These 9 Guns Were Great - So Why did They Fail-.

S&W
1 follower
2 Video Views·Aug 10, 2025
Some guns had everything going for them—great design, solid performance, and strong brand backing—yet they still failed in the market. In this video, we’re looking at 9 firearms that were objectively great but didn’t survive due to bad timing, poor marketing, high prices, or simply being misunderstood by the gun-buying public. Whether you’re a firearms enthusiast, collector, or just curious about what makes a gun succeed or flop, this breakdown will show you why even well-made guns sometimes don't make the cut.
Some guns were built to win, but ended up losing hard. Great ideas, great builds,
innovative engineering, stellar reviews, and still no happy ending. Why do good guns fail?
Sometimes it's bad timing, sometimes it's worse business decisions, and sometimes the market
just isn't ready for what you're selling. Today I'm counting down 9 firearms that had
everything going for them, except success. You might recognize some of these names,
others you probably forgot existed, and that's exactly the problem. Let's dive into the graveyard
of great guns that couldn't make it. Disclaimer, this video is based entirely
on publicly available research and industry analysis. It's not legal advice or a personal
attack on any brand, just an honest look at how certain firearms with great potential
failed in the real world. Your mileage may vary, but the market spoke loud and clear on these 9.
Number 9. Remington RP9. When a legendary American firearms company decides to enter
the striker-fired pistol market, you'd expect something special. Instead, what we got was a
textbook case of how not to launch a duty pistol. This was Remington's attempt to crack the Glock
dominated market in 2017 with the RP9. On paper, it looked promising. 18 plus 1 capacity,
class leading at the time, ergonomic polymer frame with interchangeable backstraps,
modern essentials like an accessory rail and ambidextrous controls. Best of all, an MSRP
that eventually dropped to around $400. With street prices under $350, Remington was clearly
playing the budget game. The RP9 checked every box for competitive service pistol,
high capacity, decent features, big name manufacturer, and a price that should have
made budget conscious buyers take notice. But here's where things went sideways. Early reviews
revealed quality control issues that would make a Taurus blush. 4 out of 5 initial test videos
showed malfunctions. Not a great look when you're trying to break into the Glock dominated duty
market. The problems weren't minor hiccups either. The ambidextrous slide release had a nasty habit
of flexing instead of actually releasing the slide. Some pistols exhibited feeding issues
where rounds would jam between the frame and barrel, causing severe stoppages. Even when it
worked, the RP9 offered nothing special, mediocre trigger, snappier recoil than expected, and
styling that made it look bulkier than the competition. By 2017, the market was already
saturated with proven models from Glock, Smith & Wesson, and Sig Sauer. Remington's reputation
was still recovering from the R51 disaster just a few years earlier. The RP9 was supposed to help
them break into the polymer pistol space. Instead, it became another reminder of why the company was
struggling. The pistol was quietly discontinued as Remington restructured. Unsold inventory got
heavily discounted, sometimes under $300. Not exactly the success story they were hoping for.
8. Tracking Point Precision Guided Rifle
Consider a gun that, with a single button press, could transform any weekend shooter into a
thousand-yard sniper. That isn't science fiction. It was real and far more amazing than anything
Hollywood could imagine. Not only was this a firearm, but it was also a window into the
shooting technology of the future. The Tracking Point Precision Guided Rifle. Tracking Point paired
custom high-end rifles with sophisticated Linux-powered scopes that automatically accounted
for range, gravity, wind, and even earth rotation. The shooter would tag a target in the scope,
and the guided trigger only fired when the aim was perfectly on target.
The precision was absolutely mind-blowing. CNN testers with zero long-range experience were
making thousand-yard shots. A Tracking Point rifle famously took down a wildebeest at over
1,100 yards. This was technology that turned complete novices into precision shooters overnight.
With Wi-Fi streaming and video capture built-in, it was more tech gadget than traditional firearm.
The media went crazy for it, calling it the future of shooting. So, what went wrong? Two words.
Astronomical cost. These rifles ran anywhere from $10,000 to $27,500. That's not a gun purchase.
That's a car payment. Tracking Point expected maybe 500 units in their first year.
Even that modest goal proved optimistic. By 2015, the company was laying off employees down to a
skeleton crew and announced they were no longer accepting orders due to financial difficulties.
Internal issues didn't help either. Multiple CEOs came and went amid disputes over design
and direction. The concept also faced pushback from traditional hunters and shooters who weren't
thrilled about auto-aim capabilities. Tracking Point built groundbreaking technology that almost
nobody could afford or truly needed. They restructured later to provide limited support.
But the damage was done. It remains a landmark innovation that commercially flopped harder than
Italian engineering meets military-grade features in what should have been the perfect modern
sporting rifle. Everything about this design screamed premium quality and cutting-edge
technology. We're talking about the Beretta ARX100, the civilian version of their military
ARX160 service rifle. The ARX100 had everything you'd want in a modern rifle.
Short-stroke gas piston for reliability. Quick-change barrel system that let users swap
barrels without tools. Completely ambidextrous with swappable ejection, safety, mag release,
and charging handle. The folding telescoping stock and lightweight polymer chassis made it
incredibly handy. Field stripping required no special tools. One tester put over 6,000 rounds
through his ARX100 in sand, snow, and mud with zero issues. Beretta promised modular caliber
conversion kits to 7.62x39 and 300 blackout. In theory, this was a serious competitor to the SCAR
or ACR, backed by Italian military engineering and Beretta's reputation.
The reality was less impressive. The ARX100 launched with an MSRP of $1950,
at a time when quality AR-15s were abundant for half that price. Consumers balked. Why
spend two grand on one rifle when you could buy two decent ARs with optics?
But the real killer was Beretta's broken promises. They heavily advertised a modular
caliber-swapping ability, then failed to deliver the conversion kits.
At launch, and for years after, there were no 300 blackout or 7.62x39 kits available.
Sound familiar? It's the same mistake Bushmaster made with the ACR. Companies tout modularity,
fail to supply the promised parts, then wonder why nobody wants their expensive rifles.
The ARX100's £10 military trigger didn't help matters either. Combined with polarizing aesthetics,
poor sales were inevitable. Beretta quietly discontinued it in 2019,
marking another commercial flop in a market where cheaper alternatives won out.
We have six more guns to cover before we move on to the next one. Please do us a favor and like
this video. It doesn't cost you a dime, but it means a lot to us. Now let's get back to the video.
6. Caracal F Sometimes a pistol comes along that has
everything going for it. Great ergonomics, solid engineering, and impressed experts from day one.
Then one catastrophic mistake destroys everything overnight. Meet the Caracal F,
a striker fired 9mm from the United Arab Emirates that went from rising star to cautionary tail
in record time. The Caracal was designed by Wilhelm Bubitz, who helped create the Steyr M
and Walther PPS. It featured a very low bore axis, high grip tang, and crisp trigger,
all contributing to flat shooting and fast follow-ups. Despite being polymer framed with
18 plus 1 capacity, it felt slim in hand. The innovative Quick Sight variant offered an ultra
short sight radius for speed shooting. Early reviews found it accurate, soft shooting,
and reliable. The Caracal became popular very quickly among those who tried it. Here was a
fresh option in the crowded pistol market that could potentially challenge Glock's dominance.
Then disaster struck. In 2013, reports emerged of serious safety issues,
including slides cracking apart during firing. Caracal first recalled some batches,
then eventually recalled all Caracal C compact pistols worldwide. Soon after,
they offered refunds on Caracal F models too. This sweeping recall meant the guns
virtually disappeared from dealers' shelves just as importation had begun. The company's
handling was, to put it kindly, amateurish and botched. Importer issues combined with the recall
wiped out any momentum the brand might have built. By the time Caracal tried a comeback
with an enhanced F model, their reputation was badly tarnished. Consumers asked the obvious
question, why take a chance on an exotic pistol with a problematic past when Glock, XD, and M&P
work just fine? The Caracal was genuinely a great pistol that never recovered from its early
mistakes. It remains a rarity in the U.S. market, a cautionary tale about how quickly things can go
wrong. 5. FN FS2000
What happens when European military innovation meets American civilian shooters who prefer
traditional designs? You get a rifle that's technically brilliant, but commercially doomed.
The FN FS2000 brought truly forward-thinking bullpup design to the U.S. market, and American
shooters basically said, no thanks. Derived from FN's military F2000, the FS2000 was fully
ambidextrous with a unique forward ejection system. Spent casings ejected out of front shoot,
so no more brass in the face for left-handed shooters. It packed a 17.4-inch barrel into a
very compact body with an integrated optic rail. Essentially, rifle-length ballistics in a much
shorter package. The sealed enclosure kept dirt out, and it boasted the high reliability FN is
known for. Reviewers praised it as compact, accurate, reliable, attractive, and ergonomic.
Here was a civilian legal taste of cutting-edge military bullpup technology.
But the FS2000 proved too odd for its own good in the American market. Like most bullpups,
the trigger was heavy and spongy, making precision shooting difficult. The fully enclosed design
created maintenance hassles. Clearing malfunctions was cumbersome, since access to the chamber was
limited. The wide polymer frame felt ungainly and bulky compared to an AR-15. Most fatally,
it carried a premium price over $2,000. American shooters could buy or build two AR-15s for the
cost of one FS2000. That made its quirks much harder to swallow. Sales never took off. FN
shifted focus to their SCAR rifle line and discontinued the FS2000 after only a few years
of modest production. The FS2000 became another example of a finely built and unique rifle that
ended up as a safe queen collectible due to limited civilian demand. Sometimes, being different isn't
enough. 4. Bushmaster ACR
Picture the ultimate modular rifle system. Quick barrel changes, multiple calibers,
tool-less operation, and video game fame to boot. Now picture that same rifle becoming a poster
child for over-promising and under-delivering. That's the story of the Bushmaster Adaptive
Combat Rifle, born from Magpul's highly anticipated Masada prototype. It combined
the best contemporary features – short-stroke gas piston system, folding and collapsible stock,
tool-less quick-change barrels, and multi-caliber capability. The design allowed caliber swaps in
under two minutes. In concept, one rifle could serve as a 5.56 carbine, a 7.62x39 AK alternative,
or even a designated marksman rifle with a caliber change. A true mission-configurable
platform. Early prototypes wowed enthusiasts. Pop culture gave it celebrity status when it
appeared in Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 as a cutting-edge rifle of the future.
Reality was less exciting. Sticker shock did immediate damage at launch. Bushmaster advertised
around $1,500, but the 2010 release came out at $2,600 to $3,000 – double the expectation.
An early recall for a safety issue didn't help. Some ACRs could unintentionally fire
multiple rounds – a feature the ATF definitely did not appreciate.
Meanwhile, parallel military trials yielded no contracts. Without military adoption or
volume sales, the rifle's advanced features languished. The promised caliber conversion
kits arrived eight years late, and only in odd choices like 6.8 SPC and 450 Bushmaster.
Buyers waited in vain for the promised .300 Blackout or AK mag kits that never materialized.
Too little, too late for customers who'd already moved on.
When Remington went bankrupt in 2020, the ACR was shelved. The rifle overpromised and
under-delivered, leaving enthusiasts with an expensive collectible rather than the modular
dream rifle they'd been promised. 3. Remington R-51
Few product launches in firearms history are remembered as complete disasters,
but this one earned that reputation in record time. What started as the bell of SHOT Show 2014
became a cautionary tale about rushing products to market. We're talking about the notorious
Remington R-51, a modern reboot of their classic Model 51. The R-51 used John Peterson's unique
hesitation lock action, scaled up for 9mm. This allowed a very low bore axis and slim slide
design. In theory, it promised softer recoil and muzzle flip compared to blowback or browning
actions. The gun's sleek looks, historic pedigree, and affordable .389 MSRP had enthusiasts very
excited. Here was a single stack 9mm CCW pistol with real innovation behind it.
Then Remington rushed it to market against their engineers' wishes. The first production run was
riddled with reliability problems that turned the launch into a legendary disaster. Reviews reported
constant failures to feed, extract, and eject. Even more dangerous, some R-51s would fire out
of battery before the slide was fully closed. That's the kind of malfunction that can seriously
hurt people. Within months, Remington had to recall every R-51 and scrub it from the catalog.
The gun that started with great promise became a cautionary tale overnight.
A fully fixed Gen 2 R-51 came out two years later to positive technical reviews.
But by then, as one analyst put it, no one cared. Glock, Smith & Wesson, and others already
dominated the single stack 9mm market. Remington did little marketing the second time around.
The R-51 was quietly discontinued by 2018 as the company pivoted to other products.
A neat idea destroyed by a catastrophic launch that no amount of later fixes could overcome.
2. Sig Sauer P250
Being ahead of your time in the firearms industry can be a curse disguised as innovation.
This modular pistol introduced concepts that would later prove hugely successful.
Just not for this particular gun. The Sig Sauer P250 was genuinely ahead of its time when it
launched in 2007, and that turned out to be its biggest problem. The P250 featured an innovative
removable fire control unit as the serialized core, allowing caliber and size swaps on one frame.
It boasted one of the best double action only triggers in a modern pistol.
Long, but smooth and light at around 5.5 pounds. Offered in multiple calibers including 9mm,
.45 ACP, .40 S&W, .357 Sig, and even .22 LR, it was incredibly versatile.
Sig marketed it as a cost-effective, one-gun, many-roles solution.
The problem? The market had moved on to striker fired pistols by the late 2000s.
The double action only trigger, however refined, was a turn-off for most shooters in the Glock era.
The P250's modular promise fell flat in practice. Caliber exchange kits were expensive and scarce,
making conversions nearly as costly as buying another gun. Sig also revised grip modules and
magazines mid-production, frustrating buyers with compatibility issues. Reliability concerns
sealed its fate. Most notably, Dutch police trials found the P250's performance unacceptable
and lost confidence in its quality, halting adoption plans.
With poor sales and the successful launch of the striker fired P320 in 2014, the P250 was
quietly phased out by 2017. A genuinely innovative design that arrived at exactly the wrong time.
The concepts that made the P250 ahead of its time, modularity and serialized fire control units,
would later prove successful in the P320. Sometimes being first isn't the same thing
as being successful. 1. Hudson H9
When genuine innovation meets startup enthusiasm, the results can be spectacular. Until they're not.
This pistol represented everything right about American firearms innovation and everything wrong
about business execution. And taking our top spot, the Hudson H9, a pistol that blended 1911
style trigger with striker fired action in a revolutionary low bore axis design.
When it debuted at SHOT Show 2017, the H9 earned stellar reviews. Testers called it a shooting
star with smooth handling and a crisp trigger that impressed everyone who tried it. The H9's
unique engineering placed the recoil spring in front of the trigger guard, giving it reduced
muzzle flip and lightning fast follow-up shots. Reviewers consistently had good things to say
about its performance. Hudson was a new startup that seemed to have lightning in a bottle. The H9
represented genuine innovation in a market dominated by incremental improvements to existing
designs. Hudson, however, had too much ambition for their own good. In spite of the publicity,
they went over budget. It was difficult to accept the H9's high price tag of several thousand dollars
and early mechanical problems made matters worse. Reports of parts breakages and accuracy problems
shooting low dampened consumer confidence. Even worse, Hudson spent precious resources developing
a lighter aluminum framed H9A model, causing potential buyers to wait and drying up cash flow.
Production delays and a lawsuit from a supplier further strained the young company.
By March 2019, Hudson declared Chapter 7 bankruptcy, leaving the well-regarded H9 as a
brief spark that burned out way too soon. The Hudson H9 had everything except the business
fundamentals to survive. Great engineering, positive reviews, genuine innovation, but poor
financial management killed what could have been a game changer. Sometimes failure has nothing to
do with quality. It's just bad timing, worse luck, or business decisions that seemed smart until they
weren't. These nine guns prove that being great isn't enough. You need the right price, the right
timing, the right marketing, and sometimes just plain luck to succeed in the firearms market.
Which guns do you think deserved better? Or which one do you think flopped harder than expected?
Let me know in the comments below. And if you enjoyed this deep dive into firearms history,
make sure to subscribe to All About Survival for more gear breakdowns, survival tips, and industry
analysis. Hit that notification bell so you don't miss our latest content. Some of these guns were
great. They just weren't great sellers. And in the end, that's what matters most.
