The Ten Thousand Islands, Florida_ A Watery Wilderness _ Untold Stories

Historical stories
57 followers
59 Video Views·Oct 6, 2022
This episode of Untold Stories is underwritten by
Wynn's Market, Sunshine Ace Hardware,
Collier County Government-County Commission,
District School Board of Collier County,
City of Naples City Council,
Collier County Museum,
and the Baron Collier Jr. Foundation.
A maze of mangrove islands meanders from Marco Island
to Florida Bay, fringing the western edge of the Everglades.
Ruled by tide and storms, islands come and go,
inspiring a larger-than-life name
for the ever-changing labyrinth of mangroves,
the Ten Thousand Islands.
Early visitors to this watery wilderness
found the maze of mangroves monotonous and misnamed.
My impression was of endless bays and winding channels.
It seemed I had seen all the Ten Thousand Islands.
The error was not in the number I had seen, but in the name.
It should have been designated by 100,000 instead of 10.
Zane Gray, 1924.
The actual number of islands in this water world remains unknown.
Marco Island is the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands.
Actually, if you wanted a more specific term,
you should call them the 40,000 Islands
because there's everything from an island
the size of a king-sized bed up to an island of 6,000 acres.
In this vast forest of mostly flooded islands,
only a handful of high spots
offered early settlers a place to scratch out a living.
Renegades, ruffians, fugitives, and free spirits
sought sanctuary on the scattered high hills of Shell,
most relics of ancient engineers now known as the Calusa.
These were people that lived here
from slightly before the birth of Christ
till about the time the Spaniards arrived.
We're talking roughly 2,000, 2,500 years
for the construction of these large mounds.
It got them up out of the water.
It gave them a place to live.
We're talking about debris thrown in very specific spots.
In fact, a lot of it was later mined, centuries-old stuff
mined to create bigger mounds and shape the site a certain way.
It's part of what these large public works projects were.
The really big sites probably number around 10.
The smaller sites can be in the dozens or even hundreds.
By the early 1700s,
the mound builders were nearly wiped out,
devastated by European diseases.
The Calusa vanished,
but their massive mounds of Shell remained,
mysterious monuments to the past
and a vital legacy to the future.
The high and dry mounds became convenient campsites
for Cuban fishermen
who established makeshift fishing ranchos
to salt and dry fish for the Cuban market.
By the 1830s, most of the scattered camps were abandoned
when war moved into the tranquil Tidal Islands.
The Ten Thousand Islands,
particularly in the Second Seminole War
in the 1830s and 1840s,
and the Third Seminole War in the 1850s,
provided a refuge, a haven for the Seminole Indians.
It also provided a source of food for them, transport.
On the other side of the equation,
it also provided routes of attack
for the United States Navy and Marine forces in the area.
Finding the Seminoles, however, proved a daunting task
since the maze of mangroves was mostly unknown,
unexplored, and unmapped.
Mapmaker John Lee Williams admitted in 1837,
The outline south of Tampa Bay I have been unable to fill up.
As for Shark River, I have omitted it
because I could not find it.
Removing the Seminoles from this rough region
required a new kind of warfare.
The United States Navy formed
what was known as the Mosquito Squadron of small vessels.
They called themselves the Swamp Sailors.
This was the first time that the United States Navy
was fighting in a guerrilla tropical war.
The tough terrain proved a constant challenge.
Getting lost is what they did frequently.
There were no detailed government charts
of the 10,000 islands at that time.
In fact, it was the Swamp Sailors
that made the first detailed charts
for the U.S. Navy and the Coastal Survey.
The war ended in 1858,
but not all of the Seminoles were removed to western reservations.
An estimated 200 Indians remained
in the vast wet wilderness of the Everglades.
Most of the remote region remained unexplored,
but the Swamp Sailors had discovered
that the Mangrove Islands
were more than a mosquito-filled wasteland.
There are islands there that for fertility
are equal to the delta of the Nile.
A man could plant a ten-penny nail
and come back six months later
and find it grown into a crowbar four foot long.
Andrew P. Canova, private, Florida Volunteers.
Three years after the Seminole Wars ended,
the Civil War began,
and warships ventured once again
into the twisting channels of the 10,000 islands.
By 1861, when the war started,
this was a Confederate blockade-running haven.
The Caloosahatchee River and the Peace River
harbored blockade runners.
The 10,000 islands were a hiding place
en route to the Caloosahatchee and Peace Rivers.
And when the Union Navy blockaded the coast,
the blockade runners would duck into the 10,000 islands
trying to escape them.
Few others ventured into the tangle of trees and shallows
until after the Civil War.
After the Civil War, we see a big influx
of soldiers who fought in this terrible war down here,
this guerrilla war, but they came back after the war
because they knew there was land available.
Captain Richard Turner returned to the wild land
he trekked through as a guide
and eventually settled on an ancient shell mound
on a creek that became known as the Turner River.
A handful of other intrepid settlers
began to venture into the watery wilderness,
claiming other high spots in the meandering mangroves.
Most were farmers and squatters.
Just about every piece of high ground
was occupied one time or another by squatters.
They were much like hermit crabs.
When one family moved out, another'd move in.
Ernie Carroll.
W.T. Collier settled with his family
on the northern tip of Marco Island.
Further south, John Weeks established
the first claim on what pioneers dubbed the Big Island.
The Seminoles called the large island
an ancient shell mound site,
Chokoloskee, meaning old house.
By the 1880s, several families were living on the Big Island,
including C.G. McKinney.
In 1891, he established the first post office on the island
and gave the remote settlement,
his own too-good-to-be-true name,
to William Allen, that he soon changed.
My great-grandparents were the first settlers on the island,
and they started the first post office.
He first named it Comfort, and then an outsider came in
and said this is not Comfort when he met all the mosquitoes,
so he changed it to Chokoloskee.
Nearby, on what was then known as Potato Creek,
William Allen began farming in the early 1870s.
The Storder family soon joined Allen,
and George W. Storder, Jr.
eventually bought all of Allen's property for $800.
Word of Storder's bumper crops of sugar cane
soon drew other settlers to Florida's final frontier.
One acre made about 700 gallons of syrup.
My family canned between 200,000 and 300,000 gallons each year.
Rob Storder.
The enterprising Storder established a trading post in 1892
and 3 years later became the first postmaster
of the settlement of Everglade.
Halfway between Everglade and Chokoloskee,
other cane farms flourished.
And by the 1890s, the appropriately named community
of Halfway Creek boasted 9 families.
Other pioneers settled on the outer islands,
including John Gomez,
who selected a promising place to raise goats.
After panthers ate all of his stock,
the island became known as Panther Cay.
Life wasn't easy in this untamed outback.
Names like Hell's Half Acre, Sandfly Pass, and Dismal Cay
attest to the difficulties of life in the 10,000 islands.
It's rough. Mosquitoes are terrible.
People that used to live down there
used to actually live in these houses.
They lacked screens for a long time.
They would close the shutters on the houses
and actually have a smudge pot going
in the middle of the summer at night.
Imagine being in temperature in the 90s
like you're inside some kind of a smoker.
That was preferable to being eaten alive.
The painful pests were often a topic for McKinney's column
in the American Eagle newspaper.
He would write about the swamp angels, of course the mosquito.
He said you could scoop them up in a quart jar
and get 2 gallons.
In this water world, boats were essential,
and schooners like Arby Storder's Bertie Lee
played a key role in the lives
of the isolated pioneers of the 10,000 islands.
Families all over the 10,000 islands
brought their goods to my dad
to be taken to the Keys and sold.
Back then, there was a family on every island
that could be lived on,
and everyone had something to sell.
Rob Storder.
Around the turn of the century, this was one of the few places
where winter vegetables could be grown.
A lot of what they farmed here
actually wound up on Rockefeller's table in New York.
A lot of the wealthy socialites could afford winter vegetables.
The vegetables went by schooner from these mounds to Key West
and from Key West up the East Coast.
The resourceful pioneers also found other ways
to survive in the 10,000 islands.
Charcoal making was a viable industry.
They cut buttonwood all over the back country,
and then they would stack it up and set it on fire and burn it.
They had a way of packing grass on it,
packing mud on the grass,
keep it all real hot like a kiln.
Just the right time, they would put it out,
and then they had good charcoal.
They could sell it in Key West.
It was real sought after for cooking.
The still wild inland areas
also offered a seemingly endless supply of alligators
and a ready way to make money.
In 1898, a hunter could receive as much as $1
for a 7-foot alligator hide.
One summer, over 10,000 alligator hides
were shipped out to Tampa from my uncle's general store,
Rob Storter.
Alligator hides and other furs
were also traded at a new store on Chokoloskee.
Ted Smallwood started this store in 1906.
He was part of a cracker movement
of homesteading pioneers moving through the South.
He spent $600, he got 160 acres of the highest land in the area,
plus his family home.
He got the money largely from a very successful alligator hunt
a few years before on Roberts Lake not too far from here.
He and 3 buddies removed 4,500 alligators
from the lake in a few months.
4,500 might have been a slight exaggeration,
but undoubtedly took thousands of gators.
Hunters were also taking thousands of birds,
mostly for their delicate mating feathers.
The fancy feathers were highly prized
and worth more than their weight in gold.
At one time, they sold for $5 a piece
and became so valuable
that hunters quit hunting other animals
and went after the plumes, Rob Storter.
Hunters set up temporary camps near the rookeries
and took aim at the adult birds,
leaving the eggs and babies behind.
McKinney described his first and last plume bird hunt.
The crows would go and take the eggs
and carry them away and eat them.
I decided I didn't think it was in God's service,
and I never went on that kind of hunt anymore.
The gruesome feather trade flourished, however,
until the Florida legislature outlawed plume hunting in 1901.
Guy Bradley, a former plume hunter,
was hired by the Audubon Society
to guard the rookeries near Flamingo,
but 4 years later, he was killed in the line of duty.
Illegal plume hunting continued until after 1910,
when new laws and changing fashion
ended the plundering of the plume birds.
Enforcing the law was never easy
in this remote region.
Until 1887, most of the 10,000 islands
were part of Monroe County.
The county seat was 90 miles away,
in Key West, and only accessible by boat.
When Lee County was formed in 1887,
the islands were again on the far edge
of the county line and the law.
He was at the absolute border of Lee and Monroe County,
so not much law down here.
This is the end of the road today,
and it always has been.
Many people who were here that we now know
are running from something.
One of the 10,000 islands' most notorious fugitives
was E.J. Watson.
Watson came to Halfway Creek in the 1890s
and eventually bought land further south on Chatham Bend.
There's a nice piece of land there,
got a good little prairie, you can grow the cane,
and ended up building a really pretty
2-story wood frame house,
and he commenced to producing the syrup,
the island pride.
Watson prospered, but rumors of a mysterious,
murderous past grew increasingly menacing.
We called him Mr. Watson.
He was a 200-pound, red-headed man
with a quick and sometimes quirky temper.
Watson was reported to have been
a hand of Bell Stars
and to have shot her in the back
from ambush one night in Oklahoma.
Rob Stordy.
There was always stories floating around about Ed Watson.
He was fast with a gun, an old Wild West kind of fella.
There was reports of people disappearing on this plantation
for the whole 20 years that he was here farming,
none really documented.
It became a local joke about a Watson payday.
The growing suspicion and fear of Watson
eventually spurred a still notorious act of vigilantism.
Ed Watson was shot down by all the men in town pretty much
right beside the store in October 1910.
Far from the law, living in isolation,
these tough, tenacious pioneers
learned to rely on themselves
and the bounty of the land
to survive in Florida's final frontier.
Farming, hunting, and fishing
were the mainstays of life in the Ten Thousand Islands.
Settlers worked the seasons,
often setting up temporary camps to hunt or fish.
In this tough territory,
farmers learned to taste the soil for saltiness.
Salt-free soil promised good crops,
but farmers soon discovered
the rich soil was quickly depleted.
Many settlers abandoned their finished fields,
and commercial fishing gradually became
a more important part of the pioneer economy.
By 1910, 2 fish houses were operating in Chokoloskee Bay.
Fish houses in the area handled thousands of fish.
While mackerel and kingfish were especially popular,
mullet were the most plentiful.
My dad owned the runboat.
He would come to the fish house loaded with ice
and go out loaded with fish.
The bounty of the land included rich clam beds,
and by the early 1900s,
2 clam factories were operating on Marco Island.
Far to the south, on Shark River,
the tall mangrove trees caught the attention
of a tan bark manufacturing company.
But the cost of harvesting the tan and rich bark
in the backwoods of the boondocks proved too high.
A passerby noted in 1911 that the factory was
a bold, strong etching of the ruins of despair.
On the edge of the Everglades,
W.D. Collier's store on Marco,
Storder's trading post in Everglades
and Smallwood's store in Chokoloskee
played key roles in the taming
of this wild, watery outback.
People couldn't readily live in this area,
hunting and fishing, without some access to markets
and goods necessary to live.
So as stores like this opened, more people came into the area
because it was easier to live here and make a living,
including Native American people.
By 1917, Smallwood had built a large store right on the bay.
After the 1924 hurricane, he elevated it
onto pilings to protect it from flooding.
In addition to selling medicines and basic supplies
and serving as postmaster,
Smallwood also operated a boatyard and built boats.
His competitors, Collier and Storder,
both enlarged their homes to accommodate
the growing number of sportsmen
venturing into the untamed 10,000 islands
in search of fabulous fishing and more.
Tarpon, the silver king of fish,
lured intrepid anglers to the fish-filled waters
of the 10,000 islands,
while hunters searched for game
and the strange Saurian kings of the swamp,
alligators, the massive mangrove maze
mesmerized visitors.
Mystery hovered over this forbidden place,
neither land nor water nor forest,
yet a combination of all three.
Yet a certain kind of lure began to dawn on me.
This was a country that must be understood.
Zane Gray, 1924.
By the early 1920s, much of the waterlogged land
around Everglade and Halfway Creek
was purchased by Baron Gift Collier,
a millionaire advertising magnate
who became the namesake
of the new Collier County in 1923.
Although less than a dozen families
lived in the community, Collier made Everglade,
renamed Everglades, the new county seat,
and work began on two monumental projects,
the building of a town in the swamp
and the completion of a road
through the Everglades, the Tamiami Trail.
The new town included the bank of the Everglades
and a new county courthouse.
When the new Tamiami Trail opened in 1928,
the upper 10,000 islands were no longer
completely cut off from the rest of the world,
but the region remained remote
and a refuge for those who didn't want to be found.
Prohibition had once again driven fugitives from the law
into hiding in the daunting maze of mangroves.
They say there was a low cloud of smoke
over the Everglades during Prohibition from all the stills.
While moonshiners distilled what was locally called
low bush lightning,
rum runners imported their products.
Cuba was not far away, the Bahamas weren't far away,
so our local fishermen would go out on fishing excursions
and come back loaded in whiskey, it was real easy.
It's just too vast an area to chase after local guys
who were born and raised out there.
The maze of mangroves also remained a haven for sportsmen.
I had come to the 10,000 islands and the Everglades
to fish and to photograph,
and I was finding myself slowly awakening
to a profound realization of the tremendousness
of this last and wildest region of America,
Zane Gray, 1924.
A growing awareness of the importance
of this watery wilderness launched a campaign
to establish the Tropical Everglades National Park.
One writer predicted...
The beautiful Everglades and the 10,000 islands
will be the all-year playgrounds of the coming generations,
but it needs the same protection
as Yellowstone National Park.
A.W. Dimmock, 1908.
Years later, protection became a reality
with the establishment of the new Everglades National Park
in 1947.
Most of the 10,000 islands were incorporated into the park,
and life in Florida's final frontier
changed forever.
When the park was established,
most hunting and commercial fishing,
our main source of livelihood in the 10,000 islands,
gradually came to a stop in the park waters.
The people who had deeds to their properties
within the park boundaries were paid little bit of nothing
and told to clear out.
The old squatters who lived on the shell mounds
throughout the islands without deeds
were kicked out with no compensation.
This was one hell of a blow
to the people of the Everglades.
Tots Brown.
Chokoloskee and Everglades
were just barely outside of the park boundaries.
There was a lot of concern that people would be removed
from Chokoloskee just like they were removed from Flamingo.
There wasn't a lot of people in Flamingo,
but there was some families, the House family.
They just basically told the House family
that pack it up or we'll take you out in handcuffs.
A way of life was at an end,
but so were plans to develop the remote real estate.
The developers had already laid out big subdivisions
and things that they wanted to do.
Cape Sable is just an unbelievable piece of property.
It would be like 50 Santa Bells
and you know they had their eyes set on that.
There's no way that this country
could have stayed the same as it was.
If the park hadn't gotten control on all this land,
somebody else would have.
Most of the islands reverted back into wild scrublands,
and the remaining residents were forced to find other ways
to survive in this watery wilderness.
As fishing restrictions tightened within the park boundaries,
many of the islanders turned to smuggling once again.
It's what caused a lot of people in this area
to turn to marijuana smuggling
is because their way of life was taken from them.
The National Park's closing down all the fishing
just about other than stone crabbing
and taking the property that was farmed.
There's really nothing left but tourism,
the backbone of the community today.
It's a real struggle for the old-time families here
that are fishing to see them displaced by kayakers.
Today, an estimated quarter of a million people
visit the 10,000 islands every year.
Most come to fish and explore
this still vast and vital maze of mangroves.
The 10,000 Islands is the largest
estuary and mangrove community in the U.S.,
and one of the largest in North America.
The estuaries of the 10,000 Islands
are incredible nursery grounds for open-water fish.
It's a nursery zone for those fish,
and then for unique wildlife like sea turtles and manatees.
We're in one of the neatest places there is,
the 10,000 Islands.
In this vast, watery wilderness,
much of the maze of mangroves
is still untamed, unchanged, and unknown.
Florida's final frontier
remains one of the last great wild places in the world,
a land of legends
with a fitting, larger-than-life name,
the 10,000 Islands.
To purchase a copy of this and other WGCU-produced programs,
go to wgcu.org
or call 1-888-824-0030.
This program was produced
for the citizens of Southwest Florida
by WGCU Public Media.
Show your appreciation for programs like these.
Become a member of WGCU, a business supporter,
or leave a legacy through a state or planned gift.
Call or visit our website at wgcu.org.
