The Short and Long Parliaments | A Level History

Charles I of england
1 follower
going to do in this lesson is talk about the events that ultimately lead to the formal
breakdown of relations between Charles and Parliament, and then which would eventually
culminate in the outbreak of the Civil War. Now our focus is going to be mainly on the
long and short parliaments that existed during this quite brief period, i.e. the period itself
but the long parliament lasts for a good 20 years until 1660, we'll get to that in a second.
Then we'll talk about some of the other things that take place as well, like for example
the attacks on the royal prerogative. All of these are ways in which we see an eroding
of the monarchal power that existed and the emboldening of power and authority by Parliament.
So this is really the political crisis that leads up to the outbreak of the First Civil
War. We'll talk about the purposes of, the achievements of, and the purposes for, the
achievements of both the short parliament and the long parliament, and we'll talk about
some of the other subsidiary issues that takes place as well. Let's begin with the short
parliament. The short parliament takes place first. Now the short parliament is aptly titled
that given it took very little time for it to be dissolved. In fact it was only three
weeks that the short parliament existed for. It was called in April and it ended and it
was dissolved in April, three weeks later. And so essentially the reason why it was dissolved
was because of the opposition that essentially forced Charles's hand. Now what was the reason
for Charles calling this parliament? Well essentially it was in response to a number
of financial issues. This is the case for this parliament and it's also the case for
the long parliament as well. Financial issues, as we know, plagued Charles's reign through
its entirety. So in 1639, as a result of opposition to the conflict with the Scots, the First
Bishop's War, we see a taxpayer's strike. Now this is significantly problematic for
Charles because this kind of tax was the most useful for him during the period of his personal
rule. It was the most useful for him because it raised the most revenue essentially. And
in addition to this, as a result of Wentworth, Thomas Wentworth, alienating the City of London,
they only offered him £5,000 in funding, the City of London merchants. And what had
happened as a result of this, what had happened that led to Wentworth alienating the City
of London, was in 1635 Wentworth fined the Corporation of London as a result of issues
revolving around a number of obligations that the Corporation had towards land in London's
dairy. So essentially the City of London weren't particularly happy, their London merchants,
they didn't offer much funding to Charles and there was a taxpayer's strike as a result
of the conflict with the Scots. All of this meant that there were significant financial
issues being had. The result of this was that he was running out of money and so upon advice
from Wentworth, he decided to call Parliament to ask for finances. The short Parliament
met in April of 1640 and it automatically began with instant opposition and instant
disdain towards a number of the policy initiatives that existed during the personal rule on the
part of Charles. One of the key leaders in this opposition would be a key leader throughout
the entirety of the breakdown of relationships between Charles and Parliament, as well as
the essentially the outbreak of the Civil War as well. Ultimately, this was John Pym
and John Pym, along with a number of other members of Parliament, decided to present
a petition against Charles and the petition was criticising a number of aspects of his
rule and his personal rule specifically. What is interesting is that Charles, in response
to this petition, was actually open to making a certain number of concessions to Parliament
but he was only going to do so on the condition that they would support in granting him more
finances. So essentially he was only willing and open to potentially making concessions
to Parliament if he was to get what he wanted from the short Parliament, which is obviously
more finances, and the result of which was the fact that he would be forced to dissolve
Parliament after only three weeks. The dissolving of Parliament, the dissolution of Parliament
was in response to the fact that they were opposed to this ultimatum that they had placed
upon them by Charles. So all of which leads to a situation where we have no Parliament,
we have no finances and Charles has further problems to deal with. For example, motivated
by the need to find more money, Charles would then start to think about calling Parliament
again, this time being the long Parliament. This time the issues which were had led to
Parliament being called and a Parliament that existed in November 1640 and not being formally
dissolved until March of 1660. So we have quite a significant time difference in terms
of the length of time that the long Parliament sat compared to that of the short Parliament,
three weeks to 20 years. And so ultimately the build-up of the long Parliament again
revolved around Charles' need for finances and this again resolved around conflict with
the Scots, this time being the Second Bishop's War. The Second Bishop's War was another
disastrous attempt on the part of Charles to try and fight a war with the Scots and
the end result of which left him with the problem of having to pay the Scots for a costly
settlement. He was forced to, he essentially tried to invade Scotland and instigate the
Second Bishop's War with a fighting force who were ill-equipped, unmotivated, even suggestions
were had that they sympathised with the Scots during the conflict. So we have all of these
problems taking place. The Second Bishop's War was a disaster for Charles. They were
easily fought back, defeated at the Battle of Newburn. It leads to the fact that Charles
has to reluctantly sign the Treaty of Ripon and the Treaty of Ripon, one of the terms
of the Treaty of Ripon was that Charles would have to pay £850 per day while the Scots
occupied Newcastle. All of these very problematic problems and the fact that we have now more
monetary liabilities that Charles has to deal with, more financial problems. So the
Long Parliament is also something that results in the fact that we need more finances on
the part of Charles. So again, mounting costs meant that Charles was, upon advice again
from a number of advisers, forced to call Parliament again, this time the Long Parliament
which was called in November of 1640. During the Long Parliament, we have a number of
MPs, a sort of coalition of MPs, led by John Pym, including people like John Hamden and
also Arthur Hesselrig, forming an opposition group against Charles. This opposition
group begins to grow in terms of its prominence and prevalence within Parliament, but it
also attracts a certain amount of opposition within Parliament itself. A divide begins
to exist between the Conservative Royalists, who supported Charles, and those who were
more opposed to Charles and his reign. At this point, at this point in time, in the
sort of 1640, November 1640 period, there weren't many, if any, calls specifically
made against Charles, his reign himself. There were critiques of his reign in terms of the
things that he did, but not necessarily critiques of his reign himself, as in directly attacking
Charles. They believed instead that it was the quote-unquote evil counsellors who were
the fault of the actions of Charles. And so if it was just the case that Charles could
get rid of these counsellors and maybe appoint some new ones, this could lead to a situation
which would be more politically stable, and they would actually maybe get on with Charles
a bit more. All of this goes on with the Long and Short Parliament, and at the same time
we have growing resentment beginning to take place among the actual people within London,
the society themselves, the Londoners themselves. And these would culminate in two main events,
the first of which, or at least one of these events, I should say, being the Root and Branch
Petition. Now the Root and Branch Petition was received by Parliament in December 1640,
and it was signed by around 15,000 Londoners. So it was a significantly popular and significantly
supported petition among the populace. The petition was one piece of evidence of the
degree of disdain that was essentially levied towards and against Charles and his advisors
as actions. In addition to this, we also see the fact that there was the release of two
individuals from prison who were put in prison by Archbishop Lord, these being William Pryne
and Henry Burton. They were released from prison, and when they were released from prison,
around 10,000 Londoners came out in celebration of their release. So again, this is something
that is representative of Charles's actions, and London is celebrating against Charles's
actions in the releasing of them from prison. Two pieces of evidence here that show that
the general populace were also not particularly very happy with Charles, his advisors and
all of their actions. The petition itself, the Root and Branch Petition, listed a number
of what were mainly religious grievances on the restrictions of practice, for example,
as well as the pushing and promoting of Arminianism. And because it was presented to Parliament,
what it did was actually lead to quite a certain direction that Parliament would push in terms
of their religious policy in opposition towards Charles. It would form the sort of bedrock
of religious opposition within Parliament itself, and it ultimately called for a number
of different things to try and actually try and resolve the problems. It didn't just
list problems, it also tried to provide solutions, ultimately calling for the abolition of a
number of different bishops. So the Root and Branch Petition is very, very important, but
it is also important in the sense that it shows that not only is Parliament in a vacuum
opposing some of the actions of Charles, but also individuals within London itself
actually opposing the actions of Charles. This would become very important when we think
about the outbreak of the Civil War, and we think about the relative strength of both
sides of the Civil War itself, with the Royalists and the Parliamentarians having different
advantages, specifically and mainly the Parliamentarians having the majority of the advantage. Finally
then let's think about the attacks on the prerogative, the actual attacks on the monarchal
power that Charles held himself, and by extension the enforcement of an increasing power that
was granted to Parliament by these things. So in order to protect the security of the
future of Parliament, Parliament themselves passed the Triennial Act in February 1641.
Now what the Triennial Act ultimately did was ensure that Charles would have to call
Parliament at least once every three years, so setting a certain fixed amount of times
that Parliament has to be called within a certain reign of a monarch. And what is more
important, and what is really interesting, is a bypassing of the monarchal authority
to call Parliament, because if this was not achieved, if it was not achieved that every
three years Parliament was called, the Triennial Act also imposed a provision which allowed
Parliament to just meet without the express permission of the monarch himself. This is
significant, because of course before this all monarchs would be responsible for calling
Parliament. We see that monarchs in the past call Parliament a varying amount of times
throughout their particular reign, but if we have a situation where if under the legislation
that is placed here by Parliament that Charles is unable to or refuses to call Parliament
at least once every three years, they're able to meet without the express permission of
Charles, this represents a significant attack on the royal prerogative and a significant
emboldening of power of Parliament. So all of these things are very, very important.
In May 1641, again as a result of an increased amount of pressure, what Charles was forced
to do was pass the Act Against Forcible Dissolution. Now what the Act Against Forcible Dissolution
did was ensure that the long Parliament would only ever be allowed to be dissolved if it
gives its own permission to do so. What this represents therefore is almost the other end
of the spectrum from the Triennial Act. So the Triennial Act makes it clear that Parliament
has the power to essentially call itself if Charles refuses to do so, but what the Act
Against Forcible Dissolution does is give Parliament the power to decide when it dissolves
itself. So Charles no longer has the ability to just unilaterally dissolve Parliament whenever
he chooses to. Instead, Parliament is dissolved when it gives its own permission to do so.
Again, a further attack on the monarchical power of the royal prerogative and a further
emboldening of power of Parliament. So essentially what these both did was give Parliament more
power than they ever had and represented a significant erosion of the royal prerogative
in relation to its relationship with Parliament and the calling of Parliament. In terms of
the practical things that were done in terms of the relationship between Parliament and
the advisers of Charles, there were a number of impeachments that were issued against Charles'
advisers. Again, remember, Parliament and the people within Parliament were focusing
their attention at this point not necessarily on Charles, but more on Charles' advisers,
the quote-unquote evil advisers, and there were a number of them who had been impeached.
For example, the majority of the judges who sat in the prerogative courts in the 1630s
had been impeached by this point by 1640. Archbishop Lord, who as we remember imposed
a lot of very radical religious reforms, was arrested in November of 1640 and was
held in the Tower of London and was only released from the Tower of London when he was executed
in 1645. So not necessarily a release per se. Thomas Wentworth was also arrested and
charged with high treason. We'll get on to the trial and execution of Wentworth in a
future lesson because this really does devolve into and represents how the Civil War begins.
Ultimately, he is executed on the 12th of May of 1641. He is actually executed, a little
fun fact, under the auspices and by permission of Archbishop Lord. So Archbishop Lord will
actually allow, essentially, the execution of Thomas Wentworth and then not very long
after become arrested and executed himself. A number of key advisers managed to flee the
attacks on themselves, essentially. So, for example, individuals like John Finch and Francis
Weinbank were able to flee in December 1640 before the issuance of their impeachments
actually managed to take place. So, for example, Finch fled to Holland before his impeachment
and Weinbank also fled to the continent. So we see really a number of things take place
in a relatively short amount of time. Despite the fact that the Long Parliament doesn't
officially dissolve until 1660, the period from the beginning of 1640 to the end of 1640,
to December 1640, is representative of a very significant number of events. We see the Short
Parliament take place in April of that time, we see the calling of the Long Parliament in the
November period of that time, and we see the attacks and the erosion on the royal prerogative
as well as the attacks on the advisers of Charles in this period as well. The next lesson we're
going to pick up from essentially where we've left off here, talk about the high treason charge that
was presented to Thomas Wentworth, talk about the trial and the execution of Thomas Wentworth,
and talk about the events that lead up to the outbreak of the Civil War when Charles flees
London and calls and raises his own army against Parliament.
