The Time We Nuked Five Men to Prove a Point

We Science Too
67 followers
6 Video Views·Oct 22, 2022
On July 19, 1957, five U.S. Air Force officers and one photographer volunteered to stand
a few miles behind me.
Next to them, a sign that said, Ground Zero, Population 5.
In the next few minutes, a two-kiloton nuclear warhead would detonate 18,500 feet directly
above their heads.
Why would these men volunteer for such a demonstration?
And what happened to them?
Before they were banned internationally in 1963, most above-ground nuclear weapons tests
were as much spectacles of nuclear supremacy as they were actual tests.
Mushroom clouds kilometers high, X-ray-driven fireballs hotter than the sun, light intense
enough to vaporize a vehicle's paint job.
But in this incredible archival video of five men willingly standing underneath a nuclear
explosion, we see something else.
Instead of destruction, not much more than a synchronized flinch.
A few moments earlier, 65 miles northwest of Las Vegas, an F-89 interceptor had launched
a two-kiloton nuclear warhead directly above the heads of Colonel Sidney Bruce, Lieutenant
Colonel Frank Ball, Major Norman Bottinger, Major John Hughes, Don Luttrell, and George
Yoshitake, the unseen cameraman.
These men were ground zero, population five, for a successful test of the world's first
air-to-air nuclear weapon.
These men volunteered to get nuked to prove a point.
To you.
In the background was the growing struggle between two great powers to shape the post-war
world.
In the middle years of the Cold War, but before intercontinental ballistic missiles would
render them tactically disadvantageous, Cold War America was most worried about a surprise
nuclear attack from fleets of Soviet bombers.
Anti-aircraft technology at the time wasn't equipped to handle dozens of relatively high-flying,
fast-moving planes.
So in the August of 1954, President Dwight D. Eisenhower appointed MIT President James
R. Killian, Jr. to lead some of the nation's top scientists, engineers, and industry professionals
in an effort to counter this potential threat, to develop strategy and technology that would
make this aspect of the Cold War a little colder.
307 meetings later, a panel of 42 experts produced a 190-page document entitled Meeting
the Threat of Surprise Attack.
During their four-hour testimony to the U.S. National Security Council in 1955, the experts
argued that the most effective way to meet a thermonuclear-equipped adversary in the
air was with nuclear weapons also in the air.
Indeed, the report recommended that nuclear weapons should be the main defense against
possible air attacks.
The reasoning was simple.
A single warhead of significant tonnage should be enough to wipe out an entire fleet of Soviet
aircraft flying in bombing formation.
The council was convinced.
That same year, development would begin on the McDonnell Douglas Air 2A Genie, a 1.5
kiloton nuclear warhead that could be fired air-to-air.
But there was still a problem.
The public.
Rightly sensing that Americans might not want nuclear bombs detonating above their heads
even in defense, the Killian committee also recommended that an upcoming demonstration
of the Genie technology be promoted to citizens as an advertisement of its safety.
A nuclear bomb publicity stunt.
They just needed some volunteers.
Two years later, July 19, 1957, F-89 pilot Captain Eric William Hutchinson fires a 1.5
kiloton nuclear warhead powered by a solid-fuel Thiokol SR-49TC-1 rocket engine.
The engine runs for two seconds.
Now traveling at over three times the speed of sound, the rocket flies for another 12
seconds.
Hutchinson executes a dangerous high-G maneuver to ensure that he escapes the 1,000-foot blast
radius.
And then, the Genie was out of the bottle.
There it goes.
The rocket is gone.
We felt a heat pulse.
A very bright light.
A fireball.
It is red.
The sky looks black about it.
It is boiling above us.
How is a nuclear weapon dangerous?
It may surprise you to learn that what most people imagine to be the most destructive
aspect of a nuclear weapon, the ionizing radiation and subsequent fallout, is in reality the
smallest fraction of a detonation's colossal energy output.
And ionizing radiation only makes it so far in air as it collides with the atmosphere's
atoms and molecules, while fallout is of most concern when an explosion vaporizes a large
amount of additional material, like terrestrial rock or sea coral.
Therefore, a relatively small nuclear weapon, like the Genie's W-25, detonating at an
altitude six times higher than the highest building on Earth, did in fact pose very little
threat to anyone on the ground.
Fireballs would rise into the sky and cool.
Any minimal fallout would spread out as to become mostly harmless.
A warhead-carrying Soviet aircraft, on the other hand, would find it physically impossible
to escape deletion, as a missile moving at Mach 3.3 instantly transforms into a 1,000-foot-wide
sphere of air hotter than the center of a star.
The same year that five men successfully stood beneath Shot John of Operation Plumbob, the
United States started producing some 3,100 Genie air-to-air rockets and attached them
to interceptor aircraft at 31 bases across 20 states.
The Genie would remain in service for almost another 30 years, and secretly, the only nuclear
weapon that could be launched in response to an attack without presidential authority.
Thankfully, the only Genie that was ever fired and detonated was at Ground Zero, Population
By the late 80s, nuclear strategy changed.
It had to.
Intercontinental ballistic missiles could now quickly strike nearly anywhere on Earth,
and a single one, like the Russian's R-36 warhead with a 25-megaton yield, could glass
an entire city and spread deadly fallout over half a coast.
Gone were the days of relatively slow fleets of bombers that could be stopped with unfocused
nuclear fire.
The age of mutually assured destruction was here, and we've been living atop the insane
geopolitical knife-edge that replaced the Genie ever since.
As for the five men at Ground Zero, they were right, or at least what they were told before
they volunteered was right.
Time and distance is what saved them, what made the test a suitable PR stunt.
Exploding outwards from a single point, the intensity of a nuclear bomb's pressure wave,
ionizing radiation, and scalding heat decreases exponentially with the square of the distance
traveled.
A warhead like Genie's with a 1,000-foot blast radius wouldn't be three times less
intense three radii away, it would be nine times less intense.
And therefore, with over 18,000 feet between them and a Genie out of the bottle, the men
would hear a shockingly large noise eventually, but feel little else.
And by presumably not spending very much time in the area of any potential fallout, long-term
health effects for the men were extremely unlikely.
Indeed, records show that every single one of them lived very long lives afterwards.
Some lived well into their 90s.
Donald Luttrell passed away just eight years ago.
It's not the kind of time you might expect afforded to you after standing directly below
a nuclear blast.
Time and distance.
Until next time.
