Some four thousand years ago, at the southern end of the Jordan Valley, a plain of five cities lay at the lowest place on the surface of the Earth. The Book of Genesis remembers it as well watered everywhere, like the garden of the Lord. Five kings. Walled towns. Springs in the desert, and black tar rising up through the ground.
One evening, two strangers walked up to the gate of Sodom. A man named Lot took them into his house. That night the men of the city surrounded it, and before dawn Lot went out into the dark to warn the young men who were to marry his daughters. They thought he was joking.
At first light, the strangers took Lot, his wife and his two daughters by the hand and led them out of the city. Run, they said. Do not look back. Do not stop anywhere in the plain. The sun had risen when Lot reached the little town of Zoar. Then fire and brimstone fell on Sodom and Gomorrah, and in a single morning the cities of the plain stopped existing. Behind him, his wife looked back.
But the most unsettling thing about Sodom is not the fire. It is what the valley is doing now. Genesis says that the kings of Sodom and Gomorrah fled across the vale of Siddim and fell into its pits. In 2001, a geologist from Kibbutz Ein Gedi named Eli Raz argued that the verse described the ground itself collapsing, and he warned that the holes opening along the shrinking Dead Sea would swallow people. In October 2003 he fell into one, and spent between twelve and fourteen hours at the bottom. Today there are more than six thousand of them.
In this documentary you will understand why the Dead Sea valley is a crack between two plates of the Earth's crust that have slid some 105 kilometres past each other, how the Bronze Age town of Bab edh-Dhra built a wall seven metres thick in sections that may have been meant to survive earthquakes, what ancient writers meant when they said the lake announced its tar twenty days in advance by blackening silver, how two geological reconstructions explain fire and brimstone as an earthquake, liquefied ground and burning bitumen, why a famous 2021 study claiming that a cosmic airburst destroyed a city identified with Sodom was retracted in 2025, how the pillar of salt known as Lot's wife was made by an earthquake within the last four thousand years, and why the pits of Genesis are opening again.
This video examines the biblical narrative of Sodom and Gomorrah through the lenses of geology and archaeology. It explores how the Dead Sea valley's volatile environment—characterized by tectonic activity, bitumen, and salt—provides a physical context for the story of divine judgment, suggesting that natural catastrophes likely inspired the ancient accounts of fire and brimstone.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Some four thousand years ago, first light, at the lowest place on Earth's surface,
the sky above a valley of five cities begins to burn.
In a single morning, Sodom and Gomorrah will stop existing.
Five kings, walled towns, a plain watered everywhere, like the Garden of God.
Its people have bread, water, and walls.
They think they are safe.
Nobody in those cities knew that the ground beneath their gardens was made of salt, tar, and a fault.
This is the story of Sodom's last morning.
And of a warning this valley has been repeating for four thousand years.
The evening before, two strangers walked up to the city gate.
The valley is a crack in the planet.
East of the hills of Judah, the land falls away into a trench
that runs almost in a straight line from the Sea of Galilee to the Red Sea.
It is the seam between two slabs of the Earth's crust.
On one side, the Arabian plate.
On the other, a slab that carries Sinai and belongs to Africa.
They are sliding past each other by a few millimeters a year,
and they have been doing it for millions of years.
Since the crack opened, its two sides have moved about 105 kilometers against each other,
farther than the whole length of the Dead Sea.
At the bottom of the trench lies a lake with no way out.
The Jordan River flows into it from the north.
Nothing flows out.
The water can leave only one way, by evaporating into the heat.
And everything the river carried in stays behind.
Mostly salt.
The water is nearly ten times saltier than the ocean.
No fish live in it.
A human body does not sink in it.
The same crack that made the lake made everything else in the valley.
Along its edges, where the rock is broken, springs rise out of the ground.
And in a desert that sees almost no rain, a spring is a fortune.
Through the same broken rock, something else comes up from deep below.
Bitumen. Black and sticky. A natural tar.
It surfaces so often that the Romans named the whole lake after it.
They called it Lake Asphaltides.
At the southern end of the lake, the ground holds salt as well.
A whole mountain of it.
And in the soft gray sediments at the foot of the cliffs, geologists find small lumps of pure yellow sulfur.
The old English word for sulfur is brimstone.
Water, salt, tar, and brimstone.
All rising out of the same crack.
In the book of Genesis, a herdsman named Lot looked out over this country and saw only the water.
And Lot lifted up his eyes and beheld all the plain of Jordan, that it was well watered everywhere.
Even as the garden of the Lord, like the land of Egypt.
He chose it.
Nobody has ever proved where Sodom and Gomorrah stood.
And no stone bearing their names has ever been found.
But the valley the story describes is real.
And so are the ruined towns along its shore.
A garden planted on fuel.
Genesis remembers the rulers of the valley in a single verse.
Bera, king of Sodom.
Birsha, king of Gomorrah.
Shinab, king of Adma.
Shemeber, king of Zeboiim.
And the king of a small town called Bela, whose own name was never recorded at all.
Five cities, five kings.
Among their subjects was a foreigner.
Lot was the nephew of Abraham.
A herdsman who had come down into the plain with his flocks, and in the words of Genesis, pitched his tent toward Sodom.
By the time of the story, he no longer lived in a tent.
He lived inside the city, with a house, a wife, and two daughters, promised in marriage to men of Sodom.
Genesis never gives his wife a name.
Much later, Jewish tradition called her Idit.
Edith.
A name that echoes the Hebrew word for a witness.
Of the people who really lived along this shore in the Bronze Age, not one name survives.
What survives is where they were buried.
On the southeastern shore of the Dead Sea, at a site now called Bab-eth-Dra, stood a walled town of perhaps 600 to 1,000 people.
Outside it lay a cemetery.
In its oldest part alone, a survey has estimated nearly 3,000 shaft tombs, holding some 56,000 burials, laid down over generations.
A city of the dead, far larger than the town of the living.
The bones say how they lived.
Scurvy, rickets, periods of famine, a life expectancy for the earliest of them of about 26 years.
Short lives in a rich valley.
And the valley was not finished with them.
The valley had already been emptied once.
According to Genesis, the five cities spent 12 years paying tribute to a foreign king, Chedorlaomer of Elam.
In the 13th year, they rebelled.
In the 14th, he came back with three other kings and their armies.
Four kings against five.
They met on the valley floor, in a place Genesis calls the Vale of Sidim.
And the text adds a detail that seems, at first, to belong to no story at all.
The Vale of Sidim was full of slime pits.
Modern translations call them bitumen pits.
The kings of Sodom and Gomorrah ran, and they fell into the pits.
The invaders took everything Sodom and Gomorrah had.
Their goods, their stores of food.
And they took people.
Among them was Lot.
Abraham went after them with 318 men of his household, caught them far to the north, and brought everything back.
The goods, the women, the people, and his nephew.
Sodom had been plundered.
Its king had fallen into the ground.
Its people had been marched away.
And then, all of it came back.
And Lot went home to Sodom.
The archaeology of the shore tells a similar story in stone.
At Bebedra, excavators found town walls leaning at almost 45 degrees, possibly thrown over by an earthquake.
At Numera, a smaller walled town farther south, a man had died in an earlier fire, probably choked by the smoke.
And the town wall was later built directly over his body.
Each time, the people rebuilt.
They stayed.
The wall of Babbeth Dra, at its height, was seven meters thick.
As wide as a two-lane road.
Stone at the base.
Mud brick above.
And built not as one continuous mass, but in sections.
Each of them seven to fifteen meters long.
The archaeologists who excavated it suggested that the sections may have been a protection against earthquakes.
A wall that could shift at its joints instead of coming down all at once.
These people knew the ground moved.
They built for it.
They built for their dead as well.
Outside the walls stood houses of the dead.
Rectangular buildings where the bones of generations were gathered together.
Some of them fifteen meters long.
In the largest, the excavators found gold.
Farther north, in the plain beyond the northern end of the lake, another city rose in a later age.
At a site now called Tal el-Hammam.
It covered some thirty-six hectares.
Fifty football pitches of streets and houses.
The valley was rich, and the story knows it.
When the prophet Ezekiel, writing in the 6th century BC, named the sin of Sodom,
he did not begin where many later readers would.
Behold, this was the iniquity of thy sister Sodom.
Pride, fullness of bread, and abundance of idleness was in her and in her daughters.
Neither did she strengthen the hand of the poor and needy.
Pride, too much bread, and no hand held out to the poor.
For more than two thousand years, readers have argued about what the sin of Sodom really was.
Jewish tradition gave its own answer, and it was about strangers.
In the Talmud, the people of Sodom reason like this.
Since we live in a land from which bread comes, and has the dust of gold,
we have everything that we need. Why do we need travelers?
The same tradition describes their courts.
Sodom had four judges, and their names were
and perverter of justice.
It had a bed kept for guests.
A man too tall for it was cut to fit, and a man too short was stretched.
And when a beggar came to Sodom, every household gave him a coin,
each coin marked with its giver's name.
But nobody would sell him bread.
When he died of hunger, every household came back and took its coin.
It is legend, not history.
But it is a very old answer, and it points at the same thing Ezekiel did.
They had everything.
They meant to keep it.
They felt safe.
In the story, nobody in Sodom was told in advance.
Abraham was.
Genesis sets the scene at Mamre, in the hills to the west.
Abraham was sitting at the door of his tent, in the heat of the day,
when three visitors came.
By the reckoning of Genesis, he was ninety-nine years old.
And before the visitors left, one of them told him why they had come.
Because the cry of Sodom and Gomorrah is great, and because their sin is very grievous,
I will go down now and see.
What followed is one of the strangest conversations in the Bible.
A man argued with his God about a city he did not live in.
Wilt thou also destroy the righteous with the wicked?
Peradventure there be fifty righteous within the city.
If there were fifty, the answer came, the city would be spared.
Then Abraham lowered the number.
Forty-five?
Forty?
Thirty?
Twenty?
Each time he apologized for daring to speak.
I which am but dust and ashes.
And each time he pressed again.
Shall not the judge of all the earth do right?
He stopped at ten.
Genesis does not say why he stopped there.
It says only that the conversation ended and that Abraham went home.
Ten people.
That was the price of a city.
Later Jewish tradition went further and said that the valley had been warned for years before any visitors came.
In Genesis Rabbah, a collection of rabbinic commentary on Genesis,
one rabbi taught that Sodom enjoyed fifty-two years of peace
and that for twenty-five of them the mountains thundered over the cities
and the ground shook beneath them so that the people would change their ways.
But they did not do so.
It is a legend, but it describes this valley exactly.
The fault beneath it never stays quiet for long.
It shook the region in 31 BC,
in the year 363,
in 749,
in 1033,
and again in 1927.
Anyone who lived on this shore long enough would have felt the ground move under them.
In the story, only one warning ever reached the people of Sodom.
It came on their last night.
The two visitors reached Sodom at evening.
Lot was sitting in the gate.
In the towns of the ancient Near East,
the gate was more than a way in and out.
It was where business was done,
where disputes were heard,
where men of standing sat and watched the road.
The foreigner who had once pitched his tent toward Sodom
now had a seat there.
He saw the strangers,
rose and bowed with his face to the ground.
He offered them his house for the night,
water to wash their feet,
a place to sleep,
and an early start in the morning.
They said no.
They would spend the night in the street.
He insisted,
and they came in.
It was an ordinary evening in an ordinary house.
Lot made them a feast
and did bake unleavened bread,
flatbread made quickly,
without waiting for the dough to rise.
Nobody knows the season.
Down in this valley,
on an ordinary afternoon in July,
the temperature today averages about 40 degrees.
And then there was the salt.
Salt was everywhere in this valley.
It was in the water,
in the soil,
in the mountain to the south.
It was the one thing no house there could ever have run short of.
An old Jewish tradition
preserved in the same collection
says that on that evening,
Lot's wife went from house to house among the neighbors
asking for salt.
Give me salt, she said,
as we have guests.
The rabbis who told the story
were not kind to her.
They said she did it on purpose
so that the whole street would know
that strangers had come to Lot's house.
And in the 11th century,
the great commentator Rashi
summed up her fate in a single line.
By salt, she had sinned.
And by salt, she was punished.
The valley had its own way of announcing trouble.
The ancient writers who described it
agree on one sign above all.
The smell.
The Greek historian Diodorus of Sicily
writing in the 1st century BC
recorded that the lake threw up masses of solid asphalt
from its depths.
The people who lived around it
called the large ones bulls
and the small ones calves.
And the asphalt announced itself
20 days in advance.
A foul smell spread for miles around the shore
and all the silver, gold, and bronze in the region
lost its color.
Modern chemistry has an explanation.
The asphalt of the Dead Sea rises from the deep
together with large amounts of hydrogen sulfide,
the gas that smells of rotten eggs
and that turns silver black.
The blocks could be enormous.
Some found floating on the lake
have weighed as much as 100 tons.
After an earthquake on the 1st of January, 1837,
a mass of asphalt came to the surface
that one witness compared to an island
and another to a house.
When the ground moved here,
the lake gave up its tar.
The whole valley sits lower than anywhere else
a human being can stand on dry land.
Today, the surface of the Dead Sea
lies about 440 meters below sea level.
If the Empire State Building were built on its shore,
the tip of its spire would barely reach
the level of the Mediterranean.
In the story, the last sign came at night
and it came from the people of the city.
Before anyone in Lot's house had gone to sleep,
the men of Sodom surrounded it,
both old and young,
all the people from every quarter
and demanded that he bring the two strangers out to them.
They pressed against the door to break it down.
The strangers pulled Lot inside
and the men outside were struck blind
and wore themselves out,
groping for the door.
Then the strangers told Lot what was coming.
Whoever he had in the city, they said,
he must bring out of this place,
for we will destroy this place.
Lot went out into the dark
to the young men who were to marry his daughters.
Up, get you out of this place,
for the Lord will destroy this city.
But he seemed as one that mocked
unto his sons-in-law.
They thought he was joking.
First light.
It comes gray at first,
the way it does in this valley.
Rising behind the mountains of Moab
on the far side of the lake,
long before the sun itself appears.
The two strangers do not wait for it.
Arise, they tell Lot.
Take thy wife and thy two daughters,
which are here,
lest thou be consumed in the iniquity of the city.
And Lot lingers.
Genesis does not say why.
It does not need to.
He has a house here
and goods
and two young men somewhere in the city
who laughed at him a few hours ago.
He has lived in this valley
since the day he chose it for its water.
So the strangers take hold of him.
One hand on Lot,
one on his wife,
one on each of his two daughters.
And they walk the four of them out
and leave them outside the city.
Behind them, Sodom is still asleep.
Nobody inside has been warned
except two young men who did not believe it.
Then the instruction.
Escape for thy life.
Look not behind thee.
Neither stay thou in all the plain.
Escape to the mountain,
lest thou be consumed.
Three orders.
Run.
Do not look back.
Do not stop anywhere in the plain.
Lot argues.
He cannot reach the mountain, he says.
Something will catch him on the way
and he will die.
But there is a town close by.
Behold now.
This city is near to flee unto.
And it is a little one.
Oh, let me escape thither.
Is it not a little one?
And my soul shall live.
The answer is yes.
The little town will be spared.
And then comes a line
that turns the whole destruction
into a matter of waiting for one frightened man.
Haste thee.
Escape thither.
For I cannot do anything
till thou become thither.
The fire waits for Lot.
It is a strange detail.
And the most human one in the chapter.
A whole valley is held still
while one man walks to the nearest town
because the mountain feels too far.
The four of them hurry across the plain,
past the gardens, past the fields,
toward the little town that from then on
will be called Zoar,
a name that echoes the Hebrew word
for small.
The sky over Moab
turns from gray
to white,
then gold.
The sun was risen upon the earth
when Lot entered into Zoar.
And then it begins.
Then the Lord reigned
upon Sodom and upon Gomorrah,
brimstone and fire,
from the Lord out of heaven.
And he overthrew those cities
and all the plain
and all the inhabitants of the cities
and that which grew upon the ground.
Two verses.
That is all Genesis gives it.
Brimstone and fire from the sky,
the cities overthrown,
the people,
the plain, plants.
Nobody who was inside those cities
left a description
of what that morning looked like.
But the valley has shown
again and again
what it can do.
And geologists who have studied it
have pieced together
what a morning like that would look like
from the ground.
It starts underneath.
Beneath the plain,
the two sides of the valley
have been straining against each other
for generations,
locked, loading, waiting.
Now,
the fault slips.
The ground heaves.
Walls crack along their joints.
Roofs of timber and mud
come down on the rooms beneath them.
Dust rises
from every street at once.
And the floor of the valley
begins to move in a way
that solid ground should never move.
It is made of
soft silt and clay,
soaked with water.
Shaken hard enough,
ground like that stops behaving
like ground.
The grains let go of each other.
For a few seconds,
the earth under the houses
turns to something close to liquid.
Walls that stood on firm soil
a moment ago
now stand on mud.
Houses tilt. They sink.
Whole stretches of the plain
begin to slide down toward the lake.
Then,
the valley gives up
what it has been holding.
Tar.
Forced up through the broken ground.
Gas.
And the smell.
The smell of rotten eggs.
The smell that the ancients said
always came before the tar.
Rolling across the plain so thick
that it blackens silver.
A valley full of fuel.
And in every house,
a lamp,
an oven,
a hearth.
It catches.
Smoke.
And a rain of burning sulfurous fire.
Archaeologists
have found what fire did
to the towns along this shore.
Even if they
cannot give it a date
that matches the story.
At Numira,
the town is burning.
One of the towers
on the town wall gives way
and comes down.
And three men are crushed
beneath it.
At Bab-ed-Dra, the great houses
of the dead are on fire.
The roofs of timber,
branches, and mud
collapse in flames
onto the bones of generations.
The lowest place
on the face of the earth
is filling with smoke.
Then, for one verse,
Genesis goes back
to the road across the plain.
The order was clear.
Do not look back.
But his wife looked
back from behind him
and she became a pillar of salt.
She is walking
behind him.
That is what the text says.
Behind him.
The last in the line.
The one nearest the city.
She turns her head.
Genesis gives her
one verse.
It does not give her a name or a reason
or a last word.
Only the direction
she is facing
and what she becomes.
Lot does not turn around.
Neither do his daughters.
They go on into Zohar.
In the hills
to the west, an old man
gets up early.
And Abraham got up
early in the morning to the place
where he stood before the Lord.
And he looked toward Sodom
and Gomorrah and toward all
the land of the plain
and beheld.
And lo, the smoke of the country
went up as the smoke
of a furnace.
He has come back to the same spot
where the day before
he bargained for ten people.
It was here that
he asked whether the judge of all
the earth would do right.
He looks down toward the valley.
He does not see a city.
He sees smoke
rising from the whole
land of the plain
the way it rises from a kiln.
Nobody in the story
ever tells him
how many were inside.
Three choices were made
in those last hours.
And Genesis records all three.
Lot and his
two daughters left,
pulled by the hand.
They lived.
The young men who were to marry the daughters
heard Lot's warning in the dark
and laughed at it.
They stayed in Sodom.
Genesis never mentions them again.
And between the two,
Lot's wife.
She did leave.
She took the hand she was given
and walked out of her city
with the others.
And then,
somewhere on the road,
she turned.
The text leaves open
why she looked back.
Later tradition answered it.
In the chapters of Rabbi
Eliezer, a collection of
rabbinic legends set down many centuries
after Genesis,
the answer is a mother's.
The pity of Edith,
the wife of Lot, was stirred for
her daughters, who were married in Sodom.
And she looked back.
In that telling,
she was not looking at the fire.
She was looking for her children.
The same tradition
gives a name and a story
to another daughter of Lot.
One who never appears in Genesis at all.
The rabbis called her
Pelethith.
In their telling,
Sodom had made a law.
Anyone who gave so much as a loaf of bread
to the poor would be burned.
Pelethith,
married to one of the great men of the city,
saw a starving man
in the street.
Every day, when she went down to draw water,
she hid food from her own
house in her bucket,
and she fed him.
The men of Sodom noticed that the beggar was not
dying.
They found out why.
They brought her out to be burned.
As they did,
she cried out to heaven for justice.
And the tradition says
that hers was the cry God
speaks of when he tells Abraham
that he will go down and see whether Sodom
has done according to the cry
of it. The rabbis
pointed out that in the Hebrew,
the word does not say their cry.
It says her
cry. The Talmud
tells another version,
without a name.
There, a young woman carried bread to the poor
hidden in a water jar.
When she was caught,
they smeared her with honey
and left her on the city wall.
And the hornets came.
Two versions of
the same girl.
Neither is history.
Both are Jewish traditions answer
to the question of what the cry
of Sodom was.
It was the cry
of a girl who fed a stranger.
The real
towns along the Dead Sea have
their own dead, and they
have no names either.
At Numera, the three
men under the fallen tower.
From an earlier fire,
the man who died in the smoke
and was sealed beneath the town wall
when the people rebuilt.
The people who found them do
have names.
Paul Lapp was an American
archaeologist, born in 1930.
He was
34 when he began to excavate the
in the spring of 1965.
And he came back that autumn
to dig the town, and again
in 1967.
He took the enormous cemetery
for a sacred burial ground.
He never saw the excavation
fully published.
In April 1970, he arrived
in Cyprus to begin a new dig.
On the 26th,
swimming off the beach at Kyrenia,
he drowned.
He was 39.
Two archaeologists who had
worked with him carried on.
Walter Rast, born in
San Antonio, Texas,
and Thomas Schaub, born in
South Bend, Indiana, were in
their early 40s when,
in 1973, they set
out to survey the southeastern plain
of the Dead Sea.
Beyond Bab Idra, they found
four more towns of the same age.
Strung out along the shore,
Numera,
Es Safi, Faifa,
and Qanazir.
Five sites,
the same number as the cities
of the plain.
In 1974, they cautiously suggested
there might be a connection.
By 1980,
a popular magazine of biblical archaeology
was asking whether Sodom
and Gomorrah had been found.
Rast kept working
on the question, and in the end,
he turned it around.
The towns of the plain,
he came to argue, had not been
ruined because they were Sodom and Gomorrah.
Their ruins,
burned, abandoned,
lying empty on the shore of a
lifeless lake, may have been what
gave rise to the story in the first place.
The ruins came
first. The story
came after.
Walter Rast died
in 2003,
at 73.
Thomas Schaub
died in 2015,
at 82.
The final report on Numera,
the town with the three men
under the tower, was published
in 2020.
Others came to this valley,
looking not for the cities,
but for her.
Josephus,
a priest and historian
born in Jerusalem in the year 37,
wrote near the end of the
first century that he had
seen the pillar of salt with his own
eyes. I have seen
it, and it remains at this
day. Three centuries
later, a pilgrim
named Egeria stood
on Mount Nebo, above the
northeastern shore of the lake,
and asked to be shown it.
Believe me, reverend ladies,
she wrote to the women she had
left at home, the pillar
itself cannot be seen.
Only the place is shown.
The bishop of Zoar
told her it had not been seen
for some years.
The water had covered it.
Zoar,
as far as anyone then believed,
was still there.
In Roman and Byzantine times,
a town called Zoara
stood among palm groves at
the southern end of the lake,
and Christians identified it
as the little town Lot
begged for. The only
one of the five, Egeria
was told, that still existed.
On the hillside
above it, Byzantine monks
built a church around a cave.
The cave they believed
was the one where, according to Genesis,
Lot went to live with
his daughters after he left
Zoar. On the great
6th century mosaic map
of the Holy Land at Madaba,
the church is marked
with a label,
The Holy Place of St. El.
Only the first
letter survived, and scholars
argued over whose name it had
been. In 1990,
the archaeologist
Konstantinos Politis,
digging at the site under the sponsorship
of the British Museum,
found a stone painted
in red,
O St. Lot,
remember your servants.
Nobody knows
how many people died in Sodom
and Gomorrah.
Genesis says only,
all the inhabitants of the cities.
Centuries later,
a poet, mourning the
fall of Jerusalem, wrote
that his own city had suffered more
than Sodom, because Sodom,
at least, was
overthrown as in a moment.
It became the Bible's
measure of total ruin.
When the book of Deuteronomy
describes a land destroyed by God,
it uses words that
could describe the south end of the Dead
Sea. Brimstone
and salt and burning,
that it is not
sown, nor beareth,
nor any grass groweth therein,
like the overthrow
of Sodom and Gomorrah.
The Greek and Roman
writers who came to this valley
saw the same land
and heard the same story.
The geographer Strabo
described rocks near
Masada that looked scorched,
cracks in the ground,
ashy soil, and
drops of pitch giving off
a stench that carried a long
way. The local
people, he reported, said there had
once been thirteen cities
here, with Sodom as their
capital, destroyed by
earthquakes and by eruptions
of fire.
Tacitus wrote of a plain
that had once been fertile and full
of great cities, and was said
to have been burned by lightning,
though he blamed the fumes of the lake
for the barren soil.
And Josephus, the Jewish
historian of the first century,
wrote that the shadows of
the five cities could still be
seen, together with
strange fruits that looked ripe
enough to eat, but crumbled
into smoke and ashes
in the hand. A shrub
grows at Ein Gedi today,
whose fruit looks plump and
ripe, and bursts into dry
fibers when it is squeezed.
It is called
the Apple of Sodom.
The valley went on doing what
it does. On the 11th
of July 1927,
at four minutes past three in the
afternoon, the fault
moved again. Between
250 and 500
people died across the region.
Upstream, at
Damia, the banks of the Jordan
collapsed into the river,
and the Jordan stopped flowing
for about 21 hours.
The mourning of liquefied
ground and burning tar
is a reconstruction,
not a record.
It rests on the work of
two pairs of scientists.
In 1995,
the engineering geologists
Graham Harris and Anthony Beardow
proposed that an
earthquake had turned the soft
floor of the valley to liquid,
and slid its towns
down into the lake.
The same year,
the geologists David Neve
and Kenneth Emery
proposed that an earthquake had
torn open layers rich in
bitumen, releasing gas
and tar that caught
fire. Neither
theory can be proved.
Both describe things this
valley is capable of
doing. What archaeology
cannot do
is match the story to
a single mourning.
Bab-e-Dra's walled town
ended somewhere between
about 2500
and 2300 BC.
Numera burned at the
end of the same age,
perhaps generations apart from it.
Tal-el-Hammam,
far to the north,
was destroyed around 1650
BC.
In 2021,
a team of scientists published a paper
in the journal Scientific Reports
arguing that Tal-el-Hammam
had been flattened by
a cosmic airburst,
an object exploding in the sky,
like the one that leveled
the forests of Tunguska
in Siberia in 1908,
with temperatures
above 2000 degrees.
The paper raised the possibility
that the memory of that blast
lay behind the story
of Sodom. It was
reported around the world.
Then the problems began.
Some of the paper's
images had been altered,
and the authors issued corrections.
Other scientists published
rebuttals, no mineral
evidence of an impact,
and a comparison with Tunguska
built on figures that had been
overestimated.
On 24 April 2025,
the journal retracted
the paper. The editors
no longer have confidence that the
conclusions presented are reliable.
Eleven of the authors
disagreed with the decision.
The vast majority of archaeologists
who work in the region
do not equate any of these
sites with Sodom and Gomorrah.
In the words of three of them,
writing in 2021,
ancient peoples here
likely developed oral histories
and stories to explain
these ghost towns.
The story still does damage.
At Fayfa,
one of the five sites on the southeastern
plain, an aerial photograph
shows more than 3,200
holes dug by
looters. Archaeologists
report buyers asking for
a pot from the city of
Sin. The story
itself was written down
centuries after the world it describes.
Most likely, scholars
think, in stages
between the 9th and 5th
centuries BC.
Every age has come to
this valley and found
Sodom in it.
In the story, the warning
had three parts.
Run. Do not
look back. And do
not stay anywhere in the
plain. The second
part is the one everyone
remembers. Remember
Lot's wife,
Jesus says in the Gospel of Luke.
Three words,
spoken as a warning to anyone
tempted to go back for what they
owned. In the Book of
Wisdom, a Jewish text
written in Greek, the
pillar was already a landmark.
A standing pillar of salt
is a monument of an
unbelieving soul.
People never stopped looking for
her. In April
1848, an American
naval expedition led by
William Francis Lynch
sailed along the foot of the Salt
Mountain at the southern end of the lake
and found a lofty
round pillar
of solid salt
capped with carbonate
of lime, its rounded
upper part about 40
feet high. Today
a pillar about 20
meters tall stands on the eastern
face of Mount Sodom,
above the road.
Whether it is the one Lynch saw,
nobody can say.
The mountain is made mostly
of salt, and it is
alive. It is being
pushed up from below by several
millimeters a year, while
the rare desert rain dissolves
it from above.
It is always making new shapes
of itself. In
2009, the geologist
Amos Frumkin
of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem
published a study of the
pillar. It had not been
carved slowly by the rain, he
concluded. It was what
was left standing when the roof
of a salt cave collapsed around
it, suddenly,
and probably in a catastrophic
earthquake. Wood
washed into the cave, showed
that about 4,000 years ago
a stream was still
running through it.
The pillar, the world
calls Lot's wife,
was made in a single moment
by the valley
itself, sometime
in the last 4,000 years.
A medieval Hebrew
tradition had said something
like it long before.
The oxen lick her
all day, the story went,
down to her feet,
and every morning
she grows back.
But in the story, the
warning that mattered most
was the third one.
Do not stay in the plain.
Around
1980, holes
began to open in the ground along
the western shore of the Dead Sea.
The sea was shrinking.
The Jordan River,
which once poured more than a billion
cubic meters into it every year,
now brings less than
100 million.
The rest is taken upstream.
At the southern end,
industrial evaporation ponds
draw off more.
The surface is falling by more than a meter
a year. And as
the salt water retreats,
fresh groundwater from the hills
flows into its place,
reaches a buried layer of salt,
and dissolves it.
Underground, hollows
grow in the dark.
Then the surface falls in.
One of the people who
watched it most closely
was Eli Raz,
a geologist and a member of Kibbutz Ein Gedi
on the western shore.
In 1974,
he had founded the local
rescue team. For years,
he walked the shore recording
the new holes as they opened.
And in 2001,
in a scientific paper written with
Amos Frumkin, he
pointed to what may be the oldest
description of this ground-giving way.
The kings of
Sodom and Gomorrah
fleeing across the Vale of Sidim,
falling into its pits.
The fact that
they did fall into the pits,
the paper noted, suggests
an unexpected occurrence,
presumably
catastrophic collapse.
For years,
by his own account,
he tried to warn anyone who
would listen, above all the
officials, that if nothing
was done about the Dead Sea,
the sinkholes
will swallow us up.
In October 2003,
on the eve of the
Festival of Sukkot,
he went out alone, early
in the morning, to document
new sinkholes.
Shortly after seven,
the ground opened under his feet.
I fell in,
tumbling down,
deeper, deeper.
I thought I'd be
buried alive.
The hole was eight to ten meters deep,
the height of a
three-story house.
He was trapped at the bottom for
somewhere between 12 and 14 hours.
He wrote goodbye notes
to his family on toilet paper.
When he was finally
pulled out, it was by the
rescue team he had founded himself.
The man who had read the
oldest description of a sinkhole
had fallen into one.
Today, there are more than
6,000 of them along the western
shore. They have
swallowed date groves, closed
beaches, and cut the main road.
By the time the spa
at Ein Gedi closed in 2020,
the water was
four kilometers from its door.
We lost
300 dunams, Yarev Kita,
who managed the kibbutz's businesses,
said in 2017.
It's just totally gone.
On the Jordanian side,
in 2021,
a farmer plowing his field
was swallowed by the ground.
The pits of the Vale of
Sedim are open again.
This time,
everyone knows why.
Today,
Route 90 runs
along the western shore of the Dead
Sea, from the oasis
of Ein Gedi,
south toward Mount Sodom.
It passes the old
beaches, fenced off,
their ground pitted with holes.
It passes the
hotels of Ein Bokek,
where visitors float in the heavy
water. It passes
the vast evaporation ponds
of the Dead Sea works.
And under the salt mountain,
above the road,
a pillar stands on the
cliff face. Visitors
stop to photograph it.
They turn around
and look back at her.
This place was a
paradise. Melvin
Blau, a guide from Kibbutz
Mitzvah Shalem, said of a
beach the sinkholes closed,
When I come here,
I simply cry.
The people of this valley were not a
legend. They were farmers
and herdsmen, living short
lives on the shore of a salt lake.
Three men
under a tower at Numera.
A man, sealed
beneath a wall.
A farmer,
plowing his field.
And in the oldest story anyone
tells about this place,
a girl carrying bread
to a stranger in her
water jar. Everyone
remembers the warning not to
look back. The valley
has spent 4,000 years
repeating the other one.
Do not stay.