the clash of civilizations but with far more players
involved these were the birth pangs of the very different world that thank goodness we have
largely inhabited if these men's generated questions that would last for ages though they
survived only in fragments it must have been in part because they themselves had no idea
what world was emerging if you look closer with me at heraclitus look at the the dates right he
was born in 535 bc he died around 475 bc he's long been famous and his stock seems to be rising
even now for introducing the term logos to philosophical discourse and we can return to
this i mean i'll do a whole episode on heraclitus but for now consider that the world he knew by
experience starting around 550 bc 100 years or so before thucydides around the time of his birth
persian empire conquered numerous greek city states particularly focusing on subduing the
ionians and they i'm going to fast forward some here and they crushed ephesus at one point right
during the middle of uh heraclitus's lifetime when he was like my age what did the greeks do in
response they formed what was called the delian league and this is an important part of the story
the delian league is kind of like a political or bureaucratic effort to establish logos it's when
all the city states in greece kind of get together and they start to identify not as enemies now but
as like allies and greece emerges right greater greece to defend itself against the persians
the point is heraclitus grew up in this world absolutely riven by tribal strife he saw alliances
made and broken regimes rise and fall all is flux he famously concluded and no wonder but he
caught a glimpse of something else and there's a couple of really important fragments i'll give you
one and a half of them the first one goes like this he says though logos is true evermore yet
men are as unable to understand it when they hear it for the first time as before they have heard it
at all for though all things come to pass in accordance with this logos men seem as if they
had no experience of them and when they make trial of words and deeds such as i set forth
dividing each thing according to its kind and showing how it truly is but other men know not
what they are doing when awake even as they forget what they do in sleep and that one's
wordy and hard to understand so listen to his shorter more pithy explanation of the logos he
says so we must follow the common yet though my logos is common the many live as if they had a
wisdom of their own logos is common it is shared it is single it suffuses nature and yet only a few
the wise understand this most people seem to think that's my perspective right they each think
their own experience is different and can't be squared away with others so these are like i said
fairly well known and maybe i'll come back to them in future podcasts the point is i i mean what is
this what is going on here like is there some sort of i mean in a sense he'll like there's another
sorry there's another fragment from periclitus where he says the wise is one only it is unwilling
and willing to be called by the name of zeus okay zeus like that's really interesting right what is
he talking about this is some sort of like proto monotheism zeus is common zeus is shared by all
there's this is like he's he's sort of groping for the idea of monotheism like right out of the
heart of like paganism here and consider a paragraph from sophocles written a generation
after the delian league was formed shall we lose faith in delphi's obscurities we who have heard
the world's core discredited and the sacred wood of zeus at ellis praise no more the deeds and the
strange prophecies must make a pattern yet to be understood zeus if indeed you are lord of all
thrown in light overnight and day mirror this in your endless mind our masters call the oracle
words on the wind and the delphic vision blind their hearts no longer no apollo and reverence
for the gods has died away and that is like one generation before thucydides so the gods the
reverence for the gods has died away and now all you have is not logos but just perspective right
everybody seeing things differently thinking their own thing etc and this is where the violence the
scene of the violence unfolds in thucydides again i'll come back to all this stuff about logos but
that's like how i'm reading it okay now uh well actually i have one more paragraph if you can
stand it on logos like the logos the logos the logos what do i mean by this isn't it just a
physical term having little bearing on political reality i don't think so at all instead i think
that when paul announced logos to the greeks he was inviting them to form a new sort of alliance
self-interest would no longer dominate decisions about policy you know i want the blonde but then
you realize well what if no one goes for the blonde and we sort of team up and you take this
one and i'll take this one and then you know we're all going to win instead i think uh like i
said he invited them to a new sort of alliance self-interest would no longer dominate but rather
cooperation and unification of smaller factions would be possible and so in this way heraclitus
tried to announce logos to the greeks in fact the leaders of the delian league or the archaean or
sorry the achaean league tried to construct something similar to logos something to end
the strife but it was finally paul's vision that took root after logos was made intelligible to the
greeks and to the romans anyone who insisted on holding out as a standalone tribe would be
marginalized the philippians the corinthians the ephesians and the thessalonians would now be
one new people one new man as ephesians chapter 2 says all right a couple more points about
the contrast to all of this political realism or of this political realism is exemplified by the
famous melian dialogue i think it's found in book five of thucydides the athenians call for a very
honest dialogue saying quote keep this discussion practical within the limits of what we both really
think you know as well as we do that when we are talking on the human plane questions of justice
only arise when there is equal power to compel in terms of practicality the dominant exact what
they can and the weak concede what they must end quote and the melians replied immediately
there is advantage and we must speak of advantage since you have put justice to one side and made
expediency the basis of discussion there is advantage in your preserving the principle of
the common good dot dot dot then the discussion goes on for a very nervous tentative five more
pages from there and logos you know is one thing i mean political alliances are another it never
goes quite smooth in thucydides so for understanding and reporting all of this thucydides is also
considered to be the father of modern political realism and i think that's maybe maybe the most
valuable part of reading it if you're a naive utopian one more thing about him before i go the
plague great description of a plague in book two of thucydides and it seems timely because of um
corona um he says he himself caught the plague uh i'm just going to read some chunks from this
he says the outbreak it is said originated in ethiopia there were rumors that the peloponnesians
had poisoned the wells uh he says the sensation of burning heat inside the body was so strong
that sufferers could not bear the pressure of even the lightest clothing or sheets or anything other
than going naked and their greatest wish was to plunge into cold water many who had no one to
look after them did in fact throw themselves into cisterns overcome by an insatiable thirst
but as a rule the quantity of water drunk made no difference
a constant infliction with desperate restlessness and the inability to sleep
there were those who on recovery suffered immediate and total loss of memory
not knowing who they were and unable to recognize their friends
thus i'm just skipping around here but the suffering was made yet more acute by the
influx from the country into the city chaotic conditions the dead and the dying were piled on
top of each other and half-dead creatures staggered about the streets and round every fountain craving
for water the sanctuaries in which they had encamped were full of corpses people dying there
were not moved all sacred and secular constraints came to be ignored under the overwhelming impact
of the disaster which left men no recourse all previously observed funeral customs were confounded
um blah blah blah they would bring the corpse to a pyre already lit throwing it on top of the other
bodies in the flames and then run away in here's a here's a fascinating insight into human nature
here too he says in other respects too the plague was the beginning of increased lawlessness in the
people were less inhibited in the indulgence of pleasures previously concealed when they saw the
rapid changes of fortune the prosperous suddenly dead and the once indigent now possessing their
fortune as a result they decided to look for satisfactions that were quick and pleasurable
reckoning that neither life nor wealth would last long no one was prepared to persevere in what had
once been thought the path of honor as they could well be dead before that destination was reached
immediate pleasure and any means sorry and any means profitable to that end became the new honor
and the new value no fear of god or human law was any constraint pious or impious made no difference
in their view when they could see all dying without distinction as for offenses against the law
no one expected to live long enough to be brought to justice and pay the penalty
they thought that a much heavier sentence had already been passed and was hanging over them
so they might as well have some enjoyment of life before it fell
and uh let me see if i can where's the last section i was gonna read to you there there
were also the other thing about this that's so interesting is they did consult the oracles they
had like a sense of the supernatural consulting the oracles here would be i mean what's weird is
it's like on the one hand you think of the oracles as being supernatural but it sounds very
much like the news basically like he talks there's this line where he says oracle mongers chanted all
manner of predictions eagerly snapped up by each man according to his preference so it's like these
oracles i mean a lot of them must have been complete hucksters right just sort of making
stuff up but they still they would go to these temples they they had a there were like i guess
there was like a pan-hellenic or a pan-greek agreement not to destroy the religious temples
in any town so in general they would not do that although in this war it gets so bad towards the
end uh that they just completely desecrate the altars and and sort of stop worrying about that
um let's see is there anything else i wanted to read to you in this the funeral oration i didn't
actually love the funeral oration because it seems so like basic to me um you know he he
sounds like a contemporary american democratic president or something which just isn't all that
interesting um i prefer actually the speech given the sort of anti-democratic speech given later by
uh where he says like um let's see like uh like yeah i'll read you some of this and then i'll
then i'll quit he goes i've often thought on previous occasions that democracy is incapable
of running an empire and your present change of mind over maitelini is a prime example with no
reason for fear or suspicion in the daily conduct of life among yourselves you apply the same
principle to relations with your allies and do not realize that allowing them to talk you into
mistaken policies or succumbing to pity is to display a weakness which spells danger for you
and brings no gratitude from them you do not reflect that your empire is a tyranny exercised
over unwilling subjects who will conspire against you their obedience is not won by concessions
made to your own detriment but by a domination based on force rather than popularity
uh skipping a little bit he says the good sense which comes with intellectual naivete is a more
valuable quality than the sophistication which knows no morals and generally it is the ordinary
folk who make the better citizens compared with their cleverer fellows the clever ones want to
appear wiser than the laws and to win in any public debate and if this was the most important
way of displaying their intellect and the result of such behavior is usually the ruin of their city
the ordinary folk on the other hand with no confidence in their own intelligence
intelligence accept the superior wisdom of the laws and do not presume the polished debater's
ability to dissect a speech but as impartial judges rather than competitors they generally
reach the right conclusion and he talks about this daily rhetoric in the public square he says
the result of these rhetorical contests is that the prizes go to others while the city bears the
risks and you are to blame for organizing these perverse games you like to be spectators of
speeches and an audience of actions you certainly win the prize for gullibility to novel arguments
and rejection of the tried and tested you are slaves to any passing paradox and sneer at anything
familiar every one of you would like to be an orator himself gulp but failing that is keen to
match his wits against those who do have that skill and to show himself abreast of the argument
you applaud a sharp point before it is made you're eager to anticipate what is said but slow to
foresee its consequences you are in effect looking for a different world that sorry a different world
from that in which we live and you cannot even think clearly about our present circumstances
frankly you are in thrall to the pleasure of listening and you sit here more like spectators
at the sofas displays than men taking decisions for their city what a great man isn't that an
amazing book i wish i could say more about it but i'm keeping it to one episode of book
um well maybe we'll come back to that logo stuff in future episodes if there's no logos there's
only one thing that's going to settle any dispute and that's violence all right thanks for listening
see you next time when we discuss the epic of gilgamesh bye
