The Shocking Case of the President’s Slave Girl

What Was The Life
13 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
In June 1787, Thomas Jefferson sent a letter
from Paris requesting that his daughters join him in France.
Soon afterwards they arrived,
accompanied by an enslaved teenage girl named Sally Hemings.
Over the next two decades,
she would bear six children widely believed to be Jeffersons
and become the woman at the center of one
of the most explosive controversies in American history.
But who was Sally Hemings?
and what really happened between her and the founding father.
We don't really know when Sally Hemings was born.
By the 18th century there were a growing array of records
which allow us to determine what
people's date of birth was, notably baptismal records.
But this only tended to apply towards free Americans.
We can't be entirely sure when enslaved people were or were not born.
Though in Sally Hemings' case it
is generally assumed that she was born around 1773
in Charles City County in the English colony of Virginia.
For context, at this time Thomas Jefferson was 30 years old
while the Boston Tea Party,
a key episode in the descent into the American Revolutionary War,
occurred in December 1773.
Thus, Sally grew up against the backdrop of war,
though her formative years would have
been much more peaceful in the 1780s and 1790s.
Sally's mother was Elizabeth Hemmings,
an enslaved woman who was held in bondage by
the Virginia plantation owner John Wales.
It is believed that Elizabeth was born
to a woman from West Africa and a white planter
father.
She had six children with her enslaver Wales, of whom Sally was one.
This means that on her mother and maternal grandmother's side,
Sally was of West African descent,
but three of her four grandparents were of white European
descent. Under the racial classifications of the time,
she would have been considered a quadroon.
Contemporary accounts consistently described
her as good-looking and very light-skinned,
reflecting her predominantly European ancestry.
Sally never knew her father,
as peculiar as the relationship would have been in any event.
In May 1773, John Wales died.
As such, he may have pre-deceived Sally.
When he passed away, John had left large debts,
and much of his estate and property was quickly sold off
in order to reimburse his creditors.
In settling the estate,
Wales' son-in-law took possession of Elizabeth Hemmings and her six
children by Wales. This was none other than
the future third president of the United States,
Thomas Jefferson.
Back in 1770, he had begun courting Wells' daughter Martha,
and the pair eventually married in 1772.
At the time, Jefferson was a Virginia lawyer and plantation owner,
but he was a young man,
and not yet the national figure he became
as a result of the war with Britain.
Yet this seemingly incidental family connection marked
the beginning of a relationship
that would become one of the most controversial
and debated stories in American history.
History has a funny way of reminding us how much
our lives can be shaped by decisions made
years earlier, sometimes decisions we didn't fully understand
at the time. Today many of us
are trapped in unfulfilling careers,
with Sunday nights bringing that feeling of dread because you
know another week of work is waiting.
And even if you want change, it feels like you're stuck
on a path you chose years ago. But what if there were another way?
Well, with today's sponsor,
Southern New Hampshire University, there is.
SNHU is one of the largest accredited universities in the United States
and offers some of the most affordable
online tuition rates in the nation.
There are no set class times, which means you can learn
when and where it works best for your schedule.
Many programs also emphasize real-world skills and practical experience
that can help you stand out to future employers.
And if you've already earned college credits,
served in the military, or gained relevant professional experience,
you may be able to transfer up to 90 credits,
potentially saving both time and money on your degree.
It's no surprise that SNHU has also been recognised by US News
and World Report as one of the country's most innovative universities.
So go to snhu.edu forward slash forgotten lives
to explore over 200 degree programs
and find your path forward.
At the time that Sally Hemings and her mother
and siblings came into Jefferson's possession,
he had just built his famous Monticello estate
in the Albemarle County in Virginia.
So Sally grew up to a large extent here.
Jefferson and his wife Martha Wales were extremely close
and shared interests like music, literature and horse riding.
They would go on to have
six children together,
but tragically most of their children died in infancy.
Only two of their children, Martha and Mary,
known as Polly, lived into their adult years.
There are a lot of gaps in our knowledge about what happened
to Sally during her youth,
but it is clear that she
and her siblings were at the top of the social hierarchy amongst the
slaves at Monticello for the simple reason
that they were Martha Wales's half-siblings.
As such, Sally and her siblings worked
in the household at Monticello and she became
close with Martha and Polly as they were growing up,
as they were all similar in age.
Yet the routines of plantation life
were increasingly overshadowed by events beyond Virginia.
The American Revolutionary War began in 1775 and a year later
Thomas Jefferson emerged as a leading figure in the patriotic cause
when he drafted the Declaration of Independence
for the Second Continental Congress in Philadelphia.
Jefferson's rise continued in 1779
when he was elected governor of Virginia.
Entrusted with leading the state through
the darkest years of the revolution,
He faced British invasions,
even as he sought to reshape Virginia's laws and institutions.
Yet by the early 1780s,
his wife Martha was ill and weak from her many pregnancies
and a case of smallpox. It's said that Thomas was
inconsolable about Martha's declining health and pain.
Her health continued to worsen and she died on September 6th 1782,
aged 33. Before her death, Martha asked Jefferson never to remarry.
The request was likely influenced
by her own unhappy experiences with stepmothers
and her desire to spare her daughters a similar fate.
Jefferson was devastated by her loss
and honored her wish for the rest of his life,
never taking another wife or at least not in name.
In 1784, following the end of the Revolutionary War,
Jefferson was appointed as the American minister to France,
succeeding Benjamin Franklin.
Three years later he arranged for his daughters to join him in Paris.
In the summer of 1787 they arrived
in Paris accompanied by Sally Hemings
and her older brother James.
Although slavery was not recognized in metropolitan France
and Sally could potentially have claimed her freedom under French law,
she remained in Jefferson's household
and served as a lady's maid to his daughter Martha.
While in Paris, it's likely she accompanied Martha
to former social functions,
and she was also learning French.
We are not sure where she lived though.
She may have stayed either at Jefferson's residence,
the Hotel de Lagnac,
or the Abbey de Ponthermont, where Martha and Polly were educated.
It was during the family's years in Paris,
amid the intrigue of a sigh in the twilight of the
French monarchy, that Jefferson's relationship
with Sally is generally believed to have begun.
She would have been around 15 years old at the time,
while Jefferson was in his mid-40s.
The exact nature of their relationship remains a subject of debate.
Although Sally occupied a somewhat different legal position
in France than she would have in Virginia,
the imbalance of power between the two was profound.
Jefferson was a wealthy diplomat
in his mid-40s, while Sally was an enslaved teenager
in his household. Because of this,
Sally would have had little say in the relationship
and couldn't really consent.
Though some historians argue
that genuine affection may have developed between them over the years,
though the true nature of their feelings can never
be known with certainty.
Whatever the truth, they remained in France until
the outbreak of the French Revolution in 1789.
By then, Sally was about 16 years old.
As Jefferson made plans to leave France, Sally stood at a crossroads.
One path led toward freedom in Europe,
the other led back across the Atlantic to a life of slavery.
Yet France was so far from home.
Her mother, siblings and extended family were all at Monticello,
and those ties weighed heavily on her decision.
According to the later recollections of her son Madison Hemings,
Sally agreed to return only after Jefferson promised
that any children they had together
would one day be freed.
It was a decision that would shape the rest of her life
and the lives of generations yet to be born.
Sally's relationship with Thomas was extremely controversial
and has been debated for 200 years.
For two centuries papers
and books have appeared that have tried to deny the fact that Jefferson
had a relationship with Sally.
This has consequently become known as the Jefferson-Hemings
Controversy. In the 19th century
and well into the 20th century a majority of historians either
ignored or challenged the idea that Jefferson fathered
a separate family with one of his slaves.
While it was hardly unusual for wealthy southern slave owners
to father children with enslaved women during this period,
what was out of the ordinary was the manner
in which Jefferson conducted his relationship with Sally,
in a relatively open manner and that it went on for so many years.
After they returned to the United States,
Sally is understood to have had six children via
her relationship with Jefferson.
The first, a daughter named Harriet, was born in 1795.
She died two years later in December 1797.
Another daughter, whose name was possibly Thenia, died in infancy.
Of the four who lived beyond infancy,
Three were sons. These were William Beverley born in 1798,
James Madison in 1805 and Esther in 1808,
while they also had another daughter named Harriet in 1801,
reusing the name of the first now deceased child.
Hence, three of Sally's alleged children with
Thomas were born when he was serving as President
of the United States between 1801 and 1809.
It was during Jefferson's presidency
that the first allegations of the relationship circulated.
Rumors had been going around since the 1790s,
but in 1802, the journalist James T. Callendar,
a former ally turned political enemy, claimed that Jefferson had
kept as his concubine one of his own slaves
and fathered several children by her. The story
quickly spread through the newspapers
and became a favorite attack of Jefferson's critics.
Jefferson himself never publicly addressed the accusations,
though members of his family did.
In the 1850s, his eldest grandson,
Thomas Jefferson Randolph, asserted that Sally's
children had been fathered not by Jefferson,
but by his nephew, Peter Carr. Nevertheless,
there seems to be little doubt today from a wealth
of documentary evidence, as well as DNA studies
carried out by Sally's descendants in 1998,
that Thomason was the father of Sally's children.
One further unusual thing concerning Sally's children that seems to
cement the idea that Thomas was their father comes from his farm book.
This was a ledger he kept about
his business affairs on his plantation in Virginia.
He kept a record here of the births and deaths of slaves on his estate.
Crucially, he noted the father of children born to enslaved women.
But, these details were omitted from the records pertaining
to the children he almost certainly fathered with Sally.
Despite the mountain of evidence to support the idea
that Thomas was the father of Sally's six children,
the theory did not gain widespread acceptance until
the second half of the 20th century.
As the civil rights movement gained ground
in the US in the 1950s and 1960s,
there was more discussion of this element
of US presidential history, and it was widely
written about. Yet, a small number
of critics continued to dispute Jefferson's paternity.
They note that DNA testing can identify the Jefferson male line,
but cannot distinguish between individual Jefferson men,
leading some to suggest alternative candidates such
as Jefferson's younger brother, Randolph.
Others have speculated
that Sally Hemings may have had relationships with other men.
However, most historians conclude that the combined documentary
and genetic evidence
strongly supports the view
that Jefferson fathered Sally Hemings' children,
even if absolute certainty remains impossible.
The story of Sally Hemings might not be unique
in American presidential history.
It has been speculated that four or five other presidents
also fathered children with slave women that they owned.
For instance, William Henry Harrison,
who was briefly president for one month before his death in 1841,
potentially fathered several children
with an enslaved woman named Dilsia.
None of these other presidential slave children,
though, can be confirmed.
Jefferson was unusual in that his relationship
with Sally appears to have endured for decades
and resulted in six children
and the lives they had together at Monticello
would prove every bit as intriguing as the controversy
that surrounded them. Sally's life at
Jefferson's plantation estate at Monticello
in the 1790s was different to that of most slaves.
A study in 2017 suggested that she lived in a room
that was next to Thomas's in the manor house.
She never married and effectively became a pseudo-wife of Thomas,
who, as mentioned, also did not remarry.
The Hemmings' children lived in and around the house and were treated
separately from the vast majority of slaves at Monticello,
just as Sally and her Hemming siblings had
been decades earlier when she was growing up.
The relationship between Thomas
and Sally would have been sporadic between 1797 and 1809.
He served as vice president between 1797 and 1801,
and then as third president of the US between 1801 and 1809.
Although Thomas did not go out of his way to cover up
his relationship with Sally at Monticello,
he knew there were limits to how open he should be.
While he lived in Washington, she remained in
Virginia, and there is no evidence that she ever visited
the White House during his presidency.
After his years in office, Jefferson returned to Monticello
to spend his remaining time surrounded by books,
architecture, science, and the comforts of plantation life.
For Sally and her children, however, the future was far less certain.
Virginia law precluded slaves from marrying
in the same way that free people could marry.
That being said, many enslaved couples
did form stable common-law relationships.
This did not apply to Sally Hemings.
And the impression we get is that she was considered to be a concubine,
or pseudo-wife of Jefferson for many, many years.
She continued to live in and around
the main house on a plantation estate,
where hundreds of enslaved people lived in other outhouses
and slave quarters.
Thomas lived to be a very old man by the standards of the time,
only dying in 1826 at 83s of age.
By the time he died, Sally was still theoretically a slave.
He had never manumitted her slavery,
though he did release some of Sally's children
from bondage in his last will and testament.
Despite his success in the political realm
and his vast inherited wealth,
Jefferson was a terrible businessman and died bankrupt.
A large part of his estate was therefore sold off
by Martha Jefferson to repay his debts.
This meant that the vast majority of Thomas' slaves were auctioned off,
but Sally was not among them.
Martha, who was also Sally's half-niece,
allowed her to basically live as a free woman thereafter.
She spent her final years in Charlottesville
with two of her sons and their families.
She died there in 1835 at around 62 years of age.
As noted, two of Sally's children died in infancy.
Harriet was allowed to leave Monticello in 1822
and was even provided with a large sum of money,
$50 by Thomas when she left.
Although she was still legally a slave at the time,
Jefferson never tried to have her
returned to his estate in Virginia.
It's not clear what happened to her. She wrote to her
siblings occasionally for a few years after leaving in 1822,
but thereafter she largely
disappears from the historical record.
William Beverley Hemings was apprenticed
to the skilled carpenter John Hemings,
his uncle, in 1812 at the age of 14.
Although Jefferson never formally freed him,
Beverley was permitted to leave Monticello as a young man
and establish an independent life.
In legal terms he remained enslaved,
but in practice he gained his freedom without formal
manumission. He chose to identify as a white man in his adult years,
highlighting just how
light-skinned the children from Sally
and Thomas' union would have been.
Eston and Madison Hemings were both officially freed
by Thomas in his last will and testament.
After the death of their mother in 1835,
the pair moved with their own families to Ohio,
a free state which experienced enormous settlement
in the first half of the 19th century.
Eston's family later moved on again to Wisconsin in the early 1850s.
He died a few years later in
1856. One of his sons, John,
was a prominent Union commander in the American Civil War.
Madison and his family continued to live
in Ohio down to his death in 1873.
That same year he published an article in an Ohio newspaper
which laid out the claim that he and his siblings were the illegitimate
children of the third president of the United States.
The DNA testing in 1998 provided powerful evidence linking
the descendants of Sally Hemings to the Jefferson family
and her descendants now live across the United States.
Yet the story of Sally Hemings is not exceptional because it happened.
Tens of millions of Americans have an ancestor of one kind or another
who was involved in a relationship between
plantation owners and the enslaved.
What makes her story remarkable is that it survived.
For generations efforts were made to
deny, dismiss or obscure it.
In the end however, the truth proved harder to bury than the people
who lived it. Thank you so much everyone
for watching this video on Sally Hemmings,
I hope you enjoyed it and found it interesting.
Let me know what you thought of her life down
down below in the comments
and if you want more videos on topics like this also let me know.
And if you have more videos on topics like this,
also let me know down below in the comments.
I hope you guys are subscribed and have notifications turned
on to get all my videos as soon as I upload them.
Anyway, that's all from me, so I'll see all
of you in the next forgotten life.
Thanks.
