Kansas City_ The Quintessential American City

Historical stories
57 followers
65 Video Views·Oct 13, 2022
Kansas City may seem like just another city on the map, but can it show us how other American cities came to be what they are today? And does it have any especially weird things of its own to show us? Today, we take a look at the city most famous for not actually being in the state of Kansas.
All right, Kansas City. Kansas City, where are we? All right, uh, Wichita, uh, McPherson, Salina, uh, Manhattan, ****, I'm lost, uh, Kansas City, uh, ****, okay, Missouri City, Missouri City, yeah, all right.
Anywhere that you tell me to, if you need, you need me to be with you, I will follow, oh, where you lead, I will follow.
But otherwise, it's just sort of a basic American city, and in fact, that's sort of exactly why I chose it. In a couple of important ways, Kansas City is the perfect example of an American city built out of the 20th century.
Look at this. Parking lots, parking lots over here, they try to put a park here, but it's just surrounded all by parking lots. It's just like a Disneyland of a city. It's like a theme park, you have to just drive in, lot A, lot B, this is nuts.
Like, if you saw this behind your TV, you'd wonder what blew up, this is nuts. This whole thing right here is the same size as the library district, look at this. It's like the Tangled Mess District, I'm getting lost just looking at it.
It's because of this network of highways around downtown, that this central area has been reduced to about three square blocks of skyscrapers and not much else.
And it very quickly became quite evident that you weren't going to want to walk around these for fun. It wasn't a city anymore, as much as it was just an amusement park. It's like a Disneyland for jobs.
I mean, it was nice enough in terms of being able to bring in suburban workers to work in skyscrapers and office jobs, but for the urban centers, it made them completely unwalkable.
These central business districts that are a staple of major American cities makes it so that you can access it by car, by not much else. And the consequences of that are stark.
Even by the outside of downtown, you can see there are abandoned lots, old buildings that no one really seems to want to go to, cracked pavement. You've got places that you wouldn't want to walk at night, let's just say.
And you can see, that brings big consequences to the rest of the urban core of the city. As you can see, Kansas City has an urban core that extends far beyond its skyscraper-laden downtown.
Now, in order to understand why Kansas City and a lot of American cities surrounded their downtowns with expressways and turned them into central business districts, we've got to go to New York!
Yeah, I know, it may not look like it, but this is the birthplace of Robert Moses and his plan to make extensive networks of highways and expressways going deep into the suburbs to bring car-bound workers all the way into downtown.
He had complete control of the urban planning of New York for decades, and he was a big influence on urban planners across America and around the world. Now, ironically, Manhattan is largely untouched from his sort of style of urban planning.
These dead ends would be a great place to hide in the dark if you were a mugger, but not a great place to be if no one knew you were there. You were never going to accidentally stumble across the business under the bridge.
Now, thanks to her activism, she was able to save a lot of the most vibrant neighborhoods in New York. The neighborhood she lived in, Greenwich Village, had a plan by Robert Moses to put an expressway right through Washington Square Park.
It's because of activists like Jacobs that this is such a high value and highly sought after part of the city. Contrast that with one-time similar areas that Robert Moses was able to have his way in.
But once Robert Moses built his highway there, it went from fancy downtown, or at least a nice downtown, to the warehouses and sort of urban blight that he was nominally there to avoid.
Here you have all the wide blocks and lack of institutionalized parking lots and strangulating highways on all sides that you can actually have sort of an organic growth of business. This is navigable and actually walkable in a lot of places.
This will always be a viable neighborhood, and that's why it's so enduring. This is essentially a city.
And if you look farther south, you have major prestige parks with monuments and museums, like this World War I memorial here, and this Legoland and associated sort of mall going on here.
And this is sort of anchored by hospitals, major hospitals that largely go along with the midtown areas and other American cities as well.
What these places do is they provide another place where you want to go. It's a draw. It's a place where foot traffic can go.
And if foot traffic is here, businesses want to be near it. So this midtown is feeding off of this, allowing it to go even farther and farther south away from what's nominally the downtown.
And that allows this entire urban walkable area to expand all the way down to where there are organic, fully populated residential neighborhoods.
What this means is that you can essentially walk from where you live all the way up to downtown this way, and have a viable reason to be in every single place you pass by.
You're not going to be stuck under the rail bridge by the parking lots.
There's no place that would be an easy and asking-for-it kind of place to get mugged. And that's what people are really looking for, to not get mugged.
As you can see, Kansas City's also a great example of a way to escape the kind of problems that a central business district presents.
And in that respect, it's done pretty well.
The second reason that I wanted to show you Kansas City as the quintessential American city is its city limits.
Look at that. It's just completely arbitrary. It's going all over the place. It's got chunks carved out of it, random arms going out in every which direction.
Now, I mean, part of it's understandable. This area on the west here is the state of Kansas.
And, you know, they sort of have naming rights. You can't really have Kansas City, Missouri, Kansas.
It'll just get confusing. How are you supposed to send a letter to that?
So I can understand that. But even on the Missouri side, it's like they just spilled a bunch of ink on the map and said, we'll take that, thanks.
It's got random, you know, chunks taken out of it. It's just going off in random directions.
Now, the way we can explain this is the way that American cities, just like Kansas City, expanded and annexed the territory around it throughout the 20th century.
Of course, in the early and mid-20th centuries, America was the world's largest industrial power in terms of economic output.
We had 50% of the world's industrial output after World War II.
And that meant a lot of factories, a lot of railways, a lot of warehouses, and a lot of industrial jobs were coming to American cities.
That meant it was the place to be.
We went from a largely agrarian economy, especially in Missouri and Kansas, where all of a sudden, you can make a lot more money coming here and making the world's industrial output.
And people did. And of course, they tried to live as close as they could, and that very soon became pretty far away.
There's only so much space in Kansas City to live.
And so Kansas City was making money hand over fist with this industrial base.
And they said, hey, you clearly want to live in Kansas City. In fact, everyone here only lives here because they want to live in Kansas City.
So Kansas City said, why not?
You know, you can be a part of us. We'll just pool all our tax money together.
We can coordinate things like transportation and education and city services and sort of have a better coordination of what it means to be a city.
Now, of course, that all changed in the second half of the 20th century.
We went from being a largely industrial nation to a nation whose economy was based off of service jobs and financial jobs.
If you were working in the downtown area of a city, you weren't working here or here or here.
If you had to go downtown, you were going here.
And that meant cities, especially like industrialized cities like Kansas City, were suddenly stuck with large swaths of territory that was covered in expensive railway and road and environmental gray space.
A lot of expensive infrastructure that simply wasn't making a lot of money anymore.
Not compared to the downtowns, at least, and not nearly compared to where it used to be.
What used to be a great, you know, financial boon for the city suddenly became a pretty big financial liability.
So when that change happened, the borders sort of froze where they were.
It made no sense to join Kansas City then.
I mean, just look at the example of Detroit.
Detroit was one of the best in terms of annexing the territory around it.
It had a largely contiguous expansion all the way up eight miles north of their downtown.
But of course, when industrial jobs started leaving, not just America in general, but started leaving Detroit the city for its suburbs and all small factory towns across the Midwest,
Detroit was left having to pay the bills for a lot of environmental damage, a lot of rail and road infrastructure,
and this entire extensive belt of manufactories and warehouses and factories that had cleanup costs and maintenance costs,
but no one was there to pay the bills, except for the residential people.
Residential neighborhoods were the only good source of income left,
and they all then had to pay for all this legacy infrastructure, except for a neighborhood like Hamtramck.
Now this is a town that never incorporated into Detroit.
And because of that, it doesn't have to pay through its tax monies and its fees for the infrastructure that Detroit has to maintain,
just to avoid an economic and environmental disaster.
And because of that, people can afford to live in every parcel.
All the houses are next to each other. It looks like a properly nice place to live.
As opposed to Detroit, which sort of looks like a smallholder farmland.
But back to Kansas City, now that we sort of understand why it looks like that, and sort of what the borders are doing,
we can realize that Kansas City actually made out pretty well.
A lot of places, a lot of American cities, have their international airports quite a few miles away from downtown,
for noise reasons, and so that planes don't fly too close to tall buildings.
But not a lot of American cities manage to snag a lot of suburbs that are actually quite far away from the airport,
in pretty prime real estate area.
Almost all the northern suburbs are within Kansas City limits.
And this is the sort of stuff that normally would be incorporated in exclusive suburban cities.
Getting all that tax revenue for themselves.
That's a pretty good snag, Kansas City.
But that's not the most impressive part.
In fact, if you look to the south, this entire sort of creek valley area is full of golf courses and country clubs.
In fact, there's even, quite famously, a neighborhood called the Country Club District,
which was not only one of the first early sort of luxury suburban developments on a large scale like this,
but it even included this place, Country Club Plaza,
which was America's first automobile-designed shopping center.
This is the kind of luxury, high-end suburban development
that would normally be making a lot of money for a suburban city.
Instead, it goes to Kansas City.
So I'm sure Kansas City is quite happy that they were able to get these neighborhoods when they did,
and it's really helping a lot in keeping their finances above water in the post-industrial era.
That being said, Kansas City has a couple of really interesting holdouts and weird quirks here
that even surpass those of other American cities.
The first one here is North Kansas City.
Now, at first glance, this sort of just looks like the same sort of holdout suburb that we've just talked about before.
It makes sense in that context until you look closer and realize that it's actually a heavily industrialized district.
This has got the same warehouses and factories and heavy rail infrastructure
that scar a lot of the similar neighborhoods right across the river in Kansas City itself.
It's a money pit, except for it has none of the benefits of residential or financial infrastructure to offset those costs.
How did North Kansas City find itself independent and left all on its own
when the rest of Kansas City just enveloped all the areas around it?
It wouldn't make a lot of sense today,
but it makes a lot of sense if you realize North Kansas City incorporated pretty early on in 1914.
See, in the early 20th century, most of the development and expansion of the Kansas City area
was still pretty close to what we see as the built-up area today.
Even in Kansas, it was sort of a small city by this river junction.
At the time, we had just come up with the technology and the ability to build proper levees
to stop the Missouri River from overflowing the North Bank shores.
This bend in the river especially directs the water directly towards this area and this peninsula
whenever even the slightest upsurge of water comes by.
It was only by 1914 that this area was really able to be developed into an urban area,
and North Kansas City just grabbed it at the first opportunity.
They incorporated it as their own town back when it was about the same size as Kansas City, Kansas,
and only nominally smaller than Kansas City, Missouri,
which had only really expanded, once again, about this far out.
It made perfect sense. It was a three-city area.
Kansas City had yet to see the suburban development that we see today, let alone annex it.
Now, it looked like a good idea in 1914,
but nowadays, it looks like a lot of cost and very little income to pay for it.
Even though a lot of businesses are coming back to North Kansas City,
it's still not anything like it was in the 1950s.
Thankfully, North Kansas City was able to snag a little bit of its waterfront
to fit a Harrah's Casino right along the river.
Hey, if you got bills to pay, might as well get someone to pay for it, right?
But that's not the weirdest part of Kansas City's borders.
The weirdest holdout's gotta be this little corner right here.
Now, if you look at the map, you may think it's another casino just trying to get a tax break,
not pay taxes to Kansas City.
But if we look closer, this casino is within Kansas City limits.
And in fact, if we go even farther, just a little bit north,
there's an industrial area with a Georgia Pacific warehouse, a Ford Truck Center,
but all of this is within Kansas City limits as well.
So what is in this little holdout that's so important that they refused to be annexed by Kansas City?
What's here?
Well, it's a quarry.
It's an open pit mine.
And, uh, to be fair, it's got two Baptist churches right across the street from each other.
But otherwise, that's sort of it.
It's just a quarry and a couple of churches under a bow in the highway here.
It almost looks like just a mistake, like they forgot to annex it.
But if Randolph really wanted to hold on to its quarry that badly, that it had to remain independent,
well, more power to him.
Something tells me Kansas City didn't really work all that hard to grab that piece of land.
But they did try pretty hard, it seems, to grab this piece of land, all the way down in the southeastern corner.
Now, you see this lake here?
It sort of forms a pretty even border with the rest of the south end of Kansas City.
It looks like the perfect place to end the city.
This is all suburban land anyway.
It's sort of arbitrary where you want to put the borders.
But instead, the city planners, or whoever decided to annex this area,
decided very deliberately that they needed a very specific stretch of Highway 150.
They needed it so badly, they cut through the lake.
There's not even a road connecting this area to the rest of Kansas City.
You have to go outside of city limits to get back to the rest of the city.
So what is it that they could have possibly wanted of this specific stretch of Highway 150?
It's prime agricultural farmland.
Look at this!
This isn't even like your Detroit, your depopulated post-urban core converted to farmland.
This isn't just like, ah, it looks like it's empty, it looks like it might be farmland.
This is actually prime-grade ranching and farming land.
This probably actually makes a pretty good income for itself.
Not in city limits.
If I told you this was within the city limits of Kansas City, you'd think I was kidding.
You wouldn't believe me.
And yet, this whole stretch here is within Kansas City limits.
I mean, maybe at some point it was destined to become a suburban development that just never came about.
Maybe the population of the area had contracted and it wasn't needed anymore.
But, I mean, I like to think that, hey, agriculture is a wholesome and worthy pursuit.
And maybe Kansas City just found itself a good occupation.
And hey, if urban gardening's your thing, Kansas City's got you covered.
Highway 150 is the place to be. Farmer living is the life for me.
No casinos or golf inside. Keep your quiet, just give me that countryside.
In rocks is where I'd rather crash. I get allergic making cash.
I can't afford a riverfront view. Just give me a quarry and a couple of Baptists too.
The land.
Fresh sand.
Moonland.
Gravel pit.
You on my way?
Goodbye, quarry life.
150, we are there.
What do you guys think, though?
Is Kansas City a great example of a 20th century American city?
Or am I completely off base? Let me know in the comments below.
Thank you guys so much for watching, though.
And if you liked the video, please hit that thumbs up button on the way out.
And if you want to see more content like this, please hit subscribe.
I'm Mike, and I just looked at the map.
We'd be falling in love to the rhythm of a steel drum band.
Way down in Claycombe.
Up inside a big-ass parking lot.
