This Chisel Was Going To Be Thrown Out, So I Saved It.

Create & Repair on all materials
114 followers
1 Video View·Mar 25, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
This chisel was going to be thrown away, but I'm not going to let that happen.
My dad was going through all of his old tools, trying to find some stuff to
help clear out some space, and tucked away in the very back of his tool chest,
we found this chisel. And this thing has had a very, very rough go of it from the looks of it.
The bottom of the handle is mushroomed out, meaning people were using it
in the form of a breaking chisel, which is probably not what this is for.
The head of it has some significant chips showing that it was being used to pry things out.
It's super, super rusted, and overall, it's just in really, really poor shape.
As soon as I saw this chisel, though, I knew it was something worth saving,
and that's because of the fascinating history behind this chisel,
and because the company that makes these chisels is actually regarded as one of the best among
woodworkers. But more on all that later. Let's get started with removing the handle and starting
to turn this chisel back into the beautiful piece of craftsmanship that it should be.
To start removing the handle, I first had to take off this brass retaining ring. It was pretty easy
to remove with a screwdriver, and I also started taking out the wood that was underneath it to
give me more leverage to remove the handle. Should be just about loose now. There we go.
And there's our tang and our handle, which now gives us a chisel to start refinishing.
To get this chisel looking pretty again, I'll be using an abrasive disc, some WD-40,
sandpaper, and some steel wool. Using these things, I'll remove all of the gunk from the surface,
and then I'll sand the metal slightly to remove some of the rust, to polish it up,
and to redefine the cutting edge. And while I do that, I'll explain a little bit of the history
behind the company that made this chisel. So our story actually begins in the late 1700s over in
Sheffield, England, when a one James Butcher, who was a cutler, or one who made silverware,
kind of showed his sons the importance and the profit of a business that makes things out of
metal. And the two brothers, William and Samuel, decided it would be in their best interest to
start their own metal company. In the 1820s, their company started making all sorts of metal tools,
like planes and chisels. They also did razor blades and knives and all sorts of different
things. And many of these, if not all of these products, were marked with W. Butcher. And now
that I've removed some of the gunk from this chisel, you can start to see their signature cross,
arrow, and the B within a circle, which sort of looks like the copyright symbol. On the other side
of the chisel, it's a bit worn down, but you can just make out W. Butcher with cast steel beneath it.
Moving on to the mid-1800s, their business was doing well. They'd built many different workshops
and had started working with other companies, like Philadelphia Steelworks, which is how many
of their chisels ended up in the US. Unfortunately though, both of the brothers died in the late
1800s, which started an eventual decline in the company. Additionally, they didn't do super well
keeping up with all of the innovations in industry that were happening around this time, and by the
1950s, the company was basically extinct. Now this is a very, very abridged version of the
company's history, but if you're interested in learning more, I've linked two sources down in
the bio that tell the entire story, at least as much as I could find. Now even though I did all
this research, I was not able to pin down exactly when this chisel was made, but based on what I've
seen and read, and when the company was most productive, it is likely around 100 years old.
But if you know more than I do, please let me know down in the comments. After doing quite a bit of
sanding and polishing and working, the chisel is just about finished, and I think it is looking
amazing compared to what it once looked like. Here's a little side-by-side so you can get an
idea of how much has gone into making this chisel look much more like it did when it was new. Now
here is our old handle, and this thing had a rough, rough life. So we're going to be actually
modifying our design slightly to have more of the tang of the chisel inside of the handle.
And looking at the wood that I have, I have this really, really neat piece of ambrosia maple that
is a cut off from another project I did, and I think I could make a pretty nice handle using a
piece of this. So I got to work cutting out a blank to put on the lathe, but as I mounted it
on the lathe, I realized that it would not turn on, and the lathe was unfortunately dead. It served
me well for the past couple years, but it was time to get a new one, which actually was a benefit
to the project, as I realized I had a much better wood to use for the handle, which was an old piece
of oak that I got from a salvage yard that used to be part of a barn. This piece of wood is much
harder and would look much closer to the original oak handle. Once the piece was on the lathe,
I started roughing down the corners to get it nice and circular, and started to carve the shape I
wanted into the handle. And while I do this, I'll explain a little bit about why these chisels are
so sought after. So starting with the material of the chisel itself, it's made out of a very, very,
very high quality cast steel, and this allows it to hold an edge super well, as well as being really,
really easy to sharpen. This means that with just a little bit of sharpening, your chisel will get
very sharp and stay sharp for a long time. And virtually every person who I've seen online who
has one of these chisels raves about how good it is in these areas. Additionally, the company made
them in a ton of different sizes, so you can find pretty much any size that you're looking for. And
they're also common enough, at least where I'm from, that you can pick them up from all sorts
of yard sales or estate sales for only a couple bucks a piece. So with all these factors combined,
you're left with a chisel that's nice and cheap, works well, holds an edge well, and will likely
last you the rest of your life if you take care of it well. At this point, I'd finished up the design
for the handle, and all I had to do was sand it to get rid of all of the scratches and to smooth
everything out. It's now time to drill the hole in the handle for the chisel head. And the way I'm
going to be doing this is by using a couple of different drill bits to match the width of the
tang, and then sliding this in and twisting and adjusting until it fits just right. Now I've got
three bits here and one already in the drill, so it'll be four total to fit this hole. So I'm just
going to carefully drill them, starting with the smallest bit first, going all the way in to the
hole, and then matching that spot with all of the other drills. After drilling the four concentric
holes, it was time to fit the tang of the chisel into the handle. Now you may have noticed that the
tang is square, while the holes that I've just drilled are circular. Now to make it so these
two actually fit together nicely, we're going to be using the tang of the chisel almost like a drill
bit. So we'll insert it into the handle and slowly twist and turn it around to scrape out the inside
of the hole we drilled, and to make it fit closer and closer to the chisel. As we twist this hole
out, we're eventually going to reach a point where the chisel body is just barely sticking out of the
hole. And at this point we're going to whack it in with a mallet to make sure it stays nice and tight.
After much twisting and adjusting, the chisel is finally seated quite firmly. I cannot yank them
apart anymore. Now for the final step, is putting just a little bit of tung oil on this handle to
really make it shine and to completely finish off the restoration for this chisel. I love the look
of a fresh tung oil finish. That golden color is really hard to beat. It helps protect the tool
quite well at the exact same time. So just a very nice light coat on there, just enough to fully
protect it. It doesn't need to be fancy or anything crazy, but that should just about do it. Now let
this sit for a day or two to fully dry out, and we'll have ourselves a very very beautiful
finished tool here. Well, now that everything is cleaned up and the tool is completely finished,
I am very very happy with how it came out. I think it looks very pretty, and I love the contrast
between the fresh steel and the nicely stained handle. I also love learning about the history
of the company that made this chisel, and I feel very lucky to have a unique piece of history here
in my workshop that I'll have for many many years to come. I hope you learned something from watching
this, because I sure learned a lot. I've never made a handle like this, and it was a super fun
experience the whole way through. Now if you're interested in a bit more behind the scenes, or
some even more about what I was thinking as I was making the project, consider subscribing to
my Patreon. It helps out a ton, especially considering that I just had to get a brand
new lathe after the last one broke. So it's linked down below. There's all sorts of extra content.
You'll get four videos a month on there, as opposed to the two videos on this channel.
Otherwise though, that's about all I've got on this. So thank you so so much for watching,
and I really look forward to seeing you in the next video.
